Friday, July 15, 2022

EXPLAINER: What's Wrong With Having Labour/Lib Dem/Green/Tory Party Councillors in Somerset's Councils?

 

One of our Official emblems

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We exist to improve representation in Somerset and to stand up for residents.

We are frequently critical of the Westminster parties and we say:

 Labour

 Lib Dem

 Green or 

 Tory...

 Same old story.

The fact is that now, after the 2022 local elections, that there will be fewer independent councillors in (most of) Somerset. We say (most of) because this does not apply to North Somerset Council and Bath and North East Somerset Council.

In those elections, there were only three councillors out of 110 (2.7%) elected to the County Council that in 2023 will become the New Somerset Council unitary authority when it replaces the four districts and the county council.

All of the independent councillors on the districts will go. And there will be 107 out of 110 councillors (97.3%) who are members of the Westminster parties - Labour, Lib Dem, Green or Tory. We do not include town and parish councils in these figures, but the Westminster parties have infected those councils too - sometimes in disguise by standing for the county council for their party, and then standing as a fake "independent" on the town and parish at the same time in 2022 elections - as pointed out by Scott Ward from Independents for Frome in his response to the attack by The Leveller on IFF.

Below is an explainer as to why we believe that Westminster parties should have no say in our local councils. We hope that it is useful to residents and that it helps to explain. Let us know your views by getting in touch.

We believe that councillors should represent their local residents, by listening and acting on their concerns. Having Westminster parties telling councillors what to do, via the whip and other mechanisms, gets in the way of doing this. There is also a pernicious influence of local media, which involves unaccountable decisions over what is and what is not in the public interest. This is the local politics of news.

In the main, there are two key tensions and conflicts in being an elected representative in a party-based elected democracy (e.g. a Member of Parliament or Councillor). One is between the representative's political party and the representative's constituents.

On a particular policy, the constituents may have views that are perceived to be not very “informed” by evidence or debate, but nevertheless they are the people who elected the representative, and who can vote them out. On the other hand, the party also enabled the representative to be selected as their candidate, provided them with support and had policy positions that may or may not match the constituents’ views. The representative may choose to take the party line, or may take a line determined from some or all of their constituents. All of these tensions can interfere in how the representative demonstrates accountability (or not).

If the ideal of democratic accountability is to be observed, an elected representative would always do what their electors wanted (Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s "people's will"). However, this leads to the practical concern of how the "people's will" is to be determined. Such issues raise other concerns related to the democratic goods of democratic legitimacy and popular control.

The other tension is between the representative's politics as an individual and the representative's party policy. In the UK Parliament, the party whips intervene in this matter, enforcing discipline on party members to obey the whip and vote according to party policy. There are levels of discipline, with a "three-line whip" being the strongest. Punishment for disobeying the whip is unspecified, but it does not require too much imagination to expect that MPs could lose selection at election time, have the progression of their political career halted, or suffer more devious "briefings" to the media about matters that may be political or even highly personal.  

With the implementation since 2000 of the Strong Leader and Cabinet or even more undemocratic Mayor and Cabinet model in the vast majority of councils across England, the flaws of the Westminster system have been replicated in those councils. It is just councillors instead of MPs.

The media and lobbying also intervene in policy and decision-making. The media can act as guardians of communities, taking a popular issue, making it into a story that sells newspapers and taking a particular line on the issue (e.g. opposing the fluoridation of water in Southampton). Or it can select and embellish stories that encourage viewing of television news, or hits on websites or subscriptions to magazines. Media power itself has come under the spotlight with the Leveson inquiry.

Lobbying is notorious for lacking transparency, and accusations of corruption of elected representatives have focussed heavily on corporate lobbying and PR. There is also a debate over whether "civil society groups" can, or should, create a new type of "accountability" by trying to influence government policy, despite not being accountable to the political structure of representation. Instead, they are only accountable, if that can be said, to their own members, their boards of trustees, or other groups that are not necessarily representative of the constituents that elected that government. Religious leaders also occasionally intervene in politics, despite the widespread view that "politics and religion should never mix". Despite this view, the Church of England remains traditionally privileged over other religions in the UK Parliament as well as law. For example, its bishops sit in the House of Lords - itself an unelected body.

All of the reality of the tensions and conflicts described above interfere in the ideal of democratic accountability of elected representatives to local residents - this is the ideal that Somerset Independents aims to promote.

 

  1. What do you think of the above explainer?
  2. Is it helpful?
  3. Do you agree?
  4. Do you disagree?
  5. Have we persuaded you?


Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




"Corrupt" South Somerset District Council - Did They Check On Their Councillors? No, They Did Not

 


One of our Official emblems

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We are continuing the campaign for all councillors to have to have criminal records checks (DBS). But "corrupt" South Somerset District Council did not perform these checks on all councillors. How do we know? Because we asked.

Richard Ward, the Head of Legal at SSDC and Monitoring Officer, told us when we asked him a series of questions in late 2020:

"1. Which policies of the Council include references to DBS checks for councillors, and whether these checks are Basic or Enhanced? –

I don’t believe it is in a policy. Not all district councils do checks mainly because we do not generally provide services directly to vulnerable groups. It may be something we wish to review though."

We are of the view that if a councillor does their job of representing their constituents properly, they will come into contact will all sorts of people, young and old and including vulnerable people. Yet the Monitoring Officer who was responsible for standards, didn't "believe it is in a policy" to perform DBS checks, at the same time as the former Leader of the Council was on trial.

The former Liberal Democrat Leader of South Somerset District Council, Ric Pallister, "was found guilty of 18 counts of indecent assault, with the offences committed between the 1980s and 2000s." as reported by the Chard and Ilminster News. Pallister was sentenced to 11 years in prison on 24th September 2021, as reported by SomersetLive.

A year before, in November 2020, when we became aware of the charges against Pallister, our Safeguarding Spokesperson Denise Wyatt wrote to all SSDC councillors asking them about DBS checks and quoting the answers from Richard Ward.

We did not get many replies from councillors and from their responses, there was no action taken to make sure DBS checks were made for all councillors. And you have seen one response from the Monitoring Officer - his other responses are below.

Have SSDC changed their policy since on DBS checks? We are not aware that they have, although we have asked them. And next year, they will be abolished and cannot be voted out. It is a dangerous time.

This is a council that has been described by The Leveller as "The Corrupted". It is a council that even the current Liberal Democrat Leader Councillor Val Keitch has described publicly in a public meeting as "corrupt" when discussing the case of SSDC Director Clare Pestell, who was sacked after an investigation found her to have committed gross misconduct, although she denied the allegations. Councillor Keitch survived a vote of no confidence, but her Lib Dem councillors made unsubstantiated allegations in public against a former councillor, for which they were made to apologise.

And as reported on this website, when Somerset Independents investigated their councillors and whether they paid they council tax every month, South Somerset covered up their names until we went to the Information Commissioner to make them reveal the names. South Somerset is still fighting us and covering up information relating to the arrears of its councillors.

Liberal Democrat Leader
Councillor Val Keitch

South Somerset is a council in disarray. It is a council controlled by Somerset Liberal Democrats.

It is also a council that has gone on a spending spree with public money, and where the Audit Committee Chair is a Lib Dem (and a majority of Lib Dem councillors on the Committee) who is supposedly "checking" on a Lib Dem Leader and Cabinet, but where project after project is overspending - on Wincanton Regeneration, on Chard Regeneration, on the Octagon Theatre in Yeovil, and more. These debts will be taken on by the New Somerset Council in 2023, when SSDC is scrapped. The SSDC councillors will cease to be, but their legacy is disastrous. 

So where are the investigations into SSDC councillors? That is the responsibility of the Standards Committee and the Monitoring Officer.

As we publicised a long time ago on our website (November 2021), and as you can see below in the other questions to the Monitoring Officer, the Standards Committee hardly ever met. This has been reported upon by The Leveller more recently in 2022.

So what was the attitude from the officer responsible for standards of councillors? As you look through Richard Ward's responses below, please consider: 


Where is the reckoning for the Pallister years? Or is that being ignored?

Why weren't Standards of councillors maintained or even checked, shown by the failure of the Committee to hardly ever meet?

Why have SSDC refused to carry out DBS checks, when other district councils do carry them out (e.g. Sedgemoor)?

 

Lib Dem councillors including Councillor Keitch have been elected to the Somerset County Council which will inherit their own disastrous legacy from the districts, and she has been elevated to the Cabinet position of responsibility, as well as other SSDC councillors. 

The County Council Lib Dems Leader of the Council, Bill Revans, is already complaining that finances will be tight and will have to "find" £44 million due to the deficits of the county and districts, as reported by Daniel Mumby, Local Democracy Reporter for SomersetLive.

The New Somerset Council legacy will be a Lib Dem and Tory legacy from the disastrous way that the districts and county council have been run. It will inherit:

  • bad debts
  • bad councillors
  • bad decisions
  • bad officers

and sadly, it will be the people of Somerset who will pay for it.

---

Responses To Questions on DBS Checks By Richard Ward, Monitoring Officer from Denise Wyatt, Safeguarding Spokesperson, November 2020

"Further to your enquiry re DBS checks

 

1. Which policies of the Council include references to DBS checks for councillors, and whether these checks are Basic or Enhanced? –

I don’t believe it is in a policy. Not all district councils do checks mainly because we do not generally provide services directly to vulnerable groups. It may be something we wish to review though.


    2. Whether ALL councillors are subjected to DBS checks, whether Basic or Enhanced, and how often?

 No, not to my knowledge.The District Council would not be able to undertake Enhanced checks in any event

    3. If any councillor does not have a DBS check carried out, whether or not that is a breach of the Code of Conduct including the Nolan Principles? It is not a requirement and I can’t see the Nolan principles are relevant.

    4. When any committee of the Council considered DBS checks for councillors, what decisions they took, which councillors were involved and what the officer recommendations were.

 NA

    5. Whether ALL current serving councillors have had DBS checks and confirmation of those checks and the level of checks. Your answer may include the current register for those checks. 

No not to my knowledge.

    6. The names of any councillors who have not had DBS checks, with reasons. Again, your answer may include the current register for those checks.


Some councillors do have DBS checks but not as councillors. Often they are governors and hold other roles.

    7. The reasons for the cancellation of the Standards Committee meetings, and who made the decision to cancel each of these meetings. Please see attached screenshot.

 This is usually the Chair in discussion with the Committee Administrator when there is no business to discuss.

    8. The details of what happened when the Standards Committee considered the case of former Council Leader Ric Pallister and if it did not consider this case, why not?

It has never considered the case of Councillor Pallister. Councillor Pallister was charged after he stepped down from being a councillor. As of this date he has not been convicted of those charges and so under the law of this country someone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

    9. Whether Mr Pallister went through any DBS checks and the details of whether he passed or failed?

 I am not aware Mr Pallister had a DBS check undertaken in his role as a councillor although he may have had one in other capacities he held.

 

Regards


Richard Ward"

---

 

Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Thursday, July 14, 2022

UPDATE (18/7/22): A Green Cabinet Member Replies - North Somerset Council Chairperson Responds on Councillors in Council Tax Arrears

 

Councillor Dr Karin Haverson
Chairperson of North Somerset Council

One of our Official emblems

UPDATE (18/7/22)

Cabinet Member and Green Party Councillor, Bridget Petty, has replied to us regarding our councillors council tax campaign. She said:

Councillor Bridget Petty
Executive Member
of Climate Change
and Environment
 

"Thank you for emailing us, I wanted to thank you and your organisation for your hard work and pursuit of good governance and accountability.

 

Yours sincerely

 

Councillor Bridget Petty

Executive Member of Climate Emergency and Engagement

Green Party Councillor for Backwell, North Somerset"

---

Somerset Independents has now published the names and details of three councillors on North Somerset Council who persistently did not pay their council tax for months or even over years.

We have asked every North Somerset councillor for comment on the recalcitrant councillors. 

Councillor Dr Karin Haverson, who is a Green Party councillor and is now Chairperson of North Somerset Council, has reassured us and welcomed our investigation:

Councillor Dr Karin Haverson

 

"I welcome your efforts to highlight the behaviour of all of us councillors, but can assure you that I have never been in Council Tax arrears, neither before nor after I became a councillor. I am a retired scientist and have never been in business, and it would go against my principles to withhold money from the public purse.



Best wishes 

Dr Karin Haverson 

Councillor Banwell & Winscombe 
Chairperson of North Somerset Council"

 

Earlier this year, Councillor Haverson requested at Full Council, which she chairs, that she be addressed as "Chairperson".

 

Who Are Somerset Independents?

We are Somerset's own campaign group and political party. We celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.