Showing posts with label Street. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Street. Show all posts

Saturday, November 13, 2021

The Clark's Strike and March - We Support Workers Not The Labour Party

The Picket Line at Clark's in Street


Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope responds:
 
Leader of Somerset Independents
Andrew Pope

"Somerset Independents states again its support for residents and workers of Somerset. Indeed, it is in our Constitution that we protect Somerset residents and Somerset workers at Clark's - all of them.

Somerset Independents wishes to state that we support Clark's workers, but not the Labour Party. And from their responses to our questions to them, the local Somerset Tory MPs seem to support Clark's managements actions, to their shame. Neither Labour nor Tory are helping. They are out-of-date and out-of-touch.

Somerset Independents has taken action to protect residents and workers at Clark's - whether they are in the Community Union mentioned by Clark's - or not in the union. We've taken action to support workers at Norseland in Ilchester too. Where is Labour? Where are the Tories?

Somerset Independents has tried to work with the unions. We've offered the hand of help. But we have been met with a brick wall on Clark's and also at Norseland, where the GMB Union has let workers down. Their pay and working conditions have suffered.

These unions fail because of their connections to Labour, which put workers off. The Community Union and the GMB Union both affiliate to the Labour Party. Both unions donate large sums of money to the Labour Party. At a time when MPs are being examined for paid advocacy following Tory MP Owen Paterson's corruption, this needs to be looked at.

Labour's unions have also donated to Barry Gardiner, Brent North MP from London, who is due to speak at Saturday's march. He has received tens of thousands of pounds from these unions, as shown in his Register of Interests at Parliament, seemingly for his deeply flawed Fire and Rehire Bill, but for a company that he is the sole director of, according to Companies House records.

Barry Gardiner MP controls the money and the unions give it to him. There is no other Director, despite claims to the contrary that a Labour Lord is also a Director (Labour Lord Hendy).

Sadly it's another case of Labour or Tory, same old story. Gardiner is paid by the unions, but where the union money goes is not transparent enough.

So now we know why these unions don't want to work with Somerset Independents, although we have offered to pressure Clark's management and to work with the unions in the spirit of partnership.

These Labour Party-dominated unions are more interested in dialogue with the Labour Party and Labour MPs who do not live in Somerset such as Barry Gardiner, than working with Somerset Independents to pressure Clark's management and to resolve this dispute.

The Labour Party's methods are outdated. Their attitudes are outdated. Members money is mis-spent. Labour is totally split from top to bottom between Corbyn supporters and Starmer supporters.

That's why Labour is going nowhere in Somerset.

Meanwhile, Somerset Independents is winning its campaigns:
- exposing councillors who don't pay council tax,
- exposing councils who spend public money wrongly, and
- on holding companies like Norseland and Clark's to account.

Somerset Independents is standing up for workers and residents, whereas Labour-supporting unions have failed to win for workers.

And our success in campaigns shows why Somerset Independents is gaining support for its work in Somerset, working with residents and workers.

Somerset is our County."
 


Friday, October 22, 2021

UPDATE (22/3/22): P & O Ferries and Clark's - Like the Tories - Wrap Themselves in the Flag But Are Foreign-Owned and Run!

 

Standing Up For Somerset Residents

UPDATE (23/3/21): P & O Ferries write open letter back to the Conservative Minister Kwasi Kwarteng...

... and P & O CEO Peter Hebblethwaite uses many of the same phrases that Somerset's Conservative MPs and Ministers have been quoted by us as saying.

We said that Tory MPs parroted employers and this proves it.

For example, Hebblethwaite writes, in the letter published by the BBC:

"We saw no other viable means of preserving our iconic British business, saving the 2,200 remaining jobs it provides and protecting the 15% Britain's trade capacity it facilitates."
It's British and iconic, P & O Ferries, Hebblethwaite claims. 

Is P & O British or Not British? 

It is well-documented that P & O Ferries is owned by DP World, based in Dubai, which is not British.

In the same letter, P & O state that "all relevant vessels are registered outside of the UK". The names of the ships sound British. Let's have a look at each one...

Spirit of Britain is registered in Cyprus - not British

Pride of Hull in Bahamas - not British

Pride of Canterbury in Cyprus - not British

Pride of Kent in Cyprus - not British

The employees that were dismissed were from three companies - all registered in Jersey. Is Jersey British or not? Jersey is a Crown Dependency, has its own Parliament, its own identity internationally, and is not part of the United Kingdom.

Conclusions

You can make up your own minds on whether P & O Ferries is "British" or not.

P & O Ferries operate to and from ports in Britain and some of its workers are British residents. But that seems to be about it.

P & O Ferries seem to be as "British" as the foreign-owned Premier League football teams, one of which - Chelsea - has been forced to be sold off by the UK Government after sanctions were applied to Chelsea's owner.

Whether P & O Ferries will continue to operate to and from British ports, or whether another operator will take over, will test P & O's claim that their ferries are "iconic" or not.

Will UK Governments - Labour, Lib Dem or Tory - do anything to stop it being the same old story, when it comes to workers at sea?

Their track record suggests that they will not, because they are still not serving the people that they are supposed to serve - the British people.

Instead, these Westminster parties accept money from all sorts of the wrong sources and serve the wrong interests - themselves and their rotten parties.

---

UPDATE (20/3/21): According to ITV News reporting on The Sunday Times, Conservative Ministers "knew of P&O Ferries" plans to slash jobs.

The report says:

"The Sunday Times newspaper said it received a leaked memo apparently written by a senior Whitehall official which tried to “justify” the mass redundancies, stating that “without these decisions, an estimated 2,200 staff would likely lose their jobs”...
"The newspaper said it was “widely shared across government” and recipients included the Prime Minister’s private office while Transport Secretary Grant Shapps is understood to have received a copy."

This attitude by Tory MPs echoes the response that Somerset Independents received when it asked Somerset MPs about the Clark's dispute here in Somerset (Clark's is now Chinese-owned).

Liam Fox (Tory, North Somerset) and James Heappey (Tory, Wells) made pronouncements about the Clark's dispute. And both seem to think sacking workers or attacking their rights is OK - as long as the employer claims they are struggling and claims it is done to save other jobs.

Somerset Independents stands up for residents and for workers. We want to see good employers thrive. But P & O and Clark's are clearly not good employers.

Like Liam Fox - himself a former Minister - and Wells MP James Heappey - currently a Minister - both displayed a terrible attitude during the Clark's dispute in Heappey's constituency (see our earlier report below). Fox mentioned Heappey in his response to us.

In relation to P & O, Heappey told Sky News: 'that the government "cannot force an employer to continue to employ people that the employer has said it doesn't want to employ." 

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, himself a former union representative and negotiator, says: 

Andrew Pope

"The way the Whitehall memo is written - Heappey is a Minister - mirrors the way Somerset MP Liam Fox attempted to justify attacking Clark's workers, when we asked him about the Somerset dispute.

Mr Fox told us and I quote: 'It is clear that they are trying to maintain jobs at a time when they are losing money.  The alternative to the current plan seems to be increased redundancies which I am sure people would want to avoid.'

Whether it is James Heappey or Liam Fox, the attitude is very similar.

Both Clark's and P & O are struggling, and both have attempted to use the management failures to cut jobs and attack workers. And according to Tory MPs and Tory ministers, it seems it is OK to sack 800 workers to save 2,200 workers.

No, it isn't OK.

Poor strategic decisions from management failures should not lead to sackings or reductions in terms and conditions of employment.

It seems that whether it is here in Somerset or out at sea, Tory MPs put the needs and claims of employers first and the needs of employees a very distant last.

But Grant Shapps and other ministers have expressed their false horror at the treatment of P & O workers.

Tories pretend to care and say they are "reviewing" the legality of the actions of P & O.

Were Tory ministers aware, and are Labour MPs aware, that the law at sea is not the same as UK employment law?

When workers are at sea, they would surely be covered by international maritime law, not UK law? An example is the 2014 Maritime Labour Convention on Seafarer working and living rights.

As a former councillor in a port city, I asked similar questions when I heard from workers on cruise ships. I heard all about the undermining of workers and their rights at sea.

I understood that treating workers at sea in such a poor way, was commonly done by seafaring employers.

Does maritime law apply or UK law? Government ministers should be honest about it - surely they would be able to say - or are they so incompetent that they don't know?

If they did know about it, what did they do about it?

Labour had 13 years of Government to sort this out. The Tories have had 12 years in Government. The Lib Dems even had the Coalition.

But Labour, Tories and Lib Dems showed that they cannot be trusted to stand up for Somerset residents or stand up for workers.

They pretend that they care but when it comes to the crunch, neither used Government to change international maritime law to protect workers at sea.

It's yet another case of Labour, Lib Dem or Tory, it's the same old story."


---

UPDATE (25/10/21): Conservative MPs including Somerset's Conservative MPs voted down the Private Members Bill that Somerset Independents asked them to support. The Bill would limit Fire and Rehire, which the new owners of Clark's propose to use to attack the company's workers.

Worse than this, only two Somerset MPs have responded to our challenges. At the time of writing, no other MPs have responded. And even these two lame responses do not help Somerset's workers.

Dr Liam Fox

Dr Liam Fox, Conservative MP for North Somerset did not answer our questions. Instead, he produced what amounts to an attempt at an excuse for the owners of Clark's to do what they have done to the company's workers, and for what they propose to do - to cut terms and conditions of employment without consent from the workers themselves.

Dr Fox told Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope:

"I have been in touch with Clarks and the local MP, James Heappey.  I am not sure whether you are aware of the following facts.

There have been some employees working in the factory on superior contracts from pervious owners.  In order to avoid further redundancies, they have brought them all (potentially) to the same hourly pay.  Some getting a rise and some getting a reduction.  It must be noted that Clarks’ figures have recently been published and last year they lost £180 million.  The investment they have received was £100 million and that secured the future of Clarks and jobs for their employees.   It is clear that they are trying to maintain jobs at a time when they are losing money.  The alternative to the current plan seems to be increased redundancies which I am sure people would want to avoid."

James Heappey, Conservative MP for Wells, has told campaigners that he is negotiating with the company on behalf of constituents. 

Andrew Pope responds to the two Conservative MPs by saying:

Andrew Pope

"Most Somerset MPs, all of whom are Conservative, seem too busy or too ignorant to prioritise our challenges on behalf of Clark's workers.

Somerset Independents and other campaigners have asked Mr Heappey what alternative he suggests to strikes. He previously stated on the BBC that strikes are not the answer. But he does not seem to have any alternative course of action for the workers who are under attack by the owners of Clark's. He claims to be negotiating for them - where are the results of his "negotiations"?

As for Mr Fox - yes, I told that him that Somerset Independents were already aware of these "facts". Mr Fox seems to think it is OK for workers' pay and conditions to be attacked, after management made the wrong strategic decisions for Clark's. It is not the fault of these workers, but they are made to suffer for the management failures. It's not on.

Why do these Tory MPs think this is OK? It just isn't. Fire and Rehire just is not an acceptable way to treat Somerset's workers."

Somerset Independents will continue to challenge the owners and management of Clark's and Somerset's MPs who appear to back this appalling behaviour by Clark's.

---

Somerset Independents has been supporting the Clark's employees and their representatives, in their ongoing dispute with the employer, as reported in our article here. 

The Protests at Clark's

Mendip Trades Union Council (TUC) has asked us to support the Private Members Bill being proposed by Barry Gardiner MP.

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, has responded positively to their request. Andrew says:

Andrew Pope

"As I said in my previous statement, Fire and Rehire should not be allowed. I have been of this view ever since I was an employee and union representative in the UNIFI union. Yet despite 13 years of Government, Labour failed to ban it.

Having listened to the views of other Somerset residents and workers, and listened to Mendip TUC's request to support the Bill, Somerset Independents supports the broad aims and objectives of the Bill, but believes that due to flaws in the Bill, that it may lead to unintended consequences such as dismissal without any new contract being offered.

However, on balance, some of the provisions in the Bill are very important, and would help in the dispute at Clark's, so we are asking Somerset's MPs to support the Bill when it is voted on."


Wednesday, October 13, 2021

Somerset Independents On Somerset Businesses: Just What Is Going On At Clark's?

 


Somerset Independents wants Somerset residents to be proud of what Somerset businesses produce, and for Somerset's reputation to be enhanced outside Somerset and across the world.

We will happily praise Somerset-based businesses that Somerset people can be proud of. But we will challenge businesses that we believe may be tarnishing the reputation of Somerset.

Clark's shoes was founded in Street, Somerset, by the Quakers C & J Clark. The Registered Office is still in Street. The Alfred Gillett Trust is a Somerset-based charity in Street which "preserves the heritage collections of C & J Clark Ltd., the family which founded the global shoemaking company".

It has been a large employer of Somerset workers for almost 200 years. It is a well-known and respected brand for shoes.

We were therefore concerned to hear of the ongoing industrial dispute at Clark's, which has now led to strike action.

So we have contacted workers representatives at the Mendip Trades Union Council (TUC), to try to find out the truth behind the strikes.

Somerset Independents officers Andrew Pope and Denise Wyatt wrote to the Mendip TUC, saying:

"This dispute is tarnishing the reputation of Clarks, who were founded by Quakers. And it is harming the relationship between employer and employees. This will impact on the sustainability of the business, harming Somerset's workers.

We believe that the founders would be extremely upset at the current situation and that they would never have allowed this.

What changes have occurred since the Lion Rock takeover and how are the "key" shareholders acting since the takeover to protect the company's reputation?

What changes have occurred in employment relations?

Now that workers have been forced to strike, do you believe that the new owners will bring retribution on any workers?

Finally, how can Somerset Independents assist in helping to resolving the situation?"

 

Mendip TUC told us:

"Clarks warehouse workers, members of the Community Union, face the following threats:


1. An average reduction in pay of £1.66 per hour: from the current £11.16p to £9.50p;


2. An increase in working hours of 2.5 per week, due to paid 30-minute meal breaks being abolished;


3. No pay rise for at least four years, despite the union agreeing to help the company through a 'difficult financial spell' by accepting two hours less per week INSTEAD of a pay rise on two different occasions and at the company’s proposal.


4. Drastic cuts in sick pay: from 13 weeks full pay to 6 weeks full pay and 6 weeks half pay; abolition of sick pay for the first day of absence; no sick pay entitlement from day one of employment, only after 6 months;


5. The abolition of a daily ten-minute coffee break, brought in at the company's request to ease warehouse operations;


6. A drastic reduction in redundancy entitlements: from enhanced double statutory, to statutory, (ie, one week’s wages per year of service), raising fears that the company will get rid of workers, even close the Street Distribution Centre, just as they are closing their distribution centre in Kendal.  


7. Cuts to overtime rates to time thus giving no chance to increase pay"


8. No direct cuts to maternity pay or pension entitlements, BUT with a 15-20% cut in wages, pensions will suffer a drastic fall when taken out."


Dave Chapple, Secretary of Mendip TUC, said:

"I have personally, met four Clarks workers who fear losing their homes (Inability to pay rent, mortgage) and even lose contact with their children (If only able to afford a bedsit, unsuitable accommodation for children).


Is this the Clarks Quaker Family firm that was an iconic part of manufacturing, 'factory' Britain for 200 years?


Is this, even the Clarks family firm that, even when it closed all of its Somerset factories over a 15-year period, nonetheless treated its remaining Street HQ and warehouse workers, and their trades unions, with respect?


NO! Welcome to the "Brave New World" of Clarks' new owners Lion Rock Capital.


Hong Kong based, venture capitalist, hedge fund capitalist, slash and burn capitalist, just pick your most accurate label!


Is this really the future for work in this country: no more decent trades union recognition or collective bargaining negotiations, just industrial dictatorship, "take it or leave it" "Fire and rehire?” "


Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, says:

Andrew Pope

"Just what is going on at Clark's? What do the new owners think they are doing? Do they even know about the traditions of Clark's, or even care?

Many years ago, when I was doing my training to be a union representative and negotiator, I was stunned to hear that under a Labour Government (Blair/Brown), that Fire and Rehire was commonly done. Worse, it was allowed under UK law. In 13 years of Government, Labour failed to end Fire and Rehire.

Loosely, what Fire and Rehire means is that employers are able to dismiss employees on existing contracts, and force them to accept new terms and conditions in a new contract. If the employee does not sign the new contract, then they are deemed to no longer have a job.

Indeed, this is what happened in the large negotiation in the AXA Group of insurance companies, in which I represented thousands of employees in the harmonisation of terms of conditions, after AXA had taken over other companies. 

I pushed back when the directors of AXA said that the harmonisation would be done via the termination of existing contracts, but other union representatives and the union official explained to me that this was the way it was going to be done.

So I fought very hard to ensure that if this was going to be done, that there would be an absolute minimum of employees losing out.

This situation at Clark's is therefore horrendous to hear about. It is almost as if the new owners of Clark's, Lion Rock, want to force employees out and this Fire and Rehire is their tool of choice for achieving this, by cutting pay and conditions unilaterally, without the agreement of employees."


Somerset Independents is considering its next steps in relation to this dispute.