Showing posts with label Work. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Work. Show all posts

Thursday, July 28, 2022

Wages, Prices, Strikes and Disputes: Bridgwater MP Calls Rail Staff "Lazy and Incompetent" But Bridgwater Unions Say "Save Ticket Offices!"

 

Ian Liddell-Grainger Tory MP for
Bridgwater and West Somerset
(Photo: UK Parliament)

 

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We were formed to stand up for residents. And we hold councillors and MPs to account.

As we have reported, a whole host of workers are going on strike, in a wage-price spiral of inflation where inflation feeds on itself. Union leaders from the RMT (Mick Lynch) and Unite unions (Sharon Graham) have denied that their actions to gain above inflation pay increases, will lead to higher prices. They blame rail bosses and the Tory Government. Ms Graham said:

"I will not apologise for demanding and winning fair pay rises for my members".

The Tory Government, which seems unable to deal with inflation and the rising cost of living, is in dispute with rail unions.

Bridgwater Tory MP Ian Liddell-Grainger has attacked staff at Taunton Railway Station, in a speech in the House of Commons. He said:

"Another issue of confidence, on which we need an urgent debate, has come to my attention: Taunton station. 

The staff there are utterly lazy and incompetent. 

Those who are young, vulnerable, disabled or need help cannot get from one side of the station to the other, because passengers have to walk around a main road and up a ramp, taking all their suitcases with them; it makes Gatwick and Heathrow look positively balmy. It is beyond belief! 

Great Western Railway says it is inclusive and stands up for its customers—well, Taunton does not. Can we please have a debate on the issue before somebody gets injured or, worse, killed?"

At the same time, trade unions in the Bridgwater area are launching a campaign to "Save Somerset's Rail Station Ticket Offices".

Dave Chapple, Secretary of the Bridgwater and District Trades Union Council, told us:

"Rail union, RMT has launched a campaign to resist closure of 1000 rail station ticket offices across Britain, with the loss of thousands of jobs. Rail bosses will carry out a “consultation” in August, but it is clear that the plans are to start closures in October. It is clear that, without opposition from workers and the public, ALL rail stations in Somerset, and indeed the west country, will lose their ticket offices!

All passengers, especially disabled and elderly, and those with little experience of train travel, need on-station support and information. Without that support, many will be excluded from rail travel entirely.

This is all part of the wider, ongoing attack on jobs, pay and conditions in the privatised rail industry, which the RMT is fighting so bravely and with so much support. Train drivers’ union ASLEF is also taking widespread national strike action on 30th July. We support the rail unions on all fronts, and encourage everyone to get involved:

•    join a picket line near you on 30th July (ASLEF) and 18th and 20th August (RMT)

•    you can sign the petition to save ticket offices

•    write to your MP telling him to oppose the closures"

Meanwhile, a Labour MP has been fired for doing exactly what the unions are asking above - joining a picket line. The Labour Party removed Sam Tarry from his junior Shadow Minister post, saying that he must have "collective responsibility" and stick to the collective responsibility and agreed media lines. Unions have criticised the Labour Party. Ms Graham called Tarry's sacking an "insult to the trade union movement".

Somerset Independents has contacted Somerset Labour, Somerset Lib Dems and Somerset Tory MPs for comment on the rail strike. None of them have responded.

Have you written to your MP?

Did you get a response? We ask because residents regularly complain to us that the Somerset Tory MPs do not respond.

What do you think of the unions?

Tell us what you think.

 

Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Tuesday, July 26, 2022

Another Day, Another Strike: This Time It's the Railways (Again)

 

The RMT's Campaign Badge

One of our Official emblems

While the Conservatives continue their in-fighting, giving their members only a Hobson's choice between proven failure and potential disaster (Sunak and Truss), our country has another crisis on its hands - ANOTHER rail strike.

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We stand up for workers. And we try to give fair treatment to campaigners and those they are fighting.

Before the first strike, we contacted the local RMT branch with some questions. We asked the same questions of others but Somerset Labour, Somerset Lib Dems and Somerset Tories did not answer.

But the RMT's Barry West did answer and we published. He also gave us a statement. We did not publish it at the time.

Now we are publishing it. Mr West told us that this was:

"A dispute the RMT did not want and has done all it can to avert, and avoid.

The RMT are seeking reassurances around no compulsory redundancies, they are seeking to protect our members from scathing cuts in incomes for some, and for others it means job losses and changes  on a massive scale, this we believe in some cases would pose a serious safety risk to those that travel by rail.

The wholesale loss of ticket offices, huge changes to terms and conditions, changes to the pension scheme resulting in future hardship are amongst some of the issues.

The last dispute I can remember here in the South West was 1998.

So it is clear to many that rail workers are not militant, for many they have had a pay freeze for around 3 years, the rises in inflation affects rail workers also and I have heard many stories about how it is affecting them as it does many others at this time.

MPs I understand were to get a £2,212 pay rise on 1 April, seeing an MP's basic salary go up to £84,144 a year.

At a time when millions of workers had their wages hit by a National Insurance increase. 

 

And now huge rises in the cost of living and inflation at record high levels.

There has been overwhelming response and support from members and the General public."
 
 
Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Friday, October 22, 2021

UPDATE (22/3/22): P & O Ferries and Clark's - Like the Tories - Wrap Themselves in the Flag But Are Foreign-Owned and Run!

 

Standing Up For Somerset Residents

UPDATE (23/3/21): P & O Ferries write open letter back to the Conservative Minister Kwasi Kwarteng...

... and P & O CEO Peter Hebblethwaite uses many of the same phrases that Somerset's Conservative MPs and Ministers have been quoted by us as saying.

We said that Tory MPs parroted employers and this proves it.

For example, Hebblethwaite writes, in the letter published by the BBC:

"We saw no other viable means of preserving our iconic British business, saving the 2,200 remaining jobs it provides and protecting the 15% Britain's trade capacity it facilitates."
It's British and iconic, P & O Ferries, Hebblethwaite claims. 

Is P & O British or Not British? 

It is well-documented that P & O Ferries is owned by DP World, based in Dubai, which is not British.

In the same letter, P & O state that "all relevant vessels are registered outside of the UK". The names of the ships sound British. Let's have a look at each one...

Spirit of Britain is registered in Cyprus - not British

Pride of Hull in Bahamas - not British

Pride of Canterbury in Cyprus - not British

Pride of Kent in Cyprus - not British

The employees that were dismissed were from three companies - all registered in Jersey. Is Jersey British or not? Jersey is a Crown Dependency, has its own Parliament, its own identity internationally, and is not part of the United Kingdom.

Conclusions

You can make up your own minds on whether P & O Ferries is "British" or not.

P & O Ferries operate to and from ports in Britain and some of its workers are British residents. But that seems to be about it.

P & O Ferries seem to be as "British" as the foreign-owned Premier League football teams, one of which - Chelsea - has been forced to be sold off by the UK Government after sanctions were applied to Chelsea's owner.

Whether P & O Ferries will continue to operate to and from British ports, or whether another operator will take over, will test P & O's claim that their ferries are "iconic" or not.

Will UK Governments - Labour, Lib Dem or Tory - do anything to stop it being the same old story, when it comes to workers at sea?

Their track record suggests that they will not, because they are still not serving the people that they are supposed to serve - the British people.

Instead, these Westminster parties accept money from all sorts of the wrong sources and serve the wrong interests - themselves and their rotten parties.

---

UPDATE (20/3/21): According to ITV News reporting on The Sunday Times, Conservative Ministers "knew of P&O Ferries" plans to slash jobs.

The report says:

"The Sunday Times newspaper said it received a leaked memo apparently written by a senior Whitehall official which tried to “justify” the mass redundancies, stating that “without these decisions, an estimated 2,200 staff would likely lose their jobs”...
"The newspaper said it was “widely shared across government” and recipients included the Prime Minister’s private office while Transport Secretary Grant Shapps is understood to have received a copy."

This attitude by Tory MPs echoes the response that Somerset Independents received when it asked Somerset MPs about the Clark's dispute here in Somerset (Clark's is now Chinese-owned).

Liam Fox (Tory, North Somerset) and James Heappey (Tory, Wells) made pronouncements about the Clark's dispute. And both seem to think sacking workers or attacking their rights is OK - as long as the employer claims they are struggling and claims it is done to save other jobs.

Somerset Independents stands up for residents and for workers. We want to see good employers thrive. But P & O and Clark's are clearly not good employers.

Like Liam Fox - himself a former Minister - and Wells MP James Heappey - currently a Minister - both displayed a terrible attitude during the Clark's dispute in Heappey's constituency (see our earlier report below). Fox mentioned Heappey in his response to us.

In relation to P & O, Heappey told Sky News: 'that the government "cannot force an employer to continue to employ people that the employer has said it doesn't want to employ." 

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, himself a former union representative and negotiator, says: 

Andrew Pope

"The way the Whitehall memo is written - Heappey is a Minister - mirrors the way Somerset MP Liam Fox attempted to justify attacking Clark's workers, when we asked him about the Somerset dispute.

Mr Fox told us and I quote: 'It is clear that they are trying to maintain jobs at a time when they are losing money.  The alternative to the current plan seems to be increased redundancies which I am sure people would want to avoid.'

Whether it is James Heappey or Liam Fox, the attitude is very similar.

Both Clark's and P & O are struggling, and both have attempted to use the management failures to cut jobs and attack workers. And according to Tory MPs and Tory ministers, it seems it is OK to sack 800 workers to save 2,200 workers.

No, it isn't OK.

Poor strategic decisions from management failures should not lead to sackings or reductions in terms and conditions of employment.

It seems that whether it is here in Somerset or out at sea, Tory MPs put the needs and claims of employers first and the needs of employees a very distant last.

But Grant Shapps and other ministers have expressed their false horror at the treatment of P & O workers.

Tories pretend to care and say they are "reviewing" the legality of the actions of P & O.

Were Tory ministers aware, and are Labour MPs aware, that the law at sea is not the same as UK employment law?

When workers are at sea, they would surely be covered by international maritime law, not UK law? An example is the 2014 Maritime Labour Convention on Seafarer working and living rights.

As a former councillor in a port city, I asked similar questions when I heard from workers on cruise ships. I heard all about the undermining of workers and their rights at sea.

I understood that treating workers at sea in such a poor way, was commonly done by seafaring employers.

Does maritime law apply or UK law? Government ministers should be honest about it - surely they would be able to say - or are they so incompetent that they don't know?

If they did know about it, what did they do about it?

Labour had 13 years of Government to sort this out. The Tories have had 12 years in Government. The Lib Dems even had the Coalition.

But Labour, Tories and Lib Dems showed that they cannot be trusted to stand up for Somerset residents or stand up for workers.

They pretend that they care but when it comes to the crunch, neither used Government to change international maritime law to protect workers at sea.

It's yet another case of Labour, Lib Dem or Tory, it's the same old story."


---

UPDATE (25/10/21): Conservative MPs including Somerset's Conservative MPs voted down the Private Members Bill that Somerset Independents asked them to support. The Bill would limit Fire and Rehire, which the new owners of Clark's propose to use to attack the company's workers.

Worse than this, only two Somerset MPs have responded to our challenges. At the time of writing, no other MPs have responded. And even these two lame responses do not help Somerset's workers.

Dr Liam Fox

Dr Liam Fox, Conservative MP for North Somerset did not answer our questions. Instead, he produced what amounts to an attempt at an excuse for the owners of Clark's to do what they have done to the company's workers, and for what they propose to do - to cut terms and conditions of employment without consent from the workers themselves.

Dr Fox told Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope:

"I have been in touch with Clarks and the local MP, James Heappey.  I am not sure whether you are aware of the following facts.

There have been some employees working in the factory on superior contracts from pervious owners.  In order to avoid further redundancies, they have brought them all (potentially) to the same hourly pay.  Some getting a rise and some getting a reduction.  It must be noted that Clarks’ figures have recently been published and last year they lost £180 million.  The investment they have received was £100 million and that secured the future of Clarks and jobs for their employees.   It is clear that they are trying to maintain jobs at a time when they are losing money.  The alternative to the current plan seems to be increased redundancies which I am sure people would want to avoid."

James Heappey, Conservative MP for Wells, has told campaigners that he is negotiating with the company on behalf of constituents. 

Andrew Pope responds to the two Conservative MPs by saying:

Andrew Pope

"Most Somerset MPs, all of whom are Conservative, seem too busy or too ignorant to prioritise our challenges on behalf of Clark's workers.

Somerset Independents and other campaigners have asked Mr Heappey what alternative he suggests to strikes. He previously stated on the BBC that strikes are not the answer. But he does not seem to have any alternative course of action for the workers who are under attack by the owners of Clark's. He claims to be negotiating for them - where are the results of his "negotiations"?

As for Mr Fox - yes, I told that him that Somerset Independents were already aware of these "facts". Mr Fox seems to think it is OK for workers' pay and conditions to be attacked, after management made the wrong strategic decisions for Clark's. It is not the fault of these workers, but they are made to suffer for the management failures. It's not on.

Why do these Tory MPs think this is OK? It just isn't. Fire and Rehire just is not an acceptable way to treat Somerset's workers."

Somerset Independents will continue to challenge the owners and management of Clark's and Somerset's MPs who appear to back this appalling behaviour by Clark's.

---

Somerset Independents has been supporting the Clark's employees and their representatives, in their ongoing dispute with the employer, as reported in our article here. 

The Protests at Clark's

Mendip Trades Union Council (TUC) has asked us to support the Private Members Bill being proposed by Barry Gardiner MP.

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, has responded positively to their request. Andrew says:

Andrew Pope

"As I said in my previous statement, Fire and Rehire should not be allowed. I have been of this view ever since I was an employee and union representative in the UNIFI union. Yet despite 13 years of Government, Labour failed to ban it.

Having listened to the views of other Somerset residents and workers, and listened to Mendip TUC's request to support the Bill, Somerset Independents supports the broad aims and objectives of the Bill, but believes that due to flaws in the Bill, that it may lead to unintended consequences such as dismissal without any new contract being offered.

However, on balance, some of the provisions in the Bill are very important, and would help in the dispute at Clark's, so we are asking Somerset's MPs to support the Bill when it is voted on."


Friday, July 24, 2020

UPDATED (20/5/23) - Pope's Pandemic Prediction on Flexible Working Comes To Pass - Work Is Necessary - Offices and Shops Are Not


UPDATE (20/5/23): Pope's Pandemic Prediction on Flexible Working Comes To Pass
 
Commenting on discussions on the future of work, and predictions that he made during the Pandemic, Andrew Pope says:
 
Andrew Pope
 "As predicted by me here on the Somerset Independents website, changes to the workplace were needed and wanted by workers across the country. Flexible working will become law and become the norm to be available from the start, as reported by ITV News.
 
What is so remarkable is that this did not happen before the Pandemic. It should not have taken employers to have a Global Pandemic to listen to their workers. That this was necessary tells us a lot about employers.
Almost twenty years ago, when I was a union representative, I was advocating for flexible working in the IT industry, in the jobs that I and my fellow workers were doing. We already had remote working, yet were expected to go into the office. It was totally unnecessary and literally a waste of our time and of the company's time. That travel time could also be spent working.
Yet as shown in the ITV report, we still see resistance from dinosaurs like Jacob Rees-Mogg and Alan Sugar that seem to put their own property portfolios first, or bad employers that do not assess their workers on their output, rather than being fixated on their location or being able to watch over them.
Why do they need to be so overbearing on their workers and have to physically watch them?
It is completely unnecessary if they train and motivate their workers, and the work is rewarding.

If employers really need their workers to be on site, it should be for productivity reasons and legitimate reasons - not just that they do not trust their workers.
 
As I said then:
 
"If employers don't trust their employees, why did they employ them in the first place and why are they still employing them? Avenues exist for sorting out low productivity employees, such as training, support and ultimately, disciplinary and grievance procedures."

I am delighted that workers will now get flexible working rights and that it will be the law to be able to ask for them from day one."

---
UPDATE (24/6/22): Our predictions have proved correct again. As the national BBC News has reported, train strikes have not caused as much chaos as was feared, because of the effects of the Pandemic. As we suggested in the article below two years ago, long-term changes to how people work would occur. And they have.
 "The pandemic has meant many firms are now geared up to switch to remote working.

According to official figures, 38% of workers now spend some of the week working from home."

But the impact of the strikes has still been significant. As Craig Beaumont of the Federation of Small Businesses said yesterday on BBC Breakfast, there is a split in two of the workforce - those that can do their job remotely have been able to adjust with the agreement of their employers, but those who cannot do their job remotely have been inconvenienced or cannot work at all. 
 
There is a different impact and this may mean that the already lower paid suffer even more, during the cost-of-living crisis and inflation at record levels. And so the strikes are not only affected passengers, but workers outside the rail industry too.

Unlike many other local media in Somerset, we have strived to report on the impact of the train strikes and the Pandemic on Somerset residents and Somerset workers. 
 
We have also given the Right of Reply to those on strike - the RMT union, and Conservative MPs as well as Somerset Labour and Somerset Lib Dems. So far, only the RMT union and local TUC have replied to our questions.
 
---
 

In the original Think Piece below, written by our Leader Andrew Pope and published in July 2020, Andrew suggested that there would be long-term impacts of the Pandemic on businesses and employment.
 
This has turned out to be the case.
 
Andrew says:
Andrew Pope

"I was right to predict long-term changes. These can't be wished away by the Government, which is responsible for disruption, poverty, death and illness on a massive scale. Their job is to protect British citizens and British workers but they failed. 
Instead, here in Somerset, the Somerset Tories and Tory Government have imposed an unnecessary and unwanted change to our local councils. And as we've shown on this website repeatedly, and when speaking at meetings, the local Tories at Somerset County Council failed to stand up against the Government.

David Fothergill and his Tory cronies are lickspittles of the worst kind - of the failure that is Boris Johnson.

Boris Johnson's Government seems to want to wish away the Pandemic, all the deaths and illnesses and disruption to businesses that happened when Johnson was supposed to be in charge as Prime Minister, and to forget that it ever happened. Johnson has no authority.
 
Johnson wants us to pretend that Covid-19 is just like the common cold. But it isn't. The Pandemic is not over, but Johnson wants to pretend that it is. I've heard it this week from Conservative councillors here in Somerset - and a Tory on Question Time - claiming that "Partygate" should be "got over". No, it should not. The audience at Question Time laughed, but they were angry at Boris Johnson's lies when he misled Parliament.
 
We know that Johnson's own staff at Downing Street, ignored the rules - ignored the law - that Johnson's own Government set and which MPs across the House of Commons supported. Then Boris Johnson lied about his own Downing Street staff and his own Government. 
This is why Somerset Tories don't want to comment when I have challenged them to. They put their Party first and residents last.

Johnson does not seem to have any authority, even amongst his own staff. And he certainly has no authority amongst Somerset people.

So going back to my predictions... 
The Think Piece that I wrote nearly two years ago, suggested that office work would reduce. It has massively reduced. I suggested that shops would close. As shown below, they have closed on a huge scale.

Now that infections are at record levels, the Financial Times is reporting "offices emptying fast". When will the Government help employers to make the changes that are permanent? Our country has been saddled with crippling debts for future generations to pay off but employment is struggling to adapt. The latest P & O Ferries debacle is just one example.
Some employers are taking the initiative, but this is no thanks to the Government who it is clear, are controlled by special interests instead of the national interest.

Whether Government wants to pretend or not, it is the British public and British employers, that have to try to adjust to long-term and permanent changes to employment in Britain that were caused by the Pandemic and the Government's slow response to the Pandemic. 
Government should help, but it was more of a hindrance than a help. And it is still a hindrance by operating wishful thinking instead of dealing with reality.

This Government has shown that with Covid-19, as with pretty much anything else, the British Government is largely impotent or incompetent at dealing with the things that matter to British people. 
Did Labour offer any realistic alternative nationally? No, it did not.

Did the Somerset Lib Dems offer any realistic alternative locally? No, it did not.

Once again, it's another case or Labour, Lib Dem or Tory, same old story."
 
--- 

UPDATE (19/2/22): The BBC's Business Correspondent Emma Simpson has written an article showing that "more than 17,000 chain store shops closed last year". 
 
As our Leader Andrew Pope suggested in the below article from July 2020, existing trends of closures have been continued and magnified during the Pandemic. The trends in Andrew's article have turned out to be correct. 
 
The research mentioned in the BBC article was conducted by Price Waterhouse Coopers (PwC) and these results "reflect the rise of online shopping and the impact of the pandemic."
 
Andrew says:
 

 
"Somerset Independents wants to see Somerset thrive and if Somerset is to thrive, it is important that trends are recognised and opportunities for business are supported by local authorities and national Government.
 
We will continue to try to identify these opportunities so that we can meet the aims of Somerset Independents to stand up for residents and workers, and to promote businesses in Somerset.
 
We don't just say that we do this. It is written in our Constitution and we listen to act for residents, workers and businesses."

---
 
UPDATE (6/5/21): The BBC reports huge changes to how and where people work, as predicted by the Think Piece below, which Andrew Pope wrote and we published in July 2020.
 
People want to work from home more, and it seems that companies are responding to the requests. In the piece, employers say that they will allow their employees to choose, and a hybrid model of office and home working will allow this.
 
--- 
 
UPDATE (16/8/20): The BBC reports on more research that shows that people want to work from home.
 

Coronavirus: Appetite grows for home working and local lockdowns

"King's College London (KCL) has been tracking attitudes during the pandemic.

Results from a survey reveal that 86% believe that, until a vaccine is found, workers should be able to decide whether they returned to the office.

Experts said the results show people are prioritising public health over the economy and their social lives."

 
---
 
UPDATE (31/7/20): The BBC reports on a range of people who want to carry on working from home, and more survey research supporting it. Meanwhile, the workplace advisory service ACAS are still advising that:

"Staff should continue to work from home if they can."

Andrew Pope says:

"From anecdotal reports and survey evidence, it is clear that people want to carry on working from home. What will be interesting to see is how many of them continue to do so, and how many of them will return to offices. A lot of this will be to do with employment law and the power relationships between employers and employees. Employers and employees may tray to argue that there has been a variation of the employment contract through "custom and practice". And both sides may try specious arguments to make their case.
 
We will see how it pans out, but I believe that this is a pivotal moment that needs to be grasped to make positive lasting change that should have happened years ago."
---

UPDATE (25/7/20): The i reports latest research showing that employers and employees agree with our suggestions that changes are needed and wanted.

---

Co-Founder of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope writes...

Somerset Independents has already written about the changes to education that have been brought about by the Covid-19 virus, in our piece "Education Is Compulsory - School Is Not". Somerset residents have responded positively to our reminder that parents have the choice as to how to educate their children.

In contrast, vested interests such as national Government, local councils, headteachers, teachers and unions are struggling to cope with the realisation that they have to adjust or they will soon be redundant. They are desperately asserting that "school is best", even when responsible parents have seen from their own experiences that home education is the best for their children and for the bonding of their family. The limitations of schools pre-existed Covid-19 and they have been exposed and exacerbated by the National Emergency.

We believe that permanent changes to the workplace, and to retail, have also occurred. With reports of London's Oxford Street and Bond Street being as "dead as a dodo" today (a Friday), it is a fact that existing trends have been exacerbated.

Again, vested interests such as the British Retail Consortium, the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) and the Trades Union Congress (TUC) are struggling to cope with the realisation that times have changed. Like in education, they regularly try to justify their own existence by carping on about their members being under threat. They are definitely right to be unsure about the health and safety of their members - at schools, in shops or in the workplace. But the problems with workplaces and retail have pre-existed Covid-19. Consumers have been ripped off for too long. Better ways exist.

For many years, employers and employees have had the ability to agree "flexible working". These changes were originally only for parents, but more and more workers have agreed to change their working practises. Done properly and working it out together, it can be a great situation for employer and employee - as long as higher productivity is the result. Workers feel that they are more productive, the latest surveys have shown, as reported by The i. Workers have suffered for too long. Productivity has struggled to reach the levels in other countries. Better ways exist.

With the advent of the Coronavirus and the lockdown, it has been essential for workers to use remote digital technologies and broadband to be able to carry on their work. As the New Statesman has pointed out, office-working has become home-working. And workers want it to continue. Yet there are vested interests that want to stop them - the Government thinks that they should travel to work, just to prop up cafes, restaurants and pubs that service workers. No, we say - the economy can change to be more efficient and productive.

For some, this has led to home-shirking, with employers not able to "supervise" them at home.

Others have been furloughed by their employers to be paid with Government money, but still forced to work. There has been fraud of the Government bailouts. More unintended consequences occur when legislation is rushed - despite the virus being known about for at least three months before the legislation. And then law enforcers get over-run. That is for another article...

Yet workers have realised that the commute is unnecessary. Commuting for hours every day can be better spent with loved ones, or being more productive. And travel money can be saved.

Workers have realised that the office is redundant. Not only is it unnecessary, it is unsafe and unhealthy.

Some employers worry that too much home-working leads to home-shirking, but shouldn't they evaluate their employees on productivity, not on the number of hours spent in the office? Surely productivity is better than presenteeism?

If employers don't trust their employees, why did they employ them in the first place and why are they still employing them? Avenues exist for sorting out low productivity employees, such as training, support and ultimately, disciplinary and grievance procedures.

Or do some unscrupulous employers know that their jobs are so unsatisfying, so unworthy of human attentions, that the only way to sustain them is to use a form of Jeremy Bentham's Panopticon to surveil their workers? That is, the office as a Panopticon? If they do, it needs to stop and they need to think again.

Obviously, not all jobs can be done remotely. Farming, manufacturing, construction, hairdressing and more, have to be done in-person.

But with modern Information and Communications Technology (ICT), so many jobs can be done remotely. Hybrid arrangements such as hot-desking, and only essential in-person meetings, are possible and we would argue, desirable.

And as for shops being necessary? Are they really? Not any more.

E-commerce has grown year-on-year. Now, with the lockdown, it has boomed. In-person retail was already struggling, but the lockdown has meant that people have flocked online to buy. Only today, the ONS has confirmed that 30% of sales are online.

The ONS said via the BBC:
"But the real growth has been in online sales. Online sales continue to go from strength to strength."
Delivery companies are recruiting massively. eBay even bailed out the Government who had massively failed to protect health and care workers by providing enough PPE to the NHS, with its eBay NHS Portal.

People are realising that it is not necessary to use transport to live their lives, or to buy stuff. Cars, trains, planes and buses are unnecessary for so many things.

With better planning, decent broadband - especially in rural areas, the right delivery networks and home delivery with safe working practices for customers and staff, a new, more efficient and safer way of buying and selling is possible.

Not only is it possible, it is desirable for the reduction of energy usage, slashing the use of carbon fuels (e.g. as delivery company DPD are doing with their increased rollout of electric vehicles) and the reduction in natural resources.

There are better ways to live. The virus has forced them on us to a certain extent. But those existing malaises have been exposed and now the existing trends have been exacerbated.

And if there is a silver lining to the monstrous Covid-19 clouds, it is that the future of work and retail can change for the better. It's a massive opportunity, but it needs to be taken.

It requires Government to invest in making those changes, instead of artificially propping up already dying sectors of our economy, and their old and failed working practises.

Our country has been there before, in the 1970s and 1980s and it took decades of pain for our country to adjust. Let's learn from those mistakes NOW, with gradual adjustment and radical thinking.

Andrew Pope, M.Sc. Social Sciences (Soton)