Showing posts with label Somerset County Council. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Somerset County Council. Show all posts

Friday, July 22, 2022

Tories Go, Chief Executive Goes: Lib Dem Councillors at Somerset County Council Appoint New Chief Executive

Tory Councillor David Fothergill
is now ex-Leader of the Council

 

One of our Official emblems

 

Somerset Independents puts residents first. The Tories at Somerset County Council conspired with Boris Johnson's Tory Government to force through changes to Somerset's councils - against the wishes of the majority of Somerset's residents. If you remember, previously they had cancelled an election in which our candidates were ready to stand. Then we boycotted the 2022 elections which were not cancelled.

So we laughed with glee when Councillor David Fothergill refused to speak to the Local Democracy Reporter Daniel Mumby. He blamed "inappropriate" coverage by Mr Mumby. But everyone knows it was because the Tories had lost so many council seats in the May 2022 elections and Fothergill was having a strop.

Councillor Fothergill was, until then, the Leader of Somerset County Council. Now his "Local Conservatives" had lost control of the Council. Fothergill's candidates tried distancing themselves from Boris Johnson's corrupt Government despite working hand-in-glove with them - including proven dodgy Cabinet Member Robert Jenrick - to change Somerset's councils. Johnson has gone and so has Fothergill. Good riddance to both of them.

Sadly, the Lib Dems gained from the Tory demise. Lib Dem or Tory, same old story.

When the Lib Dems took majority control of the County Council, they discovered that Chief Executive Pat Flaherty was leaving to go to Harrow. Not the school, but the Council. Obviously they may have persuaded him to leave. These details are not shared with the public - see our reports on other senior officers at Somerset's councils who left under a cloud of mystery. The public just pay the council officer's huge wages, possibly huge severance package and suffer when they cut services against what the public wants or needs.

So the new Fib Dem councillors had to appoint a new Chief Executive. And they have chosen Duncan Sharkey. Unlike the lazy and censored news outlets in and around Somerset, Somerset Independents does not parrot press releases. If you want to read what Somerset County Council wants you to read, you can go to their website and see a huge photo of Mr Sharkey's impression of the Cheshire Cat from Alice in Wonderland. We include the same photo but much smaller.

Duncan Sharkey

Mr Sharkey is currently Managing Director at the Royal Borough of Windsor and Maidenhead. You can go and find out about what has happened there, if you know how to look.

It seems that we know more about Mr Sharkey than other media outlets. 

And it seems that we know more about Mr Sharkey's performance at previous councils than the Lib Dem councillors that hired him. Or perhaps they omitted some information from the County Council's PR spin?

Nice things are said about these highly-paid council officers by councillors when they join. 

Nice things are said about them when they leave by councillors (usually). Sometimes honest councillors make balanced assessments in public, but not often.

Mr Sharkey will be paid:

  • £195,000 per year. Yes, you read that right:
  • £16,250 per month or 
  • £3,750 per week. 

This is what the Lib Dem councillors have decided.

Will Mr Sharkey be worth this huge sum? 

Will Mr Sharkey be able to cope with the huge change of scale from a Borough Council to the New Somerset Council that covers a much larger area and will destroy the district councils AND County Council, and take on bad debts, suffer proven bad councillors and take on the disastrous legacies of the districts and county councils? 

And does Mr Sharkey know where the skeletons are in the closet, some of which have been exposed by Somerset Independents and Somerset Tory MP Ian Liddell-Grainger (where are the other MPs - filling their coffers with Boris Johnson's corrupt payroll, or under investigation by Parliament)?

Somerset residents, who will pay his extortionate salary, are about to find out all of the above when he finally takes up the post in a few months time - the County says "the Autumn" which is a bit vague. The reasons for the vagueness were not explained.

Is Mr Sharkey "the boss" as described by the BBC's part-time reporter Ruth Bradley? No, he is the Head of Paid Service. The councillors are supposed to be the boss, especially Councillor Bill Revans but also his Cabinet. Councillors are supposed to represent the public.

But as readers of this website will know, many councillors lack the leadership required, and rely on officers who then can run things in their interests instead of the public interest. The proverbial "Sir Humphrey" as fans of Yes, Prime Minister will know.

That is not democracy, but bureaucracy. Sadly that seems to be all-too-common at Somerset's councils because the Lib Dem or Tory councillors are not up to the job.

Time will tell in all of these things.


Who Are Somerset Independents?

We inform Somerset residents. We advise Somerset residents to be able to stand up for themselves and to hold to account national and local authority.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Tuesday, May 3, 2022

EXPOSED: We Reveal How Former Tory Councillor Neil Bloomfield Broke The Law and Voted on Your Council Spending Despite Being Banned

 

Martock "Independent" Councillor Neil Bloomfield

UPDATE (6/5/22): Neil Bloomfield LOST his attempt to be elected to the New Somerset Council.

---

In March, Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope followed up on our previous investigations into councillors who persistently failed to pay their council tax. 

Neil Bloomfield is a Martock councillor and represents the area on South Somerset District Council AND Somerset County Council. He claims to be "independent" but is actually a former Conservative. 

To this day (2 days before the elections in which he is standing), including on his election literature and social media, Bloomfield promotes himself as "independent" but usually votes with the Tories on the councils.

So we believe that Neil Bloomfield is a Tory sheep in independent clothing. It would be interesting to know how many voters are aware of this.

Our investigations showed that Neil Bloomfield had persistently and knowingly failed to pay his council tax over months and years.

Councillor Bloomfield has not answered our questions.

He has not resigned either.

So, in March, we challenged Somerset County Council officers as to why they did not bother to check whether councillors had paid their council tax.

As we have previously shown, councillors who persistently fail to pay are DISBARRED (LEGALLY BANNED) from voting on council tax-related matters.

This is the legal opinion that we have showed to all four district councils and Somerset County Council.

Yet Somerset County Council failed to check.

And Cllr Bloomfield voted to spend YOUR money at the County Council.

He also failed to declare his arrears at the required time at the Budget Meeting of the County Council, despite clearly being told by Somerset County Council officers that he must declare his arrears.

So according to the legal advice that we have, Cllr Neil Bloomfield broke the law repeatedly.

We asked Somerset County Council to report Cllr Bloomfield to Avon and Somerset Police.

To our knowledge, Somerset County Council have failed to do so.

Voters go to the polls this Thursday.

If Councillor Neil Bloomfield is elected, he will be elected as a councillor who has committed offences and who has broken the law. 

And Somerset County Council will have failed to act, despite being made aware by us and being asked by us to review its decisions and despite the evidence being in the minutes of Somerset County Council meetings - here is the link to the Minutes - it is also copied below*.

It is not easy to see on the County Council website's version of the Minutes that Bloomfield voted - whether this is a deliberate attempt to cover it up or not we leave you to decide.

Here it is though, we've recovered it:


Somerset County Council officers have also tried to equivocate instead of answering our questions. The facts are shown in their own Minutes, and we copy them here. We are considering whether to take the matter further.

We repeat our call for all candidates for elected office to be subject to criminal records checks before becoming a candidate and also when in service to residents as a councillor or MP or Police and Crime Commissioner.

Trust is at historic lows in elected politicians.

People like Neil Bloomfield are doing little to enhance trust.


* From the official Minutes of the Somerset County Council meeting in February 2021 (emphasis added)

"Agenda item

Declarations of Interest

Details of all Members’ interests in District, Town and Parish Councils can be viewed on the Council Website at

County Councillors membership of Town, City, Parish or District Councils and this will be displayed in the meeting room (Where relevant).

The Statutory Register of Member’s Interests can be inspected via request to the Democratic Service Team.

 

Minutes:

The Chair reminded the meeting that details of all Members’ interests in District, Town and Parish Councils could be viewed on the Council’s Website and there is no need for members to individually declare these personal interests in those other councils at the meeting.

 

Members were reminded that the Monitoring Officer had granted a dispensation to enable all elected members to participate and vote on setting the Revenue Budget, Council Tax levels and the Members Allowance Scheme.  Any member who had an amount of Council Tax due to be paid which had been unpaid for at least two months needed to declare that as they could not take part in the vote relating to the Budget."

 

Saturday, October 30, 2021

Arrears Of The Year: Somerset's Rogue Councillors Who Didn't Pay Their Council Tax

 

The Rogue Councils Were All Lib Dem-Run or Tory-Run

Somerset Independents stands up for residents. 

We have investigated all 250+ district and county councillors, to find those who persistently did not pay their council tax.

By "persistently", we mean councillors who were two months or more in arrears. 

Their names? Bloomfield, Clarke, Durdan, Hayden, Hodgson, Osborne, Pailthorpe. 

The councils they are on? Mendip District, Somerset County, South Somerset District, Somerset West and Taunton District.

Read on to find out more.

It is AGAINST THE LAW and a CRIMINAL OFFENCE to vote on council tax-related matters when a councillor is persistently in arrears.

Green, Lib Dem, Tory and Fake Independent Councillors
Did Not Pay Their Council Tax

As we have made clear on many occasions, we have not pursued private individuals on their arrears in paying up. In fact, we have spoken up for hard-pressed residents when councillors have increased council tax without a Referendum. 

But councillors are not private individuals. They hold public and elected office, funded by the taxpayer. They are there to represent you. But we have found too many who have brought the office of councillor into disrepute.

Councillors increased your council tax during the Covid-19 Pandemic.

As described on this website, our officers turned up and spoke at ALL four district council budget meetings and the County Council budget meeting in February 2021, PLUS the Police and Crime Panel. We asked councillors to NOT put your council tax up.

But councillors at all councils did put YOUR COUNCIL TAX up.

So have all councillors been paying THEIR council tax? No, they have not.

We have documented the responses from the district councils and county council on this website, to our questions.

Councils attempted to cover up the wrongdoing of their councillors.

Some councils gave us the information without a problem - Sedgemoor, Somerset West and Taunton, and Somerset County Council. They did what they were supposed to do - answer our questions under the Freedom of Information Act.

But two councils obstructed our enquiries and have not answered our questions.  Mendip District Council and South Somerset District Council have broken the law on Freedom of Information and in other legal respects.

Private Eye and The Leveller have helped us to report on those councils and the councillors that the councils have tried to protect.

Speaking to The Leveller for their lead article in the October edition of the newspaper, Andrew Pope, Leader of Somerset Independents said:

Andrew Pope
 

"Somerset Independents is a campaign group formed to stand up for residents.

When we discovered that councillors had not paid their council tax, we were incensed. So as volunteers, we investigated the councillors of all districts and the County council.

We asked councillors directly at their February Budget meetings to not increase council tax during the Pandemic. But they did. Yet some councillors did not pay themselves - some of them did not pay over many months and even years. They hold public office but have brought it into disrepute.

Residents told us that these councillors should resign. We agree."

Andrew adds: 

"Now we have forced the councils to expose their rogue councillors, it is in the public interest that we publish the list of councillors who were persistently in arrears.

We have offered the Right of Reply to our questions to all of these councillors.

Too many of these councillors ignored our offer and those who did respond did not answer our questions fully and frankly. Some of them lied. Some of them were obnoxious. All of them were persistently in arrears, some of them over years.

They should all go, and go now. We will be publishing more details about them and the lengths their councils have gone to, in order to prevent the public knowing about their wrongdoing."

 

Arrears Of The Year... Or Rogues Gallery?

In alphabetical order of surname, the councillors who were persistently not paying their council tax are as follows. Click the links for their contact details if you want to ask them why they did not pay. 


Lib Dem, Green or Tory, Same Old Story
 

 

Councillor Neil Bloomfield (South Somerset District Council and Somerset County Council)

Councillor Neil Bloomfield

Independent (resigned from the Conservatives) Councillor for Martock Ward and Martock Division on Somerset County Council.

We offered him a right of Reply. His response was bizarre and unrepentant.

Councillor Bloomfield told us, while not answering our questions on his arrears:

"I’ve been in private eye twice now but first time for this...Yes was behind, now I’m ahead (I hope) and no I won’t be resigning."


Councillor Paul Bolton (Somerset West and Taunton Council)

Councillor Paul Bolton

Independent Councillor for Alcombe.

The Mayor of Minehead told us that he had paid up, following our investigation. He did not initially reply to our correspondence, so we used other ways of contacting him. When we did speak to him - he rang us - he did give some answers but he also claimed that we had not contacted him before - a false claim. More in our report here. The Leveller has reported on him in their October issue.



Councillor Louise Clarke (South Somerset District Council) 

Councillor Louise Clarke

Liberal Democrats Councillor for Martock Ward.

We offered her a Right of Reply. She did not respond. We have extended the time offered for a response.

 

Councillor Kelly Durdan (Somerset West and Taunton Council)

Councillor Kelly Durdan

Independent (former Conservative candidate) Councillor for Creech St. Michael.

We offered her a Right of Reply. She did not respond. We phoned her. She was obnoxious, did not answer our questions, and hung up, without providing any explanation. The Leveller has reported on her in their October issue.

 

Councillor Francis Hayden (Mendip District Council)

Councillor Francis Hayden

Green Party Councillor for Cranmore, Doulting and Nunney.

We offered him a Right of Reply. He did not respond with answers, and was obnoxious in his response. He even bragged about it in public, claiming that he prioritised his wife's business first. He refused to resign. The Leveller has reported on him in their October issue, citing our evidence that he committed criminal offences in voting on council tax-related matters. Mendip District Council has told Somerset Independents, and The Leveller, that they would change the way they worked on the issue of council tax.


Councillor Ben Hodgson (South Somerset District Council)

Councillor Ben Hodgson

Liberal Democrats Councillor for Crewkerne.

We offered him a Right of Reply. He did not respond. We have extended the time offered for a response.

 

Councillor Sue Osborne (South Somerset District Council)

Councillor Sue Osborne

Conservative Party Councillor for Windwhistle.

We offered her a Right of Reply. She did not respond. We have extended the time offered for a response.

 

Councillor Robin Pailthorpe (South Somerset District Council)

Councillor Robin Pailthorpe
 

Liberal Democrats Councillor for Crewkerne.

We offered him a Right of Reply. He did not respond. We have extended the time offered for a response.

 

UPDATE: We have also investigated North Somerset Council, Bath and North East Somerset Council and Bristol City Council. More information on all eight of our investigations is on this article here.

 

What Happens Next?

Hopefully these councillors will search their conscience and speak to the their constituents to see what they think, and whether residents think that they should resign as a councillor. 

Are any of the above councillors your councillor? Get in touch with us to tell us what you think. We have asked a lot of residents what they think about these councillors - in a democracy, residents' views are the views that really matter. 

No resident has told us that they think it is OK. In fact, many of them told us that these councillors should resign. We agree.

We will be publishing more details on each councillor's arrears and how they reacted to our investigation.

You may have noticed that they are all councillors at district councils run by the Liberal Democrats or the County Council that is run by the Conservatives. All of them except one is a Liberal Democrat or Tory. 

Only one of them was elected as an Independent (Bolton) but he is nothing to do with Somerset Independents, and if he was, we would have expelled him from our Party following due investigation.

We will expose councillors' wrongdoing, whether they are of the national political parties or of no party.

Our investigations are continuing, and we have involved the Information Commissioner's Office, as documented elsewhere on this website.

Standing Up For Residents and Taxpayers


 



Wednesday, October 13, 2021

Somerset's Worrying Covid-19 Trends: We Challenge The Authorities Again

 

Standing Up For Somerset Residents

During the entire Global Pandemic of Covid-19, Somerset Independents has challenged councils, councillors, MPs and national Government.

Unlike the national political parties and their elected representatives, we actually have stood up for residents.

It is in our Constitution that as residents ourselves, that our officers and supporters work together with other residents, to stand together.

Residents are extremely concerned at the Covid-19 infection trends in Somerset and the West of England.

So our officers Andrew Pope and Denise Wyatt wrote again to the Director of Public Health for Somerset, Trudi Grant.

We said:

"Further to our earlier correspondence with you and your staff, for which we thank you again, we are writing to express our great concern at the Covid-19 data for Somerset, especially for the Mendip District Council area.

For much of the Pandemic, Mendip and the other council areas for which you are responsible, have been in the lower part of the infection rates for our region.

However, Mendip is now the worst area, as presented by the BBC two days ago on BBC Points West and shown in the official figures as documented by the BBC here:


The questions followed in our letter. 

You can see the full questions and Ms Grant's responses to our questions, below.

Tell us what you think of the questions and the answers.

 

"Dear Mr Pope and Ms Wyatt

 

Thank you for your email.  To follow up your queries, please find responses below;

 

Q1. Please can you provide an explanation for this, with the evidence that you have to support your explanation?

 

Case rates in Mendip as you reference have been higher, but for the last 7 days reporting 1-7th October, rates are beginning to decline now 466.3/100,000. This is still higher than regional average. I believe in part this is probably caused by lower population immunity levels, acquired through natural immunity due to previously low levels within this district.  School age children and staff linked to education settings made up 68% of Mendip’s cases (30/9-6/10/21)

 

Q2. Please can you tell us why it is deemed, as reported on BBC Points West, that schools are deemed the source of infection, and the cause of the high infection rates? The BBC report seemed to suggest that schools were at fault. Why is this thought please? 

 

Schools are in no way at fault, but the school environment is one of the main sources of transmission currently, 68% of cases in Mendip the last week were linked to school children or staff.  Our local schools have been brilliant and SCC Public Health are working very hard with them to help put control measures in place within each school,  as per the DfE Contingency Framework. 

 

Q3. Please can you tell us what influence, if any, the mass gatherings at the Bath and West Showground have had, and what evidence there is that these are influential, or no influential on infections?  

 

Based on the information gathered through the National Test and Trace system, we have no evidence that the Bath & West Showground is featuring in the common places visited by cases prior to their disease onset.

 

Q4. What data on infections, and what actions to control infections, are Bath and West REQUIRED to carry out and what involvement do you have as DPH? 

 

SCC has funded a Covid event officer post for Somerset, hosted by Mendip DC, to work with event organisers and ensure events go ahead as Covid19 secure as possible and relevant to their setting.  This officer engages early with event organisers to review their event management plans with specific reference to controlling the risk of transmission of Covid-19.  For larger events, members of my team also attend pre-event planning meetings to ensure the public health advice is part of the consideration.  To note, that it is the event organiser, rather than the Bath and West Showground itself, which devises and implements the plan. 

 

Q5. Would you agree therefore, that the cancellation of the Pilton "Equinox" Festival had a positive effect on reducing infection in the Mendip area, and Somerset more widely?  

 

We cannot say for sure that by cancelling these events, there was a positive effect on reducing infection as it’s always hard to count what has been prevented. However, the more people we mix with, the more chance the virus has to spread. Under the new national CONTAIN framework, it is for individuals to make these choices. As DPH we make information materials available to help people make informed choices. We are about to launch a public health campaign to help inform people decisions. If you follow my twitter account, it would be great if you could help spread the reach of the campaign by retweeting these messages to your members.

 

Event organisers have worked very productively with us throughout the pandemic and have listened to public health advice.

 

Q6. And similarly to Q4, the same for the Nass Festival? 

 

Please see the above reply regarding the Equinox Festival.  The same answer applies to the NASS Festival.

 

Q7. Somerset Independents campaigned against both Nass and Equinox from going ahead, because of the threat to Somerset residents' health, and we were very disappointed that Mendip Council officers treated both events as if they were not a danger. Why did you as Director of Public Health, allow them to do so? 

 

Nationally the decision has been taken to allow events of all forms and sizes to go ahead.  Obviously, as previously stated, where there are gatherings of people there is always an increased risk of infection, but we can mitigate risks as much as possible.  As you know, this whole pandemic has been a balance of risk, in the case of events, balancing the risk of infection with the risk to the events industry.  We need to learn to live with this virus, and part of that has to be opening up events.   As mentioned above, Mendip District Council hosts the event officer and works proactively alongside SCC Public Health, and with event organisers, to support events going ahead with appropriate covid19 mitigations in place in accordance with the legal framework.

 

Q8. If you do not have the data to answer the above questions with credibility, please can you tell us why you do not have the data, and what you are doing about it?  

 

We do have all the available data.

 

Thank you for your ongoing support, it is greatly appreciated.

 

With best wishes

 

Trudi

 

 

Professor Trudi Grant,  MSc, UKPHR, FFPH

Director of Public Health

Somerset County Council

 

Visiting Professor, Centre for Public Health and Wellbeing, UWE Bristol"

 

Tuesday, June 29, 2021

UPDATE (30/7/21): Tory-Run County Council and Nunney Parish Council APPROVE MORE QUARRIES! We Join Residents Who Say No

Standing Up For Residents


UPDATE (30/7/21): Incredibly, the Conservative Party-led County Council has APPROVED the re-opening of Bartletts Quarry in Nunney. But in January 2021, they had refused it!

What a spectacular u-turn involving Conservative Party Councillor Philip Ham. Yes, the same Councillor Ham involved in the highly controversial Sandys Hill Lane development, also near Frome. 

Shepton Mallet County Councillor John Parham, also a Conservative, chairs the Council's Regulation Committee that approved the re-opening of the quarry.

---

UPDATE (2/7/21):  In its investigation of what local councillors have done to try to stop the Westdown Quarry from being re-opened, Somerset Independent has discovered that nearby Nunney Parish Council APPROVED the application, instead of listening to local residents who have objected. 

We are investigating:

  1. how this could have happened,
  2. why three parish councillors were absent from the meeting
  3. why a recorded vote was called for prior to the approval of the applications

An extract from the minutes of the Parish Council are below:

In case,you can't read it, it reads:

"Cllr Ramsay asked for a recorded vote. Those in favour of approval Cllrs Russell, Walford, Barrett and Ramsay. Those for refusal Clegg."

Presumably Cllr Russell means Cllr Sadler.

Somerset Independents will be contacting these councillors to ask them why they voted this way, and whether there were any interests that they should have declared. No interests were declared by any councillor, as you can see in the further extract below.

Yes, three parish councillors were absent when these vital planning applications were considered:


The parish councillors absent were Councillors Francis Hayden (also Mendip District Councillor for Nunney, Cranmore and Doulting, and the same councillor who didn't pay his council tax for at least ten months, as we investigated and reported on this website), Pia McGee and Ron Warwick.

To say again, the approval for re-opening was voted on by councillors with four in favour and one against. If these councillors had been present, it could have been a tied vote.

Quite why Cllr Ramsay asked for a recorded vote is interesting. Also interesting is that two people from Hanson's were there.

---

Residents say the proposed re-opening of Westdown Quarry, near Nunney, is a quarry too far.

It is a quarry that is quarrelsome. Residents are objecting to the proposals.

We have listened to the complaints from residents about the trucks on our roads and their impact on road safety on inadequate roads.

We have listened to the complaints from residents about the impact on the environment, on wildlife and on residents' lifestyles.

Somerset already has big problems with too much quarrying, with the impacts felt across the County and also over the border in Wiltshire. For example, the Maiden Bradley Weightwatchers have been campaigning in their area for residents there. But the problems impact on such a wide area, with so many quarries.

There seems to be a rush to get permissions to quarry.

Somerset Independents listens to residents and we act with residents on the issues that matter to them.

So our Officer Denise Wyatt put together the following objection to the application. It is an objection on behalf of residents that has been submitted to Somerset County Council.

Tell us what you think about the plans.


"Residents group Somerset Independents strongly objects to applications:
SCC/3795/2021, SCC/3836/2021, SCC/3837/2021, SCC/3838/2021


Our Objection is the same for all four applications and is attached in this document.


1.
Traffic
The increase use HGVs on undesignated roads is a continuing problem.
We support Maiden Bradley Weightwatchers objections:
“The B3092 is routinely used by Hansons and other business partners in
the quarry and construction industry as a ‘short-cut’. Convoys of HGVs
are blight on the well-being of our community. Our goal is to enforce
the Weight Limit agreed in 2011 for the B3092 and for HGV traffic to
use the designated strategic freight routes”
Somerset’s roads are full of these trucks. Many of the roads are totally inadequate
and the driving is atrocious. The negative impact on road safety continues.
There is also a lack of information on tonnage to be moved which the
developer claims will not require any additional vehicle movements.
Their claims are not credible. Neither are the claims about rail use credible.
2.
The Environment
The effects on the wildlife particularly Asham Wood which is an SSSI
is totally unacceptable.
National England also advised that “It is not clear that sufficient
consideration has been given to the risk to bats”
The increase in noise and dust has been insufficiently addressed by
the developer.
The overall effects on the water table have not been demonstrated.
Many properties in the area also have a private water system. The
effects of this development have not addressed the water supply to
local communities.
3.
County Council Policy
The County Council policy SMP3 requires evidence of clear economic
benefit to the local and/or wider communities and, that appropriate
mitigation measures are in place to ensure that any
adverse impacts to local communities and the environment are at
acceptable levels.
The County Council Regulations Committee on the 14th January 2021
RESOLVED: “that both Application No. SCC/3742/2020 and Application
No. SCC/3748/2020 be REFUSED as the applicant had provided
insufficient evidence that the benefit of the removal of restrictions
to allow Bartlett’s Quarry and Torr Works Quarry to operate in tandem,
would outweigh the harmful cumulative effects on local communities and 

environment from their concurrent working.”
4.
Refused
The County Council have already made their decision very clear, that
the adverse cumulative impacts of even more quarrying will be harmful
to the local communities and the environment.
Therefore like the recent previous application, these 4 applications must be REFUSED."


Friday, June 11, 2021

VICTORY: CANCELLED - "Super Spreader" September Equinox Concert at Pilton Confirmed Cancelled by Organiser Emily Eavis

 

Worthy Farm, Pilton

VICTORY UPDATE (21/7/21): Emily Eavis, organiser, has announced via Instagram that the September Equinox Event has been cancelled.

First report here from Paul Jones of the County Gazette.

Second report by SomersetLive has now been published. 

21/7/21 10:10am. This BBC report has finally arrived, hours after the County Gazette and Somerset Independents had already reported it.


Pilton resident Joanna Benner told Somerset Independents this morning:

"50,000 people during a pandemic was never a good idea - it was pure greed by a large corporate business that has little regard for villagers. This decision will be a huge relief for many in the local community."

 

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says:

Andrew Pope

"This September 'Equinox' concert was a really bad idea during a Global Pandemic. Residents across Somerset would have been put at risk by a Super Spreader event, and infection rates of Covid-19 are accelerating again.

Cancelling this event is the responsible thing to do and we applaud the organisers, Glastonbury Festival Events Ltd, for doing so.

But they should never have even thought of running this event in the first place.

Mendip District Council councillors Francis Hayden, Sam Phripp and Helen Sprawson-White should be ashamed of themselves for approving the event at the Licensing Hearing (see below).

There were clear conflicts of interest by councillors, the concerns of residents were ignored by councillors, there was terrible Chairmanship by Cllr Phripp and a lack of due process.

This debacle has brought Mendip District Council into further disrepute - if that were possible.

It's no wonder that local residents see Mendip District Council as "corrupt".

Somerset Independents listens to local residents and we acted with local residents to raise their concerns."

 

---

In May 2021, "supine" Mendip District Council took a week to decide, behind-closed-doors, to "bend over backwards" for Glastonbury Festival Events Ltd (GFEL) on their application for a premises licence at a new concert event at Worthy Farm, Pilton in September 2021. 

It took the councillors and officers a week to decide in private, after a series of chaotic public meetings of the Licensing Sub-Committee. 

The MDC press release (now missing from their featured articles on their PR website) is below, at the end of this article.

As documented elsewhere on the Somerset Independents website, local residents spoke against the application and wrote in objection to it. 

We have listened carefully to those residents and they have given us permission to publish their media release. They have raised many very important concerns.

Somerset Independents has commented on the failings of Mendip District Council (MDC):

  • in their duties to local residents and visitors to Somerset
  • in failing to prevent and manage conflicts of interest of the councillors who sat in judgement on the Licensing application by GFEL and 
  • in MDC failing to follow due process and proper governance.

Those Pilton residents accused Mendip District Council of being "supine" and "bending over backwards" to please GFEL. 

It is difficult to disagree with that view, because the evidence supports their view. The contrast in approach with other licensing applicants is stark and very concerning. There is a striking lack of consistency and an apparent favouritism to GFEL.

MDC officers both inside and outside the Sub-Committee were indeed supine. Only one environmental health officer dared to try to impose conditions on noise on GFEL. The Chair of the Sub-Commitee, Councillor Sam Phripp, then allowed that officer to be harangued and cross-examined by GFEL's solicitor.

Meanwhile, MDC's environmental health and licensing officers gave GFEL an easy ride. 

The Chair did not conduct the meeting with any semblance of due process. It was extremely long-winded and chaotic. The initial meeting went on for hours, having to be re-convened the following day. 

Even Somerset's hard-working Local Democracy Reporter Daniel Mumby had to give up his coverage at one point, because it went on so long. His frustration was clear in his eventual report that it took them "nearly a week" to decide.

Following up on points raised by residents on Covid-19 and public health, Somerset Independents has challenged Mendip District Council to show that it listened to residents.

We also have challenged Mendip District Council to show that the Sub-Committee considered the Covid-19 concerns raised by Somerset's top public health official, the Director of Public Health, Trudi Grant. MDC was unable to show this, because it did not consider them.

Instead, MDC passed the buck.

Ms Grant made 3 recommendations in a letter to the Deputy Chief Executive of Mendip District Council on 8th April 2021.

But the Sub-Committee didn't consider them. Because they were not in the report. 

We have confirmed this directly with MDC, after looking at the agenda. We could not see it, despite the agenda being huge. It was full of holes. The application was full of holes.

The holes include Covid-19.

The report to the Sub-Committee completely omitted the public health concerns raised by Ms Grant, despite them being raised in good time before the Sub-Committee agenda was produced.

We have the proof that they were not considered in writing from the author of the report, the Senior Licensing and Business Support Officer for MDC, who told us that, and we quote:

"The document you refer to was passed onto GFEL for them to take into account when they prepare their Event Management Plans for this event.

 

Somerset County Council Public Health (SCCPH)did not make a representation under the Licensing Act 2003 in respect of this application so therefore this document would not form part of the papers presented at the hearing. That said, SCCPH sit on the Multi-Agency Partnership meetings with GFEL and am sure they will monitor the situation closely in the lead up to the event taking into account current legislation.

 

This event will take place on one evening this year, Saturday 18th September 2021 and NASS over the following weekend."

We interpret this as MDC passing the buck to GFEL on Covid-19 and public health. We interpret this as ignoring the recommendations from Ms Grant. 

What other possible interpretations are there? But perhaps we have missed something, so we have gone back to Ms Grant to ask her a few questions and see if she is happy.

We also believe that the above response from the MDC Licensing Officer is also a dismissal of Ms Grant's letter. 

How can it not be a representation? It doesn't make sense at all.

Presumably as a Responsible Authority under the Licensing Act 2003, Ms Grant didn't just guess by coincidence that GFEL had put an application in? MDC would have notified her as Director of Public Health, and a Responsible Authority. And she then provided her comprehensive response.

Therefore any response would automatically be a representation under the Act?

This would seem a logical conclusion, indeed the only conclusion, when the title of the letter was:

"RE Live Music Event at Worthy Farm License Application by Glastonbury Festival
Events LTD for September 2021
"

Ms Grant's recommendations were:

"Recommendation 1: Given the uncertainty regarding future levels of transmission and
or the possible emergence of a variant of concern, we would strongly recommend that
a condition of granting the license is that the event organisers are able to evidence a
robust cancellation policy and process, that they will be liable for enacting. This will
ensure that if the local or national situation changes at short notice, the event
organisers are in a position to respond and advise people that the event is cancelled
and that they cannot attend, thereby assisting local and national teams to help protect
the nation’s health.

...

Recommendation 2: The DPH cannot see how an event of this size, at this site, could
proceed if social distancing measures remained in place at the time of the event and
would therefore suggest cancelling the event if at the time social distancing measures
were still in place at the time of the planned event. (Festival organisers referenced this
factor in their event management plan submitted for the cancelled June 2021 festival).

...

Recommendation 3: it would be helpful to have as much time as possible to review
and plan the covid19 secure measures in partnership with Festival organisers, to ensure
every opportunity is taken to protect the population’s health and well-being. We would
request a draft of the Covid-19 secure plan to be submitted at least 90 days in advance
of the planned event, to ensure adequate time to make this plan as robust as possible,
recognising that central government guidance is subject to change at any point in time."

We challenged MDC to show how all of these recommendations were addressed in the Decision Notice to approve the event.

They could not show this, because they didn't address them all. They only addressed one, and that was only partially. The Decision Notice states:

"17. ‘Covid Secure’ planning considerations and a full risk assessment will be
undertaken in partnership with Somerset County Council, Public Health
England and in line with the Government Roadmap and relevant legislation,
advice and guidance at the time if required. Such planning shall include a
cancellation and/or evacuation plan."

Yet this is still passing the buck. And leaving it all until the last minute. It is putting people at risk of harm.

We believe that Ms Grant is doing her utmost in such a difficult job in protecting Somerset residents from potential "Super Spreader" events in Somerset. We have praised her on multiple occasions and thanked her. But MDC need to back her recommendations.

Such "Super Spreader" large events include, but are not limited to, this September concert at Worthy Farm - if it goes ahead - and the NASS Festival at the Bath and West Showground. NASS was recently postponed from July to September, as reported on the Somerset Independents website.

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says:

Andrew Pope

"Somerset Independents do not oppose these events. We want people to enjoy themselves in our fantastic county of Somerset. Somerset is a welcoming place for visitors.

But we were formed to stand up for local residents.

These events need to be managed properly and there must be clearly-defined conditions and limits. It is the job of MDC to act like a Licensing Authority for all applicants, and to be consistent. But it doesn't seem to be.

MDC has not managed licensing consistently for many years. There have been too many terrible impacts on residents, and MDC has been deaf to the complaints. MDC has dismissed complaints and has even made it difficult for residents to complain.

So now during this continuing Global Pandemic of Covid-19, it is the time to begin to manage these large events properly, for everybody's sake - visitors, businesses and residents alike. We need certainty now.

We hope that MDC will urgently listen and act on residents' concerns and the concerns of the Director of Public Health to protect everybody in Somerset from Covid-19. This must start with imposing the DPH's conditions on large events and NOT by passing the buck to GFEL or anybody else.
How MDC achieves this is MDC's problem, not the problem of residents and good public servants who have been let down by MDC's supine Licensing Authority for too long.

MDC is the Licensing Authority. It needs to act like an authority that serves local residents, instead of taking the easy option. Councillors are supposed to represent the public, but at MDC they do not."


Standing Up For Residents

 

---

An application was made to Mendip District Council for a premises licence by Glastonbury Festival Events Limited (GFEL) and representations were received from responsible authorities and other persons.

A sub-committee hearing was held on 12th May 2021 for all parties to state their case.

The Licensing Sub-Committee has granted the licence, with conditions.

The Decision Notice is posted in full on the Council's website Icon for pdf Decision Notice (revised) [294.19KB]

Cllr Sam Phripp, Chair of Licensing at Mendip, said: "Whenever a licence application is considered, Mendip rightly assesses the impact of an event on local people and seeks to find a decent balance.

"With regard to Glastonbury Festival Events Limited holding a concert in September, we've heard concerns from residents, and those concerns are reflected in more than fifty conditions that have been added to this licence. We believe they're sensible measures, and match the perceived risk of the event.

"With a view to Covid-19, of course, any event would have to be Covid-safe, and Mendip will work with other organisations and the organisers to make sure that's the case."

Cllr Phripp added: "It's in everybody's interest for events like these to be a success, but as Chair of Licensing at Mendip, I'm clear that we'll keep our ears and eyes open and take on board feedback from residents in Pilton, just as we would with any other event.

"We hope that, Covid-depending, this event will be a success, and we look forward to welcoming music lovers back to our corner of Somerset this autumn."

 

Friday, June 4, 2021

CAMPAIGN UPDATE: They Put Up Your Council Tax BUT Did Your Councillor Pay Their Council Tax?

 

Challenging Councillors

Somerset Independents asked the councillors on the district councils and the county council to refuse the increases to your council tax. Councillors voted on your council tax in February 2021. 

We spoke at the February public meetings of "Full Council" and said that councillors had mis-spent public money on the wrong priorities and that people were struggling during the Global Pandemic.

But councillors voted through the increases.

It is entirely reasonable that residents who pay their council tax expect that councillors would pay their council tax, especially when those same councillors increase our council tax and get paid an allowance from public money.

Councillors do not get a salary, but do get an allowance. The councillor allowance is paid for by those residents who DO pay their council tax.

The majority of residents pay their council tax, but it is clear from what we have found that some of Somerset's councillors HAVE NOT PAID THEIR COUNCIL TAX.

After all, amongst many other important decisions that affect residents and their lives, it is councillors that decide how much council tax residents have to pay and what the council tax that residents pay is spent on.

Somerset Independents has been doing more investigation of the approximately 250 district and county councillors that are supposed to represent residents on the four district councils and one County Council.

Since our investigations discovered that not just one but TWO Mendip district councillors had NOT paid their council tax, we have been making more enquiries about the other councillors in Somerset.

Why? Because residents have told us that it is disgusting that councillors have not paid up, and especially so when it is revealed that those same councillors continued to claim their councillor allowance for doing their councillor duties. We decided to investigate further.

Here is what we have discovered so far (as at 4/6/21 1100 hours):

  • On Mendip District Council, Councillor Francis Hayden who is a Green Party Councillor for Cranmore, Doulting and Nunney, did not pay his council tax between April 2020 and February 2021 and possibly longer. He now claims to have paid it, although we have yet to have written confirmation from Mendip District Council.
  • Mendip District Council has refused to reveal the identity of another councillor who was in arrears. Somerset Independents has written to all Mendip District Councillors about the arrears, and we have asked them to come forward if they know which councillor was in arrears. Zero councillors responded with the name. One Green councillor, Michael Dunk (Frome Market), even defended his Green Party colleague Councillor Hayden for not paying his council tax!
  • All Sedgemoor District councillors have paid their council tax, as confirmed to us directly by the Council.
  • SIX councillors on Somerset West and Taunton (SWT) District Council were in arrears over the 2019/20 and 2020/21 financial years. We are offering the right of reply to councillors before publishing the full details. But what we have found has happened with some of these six councillors is truly appalling. Unlike Mendip District Council, SWT Council have provided full details of the arrears and the names of the councillors.
  • A month after the information was requested, South Somerset District Council have still not replied to our request for the information on councillor who have not paid their council tax, despite two reminders. WHAT HAVE THEY GOT TO HIDE?

We will continue our investigations.

Standing Up For Residents


Sunday, March 14, 2021

Council Tax Going Up: Why Don't You Ask Councillors Why?

 

Lib Dem, Labour, Green or Tory
SAME OLD STORY

Somerset Independents was formed a year ago to listen and act for residents.

We have listened to how people have struggled during the Pandemic.

We have listened how residents feel that councils and the Government have continually let them down and spent huge sums of public money without explanation or accountability. 

Money which we, the taxpayers, will have to pay back - or even our grandchildren will have to.

We listened to, share and empathise with residents' outrage at how and why council tax is increasing at this horrible time.

Your council tax bill is made up of several parts.

And you will find that most, if not all, parts, HAVE INCREASED! The Somerset County Gazette has reported:

"Each of the five local authorities is raising their portion of the council tax by the highest possible amount they can without triggering a referendum, with similar rises being planned by the police and fire services."

That is why we took action, after we had listened to residents.

 

Standing Up For Residents

As reported on this website, Somerset Independents Co-Founder and Leader Andrew Pope spoke at the Police and Crime Panel and Somerset County Council. Andrew pointed out their failure to spend our money wisely and with residents' priorities in mind.

Andrew asked them to refuse increases. At the first Panel, they refused the increase. But then councillors caved in with a minor change, adding more cost to council tax bills.

Also as reported on this website, Co-Founder Denise Wyatt spoke at Mendip District Council. Denise asked them to refuse increases, pointing out Mendip's major failings to deliver basic services for residents including collecting the bins every three weeks, "if we are lucky" because residents are regularly having missed collections. 

Mendip's failings make residents feel that the council lets them down, even on the bins. But they also want residents to do their own litter picking, and to fund councillors gambling with public money on property investment.

Mendip's Lib Dem, Green and Tory Councillors and fake independent councillors* all voted to increase your council tax.

They voted to do this. But one Green Councillor has not even paid his council tax. More details here.


What can YOU do to hold councillors to account?

Join us in standing up for residents! We are volunteers who formed Somerset Independents to stand up for residents.

Councillors are supposed to listen to you. They are supposed to represent your interests. Instead, they are voting through council tax increases.

Why don't you help us to hold them to account? 

We ask you to write to your councillors and ask them to justify why they voted to increase your council tax.

You can get in touch with your councillors by putting your postcode into the WriteToThem.com website. It will also tell you which councils govern your area.

You can also get in touch by visiting the Councillors page on your local council website.

For Mendip District Council, it is here.

For Somerset West and Taunton District Council (previously West Somerset and Taunton Deane councils, before councillors voted to merge them), it is here.

For South Somerset District Council, it is here. 

For Sedgemoor District Council, it is here.

For Somerset County Council, it is here.

There are also parish and town councils that take even more of your cash. Ask your parish or town councillor how they voted and why. They do not appear on the WriteToThem.com website.

For example, residents of Frome are complaining about the 9.2% increase by Frome Town Council. Frome Town councillors need to explain why they approved this. Here is their website, but we cannot publish all the parish and town councils for Somerset here. There are too many.

At least the Frome Town Council website is better than the others above, with a clear link to the councillors on the home page. One of the worst is the Sedgemoor website, on which it is very difficult to find contact details for the councillors.

We give you the tools to act.

Please let us know their responses. 

Standing Up For Residents and Their Money
 

 

* None of the Mendip independents are truly independent. More of that elsewhere on our website.