Showing posts with label Glastonbury. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Glastonbury. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 22, 2022

UPDATE (14/7/22): Covid Deaths Over 200,000 and Infections Rising - Glastonbury Festival 2022 Opens: This Year It Is Going Ahead - Over 2 Years, We Listened to Residents and Acted To Protect Somerset From Covid

 

Glastonbury Festival at Pilton, Somerset

UPDATE (14/7/22)

Official figures from the Office for National Statistics have shown that the number of deaths nationally has now exceeded 200,000, reports SomersetLive.

The number of deaths in Somerset is now over 1,200. 

The ONS figures show the number of deaths, via the below graph. You can see that while they have increased, they are not at the huge levels of the peaks of 2020 and 2021.


The ONS said:

"Deaths involving COVID-19 increased in the UK

13 July 2022

In the UK, there were 412 deaths involving COVID-19 registered in the week ending 1 July 2022, an increase from 347 in the previous week. This accounted for 3.5% of all deaths in the latest week; an increase from 2.8% in the previous week. There were 11,828 total deaths registered in the UK in the latest week, which is 12.1% above the five-year average."

 

However, without any restrictions or safeguards from Government, including on Super Spreader events, the number of infections is also continuing to rise, as shown in the following figures from the ONS.



Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says: "Now there have been 200,000 deaths, with 1,200 deaths in Somerset. At the beginning of the Pandemic I publicly stated on national radio that the Government's actions were not good enough. This proves it. Boris Johnson has gone. His legacy is total failure."

---

UPDATE (2/7/22):

ITV News is reporting that "Covid-19 infections in the UK have jumped by more than half a million in a week".

Hospital numbers and intensive care admissions are continuing to rise.

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says: 

Andrew Pope,
Leader of Somerset Independents

"These increases are no surprise to Somerset Independents. We've been listening to the experts, some of whom are local in our region. Meanwhile, the Johnson Tory Government seems to be preoccupied with surviving itself, suffering scandal after scandal. 

The Government should be protecting the citizens of the UK, but as we've seen and as Somerset Independents has shown - Somerset residents were let down by the Tory Government and the Tory County Council that is responsible for Public Health and infection control.

When I directly challenged the former Tory Leader of the County Council, David Fothergill, and the Director of Public Health in public, their answers were not convincing. There was more buck-passing and excuses.

Somerset Independents campaigned against festivals going ahead during the Pandemic. Glastonbury and Nass were stopped. But now super spreader events are allowed to go ahead unchecked, and it is no surprise therefore that infections have shot up. The Pandemic is not over.

When are the Government and the Lib Dems - who now control the County Council - going to get a grip and take the continuing Pandemic seriously?

Or is it going to be another case of Lib Dem or Tory, same old story."

---

UPDATE (24/6/22)

As we have reported on this website and via our Twitter and Facebook, the train strikes have had an effect. We have published the views of local RMT and local TUC. In contrast, Somerset Labour, Somerset Lib Dems and Somerset's Tory MPs have refused to answer our questions on the strikes.

We did not campaign against Glastonbury Festival going ahead this year or the NASS Festival at Bath and West, because residents did not contact us with their concerns.

But there is worrying news - Covid-19 has not gone away, although Boris Johnson's Government seems to wish it had. Covid has been missing from the headlines of the mainstream media.

And as we have covered via our website and social media, Covid infections were about to enter a new wave. Local mathematical biologists have predicted it and warned against it. Were you aware?

 

 

So with 200,000 people entering Somerset, and even more predicted to go to NASS Festival, what will be the effect of the rising Covid infections on Somerset?

It will not be long before we find out.

---

Somerset Independents puts residents first. Because we stand up for Somerset residents, we listened to them and did not work with residents to get the Festival cancelled this year. 

Over 2020, 2021 and now in 2022, we did some research and we published some hopefully useful information that does not often get reported by the local "journalists" or what passes for journalism from the media outlets that prefer clickbait to actual news.  

We took action, because the local councils, local councillors and other authorities were not reassuring residents sufficiently that they would be kept safe from these "Super Spreader" events - whether at Pilton or at Bath and West Showground - during the Global Covid-19 Pandemic. 

We listened to residents. We acted for residents. We acted with residents.

Here are some links to articles that we published on our research and on our action for Somerset residents and protect Somerset and its people.

4th August 2020 - Think Piece: Glastonbury Festival - Myths and Legends

14th August 2020 - Timeline of Lockdown and 2020 Glastonbury Festival Cancellation 

14th August 2020 - Glastonbury Festival: What the Authorities Told Us

14th August 2020 - Is Glastonbury Festival 2021 Going Ahead?

25th March 2021 - Avon and Somerset Police - What Does Current Commissioner Sue Mountstevens Think?

13th May 2021 - Resident Concerns on New September Concert At Pilton By Glastonbury Festival Organisers

15th May 2021 - Mendip Council In "Rush to Please" Glastonbury Organisers On New September Concert

19th May 2021 - UPDATED (21/5/21): Residents "Very Angry" As "Supine" Mendip Council "Bent Over Backwards" To Glastonbury Organisers On Pilton Event

23rd May 2021 - UPDATE (4/6/21): EVERYONE Should Get A Refund! For The Global Rip-Off Streamed from Worthy Farm by Glastonbury - while Mendip Council Stood By!

5th June 2021 - UPDATE (31/7/21): NASS Festival STILL GOING AHEAD Despite Cancellation of Glastonbury September 'Equinox' Concert 

11th June 2021 -  VICTORY: CANCELLED - "Super Spreader" September Equinox Concert at Pilton Confirmed Cancelled by Organiser Emily Eavis

21st June 2021 -  Train Strikes: Tory Government Versus RMT Union - What Do The Local Unions Say and What Is The Impact on Somerset Residents?

Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and dedicated political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Saturday, November 13, 2021

UPDATED (9/6/22): Latest Attacks on Glastonbury Government and Council Crony "Slush Fund"

 

Is Mendip District Council Corrupt?

UPDATED (9/6/22): The normally Labour-friendly Mirror is reporting the latest attacks on the Conservative Government's "Levelling Up" by the (Labour) Chair of the Commons Public Accounts Committee:

"Ministers were today accused of "gambling taxpayers' money on policies" which are "little more than a slogan" over Boris Johnson ’s flagship levelling-up plan.

The Commons Public Accounts Committee blasted the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities for using "unsatisfactory" methods to hand out billions of pounds of taxpayers’ cash.

In a report published today, the cross-party group of MPs highlighted how the first round of the £1.7bn Levelling-Up Fund was only awarded after the ministry knew the identities of shortlisted bidders."

This adds to the revelations that we have reported below in Somerset about Glastonbury money and how it has been handled by Lib Dem-run Mendip District Council, with Internal Audit intervening as we have previously reported. We have also received worrying allegations regarding Glastonbury Town Council, relating to how the money is being handled.

The Mirror goes on (Commons) Public Accounts Committee chairwoman Dame Meg Hillier "fumed": 

"Without clear parameters, plans or measures of success it's hard to avoid the appearance that government is just gambling taxpayers’ money on policies and programmes that are little more than a slogan, retrofitting the criteria for success and not even bothering to evaluate if it worked."

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, responds:

Andrew Pope

"We reported it, but local media have not given this scandal and this slush fund the attention that the public deserve.

The Tories nationally have opaquely allocated public money that has then been channelled and promoted very loudly by Lib Dems and Greens on Mendip District Council and Glastonbury Town Council.

Lib Dems, Greens or Tory, same old story - these Westminster parties want to look like "Lady Bountiful" in handing out the money. But as we've pointed out previously and many times over, it is public money that must be accounted for properly and distributed with due process and criteria.

At every level, national or local, this Levelling Up money is grubby dirty money, because of the way it has been dished out.

Residents would have hoped that these Lib Dem and Green councillors would be ashamed to have accepted this money when it has been repeatedly slammed by auditors and those accounting for it - at national level and at local level, as we have reported (see below). Lib Dems and Greens have no shame though...

One Glastonbury councillor, Chair of Mendip District Council, Nick Cottle attacked Somerset Independents for pointing out the national and local criticisms. He needs to listen to the public's valid concern.

Today's criticisms from the Public Accounts Committee are legitimate, despite them coming from a Labour-friendly newspaper quoting a Labour MP attacking the Tories.

And it's the latest criticism that makes "Levelling Up" look nothing more than a slush fund to corruptly build networks of cronies for the Lib Dems, Greens or Tories and to be used for what these Westminster parties hope - to influence voting patterns in constituencies or local council wards.

It's a scandal and the local media must give this due reporting now.

Too many local news outlets are asleep at the wheel, letting councillors and MPs get away with it."


---

UPDATED (19/2/22): Mendip District Council (MDC)'s internal audit function (a.k.a. SWAP) has now reported again to Mendip's Audit Committee of councillors. 

Minutes of the 2nd February 2022 meeting contained a report by SWAP. This had previously been mentioned as a "Fraud Risk Assessment" in a previous meeting of the Audit Committee in December 2021. 

Financial anomalies including weaknesses in how these millions were handled, were reported in Daniel Mumby's report that we linked to in the original article (see quotes below).

At the February 2022 meeting, councillors were asked to consider this report on the millions without the public being able to see it, or hear their deliberations.

This is public money, millions of pounds of public money. It is being handed out without public scrutiny.

WHAT DO THESE COUNCILLORS HAVE TO HIDE?

Somerset Independents has received information from a whistleblower about the Glastonbury Town Deal.

We will be looking into how MDC has conducted itself, and what conflicts of interest there have been in relation to how MDC, its councillors and officers have managed the money allocated by Boris Johnson's Conservative Government.

*At the August 2021 meeting, the minutes stated:

"Payments were issued without the required cashflow documentation to ensure funding was only distributed to verified project need. 

 Limited invoice and cashflow information from the grantees resulted in low level monitoring being undertaken to ensure that funds would be appropriately used during the projects’ lifecycles. 
 
The expenditure reports for Building C contain anomalies and questionable items that have not been queried by the Council. 
 
There is no distinct Code of Conduct for the Town Deal Board, nor is a formal process documented for members of the Town Deal Board to register gifts / hospitality and declarations of interest.
A follow up audit will be scheduled into the 2021-22 plan to confirm that recommendations are implemented to address the control weaknesses identified."

---

Ever since Somerset Independents was formed, we've been challenging Mendip District Council (MDC) for how it spends YOUR money and how it makes decisions.

We have not said that Mendip District Council is corrupt.

But we have provided the evidence so that Mendip residents can make up their own minds and have their own ideas about corruption.

We define corruption as the abuse of power, so we present the evidence again.

Here are just five examples of what is wrong with Mendip District Council, but there is more on this website and more to come:

  1. For two years running, we have got agreement from MDC's External Auditor Ernst and Young (EY) that how MDC operates is wrong. We are helping EY with their enquiries, following our second complaint into MDC, its accounts and governance.
  2. We have shown that conflicts of interest are not managed, including on Licensing and Planning decisions that affect Mendip residents' lives, and we have shown that MDC are mostly deaf to the public's concerns and objections but allow grave contraventions of good practice to go ahead, unchecked.
  3. We have shown that Mendip Council officers have suppressed information relating to councillors who have not paid their council tax, and taken this to local and national media, plus the Information Commissioner's Office.
  4. We have shown that Mendip Council officers allowed a Chair of Scrutiny to preside over his own election as Chair, and after the Head of Legal (Monitoring Officer) ruled it was OK to do this, then through our action we forced Mendip into a u-turn and a proper vote of the Chair, months later.
  5. After a bitter fight over 2020 and 2021, we have forced MDC to change their Constitution on Planning. Despite this, a senior planning officer described the changes to councillors as "tidying up" when presenting the changes to them. And bad governance and practises continue in MDC Planning.

But there is more.

This brings us to The Glastonbury Town Deal, part of the corrupt Prime Minster Boris Johnson's (BoJo's) Government "levelling up" agenda.

Nobody seems to know what "levelling up" means. Spitting Image have derided it in their latest episodes. Things have got so bad that Michael Gove has been sent in to explain what it is. That is desperate.

So what is The Glastonbury Town Deal? It is part of the £3.6 billion Towns Fund for England that has awarded public money to 101 towns. Some of this appears to have been done in the correct way, but most (around 60%) of the allocations were not done correctly. Tory Ministers interfered.

Glastonbury needs investment, but the way this has been done is wrong.

In short, the Towns Fund is a multi-billion pot of public money handed out by Boris to help the Conservative Party win elections. 

The Towns Fund is dirty money used for corrupt purposes. And therefore the Glastonbury Town Deal money, which Mendip District Council applied for, is also dirty. 

Why do we say this? 

Because the evidence is clear that the money was allocated with political interference by Conservative Party ministers, instead of according to clear criteria and methodology by public servants.

It isn't just Somerset Independents that says this. Multiple other credible sources also say this, including MPs, the National Audit Office and independent journalism.

According to Byline Times, it is "61 Pork Barrels", with "weak and unconvincing arguments" used by Government Ministers in defending how money was allocated, according to MPs on the Commons Public Accounts Committee.

According to the National Audit Office (NAO), "the UK's independent public-spending watchdog", in their review of the Towns Fund:

"On 27 July 2019, the government announced the £3.6 billion Towns Fund for England (The Towns Fund). The Towns Fund is expected to support towns that currently do not have the right conditions to develop and sustain strong local economies"

The NAO said:

"This review describes the process followed by the Department to select the 101 towns. First, this involved an assessment – scoring, ranking, filtering and prioritising – of all 1,082 towns across England by the Department’s officials against a range of criteria. Second, ministers selected the towns to be invited to bid for Town Deals using the officials’ assessments to guide them.1 The Department published the list of selected towns in September 2019 but did not publish the basis on which they selected the towns."

Like we have said when we have challenged local councils in how they operate, politicians should not be involved in any interference in the allocation of public money via grants. There should be clear criteria and a methodology, and civil servants or local government officers should be allowed to make the decisions in an open and transparent way.

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope says: 

Andrew Pope

"Glastonbury Town Deal money was allocated in a corrupt way by  Conservative Government Ministers. This is not the fault of civil servants, but of Boris Johnson's corrupt MPs, most of whom recently voted to protect corrupt Tory MP Owen Paterson. This included local Somerset MPs.

We say again that Glastonbury and a whole host of other towns in Somerset including Yeovil, Shepton Mallet and Frome - desperately need investment and a plan for investment and jobs.

But not like this with dirty Tory money being laundered by Liberal Democrat and Green councillors, who like the Tories are desperate to spend millions of pounds of OUR money for THEIR political gain.

The Liberal Democrat Leader of Mendip, Councillor Ros Wyke, is doing the Conservative Party's dirty work for them, when she is crowing about the money. And so is any other Lib Dem, Green or Tory councillor or MP that is crowing about this dirty money.

Already Mendip have claimed transparency, but provided anything but transparency (see here and * below). Even the normally pathetic Internal Mendip Audit (SWAP) has found "questionable items" within the accounts!

It is no surprise as Ros Wyke has form for this, which we know from our campaigning on the governance failings at Mendip on how our money is spent in the Asset Management Group and Phoenix Sponsorship Board.

The Tories have used public cash on a spending spree to enhance their election chances in a marginal seat. That's why Tory MP for Glastonbury James Heappey is so involved on this "Board" for spending the money.

Other parts of Somerset are being taken for granted, because of the broken First Post The Post voting system which provides "safe seats" for Tories.

We want to see investment in Somerset and a plan for jobs, but done in a way that Somerset can be proud of, not in a way that is shameful and grubby."

 

Standing Up For Somerset
Not Westminster

From the Mendip District Council "Frequently Asked Questions" page (emphasis added):

Where can we, the citizens of Glastonbury, see the detailed accounts of the money spent thus far?
All funds will eventually flow through Mendip District Council, which is the Accountable Body for any eventual grant allocation.  An accountable body generally takes responsibility for the legal and financial management of a grant given to a particular project or projects.  MDC's Section 151 Officer oversees the accountable body function.  As such, MDC works to government guidance and will eventually be reporting to government and the Glastonbury Town Fund Board.

Some limited prefunding of matters such as architects and project managers is taking place at the moment through MDC to enable the 12 projects to deliver their HM Treasury Green Book Business Cases.  The actual grant allocation of £23.6m will not be approved until each project completes this process.  Thus, the full grant allocations will not be available until a few months after MDC has received permission for the projects to proceed.  We anticipate that the first 'major' funds will arrive in mid 2022.

As well as MDC's role as the Accountable Body, the operation of the Glastonbury Town Deal, including financial, is overseen by the Glastonbury Town Deal Board which will receive detailed financial reporting once the grant allocations start to be received.  This reporting will be recorded in the Board minutes which are posted regularly on the MDC website.  Please note that some confidential information may necessarily be excluded if it is 'commercial in confidence'.  Both MDC and the Glastonbury Town Deal Board are committed to working in an open and transparent manner.  Currently, there is simply no information to share.

 

 

Friday, October 22, 2021

UPDATE (22/3/22): P & O Ferries and Clark's - Like the Tories - Wrap Themselves in the Flag But Are Foreign-Owned and Run!

 

Standing Up For Somerset Residents

UPDATE (23/3/21): P & O Ferries write open letter back to the Conservative Minister Kwasi Kwarteng...

... and P & O CEO Peter Hebblethwaite uses many of the same phrases that Somerset's Conservative MPs and Ministers have been quoted by us as saying.

We said that Tory MPs parroted employers and this proves it.

For example, Hebblethwaite writes, in the letter published by the BBC:

"We saw no other viable means of preserving our iconic British business, saving the 2,200 remaining jobs it provides and protecting the 15% Britain's trade capacity it facilitates."
It's British and iconic, P & O Ferries, Hebblethwaite claims. 

Is P & O British or Not British? 

It is well-documented that P & O Ferries is owned by DP World, based in Dubai, which is not British.

In the same letter, P & O state that "all relevant vessels are registered outside of the UK". The names of the ships sound British. Let's have a look at each one...

Spirit of Britain is registered in Cyprus - not British

Pride of Hull in Bahamas - not British

Pride of Canterbury in Cyprus - not British

Pride of Kent in Cyprus - not British

The employees that were dismissed were from three companies - all registered in Jersey. Is Jersey British or not? Jersey is a Crown Dependency, has its own Parliament, its own identity internationally, and is not part of the United Kingdom.

Conclusions

You can make up your own minds on whether P & O Ferries is "British" or not.

P & O Ferries operate to and from ports in Britain and some of its workers are British residents. But that seems to be about it.

P & O Ferries seem to be as "British" as the foreign-owned Premier League football teams, one of which - Chelsea - has been forced to be sold off by the UK Government after sanctions were applied to Chelsea's owner.

Whether P & O Ferries will continue to operate to and from British ports, or whether another operator will take over, will test P & O's claim that their ferries are "iconic" or not.

Will UK Governments - Labour, Lib Dem or Tory - do anything to stop it being the same old story, when it comes to workers at sea?

Their track record suggests that they will not, because they are still not serving the people that they are supposed to serve - the British people.

Instead, these Westminster parties accept money from all sorts of the wrong sources and serve the wrong interests - themselves and their rotten parties.

---

UPDATE (20/3/21): According to ITV News reporting on The Sunday Times, Conservative Ministers "knew of P&O Ferries" plans to slash jobs.

The report says:

"The Sunday Times newspaper said it received a leaked memo apparently written by a senior Whitehall official which tried to “justify” the mass redundancies, stating that “without these decisions, an estimated 2,200 staff would likely lose their jobs”...
"The newspaper said it was “widely shared across government” and recipients included the Prime Minister’s private office while Transport Secretary Grant Shapps is understood to have received a copy."

This attitude by Tory MPs echoes the response that Somerset Independents received when it asked Somerset MPs about the Clark's dispute here in Somerset (Clark's is now Chinese-owned).

Liam Fox (Tory, North Somerset) and James Heappey (Tory, Wells) made pronouncements about the Clark's dispute. And both seem to think sacking workers or attacking their rights is OK - as long as the employer claims they are struggling and claims it is done to save other jobs.

Somerset Independents stands up for residents and for workers. We want to see good employers thrive. But P & O and Clark's are clearly not good employers.

Like Liam Fox - himself a former Minister - and Wells MP James Heappey - currently a Minister - both displayed a terrible attitude during the Clark's dispute in Heappey's constituency (see our earlier report below). Fox mentioned Heappey in his response to us.

In relation to P & O, Heappey told Sky News: 'that the government "cannot force an employer to continue to employ people that the employer has said it doesn't want to employ." 

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, himself a former union representative and negotiator, says: 

Andrew Pope

"The way the Whitehall memo is written - Heappey is a Minister - mirrors the way Somerset MP Liam Fox attempted to justify attacking Clark's workers, when we asked him about the Somerset dispute.

Mr Fox told us and I quote: 'It is clear that they are trying to maintain jobs at a time when they are losing money.  The alternative to the current plan seems to be increased redundancies which I am sure people would want to avoid.'

Whether it is James Heappey or Liam Fox, the attitude is very similar.

Both Clark's and P & O are struggling, and both have attempted to use the management failures to cut jobs and attack workers. And according to Tory MPs and Tory ministers, it seems it is OK to sack 800 workers to save 2,200 workers.

No, it isn't OK.

Poor strategic decisions from management failures should not lead to sackings or reductions in terms and conditions of employment.

It seems that whether it is here in Somerset or out at sea, Tory MPs put the needs and claims of employers first and the needs of employees a very distant last.

But Grant Shapps and other ministers have expressed their false horror at the treatment of P & O workers.

Tories pretend to care and say they are "reviewing" the legality of the actions of P & O.

Were Tory ministers aware, and are Labour MPs aware, that the law at sea is not the same as UK employment law?

When workers are at sea, they would surely be covered by international maritime law, not UK law? An example is the 2014 Maritime Labour Convention on Seafarer working and living rights.

As a former councillor in a port city, I asked similar questions when I heard from workers on cruise ships. I heard all about the undermining of workers and their rights at sea.

I understood that treating workers at sea in such a poor way, was commonly done by seafaring employers.

Does maritime law apply or UK law? Government ministers should be honest about it - surely they would be able to say - or are they so incompetent that they don't know?

If they did know about it, what did they do about it?

Labour had 13 years of Government to sort this out. The Tories have had 12 years in Government. The Lib Dems even had the Coalition.

But Labour, Tories and Lib Dems showed that they cannot be trusted to stand up for Somerset residents or stand up for workers.

They pretend that they care but when it comes to the crunch, neither used Government to change international maritime law to protect workers at sea.

It's yet another case of Labour, Lib Dem or Tory, it's the same old story."


---

UPDATE (25/10/21): Conservative MPs including Somerset's Conservative MPs voted down the Private Members Bill that Somerset Independents asked them to support. The Bill would limit Fire and Rehire, which the new owners of Clark's propose to use to attack the company's workers.

Worse than this, only two Somerset MPs have responded to our challenges. At the time of writing, no other MPs have responded. And even these two lame responses do not help Somerset's workers.

Dr Liam Fox

Dr Liam Fox, Conservative MP for North Somerset did not answer our questions. Instead, he produced what amounts to an attempt at an excuse for the owners of Clark's to do what they have done to the company's workers, and for what they propose to do - to cut terms and conditions of employment without consent from the workers themselves.

Dr Fox told Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope:

"I have been in touch with Clarks and the local MP, James Heappey.  I am not sure whether you are aware of the following facts.

There have been some employees working in the factory on superior contracts from pervious owners.  In order to avoid further redundancies, they have brought them all (potentially) to the same hourly pay.  Some getting a rise and some getting a reduction.  It must be noted that Clarks’ figures have recently been published and last year they lost £180 million.  The investment they have received was £100 million and that secured the future of Clarks and jobs for their employees.   It is clear that they are trying to maintain jobs at a time when they are losing money.  The alternative to the current plan seems to be increased redundancies which I am sure people would want to avoid."

James Heappey, Conservative MP for Wells, has told campaigners that he is negotiating with the company on behalf of constituents. 

Andrew Pope responds to the two Conservative MPs by saying:

Andrew Pope

"Most Somerset MPs, all of whom are Conservative, seem too busy or too ignorant to prioritise our challenges on behalf of Clark's workers.

Somerset Independents and other campaigners have asked Mr Heappey what alternative he suggests to strikes. He previously stated on the BBC that strikes are not the answer. But he does not seem to have any alternative course of action for the workers who are under attack by the owners of Clark's. He claims to be negotiating for them - where are the results of his "negotiations"?

As for Mr Fox - yes, I told that him that Somerset Independents were already aware of these "facts". Mr Fox seems to think it is OK for workers' pay and conditions to be attacked, after management made the wrong strategic decisions for Clark's. It is not the fault of these workers, but they are made to suffer for the management failures. It's not on.

Why do these Tory MPs think this is OK? It just isn't. Fire and Rehire just is not an acceptable way to treat Somerset's workers."

Somerset Independents will continue to challenge the owners and management of Clark's and Somerset's MPs who appear to back this appalling behaviour by Clark's.

---

Somerset Independents has been supporting the Clark's employees and their representatives, in their ongoing dispute with the employer, as reported in our article here. 

The Protests at Clark's

Mendip Trades Union Council (TUC) has asked us to support the Private Members Bill being proposed by Barry Gardiner MP.

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, has responded positively to their request. Andrew says:

Andrew Pope

"As I said in my previous statement, Fire and Rehire should not be allowed. I have been of this view ever since I was an employee and union representative in the UNIFI union. Yet despite 13 years of Government, Labour failed to ban it.

Having listened to the views of other Somerset residents and workers, and listened to Mendip TUC's request to support the Bill, Somerset Independents supports the broad aims and objectives of the Bill, but believes that due to flaws in the Bill, that it may lead to unintended consequences such as dismissal without any new contract being offered.

However, on balance, some of the provisions in the Bill are very important, and would help in the dispute at Clark's, so we are asking Somerset's MPs to support the Bill when it is voted on."


Wednesday, October 13, 2021

Somerset Independents On Somerset Businesses: Just What Is Going On At Clark's?

 


Somerset Independents wants Somerset residents to be proud of what Somerset businesses produce, and for Somerset's reputation to be enhanced outside Somerset and across the world.

We will happily praise Somerset-based businesses that Somerset people can be proud of. But we will challenge businesses that we believe may be tarnishing the reputation of Somerset.

Clark's shoes was founded in Street, Somerset, by the Quakers C & J Clark. The Registered Office is still in Street. The Alfred Gillett Trust is a Somerset-based charity in Street which "preserves the heritage collections of C & J Clark Ltd., the family which founded the global shoemaking company".

It has been a large employer of Somerset workers for almost 200 years. It is a well-known and respected brand for shoes.

We were therefore concerned to hear of the ongoing industrial dispute at Clark's, which has now led to strike action.

So we have contacted workers representatives at the Mendip Trades Union Council (TUC), to try to find out the truth behind the strikes.

Somerset Independents officers Andrew Pope and Denise Wyatt wrote to the Mendip TUC, saying:

"This dispute is tarnishing the reputation of Clarks, who were founded by Quakers. And it is harming the relationship between employer and employees. This will impact on the sustainability of the business, harming Somerset's workers.

We believe that the founders would be extremely upset at the current situation and that they would never have allowed this.

What changes have occurred since the Lion Rock takeover and how are the "key" shareholders acting since the takeover to protect the company's reputation?

What changes have occurred in employment relations?

Now that workers have been forced to strike, do you believe that the new owners will bring retribution on any workers?

Finally, how can Somerset Independents assist in helping to resolving the situation?"

 

Mendip TUC told us:

"Clarks warehouse workers, members of the Community Union, face the following threats:


1. An average reduction in pay of £1.66 per hour: from the current £11.16p to £9.50p;


2. An increase in working hours of 2.5 per week, due to paid 30-minute meal breaks being abolished;


3. No pay rise for at least four years, despite the union agreeing to help the company through a 'difficult financial spell' by accepting two hours less per week INSTEAD of a pay rise on two different occasions and at the company’s proposal.


4. Drastic cuts in sick pay: from 13 weeks full pay to 6 weeks full pay and 6 weeks half pay; abolition of sick pay for the first day of absence; no sick pay entitlement from day one of employment, only after 6 months;


5. The abolition of a daily ten-minute coffee break, brought in at the company's request to ease warehouse operations;


6. A drastic reduction in redundancy entitlements: from enhanced double statutory, to statutory, (ie, one week’s wages per year of service), raising fears that the company will get rid of workers, even close the Street Distribution Centre, just as they are closing their distribution centre in Kendal.  


7. Cuts to overtime rates to time thus giving no chance to increase pay"


8. No direct cuts to maternity pay or pension entitlements, BUT with a 15-20% cut in wages, pensions will suffer a drastic fall when taken out."


Dave Chapple, Secretary of Mendip TUC, said:

"I have personally, met four Clarks workers who fear losing their homes (Inability to pay rent, mortgage) and even lose contact with their children (If only able to afford a bedsit, unsuitable accommodation for children).


Is this the Clarks Quaker Family firm that was an iconic part of manufacturing, 'factory' Britain for 200 years?


Is this, even the Clarks family firm that, even when it closed all of its Somerset factories over a 15-year period, nonetheless treated its remaining Street HQ and warehouse workers, and their trades unions, with respect?


NO! Welcome to the "Brave New World" of Clarks' new owners Lion Rock Capital.


Hong Kong based, venture capitalist, hedge fund capitalist, slash and burn capitalist, just pick your most accurate label!


Is this really the future for work in this country: no more decent trades union recognition or collective bargaining negotiations, just industrial dictatorship, "take it or leave it" "Fire and rehire?” "


Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, says:

Andrew Pope

"Just what is going on at Clark's? What do the new owners think they are doing? Do they even know about the traditions of Clark's, or even care?

Many years ago, when I was doing my training to be a union representative and negotiator, I was stunned to hear that under a Labour Government (Blair/Brown), that Fire and Rehire was commonly done. Worse, it was allowed under UK law. In 13 years of Government, Labour failed to end Fire and Rehire.

Loosely, what Fire and Rehire means is that employers are able to dismiss employees on existing contracts, and force them to accept new terms and conditions in a new contract. If the employee does not sign the new contract, then they are deemed to no longer have a job.

Indeed, this is what happened in the large negotiation in the AXA Group of insurance companies, in which I represented thousands of employees in the harmonisation of terms of conditions, after AXA had taken over other companies. 

I pushed back when the directors of AXA said that the harmonisation would be done via the termination of existing contracts, but other union representatives and the union official explained to me that this was the way it was going to be done.

So I fought very hard to ensure that if this was going to be done, that there would be an absolute minimum of employees losing out.

This situation at Clark's is therefore horrendous to hear about. It is almost as if the new owners of Clark's, Lion Rock, want to force employees out and this Fire and Rehire is their tool of choice for achieving this, by cutting pay and conditions unilaterally, without the agreement of employees."


Somerset Independents is considering its next steps in relation to this dispute.



 

Saturday, May 15, 2021

Mendip Council In "Rush to Please" Glastonbury Organisers On New September Concert

Pilton (Glastonbury) Festival
In A Year That Was NOT During a Global Pandemic

As reported by Somerset Independents yesterday, local residents have written formal objections and raised a large number of concerns at a public meeting about the hastily-planned proposal by Glastonbury Festival Events Limited (GFEL) to put on a two-day concert, possibly in September (date TBA), at Worthy Farm in Pilton. 

We say hastily-planned, because more papers were being presented "on-the-fly" at the Mendip District Council (MDC) Licensing Sub-Committee where the application was being considered. They were not on the published agenda. They were not even on the "Updating" of the agenda. 

Members of the public and local residents had not seen those papers prior to the meeting. For MDC, just reading parts out, or putting them briefly up on screen in the virtual meeting, was deemed to be adequate. It isn't right. It isn't legal. But then this is Mendip District Council. It is quite clear in the relevant legislation that such "ambushing" is not allowed.

And still more details were not set. Even GFEL's own legal representative, Mr Phipps, apologised for the lateness of papers.

Residents deserve better than Mendip District Council and its councillors.

Another Concert In A Field In Somerset

If you didn't know, Glastonbury Festival is not in Glastonbury. It is at Worthy Farm in Pilton, a village on the A361 between Glastonbury and Shepton Mallet. The road is not a dual carriageway. 

Large sections of this road are at low speed limits, including a 30mph through Pilton that is sometimes enforced by Police speed check vans. 

Pilton is not Wembley Stadium. It is not in an urban area. The "in a field" location in Somerset is part of the charm of the Glastonbury Festival. 

As we have said before and made clear to the organisers when we have queried them, Glastonbury Festival is a great global event.

Mendip's Cosy and Inappropriate Relationship

But the Festival impacts on local residents over a wide area, and in a negative and sustained way if not managed. There appears to be a growing trend of organising "spin-off" events. That's fine, if it is managed correctly and with the impact on local residents minimised.

But it isn't minimised. If it was, we wouldn't be hearing about so many complaints from residents. Not just for this new event, but all events at this venue.

It is reasonable to conclude then that local authorities including Mendip have given the Festival too much of the "light touch" of regulation over the years. Mendip District Council boasts on its website of a "good relationship" with the organisers. 

Perhaps that is why local residents complaints have not been addressed, because Mendip has the wrong priorities?

Covid-19 Global Pandemic

During Covid-19, there are very grave and substantial reasons for the Festival to have been cancelled two years in a row. Those reasons involve protecting the health of the public - not just for the visitors to Somerset, but also for the local residents and residents across Somerset.

Somerset Independents was formed to protect Somerset residents. 

We have written again to another of the local authorities - Somerset County Council's Director of Public Health, Trudi Grant - to ask her why she had not objected to the plans. It could turn out that she has, but when we checked the representations there were none directly from her. Perhaps she had delegated authority to Mendip public health staff. We await her reply.

But in the light of the growing concern over new Covid-19 variants, an event for 50,000 people when Covid-19 is still a Global Pandemic should not happen after partial planning, late planning or bad planning. And it would be wrong if approvals were rushed by Mendip District Council in an effort to please GFEL, as alleged by members of the public.

It appears from what we have heard from residents and Mendip Council itself, that the relationship between the licensee and licensor is far too cosy.

The two-day "September" event was described as "to compensate" for the loss of Pilton (Glastonbury) Festival, according to a report involving Daniel Mumby (Somerset Local Democracy Reporter) on BBC Radio Somerset this evening, Thursday 13th May 2021. Here is a transcript of the interview. It appears that Mr Mumby was using a press release as the basis for this compensatory claim.

Any compensation for loss is not a valid reason for Mendip District Council to make approvals of any event where the public have grave doubts about Covid-19 and public health, traffic, noise, lack of due legal process and other issues. Public health trumps profit.

Mendip Approving or Disapproving of What, Exactly?

It is also clear that partial information is known about the event, and partial plans have been submitted to Mendip District Council. Despite this, MDC are due to make a decision on it over the next few days. Not in public, but behind closed doors after a protracted seven hours, plus another session, in public. But then, residents are used to MDC making important decisions in private, behind closed doors, as Somerset Independents proved to the External Auditor Ernst and Young, who agreed to make MDC revise minutes of meetings involving millions of pounds to make them more open and transparent (but still not revealing the full detail).

What Have Residents Said and When?

Residents said that the event threatens noise, traffic and public health due to the deadly Covid-19. Testing for the disease is not certain until close to the event, according to Marietta Gill, Mendip District Council (MDC) Public Health Officer at the virtual meeting.

The new event was not being planned properly, said residents. MDC had not advertised the application properly, they said. And the event did not even have a proposed date, something else that is causing great worry for local residents and how they plan their lives.  

Those residents that have complained were relatively lucky to have heard. Why do we say this?

Residents from outside Pilton were not consulted or notified about the event, as confirmed by Somerset Independents in direct contact with the Licensing Officer at MDC, Jack Godley. Mendip did not consult residents outside Pilton despite the fact that events at this site have upset local residents from a wide area in the locality for many years. Complaints have not gone away, as is documented in MDC documents obtained by Somerset Independents.

What Was This Meeting?

As we reported yesterday, the comments came at the Licensing Sub-Committee of Mendip District Council on Wednesday 12th May 2021 AND also adjourned to Thursday 14th May 2021, residents spoke with their outrage, upset and worry about the proposal. The meeting went on for SEVEN hours, and then adjourned to the next day.

Members of Somerset Independents watched and live-tweeted from the virtual meeting.

MDC officers were in a "rush to please" the organisers GFEL, said one resident, who also challenged the legitimacy of the Licensing Sub-Committee.

Another local resident spoke very eloquently despite being very upset about how GFEL events had affected her and her family's life and other Pilton residents too, over many years. What she described was truly horrific, including riots, intimidation and criminal activity.

When asked by a councillor whether the impact on local residents improved recently, the resident said that they "don't give a monkeys" about local residents and that they had not improved.

And another Pilton resident, claimed that Mendip District Council did not provide her with a map of the proposal until after the closing date for comments and that Mendip did not display the "blue notices" properly. 

She also showed the big difference between how residents near Heaton Park in Manchester were consulted and involved in decisions about events near them, and contrasted this with how Mendip and GFEL were failing to do so.

You would think that councillors would speak up to support residents. No, not Mendip councillors. Instead of supporting the residents, Mendip Councillor and Cabinet Member for Economic Development, Lib Dem Simon Carswell, attacked them by mis-quoting the resident as saying that MDC officers were "placating" the organisers, GFEL. The resident corrected him on what he actually said (above). 

Conflicts of Interest By Councillors Sitting in Judgement

It is a huge conflict of interest for Cllr Carswell in his role, to be sitting in judgement over this Licensing decision. During the meeting, when asked if he wanted to adjourn the meeting, Cllr Carswell said: 

"I just want to get this finished", and also in the meeting:

"I might have missed it, I've got a migraine."

We do not think that Cllr Carswell was taking to the meeting with an open mind or giving due consideration to the decision. We think that he had made up his mind already.

And another Lib Dem councillor on the Committee, Helen Sprawson-White, appeared to question the veracity of residents' claims about the impact on their lives, when she asked whether the Festival had improved in terms of its impact on residents. She was told, in no uncertain terms, that the Festival organisers "do not give a monkeys" about local residents.

Cllr Sprawson-White did not declare an interest at the beginning of the meeting. She is very close to Green Cllr Francis Hayden, having defended him when we asked him why he had not paid his council tax. Cllr Hayden was not embarrassed, as the Stoke-on-Trent councillors who did not pay were. Cllr Hayden did not apologise for not paying his council tax. He did not tell us whether he had now paid or not. He did not resign. Instead, Cllr Hayden told us:

"My own income depends on catering for weddings, parties and music festivals (including Glastonbury) all of which have been cancelled for the last year."

In which case, why didn't Cllr Sprawson-White declare an interest?

This also begs the question, why didn't Cllr Hayden declare this on his Declaration of Interest, which has not been updated since he was elected in May 2019?

Excerpt From Cllr Hayden's Declaration of Interest

It is a criminal offence for a councillor to not keep their interests updated within 28 days of a change. Nothing is mentioned about his employment at Glastonbury Festival.

But then, as we have documented elsewhere on this website, this dodgy councillor did not pay his council tax, either - not just for a couple of months, but from April 2020 to February 2021.

And there is another councillor who did not pay their council tax. MDC have tried to cover it up and refused to tell us which councillor it was.

Par For The Course for Mendip

Sadly this lack of democracy from the councillors is not unusual for Mendip District Council. It is par for the course. It is a Council in disarray, as Somerset Independents has proved in its successful challenges to MDC's failures in governance, such an unlawful minutes of meetings conducted behind closed doors, despite the Lib Dem Council Leader Ros Wyke claiming them to be "open".

Unlawful Minutes of the
Mendip District Council
Phoenix Sponsorship Board

Mendip councillors do not stand up for residents and they do not stand up for due process. It seems that MDC always seem to have other priorities than representing the public and standing up for the public interest, despite being a public body and paid for by public money.

Somerset Independents will keep standing up for residents, especially when those paid to do so - the elected councillors and Mendip officers - still fail to do the jobs that they are paid public money to do.

 






Thursday, May 13, 2021

Resident Concerns on New September Concert At Pilton By Glastonbury Festival Organisers

Local residents have written formal objections and raised a large number of concerns in person about the "rushed" proposal by Glastonbury Festival Events Limited (GFEL) to put on a two-day concert at Worthy Farm in Pilton.

The two-day "September" event was described as "to compensate" for the loss of Pilton (Glastonbury) Festival two years in a row, according to a report involving Daniel Mumby (Somerset Local Democracy Reporter) on BBC Radio Somerset this evening, Thursday 13th May 2021. A full transcript of the interview is below.

Residents are unhappy about how Mendip District Council has not consulted them properly, and GFEL having done the same lack of involvement of residents. More on this is in the transcript.

Having previously questioned local authorities and Glastonbury Festival, Bath and West and other event organisers on the wisdom of holding mass gatherings and large events during coronavirus in 2020 and 2021, Somerset Independents is following events closely and working with local residents. We applauded the leadership of Bath and West earlier this year, when they took the responsible decision.

Somerset Independents was formed to stand up for Somerset residents. 


Somerset Independents remain extremely concerned that Mendip District Council is in a "rush to please" GFEL as alleged by a local resident at yesterday's Licensing Sub-Committee. This accusation was of course denied by Cabinet Member for Economic Development Councillor Simon Carswell who against all sound governance sat on the Licensing Sub-Committee that considered the application. This was not a conflict of interest at all according to MDC, despite Cllr Carswell declaring his meeting GFEL people as an interest during the meeting. See note* below for more on the other conflicts of interest at MDC.

This event could put not only the attendees and staff at risk, but all local residents from cross-infection before, during and after the event of current or any future variants or mutations of coronavirus.

We have written to the Somerset County Council Director of Public Health, Trudi Grant, and await an answer.

There will be more from us on this very soon.

Below is a transcript of the interview between Matt Faulkner and Daniel Mumby on BBC Radio Somerset today.

"Transcript of Daniel Mumby Interview
13/5/21
BBC Radio Somerset Matt Faulkner

Matt Faulkner:

As we were hearing, Mendip District Council is asking for more time to
decide whether a two-day concert at the Worthy Farm site could go ahead
some time in September.

Councillors on the Licensing Committee sat for seven hours yesterday and
 a further few hours today discussing the event which has prompted
concerns about noise, traffic and coronavirus precautions.

Our Local Democracy Reporter Daniel Mumby's been following the
protracted proceedings and joins me now.

Daniel, afternoon, first of all what sort of event are we talking about?

DM: Well many people will be aware that the full-blown Glastonbury
Festival won't be taking place this June in light of the coronavirus.

So to compensate for there being no festival two years on the trot, the
Festival organisers put forward plans for a smaller two-day event for
up to 50,000 people with bands playing on the Pyramid Stage only and no
on-site camping.

Now the date for the event has not yet been set. But the Festival hopes
it can take place some time in September around the time when the Pilton
Party is to be held.

Faulkner: So what are some of the concerns that have been raised about
the event so far?

DM: Well there were concerns about how legitimate the licensing hearing
was, with some residents alleging that they had not been properly consulted
about the event, something which the Festival organisers strongly
denied.

Beyond that, there were numerous complaints noise generated by the live
music and crowds, with local resident Caroline Griffiths saying  
there was an element of fear and futility in the community surrounding
the event.

Crowd size was also a concern with resident Nick Hall claiming  
people would be more tightly packed together than at the regular
Festival since only 7% of the site would end up being used.

And finally there were questions about coronavirus testing for ticket
holders, with the organisers saying they would comply with all
Government guidance at the time that the event is staged.

Faulkner: Why then has it taken so long to come to a decision?

DM: Well, licensing hearings are designed to drill down into the nitty-
gritty of an event. They're an opportunity for members of the public to
raise concerns and for official bodies like the Police, Fire Service
and Environmental Health to ensure that everything is above board and
all visitors to an event will be kept safe.

Now when you're dealing with an event of this size, not to mention the
reputation of the Glastonbury Festival, scrutinising every detail takes
time. It's pretty unprecedented for there to be seven hours of public
debate, followed by a further half-day of confidential discussion by
committee members.

Faulkner: OK, so where do we stand now. When do we find out the result?

DM: Well, we had hoped there would be a decision by the time we came on
the air, but sadly we'll have to wait a little longer. Mendip did
release a statement a little after 4 o'clock in which they blamed the
delays on the size and complexity of the event and say the decision may
now not be finalised until Wednesday next week.

Now we should point out this is entirely legal for the Council to take
that long. They are allowed up to 5 working days under Government
guidelines but it does mean a long and nervous wait for the residents
of Pilton and the neighbouring villages.

Faulkner: And once we do have a decision, what happens next?

DM: Well, if the Council says yes, the Festival will go ahead and make
their plans and announce a date once they've settled on it.

If the Council says no, the Festival organisers can lodge an appeal
within 30 days which would have to be heard by magistrates.

If they won the appeal, it would still give them enough time to put the
event together, but at this stage we're still dealing with a lot of
unknowns including of course what happens with coronavirus infection
rates once restrictions are completely lifted on the 21st June.

Faulkner: Daniel, thank you very much indeed."
*Note on conflicts of interest at MDC.

Members of the Executive or Cabinet should never sit on other committees of the Council, to avoid conflicts of interest. But as we have pointed out several times, Mendip District Council does not manage conflicts of interest, including on the Planning Board. This is the planning committee for MDC and its members include several members of Cabinet including the Leader of the Council Ros Wyke and whose Chair is Damon Hooton, who was previously in the MDC Cabinet for Planning and Development Management. All these are spectacularly bad ideas in the governance of any council and other councils including South Somerset specifically ban it.