Showing posts with label Somerset Business. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Somerset Business. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 8, 2021

UPDATE (6/7/22): Somerset Independents On Somerset Businesses: Repeat Environmental Offender Alvis Brothers at Lye Cross Farm

Alvis Brothers Ltd
Repeat Environmental Offenders

UPDATE (6/7/22)

We have repeatedly asked for a response, but have received none.

---

We will praise Somerset businesses when they are good employers, genuinely look after our wonderful County and enhance the reputation of Somerset.

And we will expose Somerset businesses when they do not, and particularly when they carry out "greenwash" to launder their image. We often find that companies that are too eager to make claims about their environmental credentials, are trying to hide something (e.g. see our reports on Wyke Farms, another "family-owned" business that claims to be "100% Green").

So we were disturbed to hear of Lye Cross Farm near Cheddar being prosecuted at Bristol Magistrates Court, which we were alerted to thanks to a report by The Leveller.

The company is Alvis Brothers Limited, who were fined £29,000 for repeated pollution incidents, after repeated visits by the Environment Agency. Apparently, says The Leveller:

"Offenders had not had as many slaps across the hand from the Environment Agency as in this case."

According to the Govwire website:

"Alvis Brothers Ltd have a long history of environmental offending, having previously received a formal caution and warning letters from the Environment Agency."

So we checked.

It turns out that like Wyke Farms, Alvis are repeat environmental offenders. And the dialogue between the Environment Agency and Alvis remained hidden until the court case. 

We believe that environmental pollution should be made public by default.

But too much pollution is hidden. And the Environment Agency do not publish their reports.

With Wyke Farms, Somerset Independents had to use Freedom of Information requests to find out what Wyke Farms had been up to, and the dialogue remained hidden until we had exposed it and reported on it.

So what of Alvis and Lye Cross Farm? On their website, they make much noise about "The Environment - Farming Responsibly". They claim that:

"The Alvis family cherish this area of outstanding natural beauty."

Really? According to Government records, Alvis were also prosecuted at the same Magistrates Court in 2014, and fined £16,000 under "EPR 2016 Regulation 38(1)(a)".

On the Alvis website, they also claim:

"Each system under Alvis management aims to protect and value wildlife and the environment by encouraging diverse habitat and the utilisation of animal manure and by crop rotation."

Their claims are difficult to reconcile with the successful prosecutions in court. Both prosecutions relate to pollution of the very environment that they claim to "cherish".

They also claim that:

"Other environmental measures include the creation and renovation of ponds and tributaries flowing into the River Yeo."

Yet they have polluted local waterways in repeated pollution incidents.

In the latest incident, the Govwire website stated that:

"Assessments by the Environment Agency the following week found a chronic impact on the aquatic invertebrates living downstream of the farm, whilst sensitive species, indicating a good water quality, were only found upstream."

The original article on Gov.uk stated that the offences were:

"Causing an unpermitted water discharge activity, namely the discharge of poisonous, noxious or polluting matter on and before 28 June 2019 from Lye Cross Farm, Redhill, Bristol into inland fresh waters contrary to Regulations 12(1)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(a) of the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016.

Fine £22,000.00

Causing an unpermitted water discharge activity, namely the discharge of poisonous, noxious or polluting matter on and before 18 September 2019 from Lye Cross Farm, Redhill, Bristol into inland fresh waters contrary to Regulations 12(1)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(a) of the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016.

Fine £ 7,000.00

Costs £ 8,003.02

Victim surcharge £ 181.00"

We will be asking Alvis Brothers to respond. We contacted Lye Cross Farm by email but they have not responded.

Standing Up For Somerset's Environment

 

Saturday, November 13, 2021

The Clark's Strike and March - We Support Workers Not The Labour Party

The Picket Line at Clark's in Street


Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope responds:
 
Leader of Somerset Independents
Andrew Pope

"Somerset Independents states again its support for residents and workers of Somerset. Indeed, it is in our Constitution that we protect Somerset residents and Somerset workers at Clark's - all of them.

Somerset Independents wishes to state that we support Clark's workers, but not the Labour Party. And from their responses to our questions to them, the local Somerset Tory MPs seem to support Clark's managements actions, to their shame. Neither Labour nor Tory are helping. They are out-of-date and out-of-touch.

Somerset Independents has taken action to protect residents and workers at Clark's - whether they are in the Community Union mentioned by Clark's - or not in the union. We've taken action to support workers at Norseland in Ilchester too. Where is Labour? Where are the Tories?

Somerset Independents has tried to work with the unions. We've offered the hand of help. But we have been met with a brick wall on Clark's and also at Norseland, where the GMB Union has let workers down. Their pay and working conditions have suffered.

These unions fail because of their connections to Labour, which put workers off. The Community Union and the GMB Union both affiliate to the Labour Party. Both unions donate large sums of money to the Labour Party. At a time when MPs are being examined for paid advocacy following Tory MP Owen Paterson's corruption, this needs to be looked at.

Labour's unions have also donated to Barry Gardiner, Brent North MP from London, who is due to speak at Saturday's march. He has received tens of thousands of pounds from these unions, as shown in his Register of Interests at Parliament, seemingly for his deeply flawed Fire and Rehire Bill, but for a company that he is the sole director of, according to Companies House records.

Barry Gardiner MP controls the money and the unions give it to him. There is no other Director, despite claims to the contrary that a Labour Lord is also a Director (Labour Lord Hendy).

Sadly it's another case of Labour or Tory, same old story. Gardiner is paid by the unions, but where the union money goes is not transparent enough.

So now we know why these unions don't want to work with Somerset Independents, although we have offered to pressure Clark's management and to work with the unions in the spirit of partnership.

These Labour Party-dominated unions are more interested in dialogue with the Labour Party and Labour MPs who do not live in Somerset such as Barry Gardiner, than working with Somerset Independents to pressure Clark's management and to resolve this dispute.

The Labour Party's methods are outdated. Their attitudes are outdated. Members money is mis-spent. Labour is totally split from top to bottom between Corbyn supporters and Starmer supporters.

That's why Labour is going nowhere in Somerset.

Meanwhile, Somerset Independents is winning its campaigns:
- exposing councillors who don't pay council tax,
- exposing councils who spend public money wrongly, and
- on holding companies like Norseland and Clark's to account.

Somerset Independents is standing up for workers and residents, whereas Labour-supporting unions have failed to win for workers.

And our success in campaigns shows why Somerset Independents is gaining support for its work in Somerset, working with residents and workers.

Somerset is our County."
 


Saturday, November 6, 2021

Somerset Tory MP Warburton Advocates Repeat Polluter Wyke Farms in Parliament and Votes to Defend Disgraced Tory MP Owen Paterson

Wyke Farms Greenwash
Involving Local Tory MP

Conservative MP for Somerton and Frome, David Warburton, has recently mentioned Wyke Farms at Prime Minister's Questions (PMQs) in Parliament. 

We hope that Mr Warburton was not following the example set by disgraced fellow Tory MP Owen Paterson, in using his position as an MP to help a company. Paterson has had to resign. We examine Mr Warburton's speech below.

Do Warburton's claims hold up to scrutiny, because he was praising Wyke Farms, using PR claims made by them?

No, they do not, because the claims come from Wyke Farms, who we have already shown are far from being "100% Green". Wyke Farms are much less than 100% "green". They are more brown than green.

We have shown that Wyke Farms are repeat environmental offenders, by showing evidence from Freedom of Information requests that we sent to the Environment Agency. 

We have shown that Wyke Farms' bad behaviour has been going on for years by showing the disgusting Pig Fattening Unit that Wyke Farms used for their "green" gas, and which was shut down after reports by animal rights activists in the Daily Mail. 

We have received the full reports from the Environment Agency and have published extracts from them to show the repeated pollution incidents and management failure by Wyke Farms at their Anaerobic Digester Plant, near Bruton in Somerset. We have more evidence and will publish it.

Warburton Advocates Wyke Farms "Green" Claims in Parliament

At PMQs, Mr Warburton asked the Prime Minister a stitched-up question making outlandish claims about Wyke Farms in a question about "National Cheese Toastie Day" (yes, really!). 

We will come to why he might be so keen to do this later, due to links between the local and national Conservative Party, Warburton and Wyke Farms. Is it advocacy or is it paid advocacy?

We hope that Mr Warburton has not been engaging in paid advocacy like Paterson did.

Warburton asked at PMQs (emphasis added, taken from Hansard):

"As the whole House will know, today is National Cheese Toastie Day. [Interruption.] It is a fact. A massive 4.3 billion toasties were consumed last year—they are the nation’s favourite snack—and glorious Somerset is the home of cheddar cheese. Wyke Farms, in my constituency, is now producing what I think is the world’s first entirely carbon-neutral cheddar cheese. Did my right hon. Friend know that eating cheddar from Somerset can reduce one’s cheese consumption carbon footprint by 55%, and will he support our vital diary industry by committing himself to enjoying a carbon-neutral cheese toastie today?"

We agree that Somerset is glorious! That's why we formed Somerset Independents. We are Somerset's only dedicated political party and campaign group that was formed in Somerset by Somerset residents and for Somerset residents.

But the rest of Warburton's question is highly dubious, laughable even, and is advocacy. 

Did Wyke Farms put Warburton up to this?

Many Tory MPs did laugh - and now we know from the recent scandal that so many Tory MPs are prepared to back a corrupt colleague who was found guilty by Standards investigation, to have done paid advocacy. 

Wyke Farms, who make much of being in Somerset, want to work with German-owned Lidl on this supposed "carbon neutral" cheese. It sounds like another exercise in greenwash from Wyke Farms, especially considering their record on the environment as evidenced by the Environment Agency, as well as complaints going back years from local residents to the authorities and further evidence from those local authorities. As we have said, we will be publishing further evidence in due course.

Warburton rarely makes a telling contribution inside or outside the House of Commons - don't take our word for it, that is what many constituents of his tell us regularly. As reported on this website, they've complained to us because he did not respond to residents. We took it up with Mark Spencer, the Chief Whip who ordered Tory MPs to back the corrupt Owen Paterson this week.

As we reported on this website, Mark Spencer told us that he could not intervene. So he covers up for failing MPs like David Warburton who do not respond to constituents. 

Letter from Chief Whip Mark Spencer
To Somerset Independents Leader

And Mark Spencer covered up for Owen Paterson as well in this week's shameful vote by Tory MPs.

Warburton has been photographed on site at Wyke Farms, with the owners of Wyke Farms and with David Cameron - another person who made grand claims of being "green" that turned out to be fake. 

David Cameron David Warburton
at Wyke Farms (photo from Wyke Farms Press Release)

David Warburton Is Hiding Behind David Cameron
(photo from Wyke Farms press release)

There are also lots of examples of Warburton mentioning Wyke Farms in Parliament and elsewhere including on his Facebook Page.

 

Is Warburton Doing Advocacy or Paid Advocacy?

We really do hope that David Warburton does not engage in paid advocacy. Standing up for local businesses is fine. Being paid to do it, whether directly, or into Conservative Party funds, is not. It is illegal and wrong, and if there is evidence presented to us, we will present it. 

Why would Wyke Farms wish to be promoted by such an MP?

Why would an MP wish to be associated with Wyke Farms?

Why didn't Warburton use PMQs to praise other Somerset cheese producers, e.g. Barber's, who have certified status as producing West Country Cheddar Cheese, as we have reported.

What is the relationship between Warburton and Wyke Farms?

Why Did Warburton Back Owen Paterson Who Was Guilty of Paid Advocacy?

Whether Warburton is engaging in paid advocacy or not, he did back paid advocacy. Why? Because he voted with other Conservative MPs who were whipped (told by the Chief Whip Mark Spencer) to back defeating the 30-day suspension of  Paterson.

It could be that paid advocacy is not limited, in the Conservative Party, to Owen Paterson. We would say that there are more MPs who have done it, and who are doing it.

These MPS need to be exposed and Parliament needs to be rid of this vile corruption.

It could be that individual MPs do not benefit from illegal payments. And it could be that the Conservative Party does benefit. The public need to know.

Other questions arise:

How many other MPs are doing paid advocacy, but have not been found out yet?

How many other MPs backed Owen Paterson to try to save their own skins, by stacking enquiries into MPs with Tories? Warburton did and Somerset MPs Marcus Fysh and Rebecca Pow also voted to protect Tory corruption.

Does the corruption include the Prime Minister Boris Johnson, a close "friend" of Owen Paterson?

And is David Warburton, with his fellow Tory MPs, now seeking to change the rules so that they are even less likely to be found out?

Investigations of MPs need to be independent of the political parties. The current system has independent lay people (non-MPs) on the Committee. They outweigh the MPs. That needs to be case. That must be the case.

The people of Somerset deserve to know the full truth about their MPs, and independence of these corrupt national political parties, is the only way of finding out the truth. That's why Somerset Independents was formed!

We will continue our investigations into MPs and councillors.


Sunday, October 31, 2021

Somerset Independents On Somerset Businesses: Wyke Farms Claims "100% Green" Energy But Environment Agency Shows Wyke Farms As Repeat Environmental Offenders

 

Wyke Farms Claims "100% Green"
But Is It? No.

As well as holding Somerset's councils and elected representatives to account, and praising them where appropriate, Somerset Independents has been penning a series of articles on Somerset's businesses.

Somerset has businesses that have great reputations in the West Country, in the UK and over the World. We want Somerset to be know for the right reasons. So far, we have looked at Clark's, Barber's and Norseland.

We have looked at employment rights, recruitment and retention, quality produce, the impact of Brexit, the impact of Covid-19 and the reputation of Somerset's businesses in general.

Now we turn our attention to Wyke Farms, a Somerset-based company in Wyke Champflower, near Bruton. The company has other sites in Somerset, including an Anaerobic Digester (AD) plant at Lamyatt, and a depot at Wincanton. They are also building a new storage facility at the former Lambrook Piggery, next to the AD plant.

Wyke Farms Sustainable Energy Visitor Centre

They claim, at the entrance to the AD plant and former Piggery, what is shown in the below photo.


Wyke Farms 100% Green

"Wyke Farms 100% Green Sustainable Energy Visitor Centre" the sign says.

They also make much of being in Somerset, and they repeat their "100% Green" claims several times on their website.

But Wyke Farms is not 100% green as they claim. Not by a long shot. It is just another load of greenwash, on the eve of the COP26 climate summit in Glasgow.

What do we mean by "greenwash". We mean that Wyke Farms appears to be yet another company that claims it is "green" but is not. The UK has enough of those already.

One earlier example of the gulf between their marketing and the reality of their business practises was the Lambrook Piggery that was next to the AD Plant. It is  now closed after animal rights activists exposed the barbaric practises at the Piggery, as reported by the Daily Mail.

Was this just a one-off offence? No. Why do we say this?

Because Wyke Farms is, in fact, a serial offender on the environment and being "green".

Do we have evidence? Yes we do. We do not state things without evidence, because we are a credible force in Somerset. It would be foolish, and illegal, to do anything else.

Any reasonable person would agree with us, presented with the evidence that we have, that Wyke Farms is a repeat offender. The facts are there in the evidence.

Our evidence is taken from Freedom of Information requests submitted by Somerset Independents, and other information that our officers and supporters have gleaned about Wyke Farms and its environmental greenwash.

The evidence is from the Environment Agency, who have been very reluctant to give it to us, and even more reluctant to enforce on Wyke Farms, despite their repeated offences. 

The evidence is also from local residents who have been impacted by Wyke Farms and its operations at various sites in Somerset.

And the evidence is also from various departments of the local authorities, Somerset County Council, Mendip District Council and South Somerset District Council. Like the Environment Agency, these local authorities have used a very "light touch" approach to regulating Wyke Farms, despite their repeated offences and despite the legal duty on the authorities to protect local residents and the environment, in co-ordination with the Environment Agency.

Below are some examples of the evidence that we have obtained. We publish it in the public interest, on the eve of COP26.

Evidence Part 1 - EPR Compliance Assessment Report from the Environment Agency on 11th March 2020 to Wyke Farms Limited regarding Lambrook AD Plant

"You have been scored a CCS 3 for the breach in emission limits with the test failure under condition 3.5.1 and table 3.1. If you are unable to fix this issue there are likely to be further scores including under management as root cause.
You should also have reported the breach as soon as you became aware of this under a schedule 5 notice of the permit - see condition."
This was a breach of an Air condition via a breach in emission limits and a breach of reporting. In other words, air pollution in the Somerset countryside.

Evidence Part 2 - EPR Compliance Assessment Report from the Environment Agency on 22nd May 2020 to Wyke Farms Limited regarding Lambrook AD Plant

"Pests
Non-compliance You have been scored a CCS 3 for presence of pests which are likely to give rise to annoyance outside the boundary of the site under condition 3.6.1. There were hundreds of gulls above and adjacent to the site. There were signs of mess on the AD domes and this has been mentioned before. It was said that these birds are present in such numbers since closure of a nearby landfill.
There has been a complaint regarding shooting of birds around the AD plant. But you say you do not use this method. There are other measures you could try.
Action Under condition 3.6.2 please submit for approval, within 1 month, a pest management plan which identifies and minimises the risk of pollution from pests."
You can see that Wyke Farms have tried to claim that "these birds are present in such numbers since closure of a nearby landfill". Wyke Farms tried to blame something else, other than their own shoddy practises - just like when Lambrook Piggery reached the national headlines and brought shame to Somerset.

Evidence Part 3 - EPR Compliance Assessment Report from the Environment Agency on 22nd May 2020 to Wyke Farms Limited regarding Lambrook AD Plant

"Odours...There was a faint gassy smell at the fence line of the AD site, but this was not detected further away over the culvert.
You said that as part of your own management regime you continue to undertake a routine leak detection and repair schedule.

Close by to the slurry lagoon there was an odour– although it was not noticed off site before my arrival. I recommended that, if ever agitation was needed, then this should be at times when the wind is not blowing from the south or towards nearby residents. The slurry pit is open and is a potential source of odour.
There is also an open circular tank in the permit which was said to be being used for surplus cow slurry. I explained that this is old infrastructure. Risks to the water course from it need to be minimised as well as being a potential source of odour. "
It is important to note the above, as there is later evidence from the Environment Agency and complaints from local residents over several years that shows repeat offences relating to pollution, noise and odours.

 

Evidence Part 4 - EPR Compliance Assessment Report from the Environment Agency on 15th February 2021 to Wyke Farms Limited regarding Lambrook AD Plant 

After an incident at the AD Plant, Wyke Farms was found to have made multiple breaches of the conditions of their permit. The four breaches were:

  1. Breach of Infrastructure Permit Conditions (Engineering for prevention & control of pollution).
  2. Breach of General Management Permit Conditions (Management system & operating procedures).
  3. Breach of Emissions Permit Conditions (Surface water).
  4. Breach of Monitoring and records, maintenance and reporting Permit Conditions (Reporting & notification).

The Environment Agency Report says:

"This was a response to a self-report of an incident involving the over topping of the permitted slurry lagoon. This arose from waste being stored in the Permastore leading to uncontrolled emissions of slurry contents to the yard, surface water drains and the stream which runs beneath the site. The report was phoned in around 8:50 on 15/02/2021, but had occurred at around 16:00 on 14/02/2021."

As we have pointed out above, Wyke Farms were warned in earlier reports of "The slurry pit is open and is a potential source of odour... Risks to the water course from it need to be minimised as well as being a potential source of odour. " 

The Report says:

"We consider pollution was caused... 

The failure to put in place appropriate measures to prevent the spill...

The root cause is considered to be a failure of management."

So despite being warned about it, Wyke Farms did not pay attention. Their management failed. And when the incident occurred, causing pollution, they delayed reporting it. 

The Environment Agency should have acted earlier. Local residents made many complaints about the AD Plant, and the Piggery. But the Environment Agency did not act early enough. And repeated pollution incidents, to air and water, have occurred.

But the same lax management of the Piggery, and the repeated failures by Wyke Farms to act on the Environment Agency reports, added to the reluctance of the Agency and local authorities, meant that pollution had occurred again at the AD Plant.

In a time when development in Somerset is held up due to pollution, it is important to note that the local river is the River Brue that flows through Bruton, past Glastonbury and eventually into Bridgwater Bay.

So Wyke Farms has polluted air and water repeatedly, as we have said at the beginning of the article. But this is only some of evidence.

The Environment Agency has set out the Actions that Wyke Farms must take:

"Actions
Monitoring the water quality including any waste or polluting sludges or slurries that are stored or spread to land
Make arrangement to tanker excess liquids away
Provide a plan to remove the contents of the tank in the safest way possible by 26 February 2021
Review your accident management plan 26 February 2021
Provide a plan for decommissioning the Permastore tank by 26 February 2021 works to be completed by August 2021.
Review and improve monitoring of the former pig slurry pit.
Review your notification procedures 26 February 2021
We consider that there is an on-going pollution risk at the site and therefore you are requested to submit an Emissions Management Plan to identify and minimise the risk of pollution to the ground and water as set out in condition 3.2.2. This shall include: Managing the water course in the culvert including an assessment to minimise potential emission sources from the site.

This is an initial Compliance Assessment Report for the incident. We may review scores and action subject to any further information that may come to light. We are considering our enforcement response."

Above are just some examples of the environment offences by Wyke Farms, that prove that the are repeat offenders, and that the exposure of the disgraceful Piggery was not just a once-off.

We will be publishing more, leading up to and during the COP26 Climate Change summit. There will be enough BS being spoken and written in Glasgow for COP26.

So we hope to restore the balance and facts to the reputation of companies like Wyke Farms who are based in Somerset, use questionable marketing and PR claims to market their products. And as we have shown, Wyke Farms' claims do not stand up to much scrutiny. 

Wyke Farms are definitely not 100% Green.



Somerset Independents On Somerset Businesses: Foreign-Owned Somerset Cheese Producer Norseland

Somerset Independents is continuing its focus on Somerset businesses. We want to see Somerset's reputation enhanced as a producer of the best goods and services, and for Somerset businesses to be the best employers, with the best pay and conditions for workers.

So we were alarmed when residents, current workers and former workers at Norseland, the company that owns Ilchester cheese, contacted us about what it is like working at the company. Norseland's UK manufacturing base in in Ilchester, Somerset. Here is the Norseland UK "About" page.

Norseland is not UK-owned. It is not owned by Somerset people. Ultimately, Norseland is Norwegian-owned, and owns a large number of cheese brands including Jarlsberg, Snofrisk, Gudbrandsdalen, Applewood and Mexicana cheeses. TINE SA is the owner and is "Norway's largest co-operative of farmers". Norseland has told us that "Norseland is an operating subsidiary of Tine SA as part of the Tine International".

So while Ilchester cheese carries the Ilchester name, and it is produced in Ilchester, the owners are Norwegian.

However, Norseland's Clive Richer Head of Human Resources (HR) and Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) told us:

"whilst Norwegian owned, with a Norwegian CEO,  Norseland runs very independently, and recruits 90%+  of its staff from the Somerset/Dorset Area (Being only 6 miles from the Dorset Border), and this will continue to be the case ongoing."

The contact with us from workers followed articles appearing in local media, including with SomersetLive (Reach/Trinity Mirror), where various claims were made by Norseland in a barely-concerned advert for the foreign-owned company, but also in the article Norseland were blaming Brexit for their recruitment and retention problems. 

These workers were incensed at the claims made, and refuted the claims made by Norseland.

During the course of 2021, Brexit has been blamed for many things - sometimes this is justified with evidence and sometimes this is not justified by evidence.

So we contacted the Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Manager mentioned in one of the article, Mr Clive Richer, to ask him some questions.

The letter from the Leader of Somerset Independent, Andrew Pope, is below, along with the responses from Mr Richer. 

We will let you make up your own minds about whether he answered our questions, and whether his claims stack up under scrutiny.

We suggest that the claims from Clive Richer do not stand up to much scrutiny.

It also took Mr Richer over two months to reply, and we had to chase him for a response.

We will be going back to the people who made the allegations with Mr Richer's responses.

We will also be asking the unions about Norseland, including what the unions did to help workers, what they did not do to help workers, and why  there is no union recognised by Norseland for collective bargaining purposes.

---

Letter from Somerset Independents to Norseland's Clive Richer

Good Morning Mr Richer,

Somerset Independents is a pressure group that was formed by residents
to stand up for Somerset residents and their rights.

We support business and the promotion of Somerset. Some of your
cheeses have the names of well-known places in Somerset.

So we were alarmed to note some of the claims made by you in the
following articles:

https://www.somersetlive.co.uk/news/somerset-news/somerset-cheesemaker-braces-huge-christmas-5587322

https://www.business-live.co.uk/manufacturing/somerset-cheesemaker-norseland-says-brexit-20829245

https://www.somersetlive.co.uk/news/somerset-news/somerset-cheese-factory-says-staff-5531197

You stated in the articles that Norseland is a "respected employer
locally; we offer training, good benefits and a career path for
workers". We also note your "Modern Slavery Statement".

Former workers have contacted Somerset Independents to tell us that at
least some of the claims that you made in that article are of
questionable veracity.

They've told us that the recruitment and retention problems faced by
Norseland are nothing to do with Brexit.

These former workers who are residents of Somerset, plus other
residents of Somerset too, have alleged that:

1. Norseland has thrown innocent people out of work
2. The problems are not to do with Brexit, but with the situation at Norseland
3. Norseland inflicts bad treatment on its workers
4. There are health and safety problems at Norseland
5. The pay at Norseland is poor
6. There is poor management and poor leadership
7. Problems are not sorted out

Q1. How do you respond to the above allegations?

Q2. What changes have been made in the management and structure of
Norseland recently, and do you believe these have had an impact on
recruitment and retention?

Q3. Why does Norseland seek to blame Brexit when it appears from these
allegations from your own former workers, that it is the way your
company is being run that is the problem and not Brexit?

Q4. When you claim in one article that, and I quote:

"So many of our staff returned to their home countries when Brexit
happened, and we have faced a struggle to recruit replacements because
of the general exodus of EU workers across the county and the UK as a
whole. "

It isn't true, is it? Because these workers have found better work for
better pay elsewhere after leaving Norseland, some of them within a
matter days.

Q5. Because of their unhappiness, we've been informed that workers
joined the GMB union, which they are entitled to do under the law. Is
there a union recognised by Norseland for collective bargaining
purposes? Which union is it?

Please give these questions your earliest attention. We offer you a
right of reply.

Regards,
Andrew Pope
Leader
Somerset Independents

 

Responses To Questions from Clive Richer to Andrew Pope

Q1. How do you respond to the above allegations?

In response to this question, we believe at Norseland that we treat all our staff with fairness and respect. The business has a number of company policies and procedures in place to ensure that everyone is treated equally. In terms of people leaving, we have conducted confidential exit interviews which demonstrate that a number of staff have left to return home.

 

Regarding Health and Safety, Norseland takes this very seriously and as such monitors our near misses and loss time accidents etc and compares these to industry standards set out by the HSE. On all measures, we are performing better than the standards set. These are achieved by all our employees following the thorough processes and procedures in place.

 

In terms of pay, Norseland’s starting rate is £10.00ph and goes up to £10.65 (Food Processor rates) and this does not include Shift premiums available for certain shifts, with an additional £2.08ph. We believe these are competitive within our area.

 

We cannot comment on specific incidents involving past employees. On the question about “Poor Management, Poor Leadership and problems not being addressed”. What we can say is that we also closely observe our retention and absence as a business and our figures are in line with national CIPD averages for our industry. It is always regrettable when people leave our business because they are unhappy, and as a responsible employer, we always try and learn from those experiences to provide a better working relationship with new and existing employees going forward.

 

Q2. What changes have been made in the management and structure of Norseland recently, and do you believe these have had an impact on recruitment and retention?

 

We have had management changes over the last 18 months, however we do not believe these have had a negative impact, to the contrary our retention figures has significantly improved over the last 2 years.

 

Q3. Why does Norseland seek to blame Brexit when it appears from these allegations from your own former workers, that it is the way your company is being run that is the problem and not Brexit?

As previously mentioned, a number of our staff have left to return home.

 

Q4. When you claim in one article that, and I quote:

 

"So many of our staff returned to their home countries when Brexit happened, and we have faced a struggle to recruit replacements because of the general exodus of EU workers across the county and the UK as a whole. "

 

It isn't true, is it? Because these workers have found better work for better pay elsewhere after leaving Norseland, some of them within a matter days.

 

In response to Q4: Some of our staff have left due to Brexit. Clearly there will always be other staff who move on to other businesses for a variety of reasons of which pay will no doubt be one of them.

 

Q5. Because of their unhappiness, we've been informed that workers joined the GMB union, which they are entitled to do under the law. Is there a union recognised by Norseland for collective bargaining purposes? Which union is it?

 

In response to Q5: Norseland does not currently have a recognised Union.

 

 

 

Clive Richer​
Head of HR & CSR

 

Wednesday, October 13, 2021

Somerset Independents On Somerset Businesses: Just What Is Going On At Clark's?

 


Somerset Independents wants Somerset residents to be proud of what Somerset businesses produce, and for Somerset's reputation to be enhanced outside Somerset and across the world.

We will happily praise Somerset-based businesses that Somerset people can be proud of. But we will challenge businesses that we believe may be tarnishing the reputation of Somerset.

Clark's shoes was founded in Street, Somerset, by the Quakers C & J Clark. The Registered Office is still in Street. The Alfred Gillett Trust is a Somerset-based charity in Street which "preserves the heritage collections of C & J Clark Ltd., the family which founded the global shoemaking company".

It has been a large employer of Somerset workers for almost 200 years. It is a well-known and respected brand for shoes.

We were therefore concerned to hear of the ongoing industrial dispute at Clark's, which has now led to strike action.

So we have contacted workers representatives at the Mendip Trades Union Council (TUC), to try to find out the truth behind the strikes.

Somerset Independents officers Andrew Pope and Denise Wyatt wrote to the Mendip TUC, saying:

"This dispute is tarnishing the reputation of Clarks, who were founded by Quakers. And it is harming the relationship between employer and employees. This will impact on the sustainability of the business, harming Somerset's workers.

We believe that the founders would be extremely upset at the current situation and that they would never have allowed this.

What changes have occurred since the Lion Rock takeover and how are the "key" shareholders acting since the takeover to protect the company's reputation?

What changes have occurred in employment relations?

Now that workers have been forced to strike, do you believe that the new owners will bring retribution on any workers?

Finally, how can Somerset Independents assist in helping to resolving the situation?"

 

Mendip TUC told us:

"Clarks warehouse workers, members of the Community Union, face the following threats:


1. An average reduction in pay of £1.66 per hour: from the current £11.16p to £9.50p;


2. An increase in working hours of 2.5 per week, due to paid 30-minute meal breaks being abolished;


3. No pay rise for at least four years, despite the union agreeing to help the company through a 'difficult financial spell' by accepting two hours less per week INSTEAD of a pay rise on two different occasions and at the company’s proposal.


4. Drastic cuts in sick pay: from 13 weeks full pay to 6 weeks full pay and 6 weeks half pay; abolition of sick pay for the first day of absence; no sick pay entitlement from day one of employment, only after 6 months;


5. The abolition of a daily ten-minute coffee break, brought in at the company's request to ease warehouse operations;


6. A drastic reduction in redundancy entitlements: from enhanced double statutory, to statutory, (ie, one week’s wages per year of service), raising fears that the company will get rid of workers, even close the Street Distribution Centre, just as they are closing their distribution centre in Kendal.  


7. Cuts to overtime rates to time thus giving no chance to increase pay"


8. No direct cuts to maternity pay or pension entitlements, BUT with a 15-20% cut in wages, pensions will suffer a drastic fall when taken out."


Dave Chapple, Secretary of Mendip TUC, said:

"I have personally, met four Clarks workers who fear losing their homes (Inability to pay rent, mortgage) and even lose contact with their children (If only able to afford a bedsit, unsuitable accommodation for children).


Is this the Clarks Quaker Family firm that was an iconic part of manufacturing, 'factory' Britain for 200 years?


Is this, even the Clarks family firm that, even when it closed all of its Somerset factories over a 15-year period, nonetheless treated its remaining Street HQ and warehouse workers, and their trades unions, with respect?


NO! Welcome to the "Brave New World" of Clarks' new owners Lion Rock Capital.


Hong Kong based, venture capitalist, hedge fund capitalist, slash and burn capitalist, just pick your most accurate label!


Is this really the future for work in this country: no more decent trades union recognition or collective bargaining negotiations, just industrial dictatorship, "take it or leave it" "Fire and rehire?” "


Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, says:

Andrew Pope

"Just what is going on at Clark's? What do the new owners think they are doing? Do they even know about the traditions of Clark's, or even care?

Many years ago, when I was doing my training to be a union representative and negotiator, I was stunned to hear that under a Labour Government (Blair/Brown), that Fire and Rehire was commonly done. Worse, it was allowed under UK law. In 13 years of Government, Labour failed to end Fire and Rehire.

Loosely, what Fire and Rehire means is that employers are able to dismiss employees on existing contracts, and force them to accept new terms and conditions in a new contract. If the employee does not sign the new contract, then they are deemed to no longer have a job.

Indeed, this is what happened in the large negotiation in the AXA Group of insurance companies, in which I represented thousands of employees in the harmonisation of terms of conditions, after AXA had taken over other companies. 

I pushed back when the directors of AXA said that the harmonisation would be done via the termination of existing contracts, but other union representatives and the union official explained to me that this was the way it was going to be done.

So I fought very hard to ensure that if this was going to be done, that there would be an absolute minimum of employees losing out.

This situation at Clark's is therefore horrendous to hear about. It is almost as if the new owners of Clark's, Lion Rock, want to force employees out and this Fire and Rehire is their tool of choice for achieving this, by cutting pay and conditions unilaterally, without the agreement of employees."


Somerset Independents is considering its next steps in relation to this dispute.



 

Saturday, September 11, 2021

Somerset Independents On Somerset Businesses: Barber's of Ditcheat and West Country Farmhouse Cheddar

Somerset Hay and Somerset Flag

UPDATE: After we offered a Right of Reply, Michael Masters of Barber's has replied to say:

"All looks fine to me thank you – I was a bit concerned as I read it initially as there appeared to be many ‘claims by Barber’s statements, which are ultimately substantiated.

 

One other aspect if you wish to amend at all, may be our desire to encourage new dairy farmers to the industry – and so bucking the trend. I have attached my most recent Farmer Newsletter for your interest, page two in particular I hope may be of interest with our focus on the next generation."

Somerset Independents is happy to promote the dairy industry. However, our support is not unconditional. We will challenge the dairy industry to do better to enhance the reputation of our County of world-leading practises in produce, farming and animal welfare.
 
---
 
Somerset is famous all over the world for its dairy products, its cows, its milk and its cheese. 
 
Somerset Independents wants Somerset residents to be proud of what Somerset businesses produce, and for Somerset to maintain its reputation as a world leader in cheddar cheese.
 
Cheddar is an actual town in Somerset, after all!
 
Barber's are located in Ditcheat, near to Shepton Mallet, Castle Cary and Bruton. Ditcheat is not very far from Cheddar itself.
 
A.J. and R.G. Barber Limited and related company A.J. & R.G.BARBER (SALES) LIMITED are located at Maryland Farm in Ditcheat. There are other companies related to Barber's, located elsewhere including at West Horrington, Wells.
 
On Barber's website, on their "About" page, they make what may seem to be a very big claim:
"The Barber family have been making cheddar cheese for longer than anyone else worldwide. So, when it comes to combining the finest West Country milk with traditional manufacturing methods to produce award-winning cheese, we'd like to think that we've learnt a thing or two."
There are a huge number of producers of cheddar cheese in the world. To claim that they have been doing it longer than anyone else is a massive statement by Barber's. 
 
Barber's also claim that they are the "oldest surviving cheddar-makers in the world":
"In 1833, our ancestor Daniel Barber began making cheese on his Somerset farm. Nearly two centuries later and we’re still here, now the oldest surviving cheddar-makers in the world. We’ve made a few changes along the way, but we’re still committed to making the finest farmhouse cheddar."

Now websites and marketing can sometimes be stretching the truth. Yet Barber's claims do seem to hold water. 

PDO-accreditation and PGI-accreditation were both European Union (EU) certification systems. EU certifications do not come easily. 

Since the UK left the EU (Brexit), the UK Government has brought in its own certification system, also called PDO.

"To make the best cheese, we need the best West Country milk. Our dairy cows graze the lush pastures of Somerset and Dorset to produce rich, creamy milk that we transform into PDO-accredited cheddar. We also work with many of our neighbouring farmers who supply us with additional milk and we’re proud to support our local farming community in this way.

We’re also the sole guardians of the country’s last remaining traditional cheese starter cultures — the ‘friendly’ bacteria that start the cheesemaking process and contribute to the final texture, aroma and taste. Only by using these cultures can we be sure that we’re making true West Country cheddar."

Under the certification, there is a:
 
PRODUCT SPECIFICATION “West Country Farmhouse Cheddar”

for the cheese. This is very involved and to be called PDO-certified "West Country Farmhouse Cheddar", a producer has to meet this specification.

In the specification, it states (emphasis added):

"Since its registration in 1955 usage of the MMB Certification Trade Mark –
“Farmhouse Cheddar Cheese” – has been restricted to makers who meet certain key
requirements, namely that:
- The cheese is made on the farm
- Milk, all or part of which, must come from the maker’s own cows
- The cheese is produced using in vat methods (rather than moving belt or cheddarmasters)
- The cheese is made by hand
- The cheese is subject to independent grading at between 2 to 4 months – only cheese which has unique characteristics of Farmhouse Cheddar may use the mark
- Cheese sold as Farmhouse Cheddar bearing the logo must be kept for at least 9 months
The independent inspection of the cheese and the routine checking of the farmhouse cheesemaker’s premises have been a regular feature of the verification process for true farmhouse cheddar."

Also on Barber's website, they confirm the certification:
 
"It’s this milk, produced in Somerset and Dorset, which means we can make PDO-accredited cheddar. The PDO certifies that our cheese was made using local milk, traditional techniques and was aged to perfection for at least nine months."
 
Somerset Independents is proud that Barber's is a Somerset company and that it is producing the pre-eminent certified West Country Farmhouse Cheddar.

We are committed to protecting Somerset's reputation as the best producer of Cheddar in the world and anybody who has tasted Barber's cheese will know just how good Barber's cheese is.

But that's not the end of it with Barber's. They also have produced a statement of Corporate Governance.

And unlike some companies, Barber's seem to practise what they preach.

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope can attest to this:
 
Andrew Pope

 
"I contacted Barber's about their large milk trucks on the country lanes around the area. As they say in their PDO-certification, the milk has to be local.

Residents had complained to me that sometimes, some of their driving was not as safe as it could be, especially given how narrow the roads are in some parts.

So I contacted Barber's and raised it with them, mentioning that I was a big fan of their cheese and a local resident too.

They got back to me very quickly. And they listened and took action.

This is what all Somerset businesses should be doing - listening to local residents and acting on their concerns. I now have regular dialogue with Barber's.

Their statement of Corporate Governance is there for everyone to see. And they practise it. So not only do they make superb cheddar, they also try to live the values that they proclaim. This can seem rare these days, as companies often fail to do so.

Barber's cheese is superb and so very tasty. It's a pity that I am a little bit allergic to cheese, but I still eat it from time to time as Barber's is the best cheddar cheese that I have ever eaten.
 
Well done to Barber's. They are a company that Somerset can be proud of."