Showing posts with label Bristol. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bristol. Show all posts

Thursday, October 13, 2022

"No Such Thing As Impartial Reporting" says Bristol-based Journalist

 

One of our Official emblems

"This notion of ‘impartial’ journalism is a Western construct. There is no such thing as impartial reporting."

Somerset Independents puts Somerset residents first. However, we sometimes venture "over the border" into Bristol because Somerset and Bristol influence each other. And sometimes these two parts of the South West compete for public resources, such as with Avon and Somerset Police.

In another part of our series on local campaigners and journalists, campaigner Andrew Pope interviewed Joanna Booth, a Bristol-based freelance journalist, book editor and researcher.

Andrew asked her:

Andrew Pope
"Where do you see the dividing line between being a journalist and being a campaigner?

Joanna Booth

Joanna replied:

"I don’t think there is a dividing line. Journalists provide certain skills in making information known. This notion of ‘impartial’ journalism is a Western construct. There is no such thing as impartial reporting. Choices are made about what to include or omit all the time. The professionalisation of journalism is a far cry from the profession of journalism where the radical press in England tried to inform people of what actually would make their lives better."

This is different to the view - often promoted by journalists or editors themselves - that journalists should not be campaigners and campaigners should not be journalists. Joanna also says:

"I don’t consider myself to be a campaigner. I am a resident who is active in how they are represented by those I pay through my taxes and other payments...

As long as I pay taxes and there are people in power who are supposed to represent me, I intend to do my best to scrutinise them...

I aim to work towards scrutiny, transparency, and accountability." 

But there are costs and drawbacks to working in the public interest. Joanna says:

"Whenever you speak in opposition to those in power, you have the added burden of having to explain everything. The dominant narrative is constructed in such a way that it never seems to need explanation." 

The problems that Joanna has found are similar to what Somerset Independents has experienced when challenging authority and holding elected representatives to account, such as:

"Any campaigner who goes against that has to prove themselves and armed with information to back up what they say. Always have the receipts. You will constantly be asked for them and you will be doubted. Expect those in power to offer no proof or evidence in return."

And the costs to a journalist who challenges authority can be severe and personal:

"I’ve recently written about being smeared – I get called a racist or a harasser, a conspiracy theorist (mentally ill), a waster of public money and time, and obsessed."

But it seems that despite this, Joanna is not put off. She says:

"As long as I am punching up and with a view of the public interest, I will keep speaking the truth."

Joanna Booth writes at Substack, tweets at @StillAwake and produces a newsletter at Substack. She has written widely on the local issues in Bristol, including on:

Andrew Pope is being trained in journalism by the National Council for the Training of Journalists (NCTJ) and tweets at @APoliticalPope. He is a former councillor and co-founded Somerset Independents in 2020, having also co-founded Southampton Independents in 2015.

 

Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future. 

Our Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) page is here.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Sunday, August 14, 2022

NIMBYs, YIMBYs and Image Laundering: The Life of a Passionate Somerset and Bristol Wildlife Campaigner

Yanley, North Somerset

 

"I couldn’t believe the council and developers were trying to tell us they could enhance the ecology of a nationally rare habitat by building over it...ecologists need to be truly independent...you wouldn’t eat at a restaurant that hired their own food safety inspector so why should we accept less for our irreplaceable environment?"


Western Slopes

Somerset Independents puts residents first. Our Constitution also commits us to protect Somerset's wildlife, ecosystems and countryside.

North Somerset is being invaded by the urban sprawl of Bristol. England's "green and pleasant land" (words from our unofficial national anthem Jerusalem) is being built upon. 

You may have heard of "NIMBYs" (Not In My Backyard) which is a frequently-used attack by developers and some councillors on local people who oppose their developments. 

For example, this accusation has been thrown at the Keep Wrington as Wrington campaign in North Somerset, which Somerset Independents advised in its early stages. "NIMBYs" was also thrown at the Easthill campaign in Frome, East Somerset - another campaign that we advised and won (see photo above approved for use by campaigners).


Easthill, Frome
Saved With Our Help


But have you heard of "YIMBYs"?

And did you know that conservation organisations are allowing developers to launder their images by doing "partnerships"?

Andrew Pope interviewed Danica Priest, originally from Virginia in the United States of America and now living in South Bristol.  


Andrew Pope

 

Like Somerset Independents and our supporters, Danica is campaigning against developers, councils, so-called "independent" ecologists and conservation organisations who - against their better judgement - allow both to launder their image. Here is what Danica told Andrew.

 

Danica Priest

 

Andrew: Why did you get involved in campaigning?

Danica: "It started with the Western Slopes/Novers Hill and snowballed when I realised how bad the planning system is, especially compared to Virginia where I grew up. The lack of regulations for environmental issues like erosion control, sewage dumping and endangered species protection is insane.

 

Yanley, North Somerset

 

"I couldn’t believe the council and developers were trying to tell us they could enhance the ecology of a nationally rare habitat by building over it. My dad worked in the housing industry for over 40 years so I grew up around construction sites and that just felt like pure gaslighting to me."


Q: What do you want to achieve personally in your campaigns?

A: "I’m hoping the wildlife habitats under threat of development will be protected permanently and all removed or kept out of the local plan. Especially The Western Slopes/Novers Hill (private and public sections), Yew Tree Farm, Brislington Meadows, Ashton Vale, Marksbury Road, Yanley/Woodsprings greenbelt land and the south Bristol greenbelt.

 

Ashton Vale
 

Danica: "I’d also love to see greater protections for wildlife and priority habitats and a requirement for truly independent ecologists for surveys. I always say you wouldn’t eat at a restaurant that hired their own food safety inspector so why should we accept less for our irreplaceable environment?

Planning wise I want to abolish the loop holes that allow developers to get out of their affordable housing requirements and other promises to contribute to the local community. It’s disgusting that Developers have more safety nets for their profits than vulnerable families have for their children.

I also want to end the unrealistic housing targets and delivery tests which are the root of all these issues. People have been misled to think higher targets = more houses built = lower prices = end of housing crisis. That’s not reality though. People forget developers are not charities and they will build when and where it’s most profitable for them. The current system results in less density, fewer green spaces, less farmland, less wildlife, fewer council homes and higher prices. Everyone loses except for developers, investors and landowners."


Q: Who and which organisations or councillors do you believe are your allies in what you want to achieve?

A: "Bristol Tree Forum definitely deserve a medal for all the hard work they do. Manor Woods Valley group and Crox Bottom have been fantastic allies along with other green spaces and friends of groups.

We’ve also been lucky to have some supportive councillors from all parties fighting in our corner.

Richard Eddy, Ed Plowden, Tony Dyer, Tim Rippington (all Bristol City Council) and Ash Cartman (Executive Member, North Somerset Council) have all gone above and beyond to help."


Q: Who and which organisations or councillors do you believe are your enemies against what you want to achieve?

A: "Most of the property industry organisations and neoliberal think tanks are against us which is to be expected since we are a threat to the broken system they make billions from.

YIMBYs (Yes In My Back Yard) are the most vile of those, especially on Twitter. There are a few awful yimby councillors in London. Luckily most that ran didn’t win their elections which tells you a lot about public opinion.

I’m sure the Bristol City Council Planning department heads are not my biggest fans either. I hope we can be friends someday though, I don’t like having enemies."


Q: Who may be fair-weather friends?

A: "I hate to say it but many of the wildlife charities have partnered with big developers so we can’t trust them anymore. Avon Wildlife Trust have been supportive of the slopes so I appreciate that it might have nothing to do with various local branches but I’ve definitely lost respect for the national Wildlife Trust and The Bumblebee Conservation Trust for supporting Redrow, who want to build over Yew Tree Farm and RSPB for partnering with Barratt Homes."


Q: Who may be hidden enemies (e.g. infiltrators)?

A: I’m not aware of any yet. I don’t think an infiltrator would be too successful since we don’t really have many secrets.


Q: Do you think that you need to get elected representation on councils to achieve your objectives, or is this just one way of achieving what you want?

A: "We can’t achieve much without the support of the Councillors on the planning committee so it’s essential we have supportive elected representatives."


Q: How long are you personally prepared to give to achieving your campaign objectives?

A: "Forever. I’ll never give up. This is my life now."


Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future. 

We exist to protect Somerset's wildlife, our ecosystems and countryside.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Wednesday, July 20, 2022

UPDATE (25/1/23): Regulator Agrees With Bristol! - Regulator Confirms Investigation into Bristol City Council - Council Refuses TWICE To Tell Us Which Councillors Did Not Pay Their Council Tax - We've Complained To The Information Commissioner

 

One of our Official emblems

UPDATE (25/1/23)

You may find it hard to believe... But after many months since they were going to investigate, the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) has issued a Decision Notice as below, which shows that they agreed with Bristol City Council that they can keep the identity SECRET of councillor or councillors who did not pay their council tax.

The ICO, in their Decision Notice have written to us to say the following. Therefore the people of Bristol will not know the names of councillors who did not pay up.

"The Commissioner does not require the Council to take any steps."

and despite:

"The Commissioner considers that the complainant is pursuing a
legitimate interest and that disclosure of the requested information is necessary to meet that legitimate interest."

that the ICO decided:

"The Council explained its reasons to the Commissioner as to why the circumstances in this case are compelling enough that to disclose the information would be unfair and unlawful."

"The Commissioner has chosen not to put the council’s explanations in this decision notice, as to do so could, in itself, reveal personal data of the Councillor which could lead to their identity being revealed...
Having considered the Council’s explanations for this case, the
Commissioner has determined that there is insufficient legitimate
interest to outweigh the fundamental rights and freedoms of the
individual in this specific case and considers that there is no legal basis for the council to disclose the withheld information and to do so would be in breach of principle (a)...
The Commissioners decision is that the Council is entitled to rely on section 40(2) of FOIA to refuse to provide the information it has
withheld to this request."

We would also like to remind you that we asked local media outlets to cover this story. They did not.

---

UPDATE (23/7/22)

The Regulator has confirmed today that our complaint about Bristol City Council is now eligible for investigation by the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO).

We imagine that Bristol is used to this, as they have been reported, repeatedly, to have failed to meet their obligations under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (see below). Anecdotally, we know this from other concerned citizens such as Mike Owen (again, see below).

So we await the result of the investigation, which might be a long wait.

It confirms that we were right to go the ICO.

---

So we have submitted another complaint to the Information Commissioner's Office about Bristol City Council's refusal to name councillors and give details of arrears.

Local campaigner Mike Owen told us: 

"I was surprised how councillors could manage to ignore reminders, and offer the public excuses akin to the dog ate my coursework.

Marvin Rees promised to carry out checks on councillors' council tax arrears, can I assume that all is 'really' ship shape and Bristol fashion when no public update is provided?"

Our Leader Andrew Pope submitted a Freedom of Information (FoI) request to Bristol City Council in March 2022. 

 

Andrew Pope
Leader of Somerset Independents

The FoI was ignored by Bristol City Council. So Andrew contacted the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), who ordered Bristol City Council to respond. 

Eventually, they responded. And the FoI was refused by Bristol City Council.

Then Andrew asked the Council for an Internal Review. Despite taking an age for the internal review, Bristol City Council still refused to give out information on councillors in arrears.

Andrew has referred the case to the ICO in a complaint.

 

Why are you looking at Bristol?

Somerset Independents puts Somerset residents first. So why are we reporting on Bristol City Council, when it is not in Somerset? It is because:

  • What happens in Bristol affects Somerset (e.g. on the resources for policing or on changes to governance such as the Mayor of Bristol being scrapped for a committee system - something which we are campaigning for in Somerset)
  • Bristol City Council, like the district and county councils in Somerset, is mired in controversy and is lacking in even basic governance and accountability. Councillors in Bristol and Somerset must be held to account for this, in a democracy where citizens are concerned about the lack of representation.
  • What happens in Somerset affects Bristol (e.g. the scrapping of the districts and county council which will have a knock-on effect on Bristol)

 

Our Victory In Somerset

Somerset Independents has claimed victory in its investigation of all district, county and unitary Councillors in Somerset on whether they paid their council tax or not. The results of our investigations are published on this website - link here.

 

Previous Investigations of Bristol Councillors

During our investigations in Somerset, we became aware from Bristol residents who contacted us that in 2017, the Bristol Post/BristolLive online published two stories on councillors at Bristol City Council that had been in arrears on their council tax. 

  1. "Deputy mayor owed more than £5,000 in council tax arrears - and Labour group paid it - Councillor Asher Craig paid the arrears - thanks to loan from the Labour group", 28th March 2017, Ian Onions
  2. "The five Bristol city councillors who fell behind with their council tax payments revealed - All of the councillors have given reasons for their late payments", 17th March 2017, Esme Ashcroft
     

A concerned citizen named Mike Owen had earlier submitted an FoI in January 2017. Bristol City Council had covered up the names in that case too, saying (emphasis added):

"Shortly prior to your request, checks were carried out on all 70 councillors to check their position in relation to payment of council tax. Five were found to be in arrears of two months or more and were contacted in this regard. All five have now cleared their arrears. On the basis that these arrears have been cleared in advance of the budget meeting, we are of the view that the adverse consequences of releasing the names of those councillors would be unnecessary and unjustified."

Mr Owen then requested an Internal Review. We do not know whether the outcome of this Internal Review was how the names were revealed. And we do not know whether the Bristol Post used this information in their reports. The instigator of the FoI is not credited in the report.

So the battle that Mr Owen had suffered, has been repeated in our experience by Andrew Pope, too. And possibly by others who have tried to get the information out of Bristol City Council.

We approached Mr Owen for comment on our investigation. He told us:

"I was surprised how councillors could manage to ignore reminders, and offer the public excuses akin to the dog ate my coursework.
Marvin Rees promised to carry out checks on councillors' council tax arrears, can I assume that all is 'really' ship shape and Bristol fashion when no public update is provided?"

Private Eye had also published details of arrears of councillors from the 2016-17 year in a nationwide expose of councillors (see image). They had not been blocked or refused by Bristol City Council. But both Mr Owen and Mr Pope had been blocked.

 

Again, we do not know what relationship there was, if any, between the Private Eye investigation and the Bristol Post's reports. Then in 2018, Esme Ashcroft of BristolLive again reported:

"Revealed: The Bristol, North Somerset, South Gloucestershire and B&NES councillors who missed council tax payments - Has your councillor made the list?", 29th May 2018

For 2016/17, Ms Ashcroft named:

  • Asher Craig (Labour) - again as named in the Ian Onions report, 
  • Sultan Khan (Labour)
  • Harriet Clough (Lib Dem)
  • Cleo Lake (Green)
  • Stephen Clark (Green).

Then also in Bristol for 2018:

  • Charlie Bolton (Green)
  • Harriet Clough (Lib Dem) - AGAIN (also in 2016/17)
  • Carole Johnson (Labour)
  • Paul Goggin (Labour).

The report also named North Somerset and Bath and North East Somerset councillors, but that is not relevant here. Somerset Independents has done separate investigations into those councils - please see elsewhere on this website.

It has been difficult to find any more recent reports than 2018, if they even exist.

 

Why Are Media Outlets Not Publishing On Bristol Councillors in Arrears since 2018?

We wondered why or whether local media outlets had not investigated councillors and the Mayor on council tax arrears.

It may have been that stories had been written and then had been squashed by editors not wanting to upset "powerful people" - as we know one Editor (outside Bristol) told a journalist recently when he wanted to report on an abusive and offensive MP.

Or it could have been that Bristol City Council refused Freedom of Information (FoI) requests for every year since 2018 when they did reveal the names of recalcitrant councillors to the Bristol Post? That would be true to form of Mr Owen's experience and ours too. 

Since 2018 investigations by Bristol's media outlets seem to have dried up, or not made their way into the public realm.

However, the Bristol Post has reported on Bristol City Council's atrocious record in not responding to FoIs in time:

  1. "Bristol City Council regularly misses legal deadline for answering information requests - Deputy mayor Craig Cheney has admitted the council has a "problem" responding to Freedom of Information requests", 16th April 2021
  2. "Bristol City Council cuts Freedom of Information requests target so it can meet it - Authority says the change followed Information Commissioner's Office advice on 'realistic' goals", 2nd Nov 2021, Adam Postans

Somerset Independents has approached the Bristol Post on this story. It was not taken up by them. So as we have done with our other investigations, we are publishing it ourselves. And we have approached Pete Gavan, the Editor at the Bristol Post/BristolLive, to ask what has happened.

Somerset Independents will not be spending much more time on Bristol. We are volunteers that stand up for Somerset, not Bristol.

But we report this in the public interest in the hope that Bristol residents can pick up the baton and discover what is happening, and then do something about it.

 

Who Are Somerset Independents?

We help residents to stand up for themselves and challenge those in power.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Monday, July 4, 2022

Safe Standing: Stand Up If You Love Your Football Team? You Might Be Able To Soon...

"Passionate Paula" Isn't Safe Standing There!

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We stand up for residents. That includes football fans in Somerset.

So we are delighted to literally stand up for football fans in supporting the campaign for "safe standing" at Somerset's football stadia in the top two divisions of English football.

But wait...you say... Somerset does not have any teams in the top two divisions of English football.

That's right, not at the moment.

Many fans in Somerset will travel to grounds in and around Somerset. But they will not find football in the Premier League or The Championship in Somerset.

Yeovil FC are the highest Somerset club. They are in the National League, the fifth tier of English football.

But in the counties around Somerset, there are teams in the top two tiers, so Somerset football fans will travel to the following grounds:

  • Bristol City
  • Cardiff City (in Wales but they play in the English leagues)
  • Swansea City (as per Cardiff)
  • Bournemouth
  • Southampton
  • Reading

Plus there are other teams who have been in the top two tiers, such as Swindon Town and Portsmouth.

We say: "Stand up if you love your club". So if you travel to these grounds, soon you may be able to stand at the match.

[Of course, outside the top two tiers, the rules on all seater stadia do not apply. So fans may be free to stand in some areas.]

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says:

Andrew Pope at St. Mary's Stadium in 2018

 

"I've been campaigning for Safe Standing for years. Jon Darch, who runs the Safe Standing Roadshow, kindly brought it to Southampton when I started the campaign there. That campaign is continuing, because the Saints owners do not give fans what they want, which is to stand up and be safe. They didn't bother applying for the pilot and are now delaying further. I invited them to Jon's demonstration of rail seats. They did not turn up.

Meanwhile, similar campaigns are going ahead across England and Wales. Jon has led the campaign at his beloved Bristol City and other fans groups have been successful, including those involved in the recent pilot. Others like Wolves have led the way.

I think it was ten years ago that I first saw rail seats, when I went to a fans conference in London in 2012. It is wrong that it has taken so long to give fans what they deserve and what they want. But sadly, that is how football fans are treated by the football businesses - they are not clubs anymore, really. 

These owners take their money, use their support to build their assets to sell on, but do not listen to them.

It's wrong in my eyes, as I learned from being an Enfield FC supporter when my boyhood club was destroyed by a dodgy property developer and dodgy councillors on Enfield Borough Council.

That process seems to be repeating itself at Enfield's old non-league rivals Yeovil FC, despite my warnings and those of the Glovers Trust. Councils and councillors cannot be trusted to protect football clubs.

I have provided my advice and support to the Glovers Trust because I care about all football supporters (yes, even Pompey supporters!), who are the true custodians of proper football clubs.

Fans are the custodians, not the owners of the football businesses that now seem to be the targets of those who want to sportswash their image, such as Saudi Arabia (Newcastle), Abu Dhabi (Man City) and Russia (Chelsea)."


Who Are Somerset Independents?

We stand up for Somerset residents. We listen and act on the issues that matter to Somerset - not London.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Friday, May 6, 2022

VICTORY in Bristol, Victory in Sheffield: Now We Need Victory in Somerset for The Modern Committee System

 

Scrapped Bristol Mayor Marvin Rees (right)
Photo: BBC
 

The people of Bristol have voted to scrap the Mayor of Bristol, in a victory for democracy over tyranny.

Despite a loud and dishonest campaign by Bristol Labour, spearheaded by Darren Jones MP (left), the count overnight showed that a clear majority of Bristol people wanted to scrap the post held by Labour's Marvin Rees.

The "It's Our City" campaign in Bristol followed the successful campaign by our friends and colleagues in Sheffield, also called "It's Our City".

Why is this relevant to Somerset?

Because Somerset Independents has been campaigning for Somerset's councils to change to a Modern Committee System too.

Last June, when the district councils conducted their flawed poll to force Somerset residents to choose between two buckets of manure - proven failure versus potential disaster - one failed system versus another failed system - we denounced their poll and suggested that Somerset should have a Modern Committee System in the current and any future councils.

The district councils' poll was not the YES/NO Referendum that residents deserved to have and which Somerset Independents campaigned for.

Instead, the Conservative Government led by Boris Johnson were aided and abetted by Conservative Councillors in Somerset, especially Conservative County Council Leader David Fothergill. There was weak opposition by the Liberal Democrats, Greens and Labour.

We know why the opposition was weak - because these Westminster parties put the interests of themselves and their parties first. They calculate that they will gain from the New Somerset Council. The Lib Dems even feel that they can control it - today, we will know.

The Conservatives imposed their unitary authority on Somerset, against the wishes of residents who voted in 2007 82% against any such changes.

Andrew Pope, Leader of Somerset Independents, says:

Andrew Pope, Leader of Somerset Independents

"Congratulations to It's Our City Bristol and It's Our City Sheffield. They have led remarkable campaigns. 

Today, the results of the elections to this New Somerset Council will be announced.

So Somerset Independents wants to see this New Somerset Council to be a Modern Committee System.

There is a danger that there will be moves for it to have an Elected Mayor.

There is a danger that it will have a "Strong Leader" and Cabinet, which has failed Somerset already.

The people of Bristol and Sheffield have rejected the Mayor and the failed "Strong Leader" model that has failed Somerset for too long.

Somerset must have a Modern Committee System.

Residents will say No to an Elected Mayor.

Residents will say No to the "Strong Leader" and Cabinet.

Residents will say Yes to a democratic system where all councillors can represent the voice of the people that they are there to represent.

We know that councillors at Somerset West and Taunton Council  resolved to support a Modern Committee System in April 2021. 

We will be holding them and the elected New Somerset Council councillors to account, to ensure that they deliver it for the people of Somerset.

The work must start immediately, and according to answers we have obtained from SWT Council, the New Council is supposed to be considering the matter in May 2022."




Friday, June 11, 2021

Somerset Green Party Thinks You Don't Need to Pay Council Tax - IF You're A Councillor, That Is!

 

Green Councillors Think They Should Not Pay Council Tax!

UPDATED (13/6/21): We've asked Green Councillor Francis Hayden to provide the details of his council tax arrears. He's refused again. More details on this new article at the link here.

---

Do you think it is right if councillors don't pay their council tax? Residents have told us that they do not think it is right. In fact, no residents have told us that they think it is OK for councillors to not pay up. Yet two of Somerset's Green councillors think that it is OK!


Green Surge or Green Slime?

In the 2019 local elections, some Green councillors were elected to Somerset's councils. 

Were any elected in 2021? No. 

The Conservatives cancelled the 2021 County Council elections. And the Greens have not won any of the recent by-elections in Somerset. They have not even come close. 

Yet Somerset Green councillors are hailing a "Green Surge" in local elections elsewhere, including in Bristol which neighbours Somerset.

Somerset Independents have been watching the Somerset Green Party closely, and especially the Green councillors.

In our opinion, and we have presented some of the evidence on our website already, these Green councillors are either naive, incompetent, or downright dangerous.

We suggest that far from being a Green Surge, that it is more like a Green Slime.

Here is one example. Green councillors in Somerset voted to increase YOUR council tax, but not all of them paid THEIR council tax. And Green councillors think it is OK for councillors not to pay.

We have the evidence, from investigations that we have conducted.

Mendip Green Councillor Francis Hayden did not pay his council tax. As we have previously reported, he did not pay not just for one month, but for nearly a year. 

When we asked Cllr Hayden to apologise, he did not apologise. When we asked Cllr Hayden to resign, he did not resign. When we asked Cllr Hayden when he would pay up, he refused to say.

Our investigation into Somerset councillors and their council tax also revealed that another Mendip Councillor had not paid their council tax. But Mendip District Council refused to give us the councillor's name.

So this brings all 46 other Mendip councillors into disrepute, and Mendip Council too.  Nearly all Mendip residents now cannot be sure that their councillor paid their council tax. 

In the case of the residents of Cranmore, Doulting and Nunney, represented by Cllr Hayden, how many of them know he didn't pay? Has he told them? We doubt it.


Residents Think Councillors Should Pay Council Tax

Do you think it is right if councillors don't pay their council tax? Residents have told us that they do not think it is right. In fact, no residents have told us that they think it is OK for councillors to not pay up.

Somerset Independents listens to residents. 

Therefore we strongly believe that the vast majority of Somerset residents believe that councillors should pay their council tax, just like the rest of Somerset residents are expected to.

We believe that is even more important that an elected representative pays their council tax, because they should set the example.

The Green Party brags about their councillors who "leave their mark" on council budgets. Council budgets are set by councillors who vote on the budget.

But if a councillor doesn't pay their council tax, the councillor is BANNED by law from voting on council tax and related matters. If they do not declare that they are in arrears on their council tax, and vote on such matters, it is a CRIMINAL OFFENCE.

Yet unbelievably, when Somerset Independents wrote to the 46 other councillors to ask them to identify themselves as the councillor who did not pay, none of them admitted to it.

And even more unbelievably, another Green Councillor, Frome councillor Michael Dunk, defended his Green colleague Councillor Hayden. Not once, but twice.


Do Other Councillors Support Councillor Hayden?

When we asked Mendip District Council to show us all correspondence from councillors relating to councillors' council tax, there were no other councillors who had written to Councillor Hayden to support his stance. Not one.

This included all of the other Green Mendip councillors. None of them support Councillor Hayden's, apart from Cllr Dunk. 

The Green Group Leader Councillor Shane Collins did not reply and we wrote to him more than once. 

Yet Councillor Hayden claimed to us that councillors supported him. There is no evidence of this in council emails, other than from Cllr Dunk, Hayden's Green councillor colleague.

So that is two Mendip councillors who think it is OK for councillors to not pay council tax. ZERO residents agree with them.

 

What About Other Somerset Green Candidates or Councillors?

The Green Candidate for Somerset's Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC), Cleo Lake, answered some questions from us.

Somerset Independents asked all PCC candidates about Councillor Hayden's non-payment of council tax.

Her answer on her Green Party colleague's arrears on council tax was not as strong as it could have been.

As reported on this website, Ms Lake told us:

"There may be various reasons why Councillors fall behind or fail to pay council tax on time, I know there have been and can be administration errors but I think that all those in public office should do the best they can and when a situation occurs to act quickly to rectify it and apologise."

So Ms Lake thought that Cllr Hayden should "act quickly". Being in arrears for nearly a year is NOT acting quickly. 

And Ms Lake thought that Cllr Hayden should "apologise". He has not apologised.

Ms Lake's response was in contrast to the other candidates, who said the following.

So by the Green Party's own PCC candidate, Cllr Hayden has not done what Ms Lake wanted.

We have contacted the Chair of the Association of Green Councillors, to ask for a comment on the situation regarding Cllr Hayden and Cllr Dunk. We await an answer.

What Did The Other PCC Candidates Say About Cllr Hayden?

Given that the Wiltshire Conservative PCC Jonathon Seed was barred from taking office due to a drink driving offence that came up after the election had taken place, Conservative (and now serving PCC) Mark Selford's response was interesting:

"I will not be drawn into specific cases and nor should you expect me at this time. In general, though I expect everyone to pay taxes they are legally required to pay. I expect public bodies to do the right thing when their members from whatever political persuasion are not leading or governing with integrity."

Kerry Barker, Labour's candidate, told us:

"I do not believe that office holders be they councillors or others appointed, as opposed to being elected, should be allowed to continue in those offices if they have not paid their taxes – either local or national taxes."

Mr Barker's is the strongest response from any of the candidates. He is unequivocal. They should go if they have not paid council tax. Cllr Hayden refused to resign.

The Liberal Democrat candidate, Mendip Councillor Heather Shearer, did not respond at all to any of our questions.

The Independent candidate, John Smith, told us:

"I believe all citizens should pay taxes that they are due to pay. I am not familiar with the individual circumstances of the councillors and have no comment to make on their cases."

So after asking residents and asking all PCC candidates, we still have ZERO residents and ZERO candidates for Police and Crime Commissioner, who think it is OK for councillors to not pay their council tax.

And it is just Green Councillors who think it is OK for councillor not to pay their council tax.

We have no evidence of any other councillors who think it is OK. But when they don't reply, and their Council tries to cover up the identity of the councillor in arrears, all Mendip residents constituents are left to wonder whether their own councillor has not paid. 

It could be another Green councillor who has not been named. But it might not be. We still don't know, and we have challenged MDC on this.

Because of this, around 100,000 people don't know whether their councillor paid their council tax, and 100,000 people who are expected to make sure that they have paid their household's council tax. But their council tax has been increased by councillors.

The Green Party Needs To Act. Mendip District Council Needs To Act.

Until Somerset Green Party or the national Green Party takes action against these councillors, residents will think that Green councillors are more of a green slime than a green surge. It is their councillors who are bringing the Green Party into disrepute. 

These councillors are also breaching the Council Code of Conduct, breaching the Nolan Principles of Public Life and it appears that they may have also broken the law by voting on matters related to council tax. Mendip District Council needs to act.

Mendip District Council has previously told us that the Nolan Principles do not apply to their councillors. They are wrong. They apply to all in public service. Mendip needs to properly investigate complaints about councillors, not dismiss them like they have done previously.

Somerset Independents will continue our investigations to stand up for Somerset residents and hold elected representatives to account.

 



Wednesday, April 28, 2021

PCC ELECTION: Labour Candidate Kerry Barker's Responses To Our Questions

 

Kerry Barker Labour PCC Candidate

Somerset Independents is not standing a candidate in the Avon and Somerset Police and Crime Commissioner Election 2021. More information on our decision, and information on all candidates, are in our updated article here.

Instead, we are holding all of the candidates to account and challenging them to answer the questions that residents want answered.

We have asked questions to all 5 candidates. Some of the questions are the same for all candidates. The other questions are based on what each candidate said in public.

All candidates were asked their questions over the most recent weekend.

Below is the FULL response from Labour Candidate Kerry Barker. He was the first candidate to respond.

They are the opinions of the candidate and NOT Of Somerset Independents.

 

Somerset Independents – Responses of Kerry Barker



Background

First as a justices’ clerk, running magistrates’ courts, and second as a barrister based in Bristol since 1991, working in all courts in Avon and Somerset, I have over 50 years’ experience of criminal justice. I know first-hand how budget cuts and local strategic decisions impact the ability of police officers to do their work; to detect crimes and to keep people safe. The effect of closing police stations, cutting back on officer numbers in local communities and disbanding specialist teams of detectives can be seen in the detection rates for the crimes that affect ordinary people in our region.

Part of my legal practice was to undertake judicial review cases. These cases always involved challenges to public bodies such as the police, local authorities, and central government departments. I am very used to challenging the decisions of public bodies and holding them to account.



  1. Mrs Mountstevens – why would you make a better Police and Crime Commissioner?



The primary purpose of the PCC is to hold the police to account on behalf of the public. Mrs Mountstevens has failed to do this. Most people regard her as a spokesperson for the police.



The consequence has been that even when she has upheld complaints against the police – as individual members of the Labour Party have told me that she has in their own cases – the police have ignored her rulings.



The Nolan principles apply to all office holders and all public bodies. The fact that you stood as an independent makes no difference. Unfortunately, “keeping politics out of policing” means that you don’t campaign against political decisions such as cuts to police budgets and other unpopular laws that place unnecessary burdens on the police.



I will hold the police to account, but I will also campaign for better resources for them and for other public services in order to reduce the burden on police officers. They should not have to be social workers. They should not have to be mental health nurses.



  1. BBC Hustings – could I do better than John Smith?



In the example that you gave quoting what I said, the interviewer cut me off before I had finished dealing with the failure of the police to catch criminals. The full statement should read:

“If you ask people what is the purpose of the Police they’ll tell you it is to prevent crime and catch criminals, and that is the test, the last nine years has been a disaster because crime has gone up but he detection rate has gone rapidly down and so if you look at things like violent and sexual crime, in 2012 there were just under 18,000 offences reported to the police and the detection rate was just under 50% …”



I later added words to the effect of:



“ … 2012 was the year that the PCC was first elected. By 2019 the number of violent and sexual offences had soared to over 47,000 but the detection rate had fallen to 12%.”



As a criminal barrister who specialised in abuse cases and who was a specialist rape prosecutor I knew that the PCC and Chief Constable had agreed, as a strategy, to scrap the specialist teams of detectives and in particular the sexual assaults team. I discussed it with them at the time of the last PCC election and warned them of the devastating consequences of disbanding that team.



Regrettably my warnings proved to be accurate. As a force the expertise of that team was lost. Experienced detectives became disillusioned and left the force. The so-called omni-competent teams of detectives failed to support victims and collect evidence in the way that the old specialist team had, and the detection rate crashed down to 12%.



2(a) Where do you think John Smith as Deputy PCC/Chief Executive has gone wrong?



Of course, John Smith was always the power behind the throne. He was behind the centralisation of police services and the scrapping of the specialist teams. He now claims to be able to prioritise the safety of girls and women whilst his record shows that he did just the opposite.



I promise to reinstate the specialist teams of detectives, but it will take time to retrain and build up the experience that those lost officers had.



The whole notion of centralising police services, closing police stations was a modern trend followed without real thought for the consequences. Just as was the involvement of Avon and Somerset Police in the doomed ‘SouthWest 1’ fiasco.



With each closure came the claim that the police would be more effective and more efficient. It is not effective policing to have to take an arrested person from Frome to Bridgwater or Keynsham or Bristol (Patchway) thus removing at least two officers from the area they were policing for a number of hours. When they remove the cells from Yeovil police station – as is proposed – the same will apply there.



The best policing is based upon intelligence. Local intelligence gathered by local police officers who know their patch and know their people. And where the local people know them.



Reducing local policing to 1.7 police officers per 10,000 population (Parliamentary Report on Funding of Community Policing 2017) is not best policing.



The public lose confidence in local policing when police stations are closed. Information desks in council offices or libraries or fire stations are not police stations. Information desks which close at 5 pm are not police stations. Information desks are not places of refuge for women attacked by their partners during the night.



In all these areas John Smith has got it wrong.



The detection rate for rural crime such as thefts from farms is only 4%. That is the result of the policies set by Mrs Mountstevens and John Smith.





2(b) Did Mrs Mountstevens appoint Mr Smith as her deputy in the right way?



It is quite clear that Mrs Mountstevens appointed Mr Smith as her deputy in order to give him a platform from which to campaign for election. Indeed, Mrs Mountstevens has herself been campaigning for Mr Smith. Just ask any of the residents’ associations that she has addressed in recent months.



Ask any serving police officer and they will, without exception, tell you that John Smith has used his office to conduct his campaign.



And they talk about keeping politics out of policing. They have been doing little else but politicking during the past twelve months.



It is also clear that the Chief Constable was seduced into giving Mr Smith a personal endorsement completely against the rules governing the involvement of Chief Constables in the election of PCCs. In years past when public standards were so much higher that might have been a resigning issue.



  1. Making better use of existing resources and getting more money for policing. What would you prefer money spent on – police being on the beat or police buildings?



As I have set out above having a local police station gives confidence to members of the public about local police operations.



The local police station is not just a building it is the location for the local command structure. It is where local police officers are based. Where the area commander is based – not in distant Portishead but in your area. It is where the local detectives are based.



My strategy will be to have a local command structure for each of the 8 local authority districts comprised in the Avon and Somerset area. That way the police will also be accountable to local councillors and the local MPs. That way public complaints will be taken much more seriously.



You say that I haven’t said where I would get the money from. That is not true. At each Labour party meeting and each public meeting that I have addressed I have raised the issue of local funding. In addition to raising the local precept in accordance with government imposed limits the PCC can seek greater increases through the medium of a local referendum. Mrs Mountstevens and her office refused to engage with such a process.



Where it can be justified, I will campaign for additional resources and identify exactly how and where any additional funds will be spent.



And, if elected I will always be responsible for the budget in accordance with my statutory duty.





  1. Publicly elected office holders who do not pay their taxes.



I do not believe that office holders be they councillors or others appointed, as opposed to being elected, should be allowed to continue in those offices if they have not paid their taxes – either local or national taxes.



I agree that all elected officials should have to undergo criminal records checks – just as I have always had to do for being a school governor or a trustee of a charity.



Kerry Barker

Labour Party Candidate for Police and Crime Commissioner for Avon and Somerset





Friday, April 9, 2021

UPDATED (2/5/21): PCC Candidates Respond to Our Questions - Avon and Somerset Police and Crime Commissioner

 

 

The Current PCC Sue Mountstevens
Is Stepping Down

UPDATED (2/5/21): We have now received answers to our questions to all 5 candidates. 

The questions that we asked to all 5 of them are here.

Please click the links on the menu for our website to see their responses, or click the links below.

Kerry Barker's Responses are here.

Cleo Lake's Responses are here.

Heather Shearer HAS NOT RESPONDED, although we have chased. UPDATE: We gave her until 9pm on the Eve of the polls opening. She STILL has not responded. So here are the questions that she failed to answer.

Mark Shelford's Responses are here.

John Smith's Responses are here.

To say again - Somerset Independents is not standing a candidate. Please read below for more on that. 

We leave it to residents to make up their own minds based on what we believe is our fair challenge to the candidates. 

And leave it to residents to decide whether to vote, to not vote, or to register a "NONE OF THE ABOVE" on their ballot to send a message of protest. 

ITV West Country have published their guide to the candidates here.

---

UPDATED (25/4/21): Following requests from residents, more information has been added on the candidates, plus information on the stance from Somerset Independents on the candidates.

Somerset Independents has submitted questions to the candidates. We are waiting for answers from 3 of the 5 candidates. Sadly there was not even an email address for Kerry Barker or Heather Shearer, so we have had to use their "Contact Form". We await responses.

---

The candidates have been confirmed for the election of a new Police and Crime Commissioner for Avon and Somerset.

They were announced today (9th April 2021). The poll will be held on Thursday 6 May 2021 between 7am and 10pm. You can vote by post if you register in time.


The Candidates in Alphabetical Order Are:


Barker, Kerry - Address in Bristol - Labour Party

Lake, Cleo Alberta - Address in Bristol - Green Party

Shearer, Heather - Address in Wells - Liberal Democrat

Shelford, Mark Grosvenor McNeill - Address in Bath - The Conservative Party Candidate

Smith, John - Address in Bristol - Independent

 

You can access their campaign websites by clicking the links under each candidate. Their website will open in a new browser window or tab.

Residents have complained to us that they either did not know about this election, or that they know nothing about the candidates. So we are trying to provide information to residents. We are trying to be as fair as possible to the candidates.

More information on the candidates is available elsewhere on the Somerset Independents website, with responses by our Spokeperson for Police and Crime Andrew Pope. Just click on the "Police and Crime" tag or this link here and scroll down to view the articles.

 

Local Media Reports

Below are the local media reports that we are aware of. If you know of more, please get in touch using our Contact link at the top of the page.

Stephen Sumner of Reach/SomersetLive has produced this article on the candidates. The article has the candidates in alphabetical order and has Q & A's with each candidate.

Jessica Chaffey of The County Gazette has published this article on the candidates. The candidates are not in alphabetical order and not all candidates have photos. There are no explanations for these oversights. But there is a photo of the Chief Constable, Andy Marsh, who is "stepping down" later this year.

The local BBC News (under Bristol, not Somerset) has published this article on the candidates.  This is a very poor attempt by the local BBC. As usual, there is no author willing to put their name to the article. There is no explanation for the order in which they showed the candidates on the article. They are not alphabetical, as they will be on the ballot paper. Worst of all, there are no photos of two of the candidates, Cleo Lake and Kerry Barker.

The local BBC Bristol also put out this report on the BBC TV "hustings" with David Garmston. For the Bristol protests, this may seem appropriate but there is often a Bristol bias in the local BBC's reporting. Somerset is barely mentioned. The Bristol BBC News, sorry "regional" BBC News, do not seem to have reported on the other part of the hustings, only the part relating to the protests. Somerset Independents has repeatedly complained about the Bristol bias.

 

Which Candidate Is Somerset Independents Supporting?

None of them!

We are holding all candidates to account by asking questions and providing information to Somerset residents.

This is so Somerset residents can make their own decision on who to vote for, or whether to put a large cross through the ballot paper to lodge a protest vote that none of the candidates are suitable, with "None of the above" written on the ballot paper.


Why Isn't Somerset Independents Standing A Candidate?

 

Somerset Independents were involved in several discussions with residents of Somerset about standing a candidate.

It was suggested that our Leader Andrew Pope should stand. We also discussed other people who could be a good candidate.

Andrew explains:

Andrew Pope

"A former member of the Police and Crime Panel suggested that I would be a good candidate. I am the Spokesperson for Police and Crime for Somerset Independents too, as well as my other experience as a councillor and campaigner.

I was not keen, as I have too many other commitments.

But I agreed to discuss my potential candidacy with:

  • Somerset residents
  • a former PCC candidate
  • other members and supporters of Somerset Independents
  • current and former police officers both here and elsewhere in England, and 
  • with the Nominations Officer for Somerset Independents, Denise Wyatt.

We decided between us that there were many reasons why Somerset Independents did not wish to stand a PCC candidate.

These included:

  1. Somerset Independents does not campaign in Bristol, Bath or South Gloucestershire. We focus on Somerset.
  2. Somerset Independents does not have the funds to put in the huge £5,000 deposit that all candidates have to make. In fact, some of our supporters were incredulous that it is such a large amount of money. Only national political parties like Labour, the Lib Dems, Greens and Tories can find this money.
  3. Somerset Independents is only a year old and is run by volunteers.
  4. Somerset Independents does not have the money for the campaign costs. We are volunteers and do not have the massive money that the national parties have.
  5. We have made it clear that we believe that the May elections should be delayed until they can be conducted safely and democratically. Neither are possible while the National Emergency continues. We will not put people at risk.

Maybe next time, we will have a PCC candidate. But not this time.

We agreed instead that we would hold the declared candidates to account.  That process has already begun."