Showing posts with label Covid-19. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Covid-19. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 7, 2022

Boris Johnson Even Lied In His Last Speech In Downing Street! Is Truss Any Better?

 

The Times, June 2020

One of our Official emblems

 

"Truss lied to Conservative Party members to become Prime Minister. Keir Starmer did the same in the Labour Party... Meanwhile, it's ordinary residents that continue to suffer crisis after crisis."

Somerset Independents puts residents first. During the Pandemic, we held Boris Johnson's Government - and his crony Tory councillors at Somerset County Council - to account. We stood up for Somerset residents.

As The Times cartoon from June 2020 suggests, Johnson failed across the board.

Over two years later the BBC has done an analysis of the claims Johnson made about his record during his last speech in Downing Street. It shows that Boris Johnson even lied in that speech.

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, says:

 

Andrew Pope

"Boris Johnson is totally disgraced as Prime Minister and as a man. But he is in denial. If he wants to lie about his record as Prime Minster to himself and his latest wife, that's up to him.

What matters more is that he has lied to the British public. Not just once, but on very many occasions. And he has lied on a wide range of topics, some of which are a matter of life and death, including the Pandemic.

Boris Johnson is a proven liar and a fraud. Having stopped the investigation into corrupt Tory MP Owen Paterson, he is now trying to stop the Parliamentary investigation into himself misleading Parliament.

It's disgraceful that there are those in the Conservative Party who wanted Johnson to stay. This includes Somerset Conservative councillors and Conservative Party members in Somerset who still defend him.

That says a lot about the Conservative Party and their lack of principles. I remember a time when the Tories had principles, although I did not agree with their principles, they seemed to have some.

Now the Conservatives just want power for its own sake. And Liz Truss is just the same as Boris Johnson. 

Truss lied to Conservative Party members to become Prime Minister. Keir Starmer did the same in the Labour Party.

Labour still want Corbyn, and have Starmer. Conservatives still want Johnson, and have Truss.

Meanwhile, it's ordinary residents that continue to suffer crisis after crisis.

Labour or Tory, same old story!"


Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future. 

Our Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) page is here.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Wednesday, June 22, 2022

UPDATE (14/7/22): Covid Deaths Over 200,000 and Infections Rising - Glastonbury Festival 2022 Opens: This Year It Is Going Ahead - Over 2 Years, We Listened to Residents and Acted To Protect Somerset From Covid

 

Glastonbury Festival at Pilton, Somerset

UPDATE (14/7/22)

Official figures from the Office for National Statistics have shown that the number of deaths nationally has now exceeded 200,000, reports SomersetLive.

The number of deaths in Somerset is now over 1,200. 

The ONS figures show the number of deaths, via the below graph. You can see that while they have increased, they are not at the huge levels of the peaks of 2020 and 2021.


The ONS said:

"Deaths involving COVID-19 increased in the UK

13 July 2022

In the UK, there were 412 deaths involving COVID-19 registered in the week ending 1 July 2022, an increase from 347 in the previous week. This accounted for 3.5% of all deaths in the latest week; an increase from 2.8% in the previous week. There were 11,828 total deaths registered in the UK in the latest week, which is 12.1% above the five-year average."

 

However, without any restrictions or safeguards from Government, including on Super Spreader events, the number of infections is also continuing to rise, as shown in the following figures from the ONS.



Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says: "Now there have been 200,000 deaths, with 1,200 deaths in Somerset. At the beginning of the Pandemic I publicly stated on national radio that the Government's actions were not good enough. This proves it. Boris Johnson has gone. His legacy is total failure."

---

UPDATE (2/7/22):

ITV News is reporting that "Covid-19 infections in the UK have jumped by more than half a million in a week".

Hospital numbers and intensive care admissions are continuing to rise.

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says: 

Andrew Pope,
Leader of Somerset Independents

"These increases are no surprise to Somerset Independents. We've been listening to the experts, some of whom are local in our region. Meanwhile, the Johnson Tory Government seems to be preoccupied with surviving itself, suffering scandal after scandal. 

The Government should be protecting the citizens of the UK, but as we've seen and as Somerset Independents has shown - Somerset residents were let down by the Tory Government and the Tory County Council that is responsible for Public Health and infection control.

When I directly challenged the former Tory Leader of the County Council, David Fothergill, and the Director of Public Health in public, their answers were not convincing. There was more buck-passing and excuses.

Somerset Independents campaigned against festivals going ahead during the Pandemic. Glastonbury and Nass were stopped. But now super spreader events are allowed to go ahead unchecked, and it is no surprise therefore that infections have shot up. The Pandemic is not over.

When are the Government and the Lib Dems - who now control the County Council - going to get a grip and take the continuing Pandemic seriously?

Or is it going to be another case of Lib Dem or Tory, same old story."

---

UPDATE (24/6/22)

As we have reported on this website and via our Twitter and Facebook, the train strikes have had an effect. We have published the views of local RMT and local TUC. In contrast, Somerset Labour, Somerset Lib Dems and Somerset's Tory MPs have refused to answer our questions on the strikes.

We did not campaign against Glastonbury Festival going ahead this year or the NASS Festival at Bath and West, because residents did not contact us with their concerns.

But there is worrying news - Covid-19 has not gone away, although Boris Johnson's Government seems to wish it had. Covid has been missing from the headlines of the mainstream media.

And as we have covered via our website and social media, Covid infections were about to enter a new wave. Local mathematical biologists have predicted it and warned against it. Were you aware?

 

 

So with 200,000 people entering Somerset, and even more predicted to go to NASS Festival, what will be the effect of the rising Covid infections on Somerset?

It will not be long before we find out.

---

Somerset Independents puts residents first. Because we stand up for Somerset residents, we listened to them and did not work with residents to get the Festival cancelled this year. 

Over 2020, 2021 and now in 2022, we did some research and we published some hopefully useful information that does not often get reported by the local "journalists" or what passes for journalism from the media outlets that prefer clickbait to actual news.  

We took action, because the local councils, local councillors and other authorities were not reassuring residents sufficiently that they would be kept safe from these "Super Spreader" events - whether at Pilton or at Bath and West Showground - during the Global Covid-19 Pandemic. 

We listened to residents. We acted for residents. We acted with residents.

Here are some links to articles that we published on our research and on our action for Somerset residents and protect Somerset and its people.

4th August 2020 - Think Piece: Glastonbury Festival - Myths and Legends

14th August 2020 - Timeline of Lockdown and 2020 Glastonbury Festival Cancellation 

14th August 2020 - Glastonbury Festival: What the Authorities Told Us

14th August 2020 - Is Glastonbury Festival 2021 Going Ahead?

25th March 2021 - Avon and Somerset Police - What Does Current Commissioner Sue Mountstevens Think?

13th May 2021 - Resident Concerns on New September Concert At Pilton By Glastonbury Festival Organisers

15th May 2021 - Mendip Council In "Rush to Please" Glastonbury Organisers On New September Concert

19th May 2021 - UPDATED (21/5/21): Residents "Very Angry" As "Supine" Mendip Council "Bent Over Backwards" To Glastonbury Organisers On Pilton Event

23rd May 2021 - UPDATE (4/6/21): EVERYONE Should Get A Refund! For The Global Rip-Off Streamed from Worthy Farm by Glastonbury - while Mendip Council Stood By!

5th June 2021 - UPDATE (31/7/21): NASS Festival STILL GOING AHEAD Despite Cancellation of Glastonbury September 'Equinox' Concert 

11th June 2021 -  VICTORY: CANCELLED - "Super Spreader" September Equinox Concert at Pilton Confirmed Cancelled by Organiser Emily Eavis

21st June 2021 -  Train Strikes: Tory Government Versus RMT Union - What Do The Local Unions Say and What Is The Impact on Somerset Residents?

Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and dedicated political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Wednesday, October 13, 2021

Somerset's Worrying Covid-19 Trends: We Challenge The Authorities Again

 

Standing Up For Somerset Residents

During the entire Global Pandemic of Covid-19, Somerset Independents has challenged councils, councillors, MPs and national Government.

Unlike the national political parties and their elected representatives, we actually have stood up for residents.

It is in our Constitution that as residents ourselves, that our officers and supporters work together with other residents, to stand together.

Residents are extremely concerned at the Covid-19 infection trends in Somerset and the West of England.

So our officers Andrew Pope and Denise Wyatt wrote again to the Director of Public Health for Somerset, Trudi Grant.

We said:

"Further to our earlier correspondence with you and your staff, for which we thank you again, we are writing to express our great concern at the Covid-19 data for Somerset, especially for the Mendip District Council area.

For much of the Pandemic, Mendip and the other council areas for which you are responsible, have been in the lower part of the infection rates for our region.

However, Mendip is now the worst area, as presented by the BBC two days ago on BBC Points West and shown in the official figures as documented by the BBC here:


The questions followed in our letter. 

You can see the full questions and Ms Grant's responses to our questions, below.

Tell us what you think of the questions and the answers.

 

"Dear Mr Pope and Ms Wyatt

 

Thank you for your email.  To follow up your queries, please find responses below;

 

Q1. Please can you provide an explanation for this, with the evidence that you have to support your explanation?

 

Case rates in Mendip as you reference have been higher, but for the last 7 days reporting 1-7th October, rates are beginning to decline now 466.3/100,000. This is still higher than regional average. I believe in part this is probably caused by lower population immunity levels, acquired through natural immunity due to previously low levels within this district.  School age children and staff linked to education settings made up 68% of Mendip’s cases (30/9-6/10/21)

 

Q2. Please can you tell us why it is deemed, as reported on BBC Points West, that schools are deemed the source of infection, and the cause of the high infection rates? The BBC report seemed to suggest that schools were at fault. Why is this thought please? 

 

Schools are in no way at fault, but the school environment is one of the main sources of transmission currently, 68% of cases in Mendip the last week were linked to school children or staff.  Our local schools have been brilliant and SCC Public Health are working very hard with them to help put control measures in place within each school,  as per the DfE Contingency Framework. 

 

Q3. Please can you tell us what influence, if any, the mass gatherings at the Bath and West Showground have had, and what evidence there is that these are influential, or no influential on infections?  

 

Based on the information gathered through the National Test and Trace system, we have no evidence that the Bath & West Showground is featuring in the common places visited by cases prior to their disease onset.

 

Q4. What data on infections, and what actions to control infections, are Bath and West REQUIRED to carry out and what involvement do you have as DPH? 

 

SCC has funded a Covid event officer post for Somerset, hosted by Mendip DC, to work with event organisers and ensure events go ahead as Covid19 secure as possible and relevant to their setting.  This officer engages early with event organisers to review their event management plans with specific reference to controlling the risk of transmission of Covid-19.  For larger events, members of my team also attend pre-event planning meetings to ensure the public health advice is part of the consideration.  To note, that it is the event organiser, rather than the Bath and West Showground itself, which devises and implements the plan. 

 

Q5. Would you agree therefore, that the cancellation of the Pilton "Equinox" Festival had a positive effect on reducing infection in the Mendip area, and Somerset more widely?  

 

We cannot say for sure that by cancelling these events, there was a positive effect on reducing infection as it’s always hard to count what has been prevented. However, the more people we mix with, the more chance the virus has to spread. Under the new national CONTAIN framework, it is for individuals to make these choices. As DPH we make information materials available to help people make informed choices. We are about to launch a public health campaign to help inform people decisions. If you follow my twitter account, it would be great if you could help spread the reach of the campaign by retweeting these messages to your members.

 

Event organisers have worked very productively with us throughout the pandemic and have listened to public health advice.

 

Q6. And similarly to Q4, the same for the Nass Festival? 

 

Please see the above reply regarding the Equinox Festival.  The same answer applies to the NASS Festival.

 

Q7. Somerset Independents campaigned against both Nass and Equinox from going ahead, because of the threat to Somerset residents' health, and we were very disappointed that Mendip Council officers treated both events as if they were not a danger. Why did you as Director of Public Health, allow them to do so? 

 

Nationally the decision has been taken to allow events of all forms and sizes to go ahead.  Obviously, as previously stated, where there are gatherings of people there is always an increased risk of infection, but we can mitigate risks as much as possible.  As you know, this whole pandemic has been a balance of risk, in the case of events, balancing the risk of infection with the risk to the events industry.  We need to learn to live with this virus, and part of that has to be opening up events.   As mentioned above, Mendip District Council hosts the event officer and works proactively alongside SCC Public Health, and with event organisers, to support events going ahead with appropriate covid19 mitigations in place in accordance with the legal framework.

 

Q8. If you do not have the data to answer the above questions with credibility, please can you tell us why you do not have the data, and what you are doing about it?  

 

We do have all the available data.

 

Thank you for your ongoing support, it is greatly appreciated.

 

With best wishes

 

Trudi

 

 

Professor Trudi Grant,  MSc, UKPHR, FFPH

Director of Public Health

Somerset County Council

 

Visiting Professor, Centre for Public Health and Wellbeing, UWE Bristol"

 

Saturday, July 31, 2021

UPDATE (8/9/21): VICTORY - Nass Festival CANCELLED: Nass Festival Was A Disaster For Locals in 2019 - Will It Be Better in 2021?

 

It Doesn't Help When Local Councillors Give Backing to Festivals!

UPDATE (8/9/21): We have just received confirmation that Vision Nine Group has CANCELLED Nass 2021.

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says:

"I attended the recent virtual residents meeting and raised once again the issues that residents had contacted me about, especially in the light of the disastrous way that Vision Nine Group organised the Boardmasters Festival in Cornwall that led to 4,700 Covid-19 infections as reported by ITV West Country.

I asked Vision Nine what lessons they had learned from Boardmasters. The answers were not convincing. Other residents at the meeting also raised concerns about anti-social behaviour, road safety and noise nuisance was also discussed.

If the organisers dealt with the issues in a way that showed that they had listened and acted, residents would not have to raise their concerns.

I congratulate Vision Nine Group for finally listening and taking the responsible action of cancelling the Festival.

Now they need to plan better in future to protect their festival goers and local residents.

Otherwise, Somerset Independents will stand up for residents again."

---

 Nass Festival was run disastrously in 2019 at Bath and West Showground.

There were many bad aspects about how it was organised, how it was run and how it was regulated by Mendip District Council who are the Licensing Authority.

After these problems, there was a review by Mendip District Council and organisers of Nass Festival - Vision Nine Group - have made many promises to residents.

Somerset Independents has been in direct contact with Vision Nine Group, who confirmed via this website that they intend to still run Nass Festival on 23rd to 26th September 2021. 

Somerset Independents has also been in touch with the Director of Public Health for Somerset, Trudi Grant, about the Covid-19 safety of the event.

And Somerset Independents has also been in touch with Licensing Officers at Mendip District Council.

Residents need more assurances and so Somerset Independents has been asking questions of the above people and organisations.

We have had to do it because the local Mendip District Councillor for Evercreech Barry O'Leary has been quoted on the Nass Festival website (see above), supporting the running of Nass Festival. 

Councillor Barry O'Leary

Somerset Independents has confirmed with Jools Butterfield of Vision Nine Group that the following quote was approved by Councillor O'Leary:


“I welcome NASS proceeding cautiously - it’s great they are working with local communities and agency’s to take account of the challenges, let’s look forward to a COVID-safe experience later this year !”

 Cllr. Barry O'Leary

Deputy Leader Mendip District Council

 

Local residents are outraged that their local ward Councillor O'Leary has given his backing to the festival, when so many residents were negatively affected by Nass Festival in 2019.

So to listen to residents and act for residents, Somerset Independents asked Mr Butterfield the following questions, in order to try to get assurances from the organisers.

Are you convinced? Contact us to tell us what you think.

Question from Somerset Independents to Nass Festival organiser:

Q1. What have you done to address the problems that occurred in the local area and affecting local residents, when the NASS Festival was last run?

 

Answer by Nass Festival:

"The best way to get the information is to attend the consultation date as there are quite a lot of solutions. No re-entry policy, the closure of Bagborough Lane, brand new traffic management plan now with gates at North and South of site run by the Glastonbury TMP team, Thursday and Friday limited entry tickets and special measures for Mendip School are some of the notable highlights."

Q2. When is this residents' meeting (that Nass Festival have repeatedly claimed to be organising) occurring? The letter did not say. The community website does not say at the time of writing.

 

Answer by Nass Festival:

"Still waiting on various stakeholders to narrow down their diaries, but approx six weeks prior to event is the optimum time. Should know this within a week."

Q3. Which areas received the letter? 

 

Answer by Nass Festival:

"16,000 addresses within an approx 5 mile radius of Bath and West. The companies you have to use for this task are never perfect I have to say, so there are always some people who don’t receive it, but all 16,000 were delivered."


Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, says:

Andrew Pope

"What do residents think of these answers? The residents that I have asked so far, have not been impressed. They are concerned.

Did you receive one of these letters? As a local resident, I did not receive one.

Are you happy that this event is going ahead?

Are you reassured by what the organisers have told us?

Contact us to let us know."

 


Friday, June 11, 2021

VICTORY: CANCELLED - "Super Spreader" September Equinox Concert at Pilton Confirmed Cancelled by Organiser Emily Eavis

 

Worthy Farm, Pilton

VICTORY UPDATE (21/7/21): Emily Eavis, organiser, has announced via Instagram that the September Equinox Event has been cancelled.

First report here from Paul Jones of the County Gazette.

Second report by SomersetLive has now been published. 

21/7/21 10:10am. This BBC report has finally arrived, hours after the County Gazette and Somerset Independents had already reported it.


Pilton resident Joanna Benner told Somerset Independents this morning:

"50,000 people during a pandemic was never a good idea - it was pure greed by a large corporate business that has little regard for villagers. This decision will be a huge relief for many in the local community."

 

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says:

Andrew Pope

"This September 'Equinox' concert was a really bad idea during a Global Pandemic. Residents across Somerset would have been put at risk by a Super Spreader event, and infection rates of Covid-19 are accelerating again.

Cancelling this event is the responsible thing to do and we applaud the organisers, Glastonbury Festival Events Ltd, for doing so.

But they should never have even thought of running this event in the first place.

Mendip District Council councillors Francis Hayden, Sam Phripp and Helen Sprawson-White should be ashamed of themselves for approving the event at the Licensing Hearing (see below).

There were clear conflicts of interest by councillors, the concerns of residents were ignored by councillors, there was terrible Chairmanship by Cllr Phripp and a lack of due process.

This debacle has brought Mendip District Council into further disrepute - if that were possible.

It's no wonder that local residents see Mendip District Council as "corrupt".

Somerset Independents listens to local residents and we acted with local residents to raise their concerns."

 

---

In May 2021, "supine" Mendip District Council took a week to decide, behind-closed-doors, to "bend over backwards" for Glastonbury Festival Events Ltd (GFEL) on their application for a premises licence at a new concert event at Worthy Farm, Pilton in September 2021. 

It took the councillors and officers a week to decide in private, after a series of chaotic public meetings of the Licensing Sub-Committee. 

The MDC press release (now missing from their featured articles on their PR website) is below, at the end of this article.

As documented elsewhere on the Somerset Independents website, local residents spoke against the application and wrote in objection to it. 

We have listened carefully to those residents and they have given us permission to publish their media release. They have raised many very important concerns.

Somerset Independents has commented on the failings of Mendip District Council (MDC):

  • in their duties to local residents and visitors to Somerset
  • in failing to prevent and manage conflicts of interest of the councillors who sat in judgement on the Licensing application by GFEL and 
  • in MDC failing to follow due process and proper governance.

Those Pilton residents accused Mendip District Council of being "supine" and "bending over backwards" to please GFEL. 

It is difficult to disagree with that view, because the evidence supports their view. The contrast in approach with other licensing applicants is stark and very concerning. There is a striking lack of consistency and an apparent favouritism to GFEL.

MDC officers both inside and outside the Sub-Committee were indeed supine. Only one environmental health officer dared to try to impose conditions on noise on GFEL. The Chair of the Sub-Commitee, Councillor Sam Phripp, then allowed that officer to be harangued and cross-examined by GFEL's solicitor.

Meanwhile, MDC's environmental health and licensing officers gave GFEL an easy ride. 

The Chair did not conduct the meeting with any semblance of due process. It was extremely long-winded and chaotic. The initial meeting went on for hours, having to be re-convened the following day. 

Even Somerset's hard-working Local Democracy Reporter Daniel Mumby had to give up his coverage at one point, because it went on so long. His frustration was clear in his eventual report that it took them "nearly a week" to decide.

Following up on points raised by residents on Covid-19 and public health, Somerset Independents has challenged Mendip District Council to show that it listened to residents.

We also have challenged Mendip District Council to show that the Sub-Committee considered the Covid-19 concerns raised by Somerset's top public health official, the Director of Public Health, Trudi Grant. MDC was unable to show this, because it did not consider them.

Instead, MDC passed the buck.

Ms Grant made 3 recommendations in a letter to the Deputy Chief Executive of Mendip District Council on 8th April 2021.

But the Sub-Committee didn't consider them. Because they were not in the report. 

We have confirmed this directly with MDC, after looking at the agenda. We could not see it, despite the agenda being huge. It was full of holes. The application was full of holes.

The holes include Covid-19.

The report to the Sub-Committee completely omitted the public health concerns raised by Ms Grant, despite them being raised in good time before the Sub-Committee agenda was produced.

We have the proof that they were not considered in writing from the author of the report, the Senior Licensing and Business Support Officer for MDC, who told us that, and we quote:

"The document you refer to was passed onto GFEL for them to take into account when they prepare their Event Management Plans for this event.

 

Somerset County Council Public Health (SCCPH)did not make a representation under the Licensing Act 2003 in respect of this application so therefore this document would not form part of the papers presented at the hearing. That said, SCCPH sit on the Multi-Agency Partnership meetings with GFEL and am sure they will monitor the situation closely in the lead up to the event taking into account current legislation.

 

This event will take place on one evening this year, Saturday 18th September 2021 and NASS over the following weekend."

We interpret this as MDC passing the buck to GFEL on Covid-19 and public health. We interpret this as ignoring the recommendations from Ms Grant. 

What other possible interpretations are there? But perhaps we have missed something, so we have gone back to Ms Grant to ask her a few questions and see if she is happy.

We also believe that the above response from the MDC Licensing Officer is also a dismissal of Ms Grant's letter. 

How can it not be a representation? It doesn't make sense at all.

Presumably as a Responsible Authority under the Licensing Act 2003, Ms Grant didn't just guess by coincidence that GFEL had put an application in? MDC would have notified her as Director of Public Health, and a Responsible Authority. And she then provided her comprehensive response.

Therefore any response would automatically be a representation under the Act?

This would seem a logical conclusion, indeed the only conclusion, when the title of the letter was:

"RE Live Music Event at Worthy Farm License Application by Glastonbury Festival
Events LTD for September 2021
"

Ms Grant's recommendations were:

"Recommendation 1: Given the uncertainty regarding future levels of transmission and
or the possible emergence of a variant of concern, we would strongly recommend that
a condition of granting the license is that the event organisers are able to evidence a
robust cancellation policy and process, that they will be liable for enacting. This will
ensure that if the local or national situation changes at short notice, the event
organisers are in a position to respond and advise people that the event is cancelled
and that they cannot attend, thereby assisting local and national teams to help protect
the nation’s health.

...

Recommendation 2: The DPH cannot see how an event of this size, at this site, could
proceed if social distancing measures remained in place at the time of the event and
would therefore suggest cancelling the event if at the time social distancing measures
were still in place at the time of the planned event. (Festival organisers referenced this
factor in their event management plan submitted for the cancelled June 2021 festival).

...

Recommendation 3: it would be helpful to have as much time as possible to review
and plan the covid19 secure measures in partnership with Festival organisers, to ensure
every opportunity is taken to protect the population’s health and well-being. We would
request a draft of the Covid-19 secure plan to be submitted at least 90 days in advance
of the planned event, to ensure adequate time to make this plan as robust as possible,
recognising that central government guidance is subject to change at any point in time."

We challenged MDC to show how all of these recommendations were addressed in the Decision Notice to approve the event.

They could not show this, because they didn't address them all. They only addressed one, and that was only partially. The Decision Notice states:

"17. ‘Covid Secure’ planning considerations and a full risk assessment will be
undertaken in partnership with Somerset County Council, Public Health
England and in line with the Government Roadmap and relevant legislation,
advice and guidance at the time if required. Such planning shall include a
cancellation and/or evacuation plan."

Yet this is still passing the buck. And leaving it all until the last minute. It is putting people at risk of harm.

We believe that Ms Grant is doing her utmost in such a difficult job in protecting Somerset residents from potential "Super Spreader" events in Somerset. We have praised her on multiple occasions and thanked her. But MDC need to back her recommendations.

Such "Super Spreader" large events include, but are not limited to, this September concert at Worthy Farm - if it goes ahead - and the NASS Festival at the Bath and West Showground. NASS was recently postponed from July to September, as reported on the Somerset Independents website.

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says:

Andrew Pope

"Somerset Independents do not oppose these events. We want people to enjoy themselves in our fantastic county of Somerset. Somerset is a welcoming place for visitors.

But we were formed to stand up for local residents.

These events need to be managed properly and there must be clearly-defined conditions and limits. It is the job of MDC to act like a Licensing Authority for all applicants, and to be consistent. But it doesn't seem to be.

MDC has not managed licensing consistently for many years. There have been too many terrible impacts on residents, and MDC has been deaf to the complaints. MDC has dismissed complaints and has even made it difficult for residents to complain.

So now during this continuing Global Pandemic of Covid-19, it is the time to begin to manage these large events properly, for everybody's sake - visitors, businesses and residents alike. We need certainty now.

We hope that MDC will urgently listen and act on residents' concerns and the concerns of the Director of Public Health to protect everybody in Somerset from Covid-19. This must start with imposing the DPH's conditions on large events and NOT by passing the buck to GFEL or anybody else.
How MDC achieves this is MDC's problem, not the problem of residents and good public servants who have been let down by MDC's supine Licensing Authority for too long.

MDC is the Licensing Authority. It needs to act like an authority that serves local residents, instead of taking the easy option. Councillors are supposed to represent the public, but at MDC they do not."


Standing Up For Residents

 

---

An application was made to Mendip District Council for a premises licence by Glastonbury Festival Events Limited (GFEL) and representations were received from responsible authorities and other persons.

A sub-committee hearing was held on 12th May 2021 for all parties to state their case.

The Licensing Sub-Committee has granted the licence, with conditions.

The Decision Notice is posted in full on the Council's website Icon for pdf Decision Notice (revised) [294.19KB]

Cllr Sam Phripp, Chair of Licensing at Mendip, said: "Whenever a licence application is considered, Mendip rightly assesses the impact of an event on local people and seeks to find a decent balance.

"With regard to Glastonbury Festival Events Limited holding a concert in September, we've heard concerns from residents, and those concerns are reflected in more than fifty conditions that have been added to this licence. We believe they're sensible measures, and match the perceived risk of the event.

"With a view to Covid-19, of course, any event would have to be Covid-safe, and Mendip will work with other organisations and the organisers to make sure that's the case."

Cllr Phripp added: "It's in everybody's interest for events like these to be a success, but as Chair of Licensing at Mendip, I'm clear that we'll keep our ears and eyes open and take on board feedback from residents in Pilton, just as we would with any other event.

"We hope that, Covid-depending, this event will be a success, and we look forward to welcoming music lovers back to our corner of Somerset this autumn."

 

Wednesday, May 19, 2021

UPDATED (21/5/21): Residents "Very Angry" As "Supine" Mendip Council "Bent Over Backwards" To Glastonbury Organisers On Pilton Event

 

Worthy Farm, Pilton

UPDATED (21/5/21): The Piltonians residents group have issued an updated Statement. It is in full below under "Second Version". The first version has been removed at the request of the residents group.

These are the views of the Piltonians residents group and not necessarily those of Somerset Independents. We respond below.

---

Mendip District Council has given the go-ahead for a huge 50,000 people event at Worthy Farm, Pilton - some time in September, perhaps...

This is despite local residents' anger and concern over it being a "super-spreader" event as a result of the Indian Covid-19 variant that is of increasing concern to public health. Now residents are considering whether to lodge an appeal.

Residents said that: 

"People are very angry. Mendip bent over backwards to give GFEL everything they wanted."

and

"The relationship between Mendip and GFEL is far too cosy."

The full Press Release from the Piltonians residents group is below. The views expressed are of the Piltonians residents group and not necessarily those of Somerset Independents. 

Responding for Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope says: 

"We want local residents to be heard, but as we have proved many times over, Mendip District Council prefers to ignore residents in favour of dodgy deals behind closed doors. 

Even Mendip's own External Auditor Ernst and Young has ordered them to be transparent in how Mendip operates and spends millions of pounds of public money.

There is a lot of merit to what residents are saying and have been saying - we saw and heard what happened at the Licensing Sub-Committee. It was shameful.

Where was the local Pilton Mendip councillor Tory Nigel Hewitt-Cooper? Was he representing local residents.? No, as usual, he was nowhere to be seen.

Events must be safe and impact on local residents must be managed. But Mendip have not done that on this site. If they had, residents would not be so angry.

As they say in their statement, now residents are considering whether to take the matter further by lodging an appeal."


(Second Version) Updated Press Release From Piltonians Residents Group

 

Anger as Council gives Glastonbury Festival new event licence


Mendip District Council has approved a new two-day event for 50,000 people on the Worthy Farm site which will be held this September and in subsequent years. The decision comes just days after Glastonbury Festival Events Limited (GFEL) received a £900,000 government handout [1] to compensate for the cancellation of the Festival owing to Covid -19. Nevertheless GFEL point blank refused to limit the license to one or two years.


The event decision came despite Mendip’s failure to re-determine its licensing policy [2] by 6 January 2021. Mendip’s principal lawyer, Lesley Dolan, described the situation as “somewhat regrettable”.


Opponents of the proposed event say Mendip’s decision is not legitimate and is the result of an unfair process from the start. Official notices were not posted in prominent locations such as village notice boards and Mendip failed to provide crucial information. Most local people knew nothing about the proposed concert, giving them little chance to reach their own opinions. Unbelievably Mendip have increased the noise limit to 70db which is 5db higher than for the Festival itself.


At the hearing some proposals were not on the published agenda, others arriving out of the blue at the last minute. Parts appeared briefly on a screen at the online meeting or were read out by Mendip Officers. Despite knowing this would be the case, Mendip went ahead with the hearing without any consideration of the critical issues of non-compliance.


GFEL hasn’t explained how it will get 50,000 people, and potentially over 1,000 vehicles, on and off the site on two successive days. Nor how long the expected 10,000 workers will be on site, and where they will stay. GFEL says it will not be erecting the usual anti-climb fence - this will bring back bad memories for locals of ticketless people hunting around the village for ways to gain access. In future years they will only receive 120 days notice of this major invasion of their village.


The potential risk from Covid-19 was not adequately addressed at the hearing. There are fears that this concert will turn into a super-spreader event. This all comes as a growing number of events are planned at the Worthy Farm site including live streaming and camping.


Any protections for the community are being left for the event management plan and planning decisions [3] sometime closer to the event. Pressure to give the go-ahead will then mean that villagers’ voices will be heard even less.


Mendip has bent over backwards to give everything GFEL wanted. The relationship between Mendip and GFEL is far too cosy. Mendip may well be worried about the legal costs of standing up to this multi-million pound commercial organisation. People are very angry.


The only surprise is that it took Mendip four days to reach this utterly predictable decision.


For further information please contact piltonians@aol.com


Editor’s Notes:
[1] On 2 April GFEL was awarded £900,000 grant as part of the second tranche of UK government’s Culture Recovery Fund.
[2] Mendip District Council has breached its statutory requirement, under Section 5 of Licensing Act 2003, to determine and publish its Licensing Policy every five years. Its previous Policy lapsed on 6 Jan 2021.
[3] GFEL has planning permission for its usual Festival but only during the period 1 May to 31 Aug. Outside this period Worthy Farm must be used for agricultural purposes. It is now widely accepted that this two day concert will require planning permission before it can go ahead.



Thursday, May 13, 2021

Resident Concerns on New September Concert At Pilton By Glastonbury Festival Organisers

Local residents have written formal objections and raised a large number of concerns in person about the "rushed" proposal by Glastonbury Festival Events Limited (GFEL) to put on a two-day concert at Worthy Farm in Pilton.

The two-day "September" event was described as "to compensate" for the loss of Pilton (Glastonbury) Festival two years in a row, according to a report involving Daniel Mumby (Somerset Local Democracy Reporter) on BBC Radio Somerset this evening, Thursday 13th May 2021. A full transcript of the interview is below.

Residents are unhappy about how Mendip District Council has not consulted them properly, and GFEL having done the same lack of involvement of residents. More on this is in the transcript.

Having previously questioned local authorities and Glastonbury Festival, Bath and West and other event organisers on the wisdom of holding mass gatherings and large events during coronavirus in 2020 and 2021, Somerset Independents is following events closely and working with local residents. We applauded the leadership of Bath and West earlier this year, when they took the responsible decision.

Somerset Independents was formed to stand up for Somerset residents. 


Somerset Independents remain extremely concerned that Mendip District Council is in a "rush to please" GFEL as alleged by a local resident at yesterday's Licensing Sub-Committee. This accusation was of course denied by Cabinet Member for Economic Development Councillor Simon Carswell who against all sound governance sat on the Licensing Sub-Committee that considered the application. This was not a conflict of interest at all according to MDC, despite Cllr Carswell declaring his meeting GFEL people as an interest during the meeting. See note* below for more on the other conflicts of interest at MDC.

This event could put not only the attendees and staff at risk, but all local residents from cross-infection before, during and after the event of current or any future variants or mutations of coronavirus.

We have written to the Somerset County Council Director of Public Health, Trudi Grant, and await an answer.

There will be more from us on this very soon.

Below is a transcript of the interview between Matt Faulkner and Daniel Mumby on BBC Radio Somerset today.

"Transcript of Daniel Mumby Interview
13/5/21
BBC Radio Somerset Matt Faulkner

Matt Faulkner:

As we were hearing, Mendip District Council is asking for more time to
decide whether a two-day concert at the Worthy Farm site could go ahead
some time in September.

Councillors on the Licensing Committee sat for seven hours yesterday and
 a further few hours today discussing the event which has prompted
concerns about noise, traffic and coronavirus precautions.

Our Local Democracy Reporter Daniel Mumby's been following the
protracted proceedings and joins me now.

Daniel, afternoon, first of all what sort of event are we talking about?

DM: Well many people will be aware that the full-blown Glastonbury
Festival won't be taking place this June in light of the coronavirus.

So to compensate for there being no festival two years on the trot, the
Festival organisers put forward plans for a smaller two-day event for
up to 50,000 people with bands playing on the Pyramid Stage only and no
on-site camping.

Now the date for the event has not yet been set. But the Festival hopes
it can take place some time in September around the time when the Pilton
Party is to be held.

Faulkner: So what are some of the concerns that have been raised about
the event so far?

DM: Well there were concerns about how legitimate the licensing hearing
was, with some residents alleging that they had not been properly consulted
about the event, something which the Festival organisers strongly
denied.

Beyond that, there were numerous complaints noise generated by the live
music and crowds, with local resident Caroline Griffiths saying  
there was an element of fear and futility in the community surrounding
the event.

Crowd size was also a concern with resident Nick Hall claiming  
people would be more tightly packed together than at the regular
Festival since only 7% of the site would end up being used.

And finally there were questions about coronavirus testing for ticket
holders, with the organisers saying they would comply with all
Government guidance at the time that the event is staged.

Faulkner: Why then has it taken so long to come to a decision?

DM: Well, licensing hearings are designed to drill down into the nitty-
gritty of an event. They're an opportunity for members of the public to
raise concerns and for official bodies like the Police, Fire Service
and Environmental Health to ensure that everything is above board and
all visitors to an event will be kept safe.

Now when you're dealing with an event of this size, not to mention the
reputation of the Glastonbury Festival, scrutinising every detail takes
time. It's pretty unprecedented for there to be seven hours of public
debate, followed by a further half-day of confidential discussion by
committee members.

Faulkner: OK, so where do we stand now. When do we find out the result?

DM: Well, we had hoped there would be a decision by the time we came on
the air, but sadly we'll have to wait a little longer. Mendip did
release a statement a little after 4 o'clock in which they blamed the
delays on the size and complexity of the event and say the decision may
now not be finalised until Wednesday next week.

Now we should point out this is entirely legal for the Council to take
that long. They are allowed up to 5 working days under Government
guidelines but it does mean a long and nervous wait for the residents
of Pilton and the neighbouring villages.

Faulkner: And once we do have a decision, what happens next?

DM: Well, if the Council says yes, the Festival will go ahead and make
their plans and announce a date once they've settled on it.

If the Council says no, the Festival organisers can lodge an appeal
within 30 days which would have to be heard by magistrates.

If they won the appeal, it would still give them enough time to put the
event together, but at this stage we're still dealing with a lot of
unknowns including of course what happens with coronavirus infection
rates once restrictions are completely lifted on the 21st June.

Faulkner: Daniel, thank you very much indeed."
*Note on conflicts of interest at MDC.

Members of the Executive or Cabinet should never sit on other committees of the Council, to avoid conflicts of interest. But as we have pointed out several times, Mendip District Council does not manage conflicts of interest, including on the Planning Board. This is the planning committee for MDC and its members include several members of Cabinet including the Leader of the Council Ros Wyke and whose Chair is Damon Hooton, who was previously in the MDC Cabinet for Planning and Development Management. All these are spectacularly bad ideas in the governance of any council and other councils including South Somerset specifically ban it.

 

Tuesday, February 23, 2021

At Mendip District Council, it's Lib Dem, Green or Tory, same old story

 

Lib Dems, Greens, Tories
all robbing your council tax

Somerset Independents Co-Founder Denise Wyatt spoke at last night's Mendip Council Budget Full Council. Her full speech is below. 

She asked councillors to not increase council tax, but they did. Every councillor did except one, Green Councilor Francis Hayden, who was barred from voting - because he had not paid his council tax. 

Yes, really.

Denise Wyatt

Responding, Denise says: 

"Lib Dem, Green, Tory - same old story. Whether it is Mendip Council or Somerset County Council, these councillors think YOU should pay more council tax. They all voted to increase it. Mendip councillors and Somerset County Councillors are a disgrace."

Denise's Full Speech is below.

Liberal Democrat Councillor Barry O'Leary, in presenting the council tax increases, said that residents should not be getting a refund of their council tax, which was suggested by Denise in her speech.

Lib Dem Councillor Garfield Kennedy, who earlier supported spending more money on "the arts", said it is a "false economy" to freeze council tax. Cllr O'Leary agreed.

Incredibly, despite residents struggling during the Pandemic and the failures of Mendip Council to provide services and value for money, ALL Mendip District Councillors voted FOR the council tax increase. 

All that was, apart from Green Cllr Francis Hayden who said that he had been told that he was in arrears, and has not paid his council tax.

So these councillors want to tell you to pay MORE council tax, but there was one who has not paid his own council tax. Isn't that the height of hypocrisy?

Several councillors mentioned at the meeting that they thought councillors might have been voting without having heard all of the debate. "We're all grown-ups", says Chair Lib Dem Councillor Helen Sprawson-White, and did not ask for any councillor's vote to be discounted.

The Chair claimed that the vote to approve the increase in council tax was "as unanimously as we could have done". She was glossing over the fact that a councillor has not paid his council tax, and is in arrears, so was barred from voting on the council tax of everybody in Mendip.

So there we have it - yet another increase to our council tax, to add to the Police and County Council increases. 

During a pandemic, they increased our council tax.

Lib Dems, Green and Tory councillors take our money for granted. They need to be removed.


Denise Wyatt Full Speech to Mendip District Council Full Council, 22nd February 2021


This budget is shocking.

Why is our council tax increasing? We should be getting a rebate

It’s not just Council Tax you want to increase - is it?

You propose to Increase the charges for - Garden waste bins and worse burial costs.

Bins that’s another subject. Less service or no service at all.  Have you seen the complaints on social media? If you’re lucky enough to get your bin collected, it now only happens every three weeks.

It’s also no surprise that fly tipping in Mendip is worse than ever.

Also you are expecting residents to do your litter picking and street weeding for you. What other services do you expect the public to do?

In your report your expectation is and I quote “Society will assist in the delivery of services.”

Your accounts - My objection to your accounts was regarding your Investment Property. This only occurred because you didn’t listen to me over your governance. So I had no choice but to contact the External Auditor Ernst and Young. Who because of my objection is investigating what has been going on?

On this point, I would like to thank your s151 Officer.

With regard to income from these investment properties, several of your tenants are falling behind with their rental payments to the tune of just under half a million.

It is also no surprise that the Council is currently maintaining an over-borrowed position.” You are gambling with public money.

Again what’s worse from your reports I gather you are expecting us to pay more money by crowd funding your pet investment schemes? Can’t you get the money from the banks?

Reorganisation costs, even the Councils rigged consultation shows that residents don’t want it.  If reorganisation goes ahead the Council has no funding allocated for transition costs. According to your reports you intend to take money from reserves or “Flexible use of Capital Receipts” So you are going to flog assets for reorganisation and fail more services.

You have also failed to spend grants to build social housing.  I refer you to the Saxonvale disaster and the Easthill  tragedy. 

What sort of a Mickey Mouse council are you?

You are providing fewer services, and likely even fewer

Expect the public to go out and do your job for you 

You are also proposing, the Lib Dem death tax to charge the dead more to be buried

You are being investigated by the external auditor

 

This Council is a disgrace and I repeat the public should be getting a rebate not an increase.

 


Thursday, February 18, 2021

At the County, it's CONFIRMED - Lib Dem or Tory, Same Old Story

 

Denise Wyatt
Somerset Independents Nominations Officer

At yesterday's unbelievable Budget Full Council meeting, our Leader Andrew Pope spoke to ask that councillors reject the Budget proposed by the Tory-run councillors and make them think again about asking for more millions from hard-pressed taxpayers during the Covid-19 Pandemic. Andrew said:

"You can’t get away with it. Not during a Global Pandemic when residents have been sacked, been furloughed, been ill or died, and businesses have folded, had to shelve expansion, or lose staff."

Andrew's full speech is below. The SomersetLive report by Local Democracy Reporter Daniel Mumby is here. Some of Andrew's speech is reported in it.
 
The Liberal Democrats, who are supposed to be the largest group of councillors in opposition, did not oppose the Tories' Budget.  
 
Much, much worse - in a sign of abject surrender, and the opposition of a limp lettuce, all Lib Dem councillors even voted for the Tories' Budget!
 
Somerset Independents Nominations Officer* (see note below) Denise Wyatt says:

"I was shocked but not surprised that the Liberal Democrat County councillors voted with the Conservatives on the Tory budget.

Andrew Pope was right to say at today's meeting that the Opposition is pathetic and Lib Dem or Tory, it's the same old story.

It's ludicrous that the Lib Dems voted with the Tory budget.

Where was the Lib Dem Opposition as the largest opposition group?

Where was the Lib Dem's Alternative Budget? They have a duty to provide one, to stand up for Somerset's residents against the Tories. Did the Lib Dem Spokesperson Liz Leyshon even read the Tory's Budget. She even stated that the money, at the direction of the Tory councillors, was being managed well by officers! 

The Lib Dems have all the strength of a limp lettuce in standing up for Somerset. Councillor Jane Lock is supposed to "lead" the Opposition. All she did was agree with the Tories!

As Somerset Independents has been saying for the past year, it's Lib Dem or Tory, same old story."

*In a political party registered with the Electoral Commission, the Nominations Officer is responsible for the candidates that Somerset Independents stands at elections.

Andrew Pope's speech and his Statement, sent prior to the meeting to all councillors, is below:

 

Andrew Pope
Leader of Somerset Independents


"Good Morning. I’m Andrew Pope and I’m the Leader of Somerset Independents, a pressure group and political party formed during the first Covid-19 lockdown. I speak to my written Statement, where I ask you to refuse the 4.99% increase in council tax.


At the Police andCrime Panel, I asked for the £15 increase to be refused. It was. Your increase is over four times higher!. It’s not on. Like the County Council, the Police and Crime Commissioner has repeatedly asked for increases. It is almost as if you all take Somerset’s money for granted. No taxation without representation.


Like the Commissioner, the County has not spent wisely. Like the Commissioner, millions spent on the wrong priorities. Like the Commissioner, hoping to get away with it. No.


You can’t get away with it. Not during a Global Pandemic when residents have been sacked, been furloughed, been ill or died, and businesses have folded, had to shelve expansion, or lose staff.


The right Council services have not been delivered, but your Council asks for more money. Is it justified? No, it is definitely not.


OFSTED and Ombudsman criticism, unsafe roads, huge disruption by roadworks at Prestleigh.


You councillors are supposed to be the custodians of taxpayers’ money. But you have not spent according to residents’ priorities or delivered the services that residents need. And still you want more millions from the taxpayer. No, it is not justified, but you think you can get away with it.


Councillors, in my Statement, I said that you have not done your jobs - the Conservative-run Council’s councillors and the opposition has been pathetic. Lib Dem, Labour or Green, you are all weak. As today’s report says, there are no recommendations from four committees. Why? How? You are not standing up for residents, so members of the public like me have to do it for you as volunteers!


No taxation without representation. That is how democracy is supposed to work, when it comes to public money. If you do not spend wisely, we vote you out. If you do not oppose properly, we vote you out. Lib Dem, Labour, Green or Tory, same old story. So out you should go.


But the majority of you councillors even voted to stop us voting you out! Not because of the dangers of Covid-19, did you want to stop residents voting, which would be sensible. You did it merely to protect your own allowances, to protect your own Tory Party and to backup your ownproposal to change our councils, AND continue to mis-spend millionsof pounds of public money.


So you ask for more millions, you stop residents delivering their verdict at the ballot box, and the merry go round continues.


NO. No more. No taxation without representation. When the time comes, even if elections are delayed, Somerset residents must vote you out.


You have the opportunity today to show that you stand up for Somerset residents. This is your chance. I suggest that you take it, and vote this budget down to make you Tories think again.


Thank you for listening."


Andrew Pope Statement to Somerset County Council at Budget Full Council 2021


Dear County Councillor,


I appeal to you to refuse the 4.99% increase in council tax. Ask yourself whether this is really justified when there has been money wasted on One Somerset which no residents of Somerset asked for, and where the County has a budget report which is deliberately opaque, long-winded and hiding the truth.


The Cabinet Member responsible, as it is Councillor Chilcott’s report after all, could have made it clearer, by asking officers to do so. Instead, the public has to interpret a total mess hiding the mis-spending of public funds on a huge scale. Why do I say the public? Because you councillors aren’t doing your jobs.


There should be no taxation without representation. And the County Council has not listened to residents who want a referendum before any changes to how we are governed. In 2007, 82% of residents voted against a unitary. Even your own rigged consultation showed a lack of support. Please just stop it now.


Not only has this money been wasted, you are proposing to pay for other past, present and future mistakes by increasing council tax. £17 million for something that residents don't want, plus countless millions on who knows what in the future. No taxation without representation.


I spoke at the Police and Crime Panel recently, and for the first time, they refused an unjustified 6.6% increase which amounted to £15. They are councillors just like all of you apart from Councillor Hunt – national party politicians. Despite this, they stood up for residents and voted 11 for and 1 abstention. Your proposals are more than four times higher. Why? How?


I suggest to you that this level of increase is not justified, so you must refuse it today. Residents feel that you've got a cheek asking for any more money, let alone 4.99%, when your Conservative-run Council has provided no pushback whatsoever on the Conservative Government's failure to protect our county and its residents from the Pandemic. Instead, you beg for letters to and from failed Prime Minister Johnson. If you think Boris Johnson’s support bolsters support for you, you are very much mistaken. He and you have failed us.


The public expect the county council to be responsible. Instead of this, you are proposing to cut support for Freedom of Information, spend millions on a solar farm that won't pay back for many years, plus more wasteful IT spending. These are just some examples but there are many more. Please think again.


You've squirreled millions of un-ringfenced Government Covid money to bolster Council's reserves, asking suffering residents to pay more again. What a cheek.


You should be standing up for us. You should be refusing this increase today. I say again, the Police and Crime Panel finally found some backbone. So should you, because you should respect the dire situation that residents find themselves in, and vote against this misguided budget. No taxation without representation.


Thank you for listening and I hope that I will get a written response, and there will be a healthy debate, about the points that I have raised. You can contact us at somerinds@gmail.com.


Andrew Pope

Leader

Somerset Independents