Showing posts with label Council Tax. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Council Tax. Show all posts

Thursday, July 14, 2022

UPDATE (18/7/22): A Green Cabinet Member Replies - North Somerset Council Chairperson Responds on Councillors in Council Tax Arrears

 

Councillor Dr Karin Haverson
Chairperson of North Somerset Council

One of our Official emblems

UPDATE (18/7/22)

Cabinet Member and Green Party Councillor, Bridget Petty, has replied to us regarding our councillors council tax campaign. She said:

Councillor Bridget Petty
Executive Member
of Climate Change
and Environment
 

"Thank you for emailing us, I wanted to thank you and your organisation for your hard work and pursuit of good governance and accountability.

 

Yours sincerely

 

Councillor Bridget Petty

Executive Member of Climate Emergency and Engagement

Green Party Councillor for Backwell, North Somerset"

---

Somerset Independents has now published the names and details of three councillors on North Somerset Council who persistently did not pay their council tax for months or even over years.

We have asked every North Somerset councillor for comment on the recalcitrant councillors. 

Councillor Dr Karin Haverson, who is a Green Party councillor and is now Chairperson of North Somerset Council, has reassured us and welcomed our investigation:

Councillor Dr Karin Haverson

 

"I welcome your efforts to highlight the behaviour of all of us councillors, but can assure you that I have never been in Council Tax arrears, neither before nor after I became a councillor. I am a retired scientist and have never been in business, and it would go against my principles to withhold money from the public purse.



Best wishes 

Dr Karin Haverson 

Councillor Banwell & Winscombe 
Chairperson of North Somerset Council"

 

Earlier this year, Councillor Haverson requested at Full Council, which she chairs, that she be addressed as "Chairperson".

 

Who Are Somerset Independents?

We are Somerset's own campaign group and political party. We celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Wednesday, July 13, 2022

IN FULL: The Apology To Us From North Somerset Council Leader Councillor Steve Bridger on Our Investigation into Councillors In Council Tax Arrears

North Somerset Council

 

One of our Official emblems

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We stand up for residents of Somerset, whether in the north, south, east or west of the County.

As explained in our article naming the councillors and listing the delays to our five-month investigation, which was began in February 2022, North Somerset Council bungled their responses to our Freedom of Information requests.

The timing of the answers, the delay, the omissions of key information including the amounts of arrears and a councillor's name, and the fact that we had to ask twice, all aroused quite reasonable suspicions that there was something awry.

Here is the full apology from the Leader of North Somerset Council, Independent Councillor Steve Bridger, to the leader of our investigation, Andrew Pope. The name of the Council officer has been redacted, but the names of councillors have not been redacted:

Councillor Steve Bridger
Leader of North Somerset Council

"Dear Mr Pope

Andrew Pope
Leader of Somerset Independents


Many thanks for your email, and I understand you have also emailed the council’s Information Governance team with additional questions relating to the handling of your Freedom of Information request. For your convenience, I am, therefore, responding to both your email to me and the email to the Information Governance team. 

Firstly, to address why your first response was missing elements of what you had asked, here the Information Governance team can only express their apologies for the initial oversight. It is quite common for the Council to receive requests for details about Councillor council tax arrears, because, as you rightly say, there is public interest in this information. Subsequently, the information provided to you was what would normally be compiled in response to this request.

Unfortunately, the Council Tax team who compiled the information didn’t read the request thoroughly enough, and didn’t realise your request was asking for additional detail to the “norm”.

<redacted>, the Information Governance Officer who sent the final response, isn’t familiar with the finer workings of the Council Tax service, and wasn’t aware that the responses the service area provided didn’t fully answer your questions. As I said, I do wish to convey the apologies of the Information Governance team, and are grateful to you for highlighting this potential training shortfall.

As to why Councillor Goddard was missing from the original response, please rest assured this was in no way intentional. Council Tax accounts aren’t “flagged” in any way to highlight the fact they belong to Councillors. In order to compile this data, the Council Tax service have to go into each individual Councillors’ account< and do so using a list of the current Councillors. The list the service went by for the initial response was based on the list of Councillors compiled for the start of the 2021/22 financial year. Councillor Goddard was elected mid-year, and therefore missing from the original list. She was identified as absent when your request for a review was received, and the team cross-referenced using the Councillor list compiled for the current financial year. I fully agree that your response should have provided an explanation of this to you, rather than just sending the additional information, and I can certainly understand why this would raise questions over the legitimacy and completeness of the remaining information. However, I can only provide my assurances to you that the full and complete records have now been disclosed to you.

I note in your email to the Information Governance team that you are asking whether, and if so, why Councillors were advised of the request. I can confirm that no Councillors were made aware of the request prior to sending, nor immediately afterwards. We were first made aware of it following your email correspondence with myself. I hope this can go someway to re-affirming my previous statement that no information has been knowingly or intentionally withheld. Both the Information Governance team and the Council Tax service are delivered on behalf of North Somerset Council in partnership with third-party contractors, so their independence in these matters is guaranteed. 

I also understand that you have asked Information Governance for a reason why your revised response took a further six weeks for you to receive it.  Again, I can only apologise on their behalf. Our normal policy in these matters is to allow 40 working days for an Internal Review response, because they can be lengthy and complex. The team were optimistic that they could provide you with a full response a lot sooner than that, hence your acknowledgement email advising it would be received earlier. Unfortunately, the revised response did turn out to be complicated, as additional teams needed to be contacted, and this was exacerbated by officer sickness and annual leave. 

I would also like to clarify one element in your revised response regarding Councillor Jacobs. Councillor Jacobs only attended the 2022 Budget Meeting remotely via Microsoft Teams. Only Councillors who attend in-person are eligible to vote, so she did not vote in the Budget Meeting. While this information was provided to you in your response, I note whether she voted was not made fully clear to you, so I just wanted to clarify that. 

I note you have approached each of the three named Councillors for comment, and I admire and appreciate your tenacity and commitment to the transparency of wider council affairs. I fully understand that you want to ensure the council are fulfilling our democratic obligations, and I hope my explanations have provided you with assurances.

kind regards,
Steve


Councillor Steve Bridger

Leader of North Somerset Council
Independent councillor for Yatton ward"


Andrew Pope responds:

"I thank Councillor Bridger for his apology. Our investigation started before he became Leader of the Council. We have contacted the previous Leader Don Davies for comment. We have published his response on our website.

The apology from Cllr Bridger was definitely more than we got when we investigated other councils in Somerset. Over a year later, we are still fighting South Somerset District Council, with the help of the Information Commissioner. South Somerset are still trying to hide information and cover up for councillors, even now.

Our investigation into North Somerset has now concluded. We are now waiting for  responses from the rest of the Council's councillors.

We know that local residents are interested. There will be elections soon. 

I very much hope that the councillors that we named will not be standing for election."


Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join us. We are Somerset's own campaigning group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We stand up for residents, while the Westminster parties look after themselves.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Monday, July 11, 2022

EXPOSED: North Somerset Independent Councillor David Shopland Who Persistently Did Not Pay His Council Tax Over Two Years

Councillor David Shopland
(Clevedon East)

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We stand up for residents and we act on the issues that matter to them.

Residents support our investigations into councillors who persistently failed to pay their own council tax. To say again, we do not pursue private individuals. 

But councillors are not just private individuals. They are public representatives who receive public money in the form of an allowance. And they spend public money when they vote at council meetings or take other actions as councillors.

We said that we would expose councillors that we found to have failed to pay, during our investigations.

We named three councillors. The third of them that we are providing details of is Councillor David Shopland. He is an Independent and is part of the ruling Independent group.


Councillor David Shopland
(Clevedon East)

Councillor Shopland was named in the initial response to our Freedom of Information (FoI) requests to North Somerset Council. It said:

"Councillor David Shopland - Reminder issued 16.04.21, 2 nd Reminder Issued 19.05.21, Final Notice Issued 14.01.21. Councillor Shopland has one instalment of £229.00 left to pay. The amount of arrears varied each month as payments were being made but payments were not as billed. We do not hold a reason for non-payment."

But the Council did not answer our FoI properly. Information was missing. The dates did not make sense. So we asked them to review it. After a long delay, they came back with the following information, which is significantly different. And the Council Leader apologised to us for how the Council had handled our requests.


"Councillor David Shopland


2020/2021


21 July 2020

Reminder Issued

£654.00

21 August 2020

2nd Reminder Issued

£654.00

Notes: The account was then maintained as required for the remainder of the financial year.


2021/2022


16 April 2021

Reminder Issued

£229.39

19 May 2021

2nd Reminder Issued

£229.00

14 January 2022

Final Notice Issued

£687.00

25 February 2022

Summons Issued

£324.00 (£229.00 Council Tax + £95 Summons Costs)

18 March 2022

Liability Order Granted


Notes: The amount of £229.00 was paid in full on 7 March 2022, which left a remaining balance of £95.00


This remained unpaid and the debt is now with the Enforcement Agency for collection.


We can confirm Councillor David Shopland did not vote in the budget meeting of February 2022."


 

So, not only did Cllr Shopland not pay his council tax in one year. He did it over two years! AND he received a court summons and a liability order was granted too.

We have offered Cllr Shopland a right of reply, which was difficult because the only contact details were by post - no email and no phone are offered on the Council website. But we have received no response to our attempts to contact him. We allowed adequate time. 
 
And Cllr Shopland not only attended the Council budget meeting when in arrears. He did not declare his arrears either. Cllr Shopland even participated in the meeting and proposed a motion! It is all there in the official Minutes and in the recording of the meeting. And we double-checked the record with officers.
 
Former Chairman of the Council David Shopland has been in trouble before - in 2013, as reported by the North Somerset Times, he and his wife were both accused of not updating their registers of interests as councillors in a timely fashion - a criminal offence. At the time, David Shopland said: "No one has approached me officially on this so I do not have any comment to make." The outcome of the Police investigation is not reported by the North Somerset Times.

It is a question of honesty. It is a question of integrity. It is a question of the Nolan Principles of Public Life, which all councillors are bound by.

Councillor David Shopland, when Chairman of the Council, said:

"Thank you for the honour you have given me. I must warn you I could make mistakes, but I will always try to be impartial and fair."


We suggest local residents submit a formal complaint into Councillor Shopland.

Do you agree that Cllr Shopland should resign?


We have asked all North Somerset Independent councillors for comment.


Who Are Somerset Independents? 

We are a campaigning group of volunteers, dedicated to better representation in Somerset. Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




EXPOSED: North Somerset Conservative Councillor Ruth Jacobs Did Not Pay Almost £2,000 Council Tax For Months

 

Councillor Ruth Jacobs

One of our Official emblems

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We stand up for residents and we act on the issues that matter to them.

Residents support our investigations into councillors who persistently failed to pay their own council tax. To say again, we do not pursue private individuals. 

But councillors are not just private individuals. They are public representatives who receive public money in the form of an allowance. And they spend public money when they vote at council meetings or take other actions as councillors.

We said that we would expose councillors that we found to have failed to pay, during our investigations.

We named three councillors. The first of them that we are providing details of is Councillor Ruth Jacobs. 

Councillor Ruth Jacobs

Councillor Jacobs was named in the response to our Freedom of Information (FoI) requests to North Somerset Council. We quote directly from the Council's responses. In the first response from the Council, they said:

"Councillor Ruth Jacobs – Reminder issued 19.05.21, Summons Issued 18.06.21, Liability Order granted 09.07.2021. The amount has now been paid in full. The amount of arrears varied each month as payments were being made but payments were not as billed. We do not hold a reason for non- payment."
But the Council did not answer our FoI properly. Information was missing. So we asked them to review it. After a long delay, they came back with more information. And the Council Leader apologised to us for how they had handled our requests.

This time they gave us the large amounts of arrears - which they omitted in their initial response, despite our request asking for the information.

ONE THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED AND TWENTY-TWO POUNDS AND TWENTY-TWO PENCE IN ARREARS - almost TWO GRAND!

Cllr Jacobs even got a court summons and liability order granted.

"Councillor Ruth Jacobs


19 May 2021

Reminder Issued

£126.22

18 June 2021

Summons Issued

£1,922.22 (£1,827.22 Council Tax+ £95 Summons Costs)

09 July 2021

Liability Order Granted


Notes: The amount has now been paid in full, with the final payment being made on 21 January 2022.


We can confirm Cllr Jacobs was not present at the budget meeting of February 2022, attending only via Teams."

We have repeatedly offered Cllr Jacobs a right of reply. All we got in response from Cllr Jacobs was a mystifying reply:

"Hi,
Full council tax will be paid on Monday 13th June2022.
I resent your implication
Yours
Councillor Ruth Jacobs"

What implication? We simply offered her a right of reply to the information we obtained. 

We went back to Cllr Jacobs and asked a series of questions - again, no reply has been received.

And on her "attendance" at the Budget Full Council - Cllr Jacobs did not declare that she had been in arrears on her council tax during the financial year. She was at the meeting "virtually". Why didn't she speak up? Was she embarrassed? Was she hoping to keep it quiet?

Councillor Jacobs won't be able to keep it quiet any more, because we are publishing it.

It is a question of honesty. It is a question of integrity. It is a question of the Nolan Principles of Public Life, which all councillors are bound by.

We suggest local residents submit a formal complaint into Councillor Jacobs.

And we have suggested to Cllr Jacobs that she should resign. Do you agree?


We have asked all North Somerset Conservative councillors for comment.


Who Are Somerset Independents? 

We are a campaigning group of volunteers, dedicated to better representation in Somerset. Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Sunday, July 10, 2022

Former North Somerset Council Leader Don Davies Denies Being in Arrears on His Council Tax

Independent Councillor
Don Davies

Somerset Independents puts residents first. When we heard that former North Somerset Council Leader Don Davies had resigned suddenly as Leader (reportedly a "bolt from the blue"), we wondered whether it was anything to do with our investigation into councillors who did not pay their council tax for months or even over years. 

We were wondering this because we were still waiting, after many weeks, for the Council to respond to our request for an Internal Review into their flawed initial response to our Freedom of Information (FoI) request on councillors in arrears on council tax. 

And the day after he resigned, when he had just given his interviews to Heather Pickstock of SomersetLive (Reach), and Carrington Walker of the Weston Mercury (Archant), we finally got our response from the Council.

What a remarkable coincidence, wouldn't you agree?

And added to this was the fact that Cllr Davies was not at the Budget Full Council in February 2022, having given apologies for attendance. We know that at least one councillor at North Somerset Council who was in arrears, was also not in attendance at that meeting. This way, they would not have to declare their arrears, as they are required by law to do. We've seen councillors elsewhere in Somerset commit this ruse.

And we have had it confirmed by North Somerset Council directly that other councillors who were in arrears during the previous financial year, were in attendance - whether virtually or in person. But these recalcitrant councillors did not declare their arrears, as confirmed by North Somerset Council in writing to us.

So we asked Cllr Davies directly. Former Council Leader Councillor Don Davies told us:

"I was not at the meeting as I was away on leave; my council tax is not and has not been in arrears. It was entirely my own decision to not stand again as Leader and the reports in the media that I have seen explain why.  Quite rightIy I am unaware of all FOI requests at the council.

I trust that answers your questions.

Best wishes
Don"

It did not answer all of our questions. We have gone back to Councillor Davies to ask him to answer our individual questions. 

We will be publishing the names of the councillors who were in arrears.

Who Are Somerset Independents?

We're Somerset's most effective campaigning group and dedicated political party for the whole of Somerset.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.





Saturday, July 9, 2022

Crewkerne Residents Outraged By Our Revelations into Their District Councillors And Take Action

 

One of our Official emblems

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We work with residents to improve their lives and their areas.

Crewkerne is a town in South Somerset, near the border with Dorset. It has a Town Council and comes within the boundaries of South Somerset District Council.

A group of angry Crewkerne residents were outraged by councillors who did not pay their council tax, and took action.

Over the last two years, Somerset Independents investigated South Somerset district councillors who did not pay their council tax. We published our findings on our website and asked local news outlets to report on it. 

Both of Crewkerne’s district councillors – Liberal Democrat councillors Ben Hodgson and Robin Pailthorpe - were named as non-payers in our investigations. Hodgson and Pailthorpe were also Crewkerne town councillors. Both councillors ignored repeated offers from Somerset Independents of a right of reply.

The group of concerned residents saw our work on our website, in The Leveller and in Private Eye. This led to action. They told us:

"We are disappointed that Crewkerne councillors who were in arrears have continued to influence and vote on budgets and precepts. Although this may not be a breach of the Town Council’s Code of Conduct, we believe that it is morally wrong. We are also seeking legal advice."

Crewkerne District Councillor
and Lib Dem
Ben Hodgson

According to SSDC responses to our Freedom of Information requests, Councillor Hodgson was as at 29th April 2021:“£834.22 in arrears, £678.46 relates to last financial year. Application for disregard in progress but SMI (Severe Mental Impairment) application will be turned down”.

 

Crewkerne District Councillor
and Lib Dem
Robin Pailthorpe

As of the same date, Councillor Pailthorpe had “vacated this address with outstanding balance of £1328.66, £470.62 of which is in arrears and subject to a liability order.” Pailthorpe’s “full balance” was due on “10th May 2022”. 

So the residents decided to run candidates in the 2022 Crewkerne Town Council elections. Two of their three Independent candidates were elected, beating Conservative Party candidates. One Independent was not elected. 

As official minutes showed, despite having attended Crewkerne Town Council meeting of April 2022, neither Pailthorpe nor Hodgson stood in the Town Council elections. Perhaps they were embarrassed by their arrears that Somerset Independents had exposed? Who knows, when they do not respond to our repeated attempts at communication.

The resident groups’ election successes and further information from Somerset Independents’ investigations, have spurred the group into more action, to challenge the non-paying councillors and to independently represent the concerns of Crewkerne residents.

Somerset Independents is in regular contact with the residents.

We are continuing our investigations into councillors.


Who Are Somerset Independents?

We are Somerset's dedicated team of volunteers who work with residents to improve their lives and their area.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Thursday, June 16, 2022

UPDATE(18/7/22): VICTORY - ONE YEAR LATER - Information Commissioner Orders South Somerset District Council To Comply

A Council Mired in Controversy

UPDATE (18/7/22)

Yes, we are still battling with South Somerset District Council over information that we requested OVER A YEAR AGO.

Despite the Information Commissioner ruling, they have again tried to wriggle out of giving us the information. They again are trying to cover up for officers and councillors.

SSDC have apologised. They have claimed that they only keep emails for 13 months, but they've committed to going through backups, due to what they claim are "extenuating circumstances".

Somerset Independents will not let them get away with it.

 

UPDATE (20/6/22)

The Data Protection Officer has been in touch with Andrew Pope "to assist in submitting a refined request so that it falls within the cost limit".

We will see if SSDC provide the information that they should have done over a year ago.

---

Our investigations into councillors in council tax arrears have now been running since early 2021.

South Somerset District Council's councillors were one council that we investigated. We have been battling with SSDC officers and councillors for over a year.

The lead investigator and Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, has now received a Decision Notice from the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), after complaining to them in May 2021 when SSDC did not provide the information that he had requested.

The ICO decision text is below.

In it, the ICO have ordered SSDC to comply, to clarify the information requested and the ICO also told SSDC that they were too slow.

But still, despite it being over a year since Andrew complained to the ICO, the investigation drags on.

We await the response of SSDC to the Decision Notice. Andrew says:

Lead Investigator Andrew Pope
 

"We have already been successful in exposing South Somerset councillors who persistently failed to pay their council tax.

Thankfully, none of them will be district councillors in less than a year's time - Bloomfield, Clarke, Hodgson and Pailthorpe will all go.

All except for SSDC Conservative Sue Osborne who was elected to the County Council that will become the New Somerset Council when the County and districts are scrapped.

It is an outrage that Conservative Councillor Nick Colbert referred to Cllr Osborne's arrears as 'trivial' when I contacted him and other Conservative councillors for comment. In typical party-political fashion, Cllr Colbert tried to deflect attention to the other problems at this Lib Dem-run Council, of which there are many. But I was not asking him about those at that time. I was asking him about his Conservative colleague.

We are delighted that our investigations have spurred local residents in Martock, Crewkerne and Chard into action, because they were so outraged at what we discovered for them. You can join us by contacting us and becoming a registered supporter.

This was no thanks to local media outlets who did not report on our investigations - West Country Voices, Somerset County Gazette, SomersetLive (Reach) and BBC Radio Somerset all ignored our success. Perhaps their readers and listeners will ask why they did not see it as in the public interest.

Thankfully The Leveller and Private Eye did report on our work.

But these cuckoo councillors including Osborne are still there at SSDC and are making decisions affecting many South Somerset residents' lives. They are still "on the nest" and cannot be removed by voters because there is no election.

They are cuckoo councillors that should resign, because the majority of residents tell us that councillors who do not pay their council tax for months or even years must go."


The ICO Decision Notice states:

"Decision notice
Date: 13 June 2022

Public Authority: South Somerset District Council

Address: The Council Offices

Brympton Way

Yeovil
Somerset
BA20 2HT

Complainant: Andrew Pope

Decision (including any steps ordered)
1. The complainant submitted a 4 part request regarding South Somerset councillors non-payment of council tax. South Somerset District Council (the Council) refused part 1 of the request as it considered it would exceed the cost limit under section 12(1) of FOIA. It also considered section 40(2) would provide a basis for withholding some of the information at the remaining parts of the request.

2. The Commissioner’s decision is that the Council has correctly applied section 12 of FOIA to refuse to comply with part one of the request. Because of this, section 12 of FOIA also applies to the rest of the request by default, as if the cost to comply with part one alone exceeds the appropriate limit, then the cost to comply with the request in its entirety will further exceed the appropriate limit. He has therefore not gone on to consider the application of section 40(2). However, the Council has breached section 16 as it failed to provide advice and assistance to the complainant in relation to part one of the request. The Commissioner also finds that the Council has breached section 10(1) of FOIA by failing to provide a valid response to the request within 20 working days.

3. The Commissioner requires the public authority to take the following steps to ensure compliance with the legislation.

Provide advice and assistance to the complainant to assist them in
submitting a refined request.

4. The public authority must take these steps within 35 calendar days of the date of this decision notice. Failure to comply may result in the Commissioner making written certification of this fact to the High Court pursuant to section 54 of FOIA and may be dealt with as a contempt of court.
 


Why Do We Do This?

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We are volunteers that work with other residents to get better representation and to stand up for residents.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.