Showing posts with label Independents for Frome. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Independents for Frome. Show all posts

Saturday, August 27, 2022

Saxonvale, Frome - The Lib Dems' Mess at Mendip Gets Even Messier - Brownfield Last, Frome's Green Fields First

 

Dodgy Council, Dodgy Councillors

One of our Official emblems

 

"Two big developments at the same site? Ridiculous...This mess is going to drag on and on, way past when Mendip District Council will cease to exist in 2023. It will be a mess inherited by the New Somerset Council, via the courts. The legal bill will cost the taxpayer a lot of money." Andrew Pope, Leader of Somerset Independents

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We have stood up for local residents and businesses in the face of Mendip District Council's mess at Saxonvale, Frome.

Our Leader Andrew Pope spoke at the Planning Board against the Acorn proposal that was so reviled. We listened to residents and acted for them.

But as reported by us, the dodgy Planning Board approved the Acorn proposal. Mendip District Council also owns the land. This is a clear conflict of interest, which Mendip claims to have managed. 

Sadly, Mendip cannot be believed, because they have not managed conflicts of interest elsewhere, including councillors voting through a planning application on land owned by a fellow councillor - and claiming that they didn't know him!

This was the "Sandys Hill Lane" development on the outskirts of Frome, near the McDonald's and Sainsbury's complex. Land involved in that application is owned by Councillor Philip Ham. 

 

Councillor Philip Ham
(Photo: Mendip District Council)

Our investigation was reported in Private Eye and remains one of the most popular articles on this website.

Mendip has dodgy councillors and is a dodgy council. We've proved it time and time again. We tried to get them to reform their ways. Our campaigns have succeeded, including at Easthill, Frome and in reform of the Planning Board. But Mendip had already made a mess at Saxonvale, a brownfield site, dithering and delaying while approving development on the green fields around Frome.

Brownfield land has come last at Saxonvale, but greenfield development in Frome has preceded it, including at Sandys Hill Lane. It's tragic. It's wrong.

So when we heard that an alternative proposal was being proposed for Saxonvale, we were curious about it.

We asked Mayday Saxonvale on more than one occasion how they proposed to manage having two planning applications being approved for the same site. They did not answer. But that situation has now occurred. It happened at the Mendip Planning Board last week.

And to make matters worse, this week, the Asset Management Group approved the signing of the Section 106 Agreement for the Acorn development, further sealing the fate of the Saxonvale site, which remember, Mendip owns.

At the Asset Management Group (AMG) meeting this week, the legal adviser Lesley Dolan stated, when asked by "opposition" (hardly!) Councillor Tom Killen (Conservative) that there was no reason why they could not agree to allow the S106 agreement to be signed.  
 
No councillor voted at that meeting against signing the Agreement between Mendip and Acorn. The head financial officer, Richard Bates, also said there was no alternative but to do so.
 
The AMG resolved to sign the S106 with Acorn, but councillors claim that everything is hunky dory. IT ISN'T. Actions speak louder than words. It took the Lib Dems at Mendip years to get to this point and Mendip dithered and delayed.

Tory Councillor Tom Killen said at the AMG meeting that he was "proud" that the Council had bought the land when he was Deputy Leader of Mendip. That's some claim, given that it has generated zero revenue since Mendip bought it. We discovered this during our investigations of the Mendip accounts and our objections to their governance in managing public money.
 
 

What is a Section 106 (S106) Agreement?

It is an agreement between the planning authority (Mendip District Council in this case) and the applicant / developer (in this case Acorn). It places obligations on the developer. 

It is usually the last part of planning permission before the final go-ahead is given as permission. So when the Planning Board gave permission to the Acorn proposal a long time ago now (Somerset Independents opposed it and our Leader Andrew Pope spoke against at the Planning Board), it was subject to this S106 agreement being agreed. 

So technically there is an opportunity to stop the development, but Mendip District Council have shown no sign of stopping it.


What Happens Now?

At the AMG, the legal adviser mentioned that there was legal action - a Judicial Review relating to the demolition at the Saxonvale site. 

Also at the AMG, the THREAT (not realised yet) was made via Councillor John Clark that if they agreed to sign the S106 there would be a Judicial Review. In reality, it was not clear what Cllr Clark was threatening as he did not seem to understand what he was threatening (such is the way with Green councillors). We believe this Judicial Review is threatened by Mayday Saxonvale.

So if that were to occur, there would be at least two pieces of legal action, putting even more delays in the way of actual development going ahead. Saxonvale remains a derelict site.


Andrew Pope, Leader of Somerset Independents, says:
 
Andrew Pope

 
"How can you have two developments at the same site? Mendip District Council that own the land on behalf of Somerset residents, are playing everyone for fools!
 
This mess is going to drag on and on, way past when Mendip District Council will cease to exist in 2023. 
 
It will be a mess inherited by the New Somerset Council - the unitary authority that nobody wanted other than the Tories and the Lib Dems who have benefited from it - via the courts. 
 
The legal bill will cost the taxpayer a lot of money and it will be Somerset residents who will pay. It's just wrong and a terrible mess created by the Lib Dems."
 
We asked Mayday Saxonvale to respond to the situation and have received an answer from them, which we have published. Residents can make up their own minds as to whether they have answered our questions or not.


Who Are Somerset Independents?

We are a campaign group formed by residents to stand up for residents across the County of Somerset - North, South, East and West.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Friday, July 15, 2022

EXPLAINER: What's Wrong With Having Labour/Lib Dem/Green/Tory Party Councillors in Somerset's Councils?

 

One of our Official emblems

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We exist to improve representation in Somerset and to stand up for residents.

We are frequently critical of the Westminster parties and we say:

 Labour

 Lib Dem

 Green or 

 Tory...

 Same old story.

The fact is that now, after the 2022 local elections, that there will be fewer independent councillors in (most of) Somerset. We say (most of) because this does not apply to North Somerset Council and Bath and North East Somerset Council.

In those elections, there were only three councillors out of 110 (2.7%) elected to the County Council that in 2023 will become the New Somerset Council unitary authority when it replaces the four districts and the county council.

All of the independent councillors on the districts will go. And there will be 107 out of 110 councillors (97.3%) who are members of the Westminster parties - Labour, Lib Dem, Green or Tory. We do not include town and parish councils in these figures, but the Westminster parties have infected those councils too - sometimes in disguise by standing for the county council for their party, and then standing as a fake "independent" on the town and parish at the same time in 2022 elections - as pointed out by Scott Ward from Independents for Frome in his response to the attack by The Leveller on IFF.

Below is an explainer as to why we believe that Westminster parties should have no say in our local councils. We hope that it is useful to residents and that it helps to explain. Let us know your views by getting in touch.

We believe that councillors should represent their local residents, by listening and acting on their concerns. Having Westminster parties telling councillors what to do, via the whip and other mechanisms, gets in the way of doing this. There is also a pernicious influence of local media, which involves unaccountable decisions over what is and what is not in the public interest. This is the local politics of news.

In the main, there are two key tensions and conflicts in being an elected representative in a party-based elected democracy (e.g. a Member of Parliament or Councillor). One is between the representative's political party and the representative's constituents.

On a particular policy, the constituents may have views that are perceived to be not very “informed” by evidence or debate, but nevertheless they are the people who elected the representative, and who can vote them out. On the other hand, the party also enabled the representative to be selected as their candidate, provided them with support and had policy positions that may or may not match the constituents’ views. The representative may choose to take the party line, or may take a line determined from some or all of their constituents. All of these tensions can interfere in how the representative demonstrates accountability (or not).

If the ideal of democratic accountability is to be observed, an elected representative would always do what their electors wanted (Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s "people's will"). However, this leads to the practical concern of how the "people's will" is to be determined. Such issues raise other concerns related to the democratic goods of democratic legitimacy and popular control.

The other tension is between the representative's politics as an individual and the representative's party policy. In the UK Parliament, the party whips intervene in this matter, enforcing discipline on party members to obey the whip and vote according to party policy. There are levels of discipline, with a "three-line whip" being the strongest. Punishment for disobeying the whip is unspecified, but it does not require too much imagination to expect that MPs could lose selection at election time, have the progression of their political career halted, or suffer more devious "briefings" to the media about matters that may be political or even highly personal.  

With the implementation since 2000 of the Strong Leader and Cabinet or even more undemocratic Mayor and Cabinet model in the vast majority of councils across England, the flaws of the Westminster system have been replicated in those councils. It is just councillors instead of MPs.

The media and lobbying also intervene in policy and decision-making. The media can act as guardians of communities, taking a popular issue, making it into a story that sells newspapers and taking a particular line on the issue (e.g. opposing the fluoridation of water in Southampton). Or it can select and embellish stories that encourage viewing of television news, or hits on websites or subscriptions to magazines. Media power itself has come under the spotlight with the Leveson inquiry.

Lobbying is notorious for lacking transparency, and accusations of corruption of elected representatives have focussed heavily on corporate lobbying and PR. There is also a debate over whether "civil society groups" can, or should, create a new type of "accountability" by trying to influence government policy, despite not being accountable to the political structure of representation. Instead, they are only accountable, if that can be said, to their own members, their boards of trustees, or other groups that are not necessarily representative of the constituents that elected that government. Religious leaders also occasionally intervene in politics, despite the widespread view that "politics and religion should never mix". Despite this view, the Church of England remains traditionally privileged over other religions in the UK Parliament as well as law. For example, its bishops sit in the House of Lords - itself an unelected body.

All of the reality of the tensions and conflicts described above interfere in the ideal of democratic accountability of elected representatives to local residents - this is the ideal that Somerset Independents aims to promote.

 

  1. What do you think of the above explainer?
  2. Is it helpful?
  3. Do you agree?
  4. Do you disagree?
  5. Have we persuaded you?


Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Wednesday, July 6, 2022

In Full: Independents for Frome Responds To Attack From The Leveller

IFF Political Party Emblem Registered
with Electoral Commission

We reported on The Leveller Editor Andrew Lee's bizarre attack on Independents for Frome (IFF).

Scott Ward who ran the campaign for IFF has responded. He told us:

"I'm no longer an ifF Councillor but was involved in running the ifF Campaign. [In the letter to the Leveller], I am speaking for myself rather than the current group of ifF Councillors."

And below is his response to Andrew Lee of The Leveller, in full:

"Hi Andrew,

I'm no longer a Frome Town Councillor myself but I am still involved with the wider group.

With regards to the article and specifically the situation that the ifF candidates found themselves in during the election with no opponents standing in the majority of wards, I can tell you that the ifF candidates were all as disappointed as residents were at the lack of choice many people found themselves facing on polling day. The candidates put themselves forward with the understanding that they would get to share their message of why they were standing and what they wanted to achieve but the lack of appetite by any of the Westminster parties meant that they were denied that opportunity and it took several days for them to digest that disappointment and move on from the feeling of a hollow victory.

Primarily, I have to say that ifF is not responsible for other parties standing candidates and any disappointment felt by voters should be directed towards the Lib Dems, Labour, Conservative and The Green party. We didn't have any deals in place with any parties for them to stand aside and a 'long standing agreement' that has been hinted at by The local Green Party is something that may have happened during the first iteration of ifF by I can say with confidence that no agreement was ever reached with the generation of ifF that I was involved with.

However, it is important that ifF evolves over time and meets the needs of the people of Frome and to do that we need to learn from things that have happened, in this case the lack of choice for voters. At the moment, the new council is finding it's feet but in due course there will be conversations around how ifF provides a greater choice will sticking to the principles of the the ifF ways of working. One idea put forward has been to allow any prospective candidate that meets the requirements to stand, regardless of the number of seats available but then there is a real possibility that we end up splitting the vote between candidates, allowing political parties to take those seats with a smaller share of the votes collectively. There is no simple answer but the work will be done in an open and inclusive way which has always been the ifF way.

One other thing of note regarding your article is the mention of Eve Berry standing as an independent candidate. It's well known in Frome that Eve is a member of the conservative party and like others have tried in the past, stood as an independent to hide her political loyalties.

I hope that answers any potential questions you might have had and feel free to contact me directly (email address redacted).

Hopefully that gives you an idea of our thoughts when we found out that nobody but Eve was standing against ifF in Frome. The candidates just had to play the hand that they were dealt and I think they did so fantastically. They could have sat on their laurels but after processing the disappointment they felt, they re-focused their energy on communicating with residents to be better informed about the issues the town faces and in supporting myself and Steve in our campaigns to stand for Somerset Council.

If you have any further questions, feel free to ask."

We have still not received any response from The Leveller.

Who Are Somerset Independents?

We are Somerset's only dedicated campaign group that covers the whole of the traditional boundaries of Somerset.

Join Somerset's own campaigning group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future. 

We help people to stand up for themselves.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Sunday, June 26, 2022

UPDATE (20/7/22): The Leveller Attacks Independents for Frome AND Wells Independents - In Just One Article - Why?

Independents For Frome Emblem
Registered with Electoral Commission

UPDATE (22/7/22)

Here is a link to our article showing the responses from Scott Ward of Independents for Frome and Denise Denis of Wells Independents.

And to confirm the number of councillors on Somerset County Council who will also be elected to the New Somerset Council, here they are:

Independent Councillors Won Just 3 of 110 Seats
(shown by the grey pie slice)
 

Total councillors 110, of which:

  • Independent 3
  • Labour 5
  • Green Party 5
  • Conservative 36
  • Liberal Democrat 61

After the local elections, the Leveller's Editor Andrew Lee chose to attack Independents for Frome and Wells Independents. We still do not have a reply from him, when we asked him why. And we have chased.

To say again, it was the editorial policy of The Leveller that Somerset's residents should have one unitary authority to replace all four districts and the county council. This editorial policy to support the unitary was clearly stated and done so repeatedly over time. 

And The Leveller's editorial policy to support the unitary was despite the fact that in 2007, 82% of residents who voted in the Referendum, voted AGAINST a unitary authority.

While the influence of The Leveller across the population of Somerset may be limited to certain types of Somerset resident, this was their editorial policy.

And it is clear that when the districts and county are scrapped in 2023, there will now be far fewer independent councillors in Somerset on the New Somerset Council (unitary authority).

---

UPDATE (6/7/22)

Somerset Independents has contacted The Leveller by email to offer a Right of Reply. No response has been received, so far. We have chased.

We have also contacted Scott Ward, who is a Registered Officer of the Independents for Frome political party. Mr Ward is also a Frome Town Councillor. There has so far been no response to our email and chasing email from Mr Ward, or from Steve Tanner, also a Frome Town Councillor and officer of the IFF political party. We have chased.

We have also contacted Denise Denis, Wells City Councillor for Wells Independents, using the email advertised on the Wells Independents website. So far, we have not received any response.

--- 

(26/6/22):

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We were formed to stand up for residents because the Westminster parties have let Somerset down, whether Lib Dems, Greens, Conservatives or Labour. As residents tell us, they are all the same.

We want to see better elected representatives on our councils and at Parliament - representatives who stand up for Somerset's towns and villages - instead of themselves or their political party.

Independent councillors and independent MPs are not perfect, but we think that is the way to go. They must be independent of big parties and listening to local people and acting for local people, with local people. 

We think that the First Past the Post election system also needs to go, in favour of the Single Transferable Vote (STV) as used by independents in the recent Australian Federal Election to the House of Representatives, equivalent to our House of Commons. STV is also used in elections in Scotland. But not in England and not for our councils or MPs here in Somerset.

So we were disappointed to read the latest issue of "The Leveller" where the newspaper attacks both Independents for Frome and Wells Independents. 

As we have made clear on this website and elsewhere, we are not formally connected to Independents for Frome (IFF) or Wells Independents. However, whenever we have dealt with one of their Frome Town councillors, Scott Ward, he has always responded and seems to have been straight with his answers. That is not always the case with other Frome councillors, especially those from the Westminster parties.

We include a photo of the Leveller article titled "Frome's journey from Democracy to Oligarchy".

 

The Leveller page 16 of the 15 June 2022 issue

In the article, The Leveller says: "Since 2015 all the councillors on Frome Town Council have signed up to IFF"...and then concluding..."having driven the politics out of local government, IFF will have driven the democracy out too". 

The Leveller also claims that Wells Independents "move closer to their goal of eliminating the politics from the council chamber". This is despite writing that Wells Council will have "nine Wells Independents, five LibDems and two Conservatives".

If there are deals being done by independents with the Westminster parties in either Frome or Wells, Somerset Independents has not been able to unearth much, if any evidence.

We have already published our evidence of the agreement between the Lib Dems and Greens in Mendip - the Leader of the Greens Shane Collins admitted it on the BBC shortly after the district elections when interviewed by David Garmston. Collins also praised Extinction Rebellion in the same programme. And the pattern of candidates in Mendip also suggests a deal was done between the Lib Dems and Greens. Following the elections, the official record shows that Green and Lib Dem councillors worked hand-in-glove on Mendip District Council.

There is no evidence that we have seen that there was any formal deal between IFF and the Westminster parties. If there is, we would like to see it.

Whilst we are disappointed in the attacks by The Leveller, we are not entirely surprised, based on our own dealings with the Editor of The Leveller, Andrew Lee. 

Years ago, in the days before Somerset Independents was registered as a political party, our now Leader Andrew Pope asked Mr Lee to add a section for independent councillors after the regular Labour, Tory (David Warburton, no less) and Lib Dem opinion sections in the paper. This seemed only fair as there were independent representatives at the time. It did not happen. Andrew had also asked for fairer coverage of independent candidates and councillors at the 2019 local elections. The reasons Mr Lee gave were less than convincing.

We still think that this slot should be offered in The Leveller, while there are independent councillors remaining. The number of independents will soon be decreasing.

As he says in the article, Mr Lee stood as an Independent candidate, and lost. This is what happens very often to independent candidates, because it is much harder to be elected without the big money and Westminster party machines.

There will be fewer independent councillors when the districts and county councils are scrapped next year. This was done against the wishes of the residents of Somerset, who voted in 2007 82% against such a change. Mr Lee questioned whether that Referendum was representative of current opinion. Somerset Independents campaigned unsuccessfully for a Yes/No Referendum - only a two or one unitary Referendum occurred - two buckets of manure, we said.

The Leveller's editorial policy, stated on multiple occasions, was to support a unitary authority and the scrapping of the districts and county.

It is a fact of political science under First Past The Post in the UK that the larger the electoral division, the more difficult it is for independents to win. Perhaps the Somerset Conservatives, Somerset Labour, Somerset Lib Dems and Somerset Greens - and their friends in high places at Westminster - already knew this and this meant their resistance to the enforced changes to our councils, was less than vigorous?

County Council elections and the election for the new council too, have more voters than district council elections, because they cover a wider geographical area. In turn, district council elections have more voters and a wider area than the smaller parish and town council elections.

Well, the recent 2022 County Council elections, which are also for the New Somerset Council when it is created in 2023, returned just three independent councillors out of 110 seats. 

The success of IFF and Wells Independents is at a smaller scale. But is still a success of independent councillors in elections.

Perhaps The Leveller would prefer that Independents for Frome and Wells Independents would also lose, as has been proven with just 3 in 110 being elected at the County, and then there would be even fewer independent representatives in Somerset?

We wonder what Independents for Frome and Wells Independents think of The Leveller's attack on them? We will be asking them.

Join Us!

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.