Showing posts with label Sandys Hill Lane. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sandys Hill Lane. Show all posts

Saturday, January 30, 2021

Saxonvale Frome - Mendip Councillors Ignore 258 Objections And Approve It!

Mendip Councillors Ignores Residents AGAIN

 

258 Written Objections were lodged to the dreadful and hated Saxonvale planning application.

Yet at Thursday's Planning Board, Mendip councillors ignored those 258 objections to somehow APPROVE the scheme.

In fact, they did worse than approve the scheme. They delegated to officers to finish it off, behind closed doors.

After the meeting, a member of the public told us, when commenting on our article on Mendip being reported in Private Eye:

"MDC Planning Board voted against allowing more voices to be heard last night at the Board meeting on the proposed Saxonvale development in Frome. Despite strong opposition from local bodies & residents the Planning Board gave approval for the current proposals."

Somerset Independents objected to the application, with Andrew Pope also speaking on behalf of Somerset Independents and all 258 objectors at the virtual meeting. Andrew mentioned that Mendip Council "love to do things behind closed doors". Some of Andrew's speech was reported by SomersetLive reporter Daniel Mumby on Twitter and in the article here.

None of the detail will be agreed in public. It will be done behind closed doors under so-called "reserved matters" and a "Section 106 Agreement". Mendip Council spends your money and does not listen to you. We've said it before and we say it again. The evidence is huge.

Responding to us, their legal officer even tried to infer openness and transparency by saying the agreement would be publicised. He did not mention that reserved matters and Section 106 Agreements are done by officers, not residents, and councillors are ignored by Mendip District Council. So it will all be done behind closed doors. We have an email from a Mendip council officer confirming that reserved matters do not involve consultation of the public.

Denise Wyatt also spoke at the meeting, to remind Mendip District Council that Somerset Independents has already, on several occasions, pointed out the failings of Mendip to listen to the public and to allow the public to have their say, and then for the Council to ACT on what the public tells them. Daniel Mumby also reported on what Denise said.

Denise Wyatt, Nominations Officer
and Expert on Council Governance

But of course, just like all the other times, they tried to ignore us. It doesn't work. And others, both locally and nationally, agree with us about Mendip's failings.

Since we pointed out Mendip's failings last year, now the Local Government Association (only now being consulted by the Chief Executive after the Council's Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Barry O'Leary and the previous Chief Finance (S151) Officer were humiliated by our investigations into Mendip's accounts), Ernst and Young, local residents worried about developments like Saxonvale, Easthill, Sandys Hill Lane, Selwood Gardens, Coleford, and now Private Eye magazine, have all pointed out the failings in Mendip District Council and its councillors.

Denise also reminded the 14 councillors on the Planning Board that it is a huge conflict of interest to allow Cabinet members who have already been doing deals behind closed doors with developers, to ALSO vote on the planning application. Yet she was ignored - 3 Cabinet members voted for Saxonvale.

Both Denise's and Andrew's speeches provoked responses from officers during the meeting, who made laughable defences of Mendip District Council. But as Andrew said in his speech, Mendip is already under investigation by Ernst and Young.

Yet Mendip councillors STILL ignored the 258 objections.

11 councillors on the Planning Board voted for the application. All of them were Liberal Democrat or Conservative councillors.

3 councillors on the Planning Board voted against approving the application. They were all Green councillors.

The two ward councillors spoke against the application. They are both Green too.

Andrew Pope says:

Andrew Pope,
Leader of Somerset Independents

 

"Like we say regularly, Lib Dem, Green or Tory, same old story.

They tried to tell everyone that the Planning Board is not party political. Yet they all voted with their political groups - WHAT A COINCIDENCE!

What opposition was there? The Green councillors were pathetic on the Planning Board. They don't know what they are doing, despite having been on there for nearly two years. And the two ward councillors were similarly weak.

When you have a campaigner for the legalisation of drugs as your Group Leader, Green Councillor Shane Collins, and there have been dodgy deals between the Lib Dems and Greens behind closed doors, it is perhaps unsurprising that the councillors are rubbish at providing opposition.

Somerset Independents has consistently spoken up for residents, and has done so again. These national party politicians from the Lib Dems, Tories or Greens cannot be relied upon to stand up for residents.

Because they don't even listen to residents in the first place! They ignore residents instead.

I spent a very long time and went through all of the objections and tried to represent them in the paltry three minutes that I was given by the Lib Dem Chair Damon Hooton, who interrupted me more than once. Other councillors also interrupted and tried to prevent me from speaking.

It was shameful that Mendip councillors did not take our advice, last year, to change the Constitution, to allow more time for public speaking. I asked Damon Hooton again, prior to the meeting, but the Chair claimed to not know that I was speaking. Can you believe it, because I don't?

 And then, when given the opportunity to vote on whether to allow more public speaking time, the councillors voted AGAINST doing so! What a shower!

Denise Wyatt, who is the Nominations Officer for Somerset Independents, says:

"Somerset Independents was formed to stand up for residents. Our profile is growing and we are helping residents in Frome, and also in other parts of Somerset. We've already won campaigns with residents and we will continue to grow throughout 2021. Join us to fight back against the national political parties who put themselves and their party ahead of residents."

Putting Residents First


Wednesday, January 20, 2021

Sandys Hill Lane Frome - Private Eye Reports On Mendip District Council

Cutting from Private Eye
taken from Frome Facebook Group

UPDATE (30/1/21): Saxonvale has now been approved by Mendip councillors despite huge objections, and only after Sandys Hill Lane had already been approved. As we said before, it's an interesting sequence of events, especially in the light of the conflicts of interests that both we, and Private Eye, have exposed.

---

Last year, Somerset Independents worked with local residents to oppose the proposal to develop housing near Sandys Hill Lane in Frome. 

Sandys Hill Lane is a single track road that is not suitable for large vehicles. It runs downhill from the Frome McDonald's that is regularly causing road traffic tailbacks. Opposite the McDonald's is Sainsbury's, Pizza Hut and KFC. As residents have noticed, it is also where Avon and Somerset Police park their vehicles.

Sandys Hill Lane, Frome

The Planning Notice
at Sandys Hill Lane

Our investigations and reports were published after the Planning Board at Mendip District Council shamefully approved the scheme in a grubby meeting that we reported here. 

As you can see in the photo, the proposal is a departure from the local plan. It is also not mentioned in the Frome Neighbourhood Plan, approved by a Referendum of residents in 2016. Yet when challenged by Somerset Independents, Frome Town Council had not objected and claimed that policies in the Neighbourhood Plan were relevant.

Land in the proposal is owned by Conservative Councillor Philip Ham. The first appearance at the Planning Board led to the issue being deferred to another meeting, because the plans were not clear enough. An administrative error meant it had already been delayed, because those who were supposed to be consulted, were not consulted by Mendip District Council. Anyone would think this was being rushed through, while the brownfield site at Saxonvale remains derelict (UPDATE 30/1/21: now approved for development, but what will actually happen?).

Now the national investigative newspaper Private Eye has reported on Philip Ham. They note the impact on local roads and the ownership of land by Councillor Ham. Private Eye's piece says, and we quote it here in full:

"Like the rest of the country, Somerset is under pressure to build more homes. In delightful Frome, a scheme for 235 houses, a commercial development and a "drive-thru" was recently approved by Mendip district council despite concerns over its impact on local roads. One of the applicants behind the scheme is Mendip councillor Philip Ham, a local farmer who owns part of the land where the large development will be built. 

While backing his own Frome plan, Ham was busy opposing - and winning the fight against - a proposal for 63 houses outside the village of Coleford. Why the sudden aversion to development? The new homes would have been in the Mendip district council ward of Coleford and Holecombe, represented by one Cllr Ham. The development is strongly opposed by the parish council, chaired by Cllr Ham. And local residents, including Cllr Ham, who lives nearby, also cited concern for its impact on ... local roads.

PS: Any local wishing to further examine Ham's role in the Frome development could contact the chair of Mendip's scrutiny board: er, Cllr Ham."

Cllr Ham has since resigned as Chair of the scrutiny board, citing a "ludicrous" lack of transparency over property dealing in Easthill, Frome.

One Frome resident told us:

"I'm sure you couldn't make this stuff up, even after a long night in (the pub)!!"

We are not making it up. It's very real and serious.

We are not amused.

These are very serious conflicts of interest, that have not been managed. We have argued that Mendip District Council is letting these conflicts of interest go unchecked, and Private Eye have noticed it too. 

When our members have spoken at the Planning Board meeting and written to Mendip District councillors to ask them to better manage the conflicts of interest, councillors have not acted to do so. They tried to ignore us, with the Leader of the Council Ros Wyke trying to brush us off and telling us that our concerns over Mendip's governance had been "noted".

Somerset Independents does not take no for an answer.

We continued our campaign to stand up for Frome residents, and for Mendip residents as a whole. And to expose Mendip District Council for its shoddiness and grubbiness in spending YOUR money and affecting YOUR lives.

We flagged a whole range of dodgy practises in a formal Objection to the Mendip District Council accounts, following detailed and lengthy questioning of Council officers including the interim Chief Financial (Section 151) Officer, Richard Bates. The former S151 Officer Paul Deal left suddenly last year.

Ernst and Young, Mendip's external auditors, are now investigating Mendip District Council. More information is available on other articles on this website, including this one. It is due to report back to Mendip's Audit Committee later this month.

We work with Somerset residents to hold Mendip District Council's Lib Dems, who are supposed to be in control, to account. 

The Lib Dems replaced the Tories that came before them. But as author of the "Flatpack Democracy" book, Peter Macfadyen, told us recently as part of our campaigning with the Frome Easthill campaigners, it seems that Mendip is still being run in the same way as the Tories, but by the Lib Dems.

Lib Dem or Tory, same old story? It seems that when we say this phrase, we are spot on, once again. 

What's the point of voting in Lib Dems when you get a plastic, yellow Tory and no change? It's the same in South Somerset District Council and Somerset West and Taunton Council. 

And the "opposition" to the Tories on Somerset County Council is pathetic. Robin Head, local National Education Union rep told our Leader Andrew Pope recently that the Lib Dem councillors are still tainted by their Coalition with the Tories by Nick Clegg and David Cameron.

Mr Head is right. We will continue to work with Somerset residents to expose the failings of Somerset councils and Lib Dem or Tory councillors.


Somerset Lib Dems
Lib Dem or Tory, Same Old Story