Showing posts with label Campaign. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Campaign. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 7, 2021

CAMPAIGN: VICTORY for a Referendum on How YOU Are Governed

 

Leader of Somerset Independents
Andrew Pope
 

"First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win." (earliest quote by Nicholas Klein, Amalgamated Clothing Workers of America - often attributed to Indian Independence Leader Mahatma Gandhi)

Somerset Independents was formed in 2020 to stand up for residents. We have done exactly that.

We had to, because those who are elected to stand up for you, did not.

Instead of listening to residents' views, Somerset's councillors tried to ignore us. They probably laughed at us behind our backs. They tried to fight us.

Now we've won.

As reported by Mendip District Council, all four district councils will be proposing a Referendum next week on how YOU are governed and how Somerset's councils are run and how they spend OUR money.

Liberal Democrat, Tory, Green and Labour and fake independent councillors in Somerset district and county councils tried to ignore us. Both of these deeply flawed proposals were supported by a majority of councillors on those councils.

The County Council Leader, Tory Councillor David Fothergill and his corrupt Minister friend, Cabinet Minister Robert Jenrick tried to ignore us.

Even the Prime Minister Boris Johnson tried to ignore us, telling Parliament that a "consultation" was enough, in response to a suggestion of a Referendum from Conservative MP Ian Liddell-Grainger. A sham consultation isn't enough.

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope responds to the news of the Referendum:

"We were right to campaign for this Referendum. But councillors, MPs and even the Prime Minister have tried to ignore us!

We said repeatedly that only a Referendum will do.

Yet this promise of a Referendum from the districts is not enough.

They are proposing a Referendum, but only between two terrible options.

There is not a "no change" option. There is not a "not now" option during the Coronavirus Pandemic.

They propose to only offer a Hobson's Choice.

A Hobson's Choice between the "One Somerset" proposal suggested by the Tories on the County Council and the "Stronger Somerset" option proposed by the Tories and Lib Dems on the four district councils.

And they need to allow adequate time for them to try to make the case, because based on the last poll in 2007, 82% of residents said a very firm "NO".

But of course, they want to try to railroad residents into a rushed decision. 

Residents deserve better than these robbers of democracy."

Somerset Independents Officer Denise Wyatt says:

Denise Wyatt
Co-Founder of Somerset Independents
And Campaigner For A Referendum

"At last, the district councils are doing what we asked them to do - to give you a choice.

They they have finally taken our suggestion of a Referendum.

A suggestion which we campaigned hard for.

This should not be happening during a National Emergency.

But at last, they have listened.

Why didn't these Lib Dems, Tories, Greens and Labour councillors do it last year, when we first campaigned for it? 

Why did us volunteers have to do it?

Because they are party politicians and they do not stand up for residents - ONLY WHEN MADE TO, do they do it. It's totally wrong.

But we are glad to have got this result.

More needs to be done to give all the options that residents deserve.

We will campaign for that now."

Somerset Independents will continue to provide the leadership that those elected cannot provide.

The Lib Dems, Greens, Tory and Labour councillors are followers, not leaders.

Somerset Independents will continue to stand up for residents and to fight to retain and improve our democratic rights.

Standing Up For You




Saturday, January 30, 2021

Saxonvale Frome - Mendip Councillors Ignore 258 Objections And Approve It!

Mendip Councillors Ignores Residents AGAIN

 

258 Written Objections were lodged to the dreadful and hated Saxonvale planning application.

Yet at Thursday's Planning Board, Mendip councillors ignored those 258 objections to somehow APPROVE the scheme.

In fact, they did worse than approve the scheme. They delegated to officers to finish it off, behind closed doors.

After the meeting, a member of the public told us, when commenting on our article on Mendip being reported in Private Eye:

"MDC Planning Board voted against allowing more voices to be heard last night at the Board meeting on the proposed Saxonvale development in Frome. Despite strong opposition from local bodies & residents the Planning Board gave approval for the current proposals."

Somerset Independents objected to the application, with Andrew Pope also speaking on behalf of Somerset Independents and all 258 objectors at the virtual meeting. Andrew mentioned that Mendip Council "love to do things behind closed doors". Some of Andrew's speech was reported by SomersetLive reporter Daniel Mumby on Twitter and in the article here.

None of the detail will be agreed in public. It will be done behind closed doors under so-called "reserved matters" and a "Section 106 Agreement". Mendip Council spends your money and does not listen to you. We've said it before and we say it again. The evidence is huge.

Responding to us, their legal officer even tried to infer openness and transparency by saying the agreement would be publicised. He did not mention that reserved matters and Section 106 Agreements are done by officers, not residents, and councillors are ignored by Mendip District Council. So it will all be done behind closed doors. We have an email from a Mendip council officer confirming that reserved matters do not involve consultation of the public.

Denise Wyatt also spoke at the meeting, to remind Mendip District Council that Somerset Independents has already, on several occasions, pointed out the failings of Mendip to listen to the public and to allow the public to have their say, and then for the Council to ACT on what the public tells them. Daniel Mumby also reported on what Denise said.

Denise Wyatt, Nominations Officer
and Expert on Council Governance

But of course, just like all the other times, they tried to ignore us. It doesn't work. And others, both locally and nationally, agree with us about Mendip's failings.

Since we pointed out Mendip's failings last year, now the Local Government Association (only now being consulted by the Chief Executive after the Council's Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Barry O'Leary and the previous Chief Finance (S151) Officer were humiliated by our investigations into Mendip's accounts), Ernst and Young, local residents worried about developments like Saxonvale, Easthill, Sandys Hill Lane, Selwood Gardens, Coleford, and now Private Eye magazine, have all pointed out the failings in Mendip District Council and its councillors.

Denise also reminded the 14 councillors on the Planning Board that it is a huge conflict of interest to allow Cabinet members who have already been doing deals behind closed doors with developers, to ALSO vote on the planning application. Yet she was ignored - 3 Cabinet members voted for Saxonvale.

Both Denise's and Andrew's speeches provoked responses from officers during the meeting, who made laughable defences of Mendip District Council. But as Andrew said in his speech, Mendip is already under investigation by Ernst and Young.

Yet Mendip councillors STILL ignored the 258 objections.

11 councillors on the Planning Board voted for the application. All of them were Liberal Democrat or Conservative councillors.

3 councillors on the Planning Board voted against approving the application. They were all Green councillors.

The two ward councillors spoke against the application. They are both Green too.

Andrew Pope says:

Andrew Pope,
Leader of Somerset Independents

 

"Like we say regularly, Lib Dem, Green or Tory, same old story.

They tried to tell everyone that the Planning Board is not party political. Yet they all voted with their political groups - WHAT A COINCIDENCE!

What opposition was there? The Green councillors were pathetic on the Planning Board. They don't know what they are doing, despite having been on there for nearly two years. And the two ward councillors were similarly weak.

When you have a campaigner for the legalisation of drugs as your Group Leader, Green Councillor Shane Collins, and there have been dodgy deals between the Lib Dems and Greens behind closed doors, it is perhaps unsurprising that the councillors are rubbish at providing opposition.

Somerset Independents has consistently spoken up for residents, and has done so again. These national party politicians from the Lib Dems, Tories or Greens cannot be relied upon to stand up for residents.

Because they don't even listen to residents in the first place! They ignore residents instead.

I spent a very long time and went through all of the objections and tried to represent them in the paltry three minutes that I was given by the Lib Dem Chair Damon Hooton, who interrupted me more than once. Other councillors also interrupted and tried to prevent me from speaking.

It was shameful that Mendip councillors did not take our advice, last year, to change the Constitution, to allow more time for public speaking. I asked Damon Hooton again, prior to the meeting, but the Chair claimed to not know that I was speaking. Can you believe it, because I don't?

 And then, when given the opportunity to vote on whether to allow more public speaking time, the councillors voted AGAINST doing so! What a shower!

Denise Wyatt, who is the Nominations Officer for Somerset Independents, says:

"Somerset Independents was formed to stand up for residents. Our profile is growing and we are helping residents in Frome, and also in other parts of Somerset. We've already won campaigns with residents and we will continue to grow throughout 2021. Join us to fight back against the national political parties who put themselves and their party ahead of residents."

Putting Residents First


Wednesday, January 20, 2021

Sandys Hill Lane Frome - Private Eye Reports On Mendip District Council

Cutting from Private Eye
taken from Frome Facebook Group

UPDATE (30/1/21): Saxonvale has now been approved by Mendip councillors despite huge objections, and only after Sandys Hill Lane had already been approved. As we said before, it's an interesting sequence of events, especially in the light of the conflicts of interests that both we, and Private Eye, have exposed.

---

Last year, Somerset Independents worked with local residents to oppose the proposal to develop housing near Sandys Hill Lane in Frome. 

Sandys Hill Lane is a single track road that is not suitable for large vehicles. It runs downhill from the Frome McDonald's that is regularly causing road traffic tailbacks. Opposite the McDonald's is Sainsbury's, Pizza Hut and KFC. As residents have noticed, it is also where Avon and Somerset Police park their vehicles.

Sandys Hill Lane, Frome

The Planning Notice
at Sandys Hill Lane

Our investigations and reports were published after the Planning Board at Mendip District Council shamefully approved the scheme in a grubby meeting that we reported here. 

As you can see in the photo, the proposal is a departure from the local plan. It is also not mentioned in the Frome Neighbourhood Plan, approved by a Referendum of residents in 2016. Yet when challenged by Somerset Independents, Frome Town Council had not objected and claimed that policies in the Neighbourhood Plan were relevant.

Land in the proposal is owned by Conservative Councillor Philip Ham. The first appearance at the Planning Board led to the issue being deferred to another meeting, because the plans were not clear enough. An administrative error meant it had already been delayed, because those who were supposed to be consulted, were not consulted by Mendip District Council. Anyone would think this was being rushed through, while the brownfield site at Saxonvale remains derelict (UPDATE 30/1/21: now approved for development, but what will actually happen?).

Now the national investigative newspaper Private Eye has reported on Philip Ham. They note the impact on local roads and the ownership of land by Councillor Ham. Private Eye's piece says, and we quote it here in full:

"Like the rest of the country, Somerset is under pressure to build more homes. In delightful Frome, a scheme for 235 houses, a commercial development and a "drive-thru" was recently approved by Mendip district council despite concerns over its impact on local roads. One of the applicants behind the scheme is Mendip councillor Philip Ham, a local farmer who owns part of the land where the large development will be built. 

While backing his own Frome plan, Ham was busy opposing - and winning the fight against - a proposal for 63 houses outside the village of Coleford. Why the sudden aversion to development? The new homes would have been in the Mendip district council ward of Coleford and Holecombe, represented by one Cllr Ham. The development is strongly opposed by the parish council, chaired by Cllr Ham. And local residents, including Cllr Ham, who lives nearby, also cited concern for its impact on ... local roads.

PS: Any local wishing to further examine Ham's role in the Frome development could contact the chair of Mendip's scrutiny board: er, Cllr Ham."

Cllr Ham has since resigned as Chair of the scrutiny board, citing a "ludicrous" lack of transparency over property dealing in Easthill, Frome.

One Frome resident told us:

"I'm sure you couldn't make this stuff up, even after a long night in (the pub)!!"

We are not making it up. It's very real and serious.

We are not amused.

These are very serious conflicts of interest, that have not been managed. We have argued that Mendip District Council is letting these conflicts of interest go unchecked, and Private Eye have noticed it too. 

When our members have spoken at the Planning Board meeting and written to Mendip District councillors to ask them to better manage the conflicts of interest, councillors have not acted to do so. They tried to ignore us, with the Leader of the Council Ros Wyke trying to brush us off and telling us that our concerns over Mendip's governance had been "noted".

Somerset Independents does not take no for an answer.

We continued our campaign to stand up for Frome residents, and for Mendip residents as a whole. And to expose Mendip District Council for its shoddiness and grubbiness in spending YOUR money and affecting YOUR lives.

We flagged a whole range of dodgy practises in a formal Objection to the Mendip District Council accounts, following detailed and lengthy questioning of Council officers including the interim Chief Financial (Section 151) Officer, Richard Bates. The former S151 Officer Paul Deal left suddenly last year.

Ernst and Young, Mendip's external auditors, are now investigating Mendip District Council. More information is available on other articles on this website, including this one. It is due to report back to Mendip's Audit Committee later this month.

We work with Somerset residents to hold Mendip District Council's Lib Dems, who are supposed to be in control, to account. 

The Lib Dems replaced the Tories that came before them. But as author of the "Flatpack Democracy" book, Peter Macfadyen, told us recently as part of our campaigning with the Frome Easthill campaigners, it seems that Mendip is still being run in the same way as the Tories, but by the Lib Dems.

Lib Dem or Tory, same old story? It seems that when we say this phrase, we are spot on, once again. 

What's the point of voting in Lib Dems when you get a plastic, yellow Tory and no change? It's the same in South Somerset District Council and Somerset West and Taunton Council. 

And the "opposition" to the Tories on Somerset County Council is pathetic. Robin Head, local National Education Union rep told our Leader Andrew Pope recently that the Lib Dem councillors are still tainted by their Coalition with the Tories by Nick Clegg and David Cameron.

Mr Head is right. We will continue to work with Somerset residents to expose the failings of Somerset councils and Lib Dem or Tory councillors.


Somerset Lib Dems
Lib Dem or Tory, Same Old Story


Tuesday, January 5, 2021

CAMPAIGN: When Will All of Somerset Get Superfast or Even DECENT Broadband?

 

Standing up for residents
and businesses

Somerset Independents is campaigning for better broadband for Somerset residents. Why?

Because our residents and our businesses deserve it. And despite broken promise after broken promise by the County Council and Government, Somerset still suffers from poor broadband in too many areas. Their latest promise in late December, is likely to end in more disappointment.

Never mind superfast broadband*, too many households suffer from not even having decent broadband**!

Figures published by the House of Commons Library prove it. They are based on the data provided by OFCOM, the Regulator for communication.

For example, the figures below show how terrible the lack of decent broadband is in the Constituency of Somerton and Frome, currently represented in Parliament by Conservative MP David Warburton.

According to those figures:

  • The average download speed was 42.8 Mbps (Mega bits per second) in Somerton and Frome, just less than 25% slower than for the South West of England as a whole. It is 30% slower than the average download speed for the whole of the UK.
  • Superfast broadband was available for only 81.5% of Somerset's premises, lower than 91.9% for the South West and 94.8% for the UK. Put another way, 18.5% of households do not have superfast broadband connectivity.
  • Just under 10% (9.4%) of premises cannot get decent broadband. This is three times as many as just 3.1% for the South West and five times as bad as for the UK.

When the averages are broken down into smaller areas within the Constituency, it is even worse. 

Plotted on a map, you can see vast areas with terrible broadband. About the only area that is OK is the northern part of Frome, an urban area.

Mr Warburton has made statements in Parliament and on his website about his "concern" on the failure to deliver.

But he does not need to look far for who has failed to deliver.

It is his own Conservative Party's failure to deliver broadband in Somerset. They've been in power at the County Council for years.

And it is his own Conservative Party's Government's failure to deliver. They've been in power for a decade, since 2010.

His Party's failures might explain why Mr Warburton appears to have done little about it. 

As noted by the Parliament-watching website, TheyWorkForYou.com, Mr Warburton only sometimes differs from his Party and only occasionally rebels against the Conservative Party. And as also shown there, and as found by our own research, Mr Warburton hardly spoke in Parliament in 2020, with very long gaps of months between appearances. 

Even so, speaking in Parliament is just words. Somerset Independents prefers to see ACTION, not just words from Somerset's elected representatives.

Let's not forget, Mr Warburton is one of several Somerset Tory MPs who tried to defend the indefensible on Free School Meals - his Government's failure to sign up for it - and then his humiliation when they were forced to u-turn.

So he is likely to not provide much in the way of exposure of his Government's, and his County Council's failures.

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope, says:

"I live in a rural area. My broadband is provided via copper wires that run on telegraph poles running to an exchange miles away. We are at the end of the line and the broadband is only ADSL. I need decent broadband to run my online business from home. And if my business is to expand, I need superfast broadband.

BT Openreach is so bad that when our line was struck by lightning and the shock came into our house, they failed to investigate what happened, or to visit our property to check the safety.

In fact, it was impossible to get them to give any meaningful response to our concerns. We were told to phone India. The call handlers had no idea about our area and they ignored our problem. We even took it the Ombudsman, who were useless.

So we switched provider. But that has not changed the terrible infrastructure that is so out-of-date.

We had a public meeting at our village hall, with Truespeed giving us empty promises. It was only if we signed up, and if all other villages signed up between us and where Truespeed have their cables already installed. We have no idea when, or if, it will be provided by them, by land. Now the County Council have named them as a new partner. But it is likely that they will fail to deliver, as the others before them, did.

So I am supporting the Voneus satellite broadband that is being rolled out in rural areas. The latest application that I am aware of is in Pilton. I have supported their planning application, because I believe that Voneus have tried their utmost to minimise the visual impact, rejecting sites due to genuine concerns from local residents.

The history of the Mendip Hills shows that, if you cannot go under, you have to go over. But specious and fake objections to technology, such as happened with some people and vested interests when the trains were installed through the Hills two centuries ago - cannot stop genuine progress. Populism cannot stop genuine progress for society as a whole.

 

Somerset Fib Dems Fibbing About 5G

But Liberal Democrat councillors in Somerset like Councillor Liz Leyshon and Lib Dem Bath MP Wera Hobhouse have even used pseudo-science to oppose 5G, just like the Conservative Government has with Covid-19, to justify their populist vote grabbing. To object to masts for visual impact reasons is one thing, but to speak at meeting after meeting in a Luddite way to oppose technology to catch votes, is another.

Somerset Independents will be supporting the rollout of technology that helps residents and businesses survive and hopefully thrive."


* Superfast broadband is defined by OFCOM as "The percentage of lines that were capable of receiving download speeds of at least 30 Mbps in May 2020".

** Decent broadband is defined by OFCOMS as "Premises below the Universal Service Obligation - those unable to receive 10 Mbps download speed or 1 Mbps upload speed".

Friday, November 13, 2020

Independents across England Raise Alarm on "Stalinist" Government Trojan Horse

 

England's Green and Pleasant Land
UNDER THREAT

 

Denise Wyatt, Planning Spokesperson for Somerset Independents says:

Denise Wyatt

"The Conservative Government has put forward a Planning White Paper. What this means is that they want to change how planning works in England. The proposals look disastrous, and are a blatant Stalinist attack on residents' democratic rights under the Trojan Horse of promoting those very same rights.

Our friends in Lincolnshire at Lincolnshire Independents have submitted their response and published it on their website. 

Somerset Independents is now publishing its response, submitted before the deadline two weeks ago. It includes our promotion of MORE, not LESS democracy, including the right of appeal for residents on planning applications, I have long thought that it is wrong that developers have this right but residents do not.

We have no doubt that other independent groups share our concerns. Whilst all independents will not agree on every aspect, there is a great amount of common ground, and the excellent Lincolnshire response covers that common ground.

Will the Tory Government listen? I doubt it, but it is worth a try!

Let us know what you think of our response by contacting us."


"Response to Planning White Paper Consultation from Somerset Independents

29th October 2020


This Planning White Paper is a Trojan Horse for development without local democracy and without local accountability. It is a cynical ploy to exploit Covid-19 and to blindside the public. It must be scrapped without delay. If it is not, then the public will know that this Government wants to centralise decision-making in a Stalinist coup.


This Planning White Paper is a manifesto for development and developers that claims that more of the public will be involved in the planning process. Yet more public involvement is a pretence of this Planning White Paper. The White Paper is a smokescreen for dishing out contracts to PropTech and GIS firms (p.26 et al) that have already failed to provide mapping systems for the public to be able to participate in the planning process.


The current local plan process does not involve the public. There is more than enough evidence here in Somerset. Putting more emphasis on the local plan part, and less emphasis on the individual applications, would exclude even more people than is the case now. It is unacceptable already.


Somerset Independents agree with our colleagues in Lincolnshire Independents that house-building targets are too high to protect our environment and too high to tackle climate change. Such high targets already mean that the local plans are regularly ignored or sidelined by the councils, because the pressure is too much. And these targets being “nationally-determined, binding” (p.23) is wrong. They should be locally-determined in a democracy. The proposals smack of the Soviet Union, not the UK. Yet this Government seems to enjoy promoting its autocratic and centralising tendencies (we reference Lady Hale’s recent comments on this) that have failed our country on Brexit, on the Supreme Court judgement on suspending Parliament, and on Covid-19. It should not make the same mistakes with the planning system.


The problems that already exist with the current planning system that exclude over 90% of residents would be exacerbated by this Planning White Paper. Power must not be taken away from local residents. They need to be given more power. But this Planning White Paper does not do that. Instead, it pretends that “going digital” will magically fix this, but the same people will continue to be involved and the very large majority will continue to be ignored or excluded.


The claim in the White Paper that it is the planning system that puts “delay” in, is just nonsense. The current involvement of the public is appropriate and time deadlines are appropriate (8 or 13 weeks) but public participation needs to be increased, not decreased as proposed in this anti-democratic White Paper. The vast majority of applications are approved without committee and without public participation. If anything, the number with public participation needs to be increased, with more involvement of the public, not increased. Yet this White Paper excludes the public more.


Site notices, notices in newspapers and notifications of local residents need to be expanded at the application stage, because public participation is already not enough. Any new digital methods of involvement need to be done as well as the existing arrangements, not instead of (p.24). How many times have residents complained that they were not told about a development? This is the normal feeling in the current system. We have had to fill in for the failing planning process, in order to involve the public but such public participation should be part of the system, not an adjunct to it.


Any involvement of the public must now allow for virtual meetings in the planning process (p.24). With safeguards on thresholds, any change to the planning system must now also allow for groups of residents to send applications to the Planning Inspectorate as an appeal. This would make the system fairer than it is now, with only applicants being able to appeal.


The centralising tendency of this Government is clear again (p.24) when it says “The Infrastructure Levy will be more transparent than Section 106, and local communities will have more control over how it is spent.” Yet it is not clear how a nationally-determined Levy, which appears to be suggested in the White Paper, can be locally-decided.


Again, we agree with our colleagues in Lincolnshire Independents that “the Government’s squeeze on local councils now extends to centralising planning in a framework where local decision-making could become a thing of the past and leave local residents without a proper voice on applications”. This is why we have described this Planning White Paper as “Stalinist”. It would suit the Soviet Union command economy, instead of a democracy where local residents are listened to and their concerns acted upon.


On the environment, on food security and on climate change, brownfield sites plus wildlife corridors plus agricultural sites must be prioritised. Already in the current system, they are not. And this White Paper does not address this.


For example, Mendip District Council has approved the Sandys Hill Lane development in Frome on farm land, but still the Saxonvale brownfield site remainsderelict. There are many other examples of divergence from the local plan. So this White Paper, by excluding even more of the public from the entire process, would make this problem even worse, when it should be ensuring that it is made better.


Conflicts of interest amongst councillors are not managed in the current system. Somerset Independents has made representations to the LGA on their consultation on Councillors Code of Conduct. And developments that local residents do not want, are given the go-ahead by councillors that are closely linked with developers. Is this what the Government wants? If this White Paper goes ahead, it will confirm that the Government does want an anti-democratic system to be promoted and made worse.


This Planning White Paper is a Trojan Horse for development without local democracy and without local accountability. It is a cynical ploy to exploit Covid-19 and to blindside the public from what they entitled to – greater involvement in their local area and local democracy.


For the above reasons, now is not the time to be changing the planning system. This Stalinist Planning White Paper should be scrapped and more democratic alternatives that address the real issues brought forward instead."





VICTORY (19/12/20): Easthill Frome PAUSED: Mendip Lib Dems In Another Dodgy and Rushed Deal

Easthill, Frome


VICTORY UPDATE (19/12/20): The Liberal Democrats have been forced into a humiliating u-turn and have stopped the sale of Easthill - for now.

This is due to the pressure from Somerset Independents advising the local campaigners.

It is the second victory for Somerset residents that we are advising.

But it is only a temporary reprieve.

Denise Wyatt says:

"It is another example of the farcical Liberal Democrat Administration of Mendip District Council. They should never have agreed the sale in the first place. They were hoping to sneak it through, but we worked with local residents to stop it. We will be watching them very closely."

---

The Liberal Democrat-run Mendip District Council recently made a decision behind-closed-doors, to sell land at Easthill in Frome. Local residents are shocked and surprised by this decision, yet at the Full Council Meeting on 9th November, Lib Dem Council Leader Ros Wyke claimed that the decision was "open"!  

 

Mendip Lib Dems
Mis-using YOUR Money

This is despite local residents speaking at the meeting to prove that the decision was far from open, and making clear their anger and distress at the development.

Local resident Ba Pardhy spoke at the meeting. She told Somerset Independents:

"Mendip District Council wants to build on Easthill Field between the Cemetery and Easthill/Styles Park boundaries.

What does the Council think it is doing?

This is the Council that, in 2019, declared a 'Climate and Ecological Emergency'.  Now the Council is going to build on a habitat with bats, dormice, slow worms, owls, birds, amphibians, endangered species and numerous beneficial insects.

What the Council says and what the Council do are two different things.

Mendip Council is not listening and this development must be stopped."

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope spoke in support of the local residents, pointing out that the decision was not open or transparent and that Mendip District Council does not uphold the Nolan Principles of openness or transparency. His speech is here.

Denise Wyatt, Somerset Independents County Council Candidate for Frome, says:

Denise Wyatt
 

"What took Mendip District Council so long? They've had two years! Why the secrecy? Residents contacted Somerset Independents for our help. This rushed and hidden scheme should have been proposed a year ago, and residents properly listened to, with their concerns acted upon.

Instead, it's being rushed through by Lib Dem councillors amid false claims of building "council housing". It isn't. These won't be council-owned. Mendip Council is selling land for social housing that it should not be selling, behind-closed-doors and in a rushed way.

Somerset Independents has triggered an investigation by the Council's External Auditors, Ernst and Young. The Auditors are asking more questions about the Council's openness and transparency in property investment. Money from the sale of this land might be used for commercial property investment, a highly controversial and risky Mendip Council policy that needs to be stopped. Millions are at risk.

Cabinet members that made the decision to sell behind-closed-doors at Cabinet, also sit on the Planning Board. How can anybody believe that they won't approve this, when they have already approved the sale of the land, and the funding from Government runs out very soon!

Somerset Independents stands with local residents and local wildlife to protect them from this dreadful dodgy deal."

Standing Up For Residents

Saturday, October 10, 2020

CAMPAIGN: Does Your Councillor Have a Criminal Background?

 


Would you like to know?

 

For months, Somerset Independents has been campaigning for ALL Somerset councillors to be checked against criminal records. These used to be called "CRB" checks and are now called "DBS Checks", as explained in our previous articles.

 

Two months ago back in August, we asked all four Somerset district councils whether they checked their councillors. We also asked Somerset County Council. The Leveller newspaper also asked questions in its September edition (see photo).


The Leveller Article 15 Sept 2020

The lack of quick replies from most of the councils was concerning. You would think that they had given this issue due consideration, wouldn't you, and answers would be at their fingertips? But they hadn't. And the answers were not forthcoming.

 

But when we actually got the answers, they were extremely concerning. They confirmed what we had suspected - that most councils in Somerset do not check on their councillors!

 

Three of the district councils are now Lib-Dem controlled. One (Sedgemoor) is Tory-controlled. The Tories also control the County.

 

The Results Are In!


Somerset West and Taunton Council

Two months after we had asked, Lib-Dem controlled Somerset West and Taunton Council STILL HAD NOT ANSWERED! When they did finally answer, after us having to chase them, they confirmed that they DID NOT check on councillors. They promised us a response in 20 days but it took three times as long. Do you think this is right?

Mendip District Council

Lib-Dem controlled Mendip District Council answered quickly. BUT they confirmed that they DID NOT carry out any criminal records checks for any of their councillors. And even more disturbingly, it was Mendip councillors THEMSELVES that had REPEATEDLY refused to bring in checks! Officers at the Council had brought it up on the agenda of more than one meeting, for councillors to decide. And time and again, those same councillors decided to not subject themselves to checks. Do you think this is right?

South Somerset District Council

Lib-Dem controlled South Somerset District Council confirmed that they also DID NOT check on councillors. Let's not forget that former Lib-Dem Leader of this Council Ric Pallister is to face trial for a large number of alleged criminal offences. He is innocent until proven guilty of course. We asked this Council extra questions, but subject to the outcome of the trial, we will not be publishing any answers relating to Mr Pallister for now. Do you think this is right, especially given the gravity of the situation?

Sedgemoor District Council

Tory-controlled Sedgemoor District Council confirmed that it DID perform checks on councillors. This is the only district council of the four Somerset districts. BUT the reasons they gave were odd and related to IT systems.

Somerset County Council

Somerset County Council confirmed that they DID carry out checks on councillors, with extra checks for some roles.  

 

Somerset Independents Spokesperson on Safeguarding, Denise Wyatt, says:

 

Denise Wyatt

"We applaud Somerset County Council for doing the criminal records checks. We ask all district councils to follow their lead.

Why aren't the districts doing it? How can they justify this? 

Why are there so many inconsistencies? Because the councils are not required by law to check on councillors.

The reasons given by the councils are not only wrong morally and in terms of safeguarding, these councils are showing clear ignorance of the facts and of the law."

 

Somerset Independents Leader Andrew Pope, says:

Andrew Pope

"If Somerset's district councils are not allowed to make DBS checks as they told us, why is it that other districts outside Somerset are doing the checks, then? Are Somerset district councils subject to different laws than others in England? No.

Cost should not come into it. What some councils do is take the fee for the DBS checks from the councillors allowances. It is a small price to pay for councillors to protect themselves and others.

Do you think that the councils should check on councillors? Please let us know your views, yes or no and why.

Join us to campaign for better councillors and better councils.

To get updates, Like our Facebook page at Somerset Independents, follow our Twitter @SomerInds and email us at somerinds [at] gmail.com ."

  

Protecting Residents

 

Thursday, September 10, 2020

CAMPAIGN: Modern Committee System - Somerset Independents' Democratic Alternative

 

Standing Up For Democracy

UPDATE (14th April 2021): Now that the district councils have finally agreed to our campaign of a Referendum on the future of the councils in Somerset, we are campaigning for whatever comes next to Somerset to be a Modern Committee System (MCS). 

An MCS has been proposed for years in Sheffield by our inspirational friends in the "It's Our City" campaigners in Sheffield. It is now being proposed in a Referendum in Sheffield. More details are here on the Sheffield City Council website. 

Somerset Independents says that any Referendum in Somerset must include a no change option and this MCS option. 

Over the next two days, we will ask all four district councils to change the Referendum to include an MCS. We will also ask them to do the Referendum when it is safe to do so, and when it allows a proper campaign to be done, so that the public can make an informed decision:

  • Sedgemoor District Council today, with Denise Wyatt speaking at Full Council at 2.30pm today
  • South Somerset District Council tomorrow morning at their Cabinet meeting, with Andrew Pope speaking. The Full Council meeting clashes with the Mendip one, so Andrew has asked for his speech to be read out at the Full Council.
  • Somerset West and Taunton District Council tomorrow afternoon at 4pm, with Denise Wyatt speaking there - except they do not seem to want to allow her to speak, unlike the other districts - so her speech will be read out by an officer
  • Mendip District Council at 6.30pm tomorrow evening

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says today:

Andrew Pope

"We at Somerset Independents tried to get the district and county councils to properly listen to Somerset's residents. But they did not want to listen. So now we think they should be abolished - all 5 of them. 
What comes next must be a Modern Committee System and we will continue our campaign for it, which we started last year."

 

---

10/9/2020: At tonight's Special South Somerset District Council meeting, the Leader of Somerset Independents spoke to ask councillors to amend the report before them to add a Referendum and a Modern Committee System.


His speech is below.


"Good Evening everybody. My name is Andrew Pope and I am the Leader of the Somerset Independents pressure group. When I last spoke at your Full Council, I asked you to support a Referendum on any changes to how Somerset residents are governed.


Tonight, I am asking you to amend the report to include a Referendum and a Committee System. I was pleased that some councillors such as Tony Lock and Adam Dance spoke in support of a Referendum. But at Somerset Independents, we want action as well as warm words. And to our knowledge, no councillors have taken action to support a Referendum.


Worse than that, district councillors have allowed a falsehood to be promulgated by Stronger Somerset – that a vote cannot take place due to the Coronavirus Act. That is not the case.


It was done at the request of the districts in 2007. And in 2007, 82% of residents in a turnout over 200,000 voted AGAINST a unitary. And it needs to be done again, now.


Somerset residents need to be given the opportunity to express their opinion on any and all proposals, and especially so when neither the Stronger Somerset unitary proposal nor the One Somerset unitary proposal, was suggsested by ordinary residents of our County. It was politicians that came up with these bad ideas.


There is no mandate for a unitary authority. Residents haven’t changed their minds since 2007.


You have to convince the public and have them vote. May I suggest that it is unlikely that you will be able to convince them. Which is why you don’t want a vote, but sham consultations instead!


But you HAVE TO HAVE A VOTE. And Somerset Independents has done the work for you. I have a statement from Civica, who used to be Electoral Reform Services, that says they will do it for the district councils. They’ve even provided us with a quote of £312,000. You have to do this!


Somerset Independents does not want to make you have a Referendum by getting the Verification Number of petitioners under the 2011 Regulations. You will then legally HAVE to have a Referendum!


YOU SHOULDN’T BE MADE TO BY SOMERSET RESIDENTS, YOU SHOULD DO IT BECAUSE IT IS THE RIGHT THING TO DO!


But Somerset Independents does not just want to criticise BOTH undemocratic unitary proposals. We have an alternative, and the Regulations allow a better alternative, and a Referendum too!


So we urge you to commit to change to a Modern Committee System, one that allows ALL councillors to make decisions, not 9 or 10 under the current undemocratic Cabinet system. They are doing it in Sheffield, they have the petition numbers. They’ve done it in other councils. Do it here!


The Committee System is more democratic, so whether it is the current councils or any successor councils, we hope that you will agree with Somerset Independents’ proposal of a committee system.


Commit to doing it now, without being forced to by the Regulations. Residents will thank you for it. Thank you for listening. 

 

Please amend the report to include a poll of residents and Committee System."

Sunday, August 30, 2020

CAMPAIGN: Criminal Checks for Councillors - Mendip Councillors Commit to Checks

 

 

Somerset Independents is campaigning for ALL Somerset councillors to have criminal records checks - now known as DBS checks.


Early in August, we wrote to all four Somerset district councils and Somerset County Council, asking them what they did on these checks for their councillors.


So far, as we have reported, Mendip District Council said that councillors had considered the matter twice in the last four years. And BOTH times, councillors refused to bring in checks.


After dialogue with the Chairmen of two Mendip committees, Licensing and Standards, we are pleased to have received the support from Councillor Sam Phripp and Councillor Richard Pinnock who chair each respective committee. The Licensing Committee makes decisions to approve or revoke licenses on taxi drivers, the serving and sale of alcohol, and other establishments. The Standards Committee makes decisions relating to the rules of the Council (including the Constitution) and on the discipline of councillors under the Code of Conduct.


We are delighted that both councillors have given support to our campaign. But we need to see action, so we have written again to both Councillor Phripp and Councillor Pinnock, asking them to ensure the Council brings in these checks immediately by recommending to the other 45 councillors at Mendip.

 

So what of the other councils?

 

Despite having several weeks to reply, the only one that has replied has been Sedgemoor District Council. They DO implement the Basic DBS Checks for all councillors, which we are pleased to hear, although we would prefer that they implement the Standard Check, which includes more information about a councillor's record. But they do not implement Enhanced DBS Checks. We would like to see them do so.


Shamefully: 

  • Somerset County Council has still not replied, although we have chased. Instead of giving us the answers, they created a Freedom of Information request instead. They have only days remaining to give us the information.
  • South Somerset District Council assured us that we would get a reply, but we have not received one.
  • Somerset West and Taunton Council have not replied, although we have chased.

 

And we have discovered from our research, that 17 (SEVENTEEN) Mendip councillors did not return their financial "party returns" to officers at Mendip, despite them being legally required to.


We have asked Mendip District Council to tell us which councillors they are. But they are "seeking legal advice", instead of giving us their names.


So if councillors want to be trusted by Somerset residents, isn't it really better to be open and transparent, and to be checked out?


What do these councillors have to hide? We think that Somerset residents deserve better councillors.


Tell us what you think by contacting us at somerinds[at]gmail.com , or via Twitter @SomerInds or via our Facebook Page @SomerInds (Somerset Independents).




Friday, August 14, 2020

CAMPAIGN: Criminal Checks for Councillors - Somerset Independents Receives Apology

 

Our Leader Andrew Pope has today received an apology from the Chief Legal Officer (Monitoring Officer - MO) of Mendip District Council.

 

As in our earlier article, Somerset Independents has been asking questions regarding whether Mendip District Council checks criminal records ("DBS checks") for councillors.

 

The short answer is NO. 

 

How many councillors have been checked? ZERO.


The MO wrote to Andrew today to apologise for giving incorrect information about when councillors considered the issue.


He originally told us that they last considered it in 2018.


But the MO apologised and now he says that another set of Mendip district councillors considered the issue again as recently as October 2019.

 

"Apologies for a small error in my previous response... This matter was considered again by the Standards Committee in October 2019 and the papers and minutes can be found here

 

I apologise for any inconvenience caused."

 

And incredibly, the councillors present decided AGAIN to not have councillors be subjected to DBS checks.


Somerset Independents Spokesperson for Safeguarding, Denise Wyatt, has written to councillors on the Standards Committee and Licensing Committee, to ask them why, and to urgently recommend that DBS checks are brought in.


Somerset Independents now believes that ALL councillors should have the Standard Check - which includes more checks than the Basic Check - and the Enhanced Check must apply to councillors in the roles that the law allows those increased checks to occur.


We have also asked the three other district councils and the County Council, and still await their answers to our questions.


Protecting Somerset Residents
 

 

 

Friday, August 7, 2020

CAMPAIGN: ALL Councillors Must Have Criminal Records Checks


UPDATE (10/8/20): Mendip District Council has confirmed in writing to us that ZERO of their 48 councillors has had any DBS checks. Why?

They said that councillors did not think it was needed:

"due to the very limited exposure that elected members had to vulnerable people or groups through their role as a District Councillor"
 
Denise Wyatt, our Spokesperson for Safeguarding says:

"What a joke these councillors are, if they think they would not have 'exposure' to people. It's their job! 
If these so-called councillors were any good at representing people, which councillors are elected for and paid an allowance to do, then they would come into contact with hundreds if not thousands of people, including so-called 'vulnerable' people. 
To give two examples - if councillors helped residents with a housing enquiry or if a resident needed assisted collection for their bins.
 
In 2018 they refused to do it - their excuse is pathetic. It's their chance to save their reputations. Other councils have already done it, so Mendip must do it too.
They need to agree to all 48 Mendip councillors having the Basic DBS Check and for Cabinet Members and the Leader to have the Enhanced DBS Check.
 
And they need to do it now!"

---
 
 
It is for the court to decide on Pallister's case. Whatever happens with Pallister, Somerset Independents believes that ALL elected councillors - county councillors, district/borough councillors and parish/town councillors - should be subjected to regular checks by the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS).

These used to be commonly known as Criminal Records Bureau (CRB) checks.

Why do we think this?

There are many reasons:
  1. for the protection of children
  2. for the protection of vulnerable adults
  3. so that the public can have trust in their elected representatives
  4. for the protection of the councillors from specious allegations, particularly those that may emanate from party political rivalries.

The Ric Pallister trial is an example. As we have said, it is for the court to decide on Mr Pallister's case. He was a councillor. He was a member of the Cabinet, making decisions over large amounts of money and affecting thousands of people's lives. More than being a member of the Cabinet, he was THE LEADER OF THE COUNCIL!

As the report says:

"Mr Pallister was the Liberal Democrat leader of the South Somerset District Council between 2011 and 2018 – before he stood down ahead of last year’s local elections."

Whatever the outcome of the trial, Somerset Independents believes that these checks should be required by law, because they are currently not required by law.
 
Liberal Democrat and Conservative Members of Parliament voted the Localism Act 2011 through. It removed a whole raft of punishments and regulation of elected councillors and made the regulation of councillors local, rather than having set laws.
 
And like this "Wild West" for Councils, it is left to local councils to decide. Worse than that, it is left to local councillors to decide whether they wish to order checks on themselves.

To give a few examples:
  • councillors at Mendip District Council decided in 2018 - against officer's recommendations - to NOT implement DBS checks
  • councillors at Somerset County Council decided in 2017 to implement DBS checks for ALL councillors
  • councillors at Devon County Council decided to implement DBS checks for ALL councillors
  • councillors at Bursledon Parish Council in Hampshire decided to NOT implement DBS checks

The case of Bursledon is very important to note. Former parish councillor and Chair of the Parish, Mark McCormick, "pleaded guilty to 14 indecent assaults between 1997 and 2011", as reported by the Southern Daily Echo. McCormick had actively avoided the checks, according to the BBC:
 
"In 2016, while council chairman, McCormick had opposed the implementation of Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) checks, which allow employers to check criminal records to see if candidates are suitable for work involving children or vulnerable adults.

Despite being warned the checks were required by Lowford Community Centre's insurers, the council refused to comply and was evicted."


 
"people in Bursledon will be asking how it was possible for someone who had been subject to a police investigation into allegations of serious sexual assaults against children could rise to a position of trust within the community that gave him access to the both the local Children’s Library and school that was attended by several of his young victims."
 
When the local Eastleigh Conservative MP Mims Davies accused other Bursledon parish councillors, including the Leader of Eastleigh Borough Council Keith House, of making a "grave error of judgement" in not supporting the DBS checks for Bursledon Council, she was branded as "rude" and interrupted by the Chair (the Mayor)*. House even appeared to suggest that parish and borough councils should not have DBS checks, as "their roles do not include unsupervised contact with children as part of their duties".
 
Somerset Independents points out that councillors, if they are doing their jobs properly of representing thousands of people, will be dealing with children, vulnerable adults and every other kind of people. SO THEY MUST BE DBS CHECKED!

We applaud Somerset County Council and Devon County Council's decisions, but we abhor Mendip District Council's decision. But then this is Mendip District Council, who also do a lot of "odd" other things that other councils do not do. MDC do not do lots of things that are normal in other councils.

These inconsistencies are why it has to be made law. Devon County Council resolved to persuade the Government that it should be the law. We agree.

Spokesperson for Safeguarding, Denise Wyatt, says that:

"As a minimum, Somerset Independents believes that all councillors should be DBS-checked - the Basic Check** - when first elected and every time they are re-elected, which is usually four years. They should also be checked whenever they change role - for example, if they become a Cabinet member - then the Council should put them through the Enhanced Check. There may be also be a case for these checks being re-done annually, which we are prepared to discuss."
"Somerset Independents thinks DBS checks for councillors should be the law, but until it is, all councils should make it mandatory and a breach of their Council's Code of Conduct if a councillor does not have the required DBS checks done."
 
What do you think?

Contact us and tell us.

Protecting Somerset Residents

 
* Davies is no longer the Eastleigh MP, having been replaced by a careerist politician (yes, another one!) Paul Holmes. The siren calls of a safer seat beckoned for Davies in Mid-Sussex. Initially, Davies claimed that she was stepping down from Eastleigh to spend more time with her children.

 ** From the DBS:
 
"A basic check will contain details of convictions and conditional cautions considered to be ‘unspent’ under the terms of the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974.

The Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 aims to give those with convictions or cautions the chance - in certain circumstances - to wipe the slate clean and start afresh.

Under the Act, eligible convictions or cautions become ‘spent’ after a specified period of time known as the ‘rehabilitation period’, the length of which varies depending on how the individual was dealt with.

A table of rehabilitation periods for the most common sentences and disposals can be found here, along with some example scenarios."