 |
England's Green and Pleasant Land UNDER THREAT
|
Denise Wyatt, Planning Spokesperson for Somerset Independents says:
 |
Denise Wyatt
|
"The Conservative Government has put forward a Planning White Paper. What this means is that they want to change how planning works in England. The proposals look disastrous, and are a blatant Stalinist attack on residents' democratic rights under the Trojan Horse of promoting those very same rights.
Our friends in Lincolnshire at Lincolnshire Independents have submitted their response and published it on their website.
Somerset Independents is now publishing its response, submitted before the deadline two weeks ago. It includes our promotion of MORE, not LESS democracy, including the right of appeal for residents on planning applications, I have long thought that it is wrong that developers have this right but residents do not.
We have no doubt that other independent groups share our concerns. Whilst all independents will not agree on every aspect, there is a great amount of common ground, and the excellent Lincolnshire response covers that common ground.
Will the Tory Government listen? I doubt it, but it is worth a try!
Let us know what you think of our response by contacting us."
"Response to
Planning White Paper Consultation from Somerset Independents
29th
October 2020
This Planning
White Paper is a Trojan Horse for development without local democracy
and without local accountability. It is a cynical ploy to exploit
Covid-19 and to blindside the public. It must be
scrapped without delay. If it is not, then the public will know that
this Government wants to centralise decision-making in a Stalinist
coup.
This Planning White
Paper is a manifesto for development and developers that claims that
more of the public will be involved in the planning process. Yet more
public involvement is a pretence of this Planning White Paper. The
White Paper is a smokescreen for dishing out contracts to PropTech
and GIS firms (p.26 et al) that have already failed to provide
mapping systems for the public to be able to participate in the
planning process.
The current local
plan process does not involve the public. There is more than enough
evidence here in Somerset. Putting more emphasis on the local plan
part, and less emphasis on the individual applications, would exclude
even more people than is the case now. It is unacceptable already.
Somerset
Independents agree with our colleagues in Lincolnshire Independents
that house-building targets are too high to protect our environment
and too high to tackle climate change. Such high targets already mean
that the local plans are regularly ignored or sidelined by the
councils, because the pressure is too much. And these targets being
“nationally-determined, binding” (p.23) is wrong. They should be
locally-determined in a democracy. The proposals smack of the Soviet
Union, not the UK. Yet this Government seems to enjoy promoting its
autocratic and centralising tendencies (we reference Lady Hale’s
recent comments on this) that have failed our country on Brexit, on
the Supreme Court judgement on suspending Parliament, and on
Covid-19. It should not make the same mistakes with the planning
system.
The problems that
already exist with the current planning system that exclude over 90%
of residents would be exacerbated by this Planning White Paper. Power
must not be taken away from local residents. They need to be given
more power. But this Planning White Paper does not do that.
Instead, it pretends that “going digital” will magically fix
this, but the same people will continue to be involved and the very
large majority will continue to be ignored or excluded.
The claim in the
White Paper that it is the planning system that puts “delay” in,
is just nonsense. The current involvement of the public is
appropriate and time deadlines are appropriate (8 or 13 weeks) but
public participation needs to be increased, not decreased as proposed
in this anti-democratic White Paper. The vast majority of
applications are approved without committee and without public
participation. If anything, the number with public participation
needs to be increased, with more involvement of the public, not
increased. Yet this White Paper excludes the public more.
Site notices,
notices in newspapers and notifications of local residents need to be
expanded at the application stage, because public participation is
already not enough. Any new digital methods of involvement need to be
done as well as the existing arrangements, not instead of (p.24).
How many times have residents complained that they were not
told about a development? This is the normal feeling in the current
system. We have had to fill in for the failing planning process, in
order to involve the public but such public participation should be
part of the system, not an adjunct to it.
Any involvement of
the public must now allow for virtual meetings in the planning
process (p.24). With safeguards on thresholds, any change to the
planning system must now also allow for groups of residents to send
applications to the Planning Inspectorate as an appeal. This would
make the system fairer than it is now, with only applicants being
able to appeal.
The centralising
tendency of this Government is clear again (p.24) when it says “The
Infrastructure Levy will be more transparent than Section 106, and
local communities will have more control over how it is spent.” Yet
it is not clear how a nationally-determined Levy, which appears to be
suggested in the White Paper, can be locally-decided.
Again, we agree with
our colleagues in Lincolnshire Independents that “the Government’s
squeeze on local councils now extends to centralising planning in a
framework where local decision-making could become a thing of the
past and leave local residents without a proper voice on
applications”. This is why we have described this Planning White
Paper as “Stalinist”. It would suit the Soviet Union command
economy, instead of a democracy where local residents are listened to
and their concerns acted upon.
On the environment,
on food security and on climate change, brownfield sites plus
wildlife corridors plus agricultural sites must be prioritised.
Already in the current system, they are not. And this White Paper
does not address this.
For example, Mendip
District Council has approved the Sandys Hill Lane development in
Frome on farm land, but still the Saxonvale brownfield site remainsderelict. There are many other examples of divergence from the local
plan. So this White Paper, by excluding even more of the public from
the entire process, would make this problem even worse, when it
should be ensuring that it is made better.
Conflicts of
interest amongst councillors are not managed in the current system.
Somerset Independents has made representations to the LGA on their
consultation on Councillors Code of Conduct. And developments that
local residents do not want, are given the go-ahead by councillors
that are closely linked with developers. Is this what the Government
wants? If this White Paper goes ahead, it will confirm that the
Government does want an anti-democratic system to be promoted and
made worse.
This Planning White
Paper is a Trojan Horse for
development without local democracy and without local accountability.
It is a cynical ploy to exploit Covid-19 and
to blindside the public from
what they entitled to – greater involvement in their local area and
local democracy.
For the above
reasons, now is not the time to be changing the planning system. This
Stalinist Planning White Paper should be scrapped and more democratic
alternatives that address the real issues brought forward instead."