Showing posts with label Finances. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Finances. Show all posts

Saturday, August 27, 2022

Yes, Another Strike - This Time it's the Posties at Royal Mail

 

CWU picket line at Bridgwater Royal Mail

One of our Official emblems

 

Somerset Independents puts residents first. Residents and workers are feeling the pinch. It seems like everybody is going on strike, and inflation is very high. The two things often go together, in a wage-price spiral of inflation. 

Meanwhile, the Tory Government is doing nothing to help and is replacing its "Leader" with another hopeless joke.

So we report on another strike. This time it's the workers at Royal Mail, a.k.a. the Posties.

So your mail might not be delivered on some days. But it will be delivered eventually.

Somerset Independents does not often repeat press releases in full. However, on this occasion we will and we will offer Royal Mail the right of reply. It's up to Somerset residents to decide on the merits of the industrial action. Darren Granter, who is CWU Rep at Bridgwater, told us:


"I would like to apologise to all those living in the Taunton/TA 5,6 and 7 postcode areas for the disruption of their mail service during this strike action.

The Royal Mail postmen and women throughout the country-115,000 of us-were left with no choice but to take industrial action following the recent attacks on their pay and working conditions by Royal Mail.

Earlier this year, Royal Mail announced a £758 million pound profit, but then imposed a 2% pay increase without any agreement with the CWU.

However, £400 million pounds was given to shareholders in addition to large bonuses to senior management.

Royal Mail seem to have forgotten that this huge profit was enhanced by the postmen and postwomen working throughout the pandemic, as 'key workers', often putting their own families and loved ones at risk.

Later start times impacting on deliveries, annualised hours and reduced sick pay are just a few of the changes Royal Mail are looking to impose.

Sickeningly, it was announced this week that Royal Mail are offering £1,000 to £1,500 to their managers as a 'thank you' bonus, in addition to their normal pay, for attending work during our strike days."


Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Thursday, July 28, 2022

Wages, Prices, Strikes and Disputes: Bridgwater MP Calls Rail Staff "Lazy and Incompetent" But Bridgwater Unions Say "Save Ticket Offices!"

 

Ian Liddell-Grainger Tory MP for
Bridgwater and West Somerset
(Photo: UK Parliament)

 

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We were formed to stand up for residents. And we hold councillors and MPs to account.

As we have reported, a whole host of workers are going on strike, in a wage-price spiral of inflation where inflation feeds on itself. Union leaders from the RMT (Mick Lynch) and Unite unions (Sharon Graham) have denied that their actions to gain above inflation pay increases, will lead to higher prices. They blame rail bosses and the Tory Government. Ms Graham said:

"I will not apologise for demanding and winning fair pay rises for my members".

The Tory Government, which seems unable to deal with inflation and the rising cost of living, is in dispute with rail unions.

Bridgwater Tory MP Ian Liddell-Grainger has attacked staff at Taunton Railway Station, in a speech in the House of Commons. He said:

"Another issue of confidence, on which we need an urgent debate, has come to my attention: Taunton station. 

The staff there are utterly lazy and incompetent. 

Those who are young, vulnerable, disabled or need help cannot get from one side of the station to the other, because passengers have to walk around a main road and up a ramp, taking all their suitcases with them; it makes Gatwick and Heathrow look positively balmy. It is beyond belief! 

Great Western Railway says it is inclusive and stands up for its customers—well, Taunton does not. Can we please have a debate on the issue before somebody gets injured or, worse, killed?"

At the same time, trade unions in the Bridgwater area are launching a campaign to "Save Somerset's Rail Station Ticket Offices".

Dave Chapple, Secretary of the Bridgwater and District Trades Union Council, told us:

"Rail union, RMT has launched a campaign to resist closure of 1000 rail station ticket offices across Britain, with the loss of thousands of jobs. Rail bosses will carry out a “consultation” in August, but it is clear that the plans are to start closures in October. It is clear that, without opposition from workers and the public, ALL rail stations in Somerset, and indeed the west country, will lose their ticket offices!

All passengers, especially disabled and elderly, and those with little experience of train travel, need on-station support and information. Without that support, many will be excluded from rail travel entirely.

This is all part of the wider, ongoing attack on jobs, pay and conditions in the privatised rail industry, which the RMT is fighting so bravely and with so much support. Train drivers’ union ASLEF is also taking widespread national strike action on 30th July. We support the rail unions on all fronts, and encourage everyone to get involved:

•    join a picket line near you on 30th July (ASLEF) and 18th and 20th August (RMT)

•    you can sign the petition to save ticket offices

•    write to your MP telling him to oppose the closures"

Meanwhile, a Labour MP has been fired for doing exactly what the unions are asking above - joining a picket line. The Labour Party removed Sam Tarry from his junior Shadow Minister post, saying that he must have "collective responsibility" and stick to the collective responsibility and agreed media lines. Unions have criticised the Labour Party. Ms Graham called Tarry's sacking an "insult to the trade union movement".

Somerset Independents has contacted Somerset Labour, Somerset Lib Dems and Somerset Tory MPs for comment on the rail strike. None of them have responded.

Have you written to your MP?

Did you get a response? We ask because residents regularly complain to us that the Somerset Tory MPs do not respond.

What do you think of the unions?

Tell us what you think.

 

Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Sunday, July 24, 2022

UPDATE (26/7/22): The NHS Responds. Why Is It that GPs ("Doctors") Are On Huge NHS Pay But Patients Can't Get Appointments?

 

One of our Official emblems

UPDATE (26/7/22)

We asked the NHS to respond to the patient's letter to the Weston Mercury, asking them:

"We are writing to you because we believe that you are responsible for managing the supply and demand of GP care in North Somerset, Bristol and South Gloucestershire."

A spokesperson for NHS Bristol, North Somerset and South Gloucestershire ICB, said:

“GP practices are working hard, and are seeing more people than ever to make sure everyone can access the right support when they need it; whether that’s online or face-to-face. Surgery teams are growing, and patients may be offered an appointment with a specialist, such as an advanced nurse practitioner, physiotherapist, or clinical pharmacist rather than a GP.

“More than 5.5m appointments were carried out in GP practices across Bristol, North Somerset and South Gloucestershire during 2021; with 442,207 appointments carried out in June 2022 alone.

"All appointments within primary care are triaged, with appointments offered based on the clinical needs of the individual. The majority of the time, people are seen on the same day as their appointment request; and in many cases, conditions can be managed remotely. However, if a person’s condition means they need a face-to-face appointment, or if they would prefer this, this will be offered."
Does this answer the patient?

Do you think they should be doing better?

What do you think of GP pay?

Tell us what you think. 

You can message us on Facebook at Somerset Independents, or Twitter @SomerInds or email us at somerinds (at) gmail.com. Or you can phone us on 07591691543.

---

Doctors are on double, treble or even quadruple the average weekly earnings. So why can't patients get an appointment?

Somerset Independents puts residents first. Residents regularly complain that they struggle to get appointments at their local General Practitioner (GP) - their doctor. The Weston Mercury published a letter from a patient, which we quote here:

"I recently needed an appointment with the doctor, so I telephoned at 8am and eventually, somebody answered.

I was told that I was number 18 in the queue! So, I waited and at 9am I spoke to a lady who told me that the only doctor’s appointment I could have was in 23 days’ time. 

I asked why Congresbury Surgery was not open and I was told that Congresbury has no longer got a surgery, it is now an admin centre. 

So, a purpose-built doctor’s surgery with examination rooms, a good size waiting room and a reception area is now being used for two or three people to write letters! 

People like me, who face having to wait over three weeks, are going to put more pressure on the A&E and ambulance service because whereas now a 10-minute doctor’s appointment would have got things sorted out; by waiting longer thing are going to get worse! 

How can a village the size of Congresbury be stripped of a doctor’s surgery like this? 

In fact, there’s a small office to rent only 50 yards away, why couldn’t this be used as an admin centre and the surgery opened?"

So we have investigated the pay of GPs (doctors).

According to NHS figures, the estimated figures for GPs in England were in 2019/20 (later figures are not yet available):
"The estimated average income before tax of GPs in either a General Medical Services or a Primary Medical Services practice was:
£100,700 for combined (contractor and salaried) GPs
£121,800 for contractor GPs
£63,600 for salaried GPs"
The NHS negotiates with the trade union for GPs, the British Medical Association (BMA). GP pay is determined by these negotiations. The pay for each GP varies above or below the average stated above, depending on the contract that they have.
 
But if we convert the above figures to weekly figures and compare with average weekly earnings, you can see that GPs in England on average get two, three of four times the average pay in England.
 
(1) £100,700 converts to £1936.53 per week
(2) £121,800 converts to £2342.30 per week
(3) £63,600 converts to £1223.07 per week
 
According to the Office for National Statistics, the Average Weekly Earnings in May 2022 was £601 per week.
 
This converts to £31252 per year.
 
So a GP on (1) gets over THREE TIMES the average pay.
A GP on (2) gets almost FOUR TIMES the average pay.
And a GP on (3) gets over TWO TIMES the average pay.
 
And bearing in mind the above NHS figures are from 2019/20, not 2022.
 
GP pay will have increased since then!


Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Wednesday, June 1, 2022

UPDATE (2/6/22): Lib Dem Cuckoo Councillors Spend Millions on Yeovil FC - Against the Wishes of Supporters and Residents

 

Liberal Democrat Councillors
Spending YOUR Money

UPDATE (2/6/22): Ian Perkins of the Gloverscast Yeovil FC podcast (see link below), has responded to our article. Mr Perkins told us:

"I believe SSDC have good intentions with this deal and that they genuinely believe the initial lump sum will benefit the club. However scepticism among supporters about the owner's intentions and commitment to the club have made this deal extremely negative in the eyes of many. The settling of a £1.35m private debt accrued when purchasing the club leaves a sour taste and the sporadic communication, apparently when a good bit of PR is needed has left supporters deeply cynical about the owner."

These are the views of Mr Perkins, and not Somerset Independents. Mr Perkins was formerly of the Glovers Trust, which has been going through a lot of changes in personnel recently.

---

On 31st May 2022, we said in an article that we would publish more details of the spending spree by Liberal Democrat councillors on South Somerset District Council (SSDC).

SSDC is a Somerset Council that has been dogged by controversy. More on that is elsewhere on this website in our investigations and reports, in the Rotten Boroughs section of Private Eye magazine and in The Leveller newspaper.

It is a Council that has less than a year to live. This was remarked upon with sadness by the Chair of the Council Councillor Maxwell, at the last Full Council meeting.

But its councillors cannot be voted out, because the Council will not have another election. The public cannot deliver its verdict at the ballot box.

They are cuckoo councillors, sitting in the nest of the Council and gambling with millions of pounds of public money like it is going out of fashion. And bad decisions, bad debts, bad officers and bad councillors will infect the New Council when it takes over next year. 

The recent example of the merger of West Somerset and Taunton councils is a very recent example of what goes wrong in forced mergers of councils. But the Tory Government and Tory and Lib Dem councillors do not seem to learn from their mistakes.

One example of SSDC's profligate spending is on Yeovil Football Club - the Glovers.

Supporters of Yeovil FC at the Glovers Trust, the official supporters trust of Yeovil, are opposed to SSDC being involved. They had even asked their members to write to SSDC councillors to urge them to stop any purchase.

Other fans including those at the Gloverscast, expressed concern. They asked lots of questions in their 27th May podcast and also published information given to them by the Cabinet member responsible, Cllr John Clark. Clark had given Gloverscast this information before SSDC had responded to our questions. taking a fortnight to answer our questions on Yeovil Town FC, we must point out).

Yet officers at this Council run by Liberal Democrat councillors confirmed on 31st May 2022 to the Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, that they had spent £2.8 million of public money on Yeovil FC and that the deal had just completed.

The deal had just been completed, apparently the day before we asked questions, according to SSDC's response to Andrew.

And they did it behind closed doors with a confidential report.

In a written set of questions, Andrew asked SSDC on 18th May 2022:

Leader of Somerset Independents
Andrew Pope


"As a former member of the Glovers Trust, I have received information from them advising that SSDC is continuing its plans to purchase Yeovil FC and/or its assets. Please advise the full facts and point me to agenda items of any SSDC meetings where this has been discussed. Will it be mentioned at this Full Council tomorrow? Has the Audit Committee considered this expenditure? If not, why? Has there been an Internal Audit study of this?"

SSDC refused Andrew to be allowed to speak at the Full Council, because he missed their deadline by a few hours. 

SSDC said the following. SSDC did not answer until 31st May 2022. We will leave it to readers to decide whether they answered Andrew's questions or not.


"Due to the financial pressures on the club caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, a confidential report on the proposed purchase and leaseback of land at Huish Park was discussed at the Scrutiny Committee on 1st December 2020 and the District Executive approved the purchase & leaseback transaction on 3rd December 2020.  The capital for this purchase was approved by Full Council in February 2022 as part of the budget setting report.  Complex legal work was progressed to conclude the transaction in accordance with the decisions taken.  The transaction exchanged and completed legally on 17 May 2022."

Andrew says:

Andrew Pope

"It must have been a remarkable coincidence that the transaction 'completed and exchanged' the day before I asked my questions, after such a long delay.

And it must have also been a remarkable coincidence that after a very long silence, just two days after I sent my questions, that SSDC published a long press release on the exact same topic.

It was almost as if they wanted to keep it quiet and behind closed doors. My questions flushed out these secretive councillors and secretive council. I forced this controversial council to break their silence.

It is reasonable to conclude that these cuckoo councillors want to continue on their spending spree with millions of pounds of public money that belongs to Somerset residents. Lib Dem councillors want to continue their cloak and dagger way of working, preferring fixed and pre-determined "consultations" to actually listening properly to fans of Yeovil or residents of Somerset.

Somerset residents deserve to have light shone on SSDC's secretive dealings.

Because it is Somerset residents who are suffering with essential services run down or cut and their towns and villages neglected by the council. Money is instead being spent on the wrong things. Spending is profligate and inappropriate.

The governance of this council is out of control. It is unaccountable to the public.

There were no answers about the Audit Committee or Internal Audit. Are these councillors asleep at the wheel? They are supposed to be there to account for public money, on behalf of Somerset residents. But of course, most of them are also Lib Dems supposedly challenging other Lib Dems spending the millions.

People of Somerset want essential services for all that are run properly and funded properly.

Spending millions on a football club, which is a private business, and against the wishes of Yeovil supporters, is just plain wrong.

  And it is just plain cuckoo to think otherwise."



Tuesday, May 31, 2022

UPDATE (2/6/22): Dangerous Lib Dem-Run South Somerset District Council In Spending Spree with Public Millions

 

Spending YOUR Money
Behind Closed Doors

UPDATE (2/6/22): Updated to include link to new article on Yeovil Town FC and the purchase of land by South Somerset District Council at taxpayer's expense, with quotes by fans and residents.

---

Somerset Independents Leader Andrew Pope has been asking questions about the spending spree by South Somerset District Council. It is the spending of public money, much of it done in secret with confidential reports, despite it being public money that councillors are paid an allowance to account for on behalf of residents.

The Council will be scrapped in less than a year. But the Liberal Democrat councillors that are running the Council are spending millions of pounds of public money.

Yet they cannot be voted out, because there will not be any elections.

As we have already warned residents, the new unitary authority ("New Somerset Council") that replaces all four district councils and the county council will inherit the bad debts, bad decisions, bad officers and bad councillors.

Some of these councillors have already been elected to the new authority, before the New Somerset Council has even come into existence.

And some of them have already been given elevated positions of responsibility, despite their failures on the district councils.

Andrew says:

Andrew Pope

"This is the fix that Conservative councillors and the Conservative Government forced through against the wishes of the residents of Somerset. No residents asked for this!

And the Lib Dems did not resist sufficiently to stand up for residents. Why?

Because they wanted to take over the New Somerset Council.

And after the elections, the Lib Dems will control the County Council until it is replaced by the New council.

I have obtained more details of the Lib Dem spending spree.

And we will be publishing them and asking local media to publish them too.

The Liberal Democrats cannot be trusted any more than their predecessors, the Conservatives.

Like we have said since we were created - Lib Dem or Tory, same old story.

These are dangerous times for the county of Somerset and its residents.

They are spending our money but will not be accountable for it.

Somerset Independents was formed to stand up for Somerset residents.

We have been true to our word and the objectives of our Constitution.

We have continued our investigations despite our lack of money and people to do the work.

We have done it as volunteers and as a public service. Because it is the right thing to do."


Somerset Independents - standing up for you



Thursday, January 20, 2022

Arrears of the Year Part 2: Will Councillors Increase YOUR Council Tax AGAIN Despite Some Of Them Failing To Pay Up?

 

Lib Dem, Green, Labour or Tory
SAME OLD STORY

Somerset's councillors tried to stop residents from finding out that some of them persistently failed to pay their own council tax.

But Somerset Independents stands up for residents. We investigated and exposed councillors who persistently refused to pay. Some councils and council officers - South Somerset and Mendip - tried to hide the names of the councillors.

We are still pursuing those councillors and those councils.

We asked all of the non-paying councillors to resign, because residents told us that these councillors should resign.

One of them is no longer a district councillor - Councillor Paul Bolton - has caused a by-election in the Alcombe ward. 

But other councillors are still there! How can they be? Do they have any shame? It seems not.

To add insult to injury, in 2021, councillors voted to increase your council tax. All parts of your council tax increased, because councillors voted to increase it all:

- your district council council tax

- your county council council tax

- the Police part of your council tax

- the Fire Service part of your council tax

Councillors increased your council tax during a Global Pandemic DESPITE Somerset Independents asking councillors not to increase it. Our officers spoke at the budget meetings and we also wrote to them.

NONE of the Westminster parties - Liberal Democrats, Conservatives, Greens or Labour - ACTED to stop your council tax going up. Whether Lib Dem, Green, Labour or Tory, it's the same old story.

Only Somerset Independents stood up for residents.

Soon, councillors will be voting on whether to increase YOUR council tax again.

Will the councillors DARE to increase it, after some of did not even pay their own council tax?

A resident contacted us to say:

"Thank you for your diligence in pursuing SSDC in regards to unpaid council 
tax.  

Two of my local councillors have been implicated in your 
investigations,  Cllr Ben Hodgson and Cllr Robin Pailthorpe.  

At a time when local precepts are being set I and others within my community are 
concerned that behind closed doors councillors could still have the 
opportunity to add their vote to the precept.

Have Somerset Independents advanced any further with their investigations in this matter?.  I am trying to uncover if summons have been sent and payment of arrears has been settled by our councillors.  

Thank You"

Councillor Robin Pailthorpe
DID NOT PAY UP!

Councillor Ben Hodgson
DID NOT PAY UP!

According to the information that South Somerset District Council EVENTUALLY gave us,  as of 29th April 2021, Councillor Robin Pailthorpe (Liberal Democrats):

"Vacated this address with outstanding balance of £1328.66, £470.62 of which is in arrears and subject to a liablility order.  Full balance due 10th May.  Not liable at forwarding address."

And Councillor Ben Hodgson (also Liberal Democrats):

"£834.22 in arrears, £678.46 relates to last financial year.  Application for disregard in progress but SMI application will be turned down"

We will be publishing more details of the arrears of other councillors.

Andrew Pope
Leader of Council Tax Investigation


Andrew Pope, who is leading the investigation, says:

"The Information Commissioner's Office has confirmed to me that they will be investigating South Somerset District Council further, because  the council failed to give us the information that we asked for.

Not only did they fail to give it to us, I had to complain to the ICO to get any movement from the council. It has taken months.

It is in the public interest that this information on councillors who have not paid, is published and in full.

That is why we at Somerset Independents are continuing our investigation.

The public pay their council tax and the public deserve to know about their councillors and what their council officers do to protect councillors who have done wrong."


Thursday, March 18, 2021

Council Tax - Hypocrite Green Councillor Hayden Cannot Justify Not Paying!


Green Councillor
Francis Hayden

We reported on Green Councillor Francis Hayden who was banned from voting on Mendip residents' council tax for 2021-22.

Why was he banned? Because he hadn't paid his council tax.

Councillor Hayden is Councillor for Cranmore, Doulting and Nunney on Mendip District Council in Somerset. The ward is between Shepton Mallet and Frome.

We asked Councillor Hayden a set of questions to see if he could justify his failure(s) to pay council tax.

Although he replied, he couldn't justify them. We offered him a right of reply, but he did not answer all of the questions (see below). 

He barely even answered any of them, instead providing pathetic and facetious non-answers.

But Councillor Hayden reckons that his fellow Mendip councillors support his non-payment of council tax. He hasn't provided any evidence. But one Lib Dem Mendip Councillor has leapt to his defence...

It is Frome Councillor Helen Sprawson-White. She is one of the fake independents who used to be Lib Dem, then Independent, then Lib Dem again - despite telling us by email that she would not join any political party! She claimed our pointing out his non-payment of council tax was:

"Below the belt, this year has been incredibly tough financially on many people due to the pandemic; Francis was incredibly honest by stating he was in arrears - not through choice. He didn’t have to declare his personal circumstances he could have abstained."

Not only is her defence lacking in credibility. It is incorrect.  

He was barred from voting at all, by law. And by senior council officers! He cannot abstain, because he cannot vote at all! An abstention IS a vote.

Do you think that Mendip councillors should be supporting a councillor that does not pay their council tax?

One member of the public told us that the Greens are:

"Footpads, vagabonds and hypocrites".

Do you agree?

It seems that Mendip residents are outraged by the increases to council tax. All you need to do is listen to and read the comments from residents of Frome and other parts of the Mendip area such as Evercreech, where Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Barry O'Leary is the ward councillor.

We asked Councillor Hayden the following questions:

Q1. We like to offer the right of reply to councillors, so would you like to give the public an explanation, and how much you owed Mendip District Council at the time of the meeting?

Councillor Hayden did not tell us how much money he owed on his council tax, or whether he still owes the council tax.

Q2. Would you like to let everyone know whether you will be paying your council tax in the future?

Cllr Hayden also did not say whether he would pay it back.

What did he say, instead of providing some justification. Apparently, he thinks it is OK for him not to pay his council tax:

"there is a global corona virus pandemic going on and that some industries have been hit particularly hard. My own income depends on catering for weddings, parties and music festivals (including Glastonbury) all of which have been cancelled for the last year. Many of my friends have wound up their businesses altogether and are surviving on Universal Credit. Others have adapted and are keeping going on life support with loans, grants, overdrafts, mortgage holidays and, when the worst comes to the worst, delayed bills."

It seems to be lost on Councillor Hayden that he is a councillor, and not separate to your council tax. Councillor Hayden is one of the Mendip councillors that voted on OUR council tax in 2020/21.

Councillors vote on our council tax. Councillors SET THE COUNCIL TAX.

He voted to increase YOUR council tax - but did not pay it himself. 

We think that he should resign. So we asked him whether he would...

Q3. Or will you be resigning your seat, which would seem reasonable?

Of course, Councillor Hayden did not answer this question.

Q4. If you had been able to vote on the council tax setting, how would you have voted? I note that despite being in an "opposition" party, that you voted FOR the council tax setting last year - ANOTHER increase.

Would you have gone along with your Group Leader Shane Collins, who despite being the Leader of an Opposition Group voted FOR the Lib Dems Council Tax increase? 

Of course, Councillor Hayden did not answer these questions either. 

As the Green Group Leader Councillor Shane Collins, voted for the council tax to go up, is it safe to say that Cllr Hayden would have done so, if he was not banned? 

We do not know for sure, because Councillor Hayden did not answer. But it is a reasonable conclusion, because of what he said instead of answering our question. And in the light of the fact that Hayden had voted for an increase the year before, in 2020:

"When it comes to the level of Council Tax we should pay, you will be aware (or at least you should be) that over recent years the government in Westminster has stopped contributing to our income altogether and that as a result our budget has been slashed by around 30%. Under the circumstances I take considerable pride in the services that Mendip continues to be able to offer, especially to the people who need those services most, and perhaps I could offer you the chance to explain if we were to reduce our budget even further which of these services you think should be cut."

So Councillor Hayden does not even think to mention that the budget could be spent more wisely. 

Councillor Hayden even takes pride in Mendip District Council.

At the Council meeting, Hayden did not speak against the increase. He took no action.

Most residents don't take pride. Residents are appalled at Mendip's performance and the increase to council tax by all councils in Somerset.

Try telling Mendip's residents of Councillor Hayden's "pride" when:

  • residents' bins were not collected, and if they were, we had to wait THREE WEEKS
  • residents' recycling was not done, and/or not done properly
  • we are paying more council tax
  • volunteer residents are having to clear up the litter on the streets of Frome that is not collected by Mendip District Council, whose job it is to do this
  • residents are having pay more to bury the dead
  • residents are having to pay more so that Councillor Barry O'Leary and the other Liberal Democrat councillors who run Mendip, can gamble millions of pounds of public money on "property investment"

We think that Councillor Hayden will find that residents do not support his view.

He is trying to defend the indefensible.

And again, we point out that Liberal Democrat and Green councillors in Mendip are one and the same.  

They appear to have had a secret deal on where to stand candidates in the 2019 District council elections - and where to not stand candidates - as told to us by a Liberal Democrat but denied by Greens. Just look at the candidate lists - you will see the pattern of collusion.

Some kind of pact continues to this day, with Lib Dems and Greens voting together on increasing your council tax. The Tories did too!

What is the point of voting out the Tories if you just get more incompetence or corruption as with the Tories?

Somerset residents deserve better than Lib Dem, Green or Tory, same old story. 

Whether the rosette is Yellow, Orange, Green or Blue, they all do the same to you.




Sunday, March 14, 2021

Council Tax Going Up: Why Don't You Ask Councillors Why?

 

Lib Dem, Labour, Green or Tory
SAME OLD STORY

Somerset Independents was formed a year ago to listen and act for residents.

We have listened to how people have struggled during the Pandemic.

We have listened how residents feel that councils and the Government have continually let them down and spent huge sums of public money without explanation or accountability. 

Money which we, the taxpayers, will have to pay back - or even our grandchildren will have to.

We listened to, share and empathise with residents' outrage at how and why council tax is increasing at this horrible time.

Your council tax bill is made up of several parts.

And you will find that most, if not all, parts, HAVE INCREASED! The Somerset County Gazette has reported:

"Each of the five local authorities is raising their portion of the council tax by the highest possible amount they can without triggering a referendum, with similar rises being planned by the police and fire services."

That is why we took action, after we had listened to residents.

 

Standing Up For Residents

As reported on this website, Somerset Independents Co-Founder and Leader Andrew Pope spoke at the Police and Crime Panel and Somerset County Council. Andrew pointed out their failure to spend our money wisely and with residents' priorities in mind.

Andrew asked them to refuse increases. At the first Panel, they refused the increase. But then councillors caved in with a minor change, adding more cost to council tax bills.

Also as reported on this website, Co-Founder Denise Wyatt spoke at Mendip District Council. Denise asked them to refuse increases, pointing out Mendip's major failings to deliver basic services for residents including collecting the bins every three weeks, "if we are lucky" because residents are regularly having missed collections. 

Mendip's failings make residents feel that the council lets them down, even on the bins. But they also want residents to do their own litter picking, and to fund councillors gambling with public money on property investment.

Mendip's Lib Dem, Green and Tory Councillors and fake independent councillors* all voted to increase your council tax.

They voted to do this. But one Green Councillor has not even paid his council tax. More details here.


What can YOU do to hold councillors to account?

Join us in standing up for residents! We are volunteers who formed Somerset Independents to stand up for residents.

Councillors are supposed to listen to you. They are supposed to represent your interests. Instead, they are voting through council tax increases.

Why don't you help us to hold them to account? 

We ask you to write to your councillors and ask them to justify why they voted to increase your council tax.

You can get in touch with your councillors by putting your postcode into the WriteToThem.com website. It will also tell you which councils govern your area.

You can also get in touch by visiting the Councillors page on your local council website.

For Mendip District Council, it is here.

For Somerset West and Taunton District Council (previously West Somerset and Taunton Deane councils, before councillors voted to merge them), it is here.

For South Somerset District Council, it is here. 

For Sedgemoor District Council, it is here.

For Somerset County Council, it is here.

There are also parish and town councils that take even more of your cash. Ask your parish or town councillor how they voted and why. They do not appear on the WriteToThem.com website.

For example, residents of Frome are complaining about the 9.2% increase by Frome Town Council. Frome Town councillors need to explain why they approved this. Here is their website, but we cannot publish all the parish and town councils for Somerset here. There are too many.

At least the Frome Town Council website is better than the others above, with a clear link to the councillors on the home page. One of the worst is the Sedgemoor website, on which it is very difficult to find contact details for the councillors.

We give you the tools to act.

Please let us know their responses. 

Standing Up For Residents and Their Money
 

 

* None of the Mendip independents are truly independent. More of that elsewhere on our website.


Mendip Green Councillor Hasn't Paid His Council Tax!

 

Green Councillor Francis Hayden
Has Not Paid His Council Tax

Green Councillor Francis Hayden was BANNED from voting on your council tax. 

Because he had not paid his council tax. Yes, really. Ask him why. Here is his email address:

cllr.Hayden@mendip.gov.uk

We have asked Councillor Hayden and his answers were facetious and pathetic. He did not answer our questions and cannot justify his non-payment of council tax - as we show in this article here. We would be interested to hear what his response is to you. Here are his other contact details.

Mendip councillors voted to increase your council tax, but one of their councillors hasn't paid.

WHAT A CHEEK!

The Green Group of councillors Leader Shane Collins voted to increase your council tax. We have asked him why, but he has not responded. Here are his contact details.

We have suggested that Councillor Hayden should resign his council seat.

Councillor Hayden and Councillor Collins both voted in 2020 to increase the council tax, along with almost all other Mendip councillors - Lib Dem, Green, Tory or fake independents*. Ask them why. We have.

We provide the contact details for you on this website here. 

Standing Up For Residents

 

* We say "fake" independent. Because we have the evidence to show that none of the so-called "independent" councillors on Mendip are truly independent. We challenged them and several squirmed back to the Lib Dems or Tories. The worst culprit was Councillor Helen Sprawson-White, the Chair of Mendip District Council. We have it in writing that she would not join a political party. Then she did - the Liberal Democrats which she was previously a member of. Councillor Hayden has been trying to defend Councillor White on social media, in the light of attacks from Frome residents and businesses.



Tuesday, February 23, 2021

At Mendip District Council, it's Lib Dem, Green or Tory, same old story

 

Lib Dems, Greens, Tories
all robbing your council tax

Somerset Independents Co-Founder Denise Wyatt spoke at last night's Mendip Council Budget Full Council. Her full speech is below. 

She asked councillors to not increase council tax, but they did. Every councillor did except one, Green Councilor Francis Hayden, who was barred from voting - because he had not paid his council tax. 

Yes, really.

Denise Wyatt

Responding, Denise says: 

"Lib Dem, Green, Tory - same old story. Whether it is Mendip Council or Somerset County Council, these councillors think YOU should pay more council tax. They all voted to increase it. Mendip councillors and Somerset County Councillors are a disgrace."

Denise's Full Speech is below.

Liberal Democrat Councillor Barry O'Leary, in presenting the council tax increases, said that residents should not be getting a refund of their council tax, which was suggested by Denise in her speech.

Lib Dem Councillor Garfield Kennedy, who earlier supported spending more money on "the arts", said it is a "false economy" to freeze council tax. Cllr O'Leary agreed.

Incredibly, despite residents struggling during the Pandemic and the failures of Mendip Council to provide services and value for money, ALL Mendip District Councillors voted FOR the council tax increase. 

All that was, apart from Green Cllr Francis Hayden who said that he had been told that he was in arrears, and has not paid his council tax.

So these councillors want to tell you to pay MORE council tax, but there was one who has not paid his own council tax. Isn't that the height of hypocrisy?

Several councillors mentioned at the meeting that they thought councillors might have been voting without having heard all of the debate. "We're all grown-ups", says Chair Lib Dem Councillor Helen Sprawson-White, and did not ask for any councillor's vote to be discounted.

The Chair claimed that the vote to approve the increase in council tax was "as unanimously as we could have done". She was glossing over the fact that a councillor has not paid his council tax, and is in arrears, so was barred from voting on the council tax of everybody in Mendip.

So there we have it - yet another increase to our council tax, to add to the Police and County Council increases. 

During a pandemic, they increased our council tax.

Lib Dems, Green and Tory councillors take our money for granted. They need to be removed.


Denise Wyatt Full Speech to Mendip District Council Full Council, 22nd February 2021


This budget is shocking.

Why is our council tax increasing? We should be getting a rebate

It’s not just Council Tax you want to increase - is it?

You propose to Increase the charges for - Garden waste bins and worse burial costs.

Bins that’s another subject. Less service or no service at all.  Have you seen the complaints on social media? If you’re lucky enough to get your bin collected, it now only happens every three weeks.

It’s also no surprise that fly tipping in Mendip is worse than ever.

Also you are expecting residents to do your litter picking and street weeding for you. What other services do you expect the public to do?

In your report your expectation is and I quote “Society will assist in the delivery of services.”

Your accounts - My objection to your accounts was regarding your Investment Property. This only occurred because you didn’t listen to me over your governance. So I had no choice but to contact the External Auditor Ernst and Young. Who because of my objection is investigating what has been going on?

On this point, I would like to thank your s151 Officer.

With regard to income from these investment properties, several of your tenants are falling behind with their rental payments to the tune of just under half a million.

It is also no surprise that the Council is currently maintaining an over-borrowed position.” You are gambling with public money.

Again what’s worse from your reports I gather you are expecting us to pay more money by crowd funding your pet investment schemes? Can’t you get the money from the banks?

Reorganisation costs, even the Councils rigged consultation shows that residents don’t want it.  If reorganisation goes ahead the Council has no funding allocated for transition costs. According to your reports you intend to take money from reserves or “Flexible use of Capital Receipts” So you are going to flog assets for reorganisation and fail more services.

You have also failed to spend grants to build social housing.  I refer you to the Saxonvale disaster and the Easthill  tragedy. 

What sort of a Mickey Mouse council are you?

You are providing fewer services, and likely even fewer

Expect the public to go out and do your job for you 

You are also proposing, the Lib Dem death tax to charge the dead more to be buried

You are being investigated by the external auditor

 

This Council is a disgrace and I repeat the public should be getting a rebate not an increase.

 


Thursday, February 4, 2021

VICTORY: Somerset Independents Succeeds In Halting Increase to Taxpayers on Police Costs

Leader of Somerset Independents
Andrew Pope


UPDATE: Councillors finally caved in to the PCC's Budget in a hurriedly-organised second meeting, only making a minor change to the Budget.

It proves that tou can't trust party politicians to do the right thing unless you are directly challenging them, and increases our concerns about three Independent members positions on the Panel being vacant.

---

BREAKING: Following Andrew Pope's speech to them today to stand up for taxpayers, the Avon and Somerset Police and Crime Panel have just voted by majority to veto the 6.6% increase asked for by Police and Crime Commissioner Sue Mountstevens and Chief Constable Andy Marsh.

Somerset Independents listen and acts for residents. 

As Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope listened to residents who said they did not wish to pay more for the Police and questioned the increase during a Global Pandemic and when families are feeling the crushing weight of Covid-19 on their lives.

Andrew sent a written statement that was forwarded by the officer to all members of the Panel. It is shown in full below.

Andrew had listened to residents who asked why the Police were spending so much money on relocations and buildings, and asked what had happened to the money from the sale of police stations such as in Wells.

Andrew questioned the budget proposals, pointing out to members of the Panel that Somerset residents were really feeling the strain of Covid on their finances. 

When he spoke at the Panel in the virtual meeting today, Andrew said that there was no mention of delays to police buildings, the use of reserves or better use of the massive IT budget.

The Chief Constable responded to Andrew's points.

Then after a long debate, members of the Panel deliberated.

They voted by 11 votes to veto the budget, with 1 abstention.

Andrew says:

"Somerset Independents was formed to stand up for residents. We listen and we act on residents' concerns.

The Commissioner should have looked harder at the budget, and provided more options, instead of just one alternative.

So I am pleased that Sue Mountstevens and the Chief Constable Andy Marsh have been asked to think again.

They will now have to re-consider the budget and come back to the Panel."

Andrew also spoke to appeal to the Panel for help to delay the May 2021 elections - something which Somerset Independents believes is right and has contacted MPs and council officers to suggest. Sadly, not a single mention was made by members of the Panel at the meeting. However, the meeting was cut short after 3 hours on the budget, with later agenda items postponed until a future meeting.


Andrew Pope Statement to the Avon and Somerset Police and Crime Panel, 4th Feb 2021

Dear Police and Crime Panel,

 

Firstly, I would like to appeal to you to refuse the 6.6% increase in the precept for the Police. Ask yourself whether this is really justified when there has been money wasted on Police moving from station to station - for example in Shepton Mallet. The public expect police to be on the beat, and out of the office, so police stations are not the priority of the public. At least, that's what the public has been told by the police - that front desks and police stations are not really needed. Yet your press releases on the budget make multiple mentions of police buildings. This level of increase is not justified, so please refuse it.

 

Secondly, I would also question whether the surveys quoted in the reports before you today, are representative samples of the population of Somerset. If they are not, then why are they being used to make decisions? As a Panel, you should demand better, to make better decisions and provide better advice.

 

Thirdly and finally, regarding the May 2021 elections. I am Leader of Somerset Independents, a pressure group of residents and registered political party that is considering, amongst a group of Somerset residents, whether to stand a candidate in the Police and Crime Commissioner elections. We are aghast at the £5,000 deposit and the strange decisions made by MPs prior to the last PCC elections.

 

I note that today there are no Independent Panel members present, with two recent resignations, a vacancy and an illness. I find this all rather worrying.

 

Somerset Independents has this week sent its view to all Somerset MPs and all returning officers, plus SOLACE and the AEA. Our view is that the May 2021 elections must be delayed, in the interests of public health, public safety, scrutiny and for free and fair elections. When they are safe, they can be held. If this is not until October, or even next year, so be it. I hope that you agree, but I am here to listen.

 

I would ask you, therefore, that in the event of a delay that you consider very carefully how you deal with such a delay. I suggest very strongly that you do not consider appointing any PCC without an election, even on a temporary basis. Any previous or existing candidate should not be appointed. This would be anti-democratic and set a dangerous precedent. I would also question the wisdom and legality of such a move. I hope that you agree.

 

Thank you for listening and I hope that I will get a written response, and there will be a healthy debate, about the points that I have raised. You can contact us at somerinds@gmail.com.

 

Andrew Pope

Somerset Independents

 

Wednesday, January 27, 2021

UPDATED (2/2/21): Shady Mendip Lib Dems Spend YOUR Money On The Wrong Things

 

Lib Dem Councillor Barry O'Leary
Mendip Cabinet Member for Finance

UPDATE (2/2/21): Mendip District Council's Cabinet, which includes Lib Dem Councillor Barry O'Leary (above) who is councillor responsible for the finances of the Council, received a report yesterday which stated:

"28. The Council’s External Auditor, Ernst & Young, gave an unqualified opinion on the 2019-20 financial statements. The Value for Money opinion has been delayed due to an objection to the accounts by a member of the public. The external auditor is yet to complete his investigation into this matter. The Council has considered the issues raised and has taken steps to mitigate the issue which was identified. We will continue to work closely with the External Auditors and react positively to any issues identified"

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, who was one of the Somerset Independents investigators into Mendip's accounts that led to Ernst and Young investigating, says: 

Andrew Pope
Leader of Somerset Independents
 

"In other words, the Council's own report shows that Ernst and Young are not prepared to state that the taxpayer (you and I) got value for money for our council tax. 

In a democracy where we pay taxes to councils, it is essential that residents know whether YOUR MONEY is being spent correctly by those councils. And if it isn't, councillors must answer our questions. If they don't want to, then it looks suspicious.

Mendip Lib Dems, especially Finance Cabinet Member Councillor Barry O'Leary, are not spending our money on the correct priorities. And they want to hide their spending.

Councillor O'Leary and his Lib Dem mates are gambling millions of taxpayers' pounds on property, but the streets in places like Frome and Evercreech aren't being cleaned, despite it being Mendip's responsibility!

They want volunteers, who pay their council tax, to clean the street for free instead!

Which in a democracy, is wrong.

This shows that we were right to raise the Council's accounts with Ernst and Young. And we look forward to their investigations being concluded and reported on."

---

UPDATE (1/2/21): The Audit Committee stopped the public from seeing the agenda item 

"14        SECTION 25 REPORT OF THE SECTION 151 OFFICER   "

Why would they not want the public to see a Section 25 report? 

We quote from the Surrey County Council minutes:

"The Local Government Act 2003 (Section 25) requires that when a local authority is agreeing its annual budget and precept, the Section 151 Officer must report to it on the following matters: the robustness of the estimates made for the purposes of the calculations, and; the adequacy of the proposed financial reserves."

Surely it is in the public interest to know?

And especially so, given Ernst and Young is investigating the property investment of the Council's accounts?

Other councils such as Surrey and Waltham Forest did not seem to have a problem with it.

But Mendip District Council does.

WHAT ARE THEY TRYING TO HIDE?

---

There was an Audit Committee meeting for Mendip District Council this evening (27/1/21) at 6.30pm, where our Lead on Governance Denise Wyatt spoke about the "External Audit Update" that relates to her formal Objection to Mendip District Council's accounts.

Denise mentioned the real-life impact on people's lives, that the mismanagement of Mendip Council's finance by the Liberal Democrats has had. She mentioned the Easthill proposal by the Lib Dems to sell their land to Aster for social housing. 

And she mentioned the failure of Lib Dem, Tory and Green councillors to hold them to account. 

This is the purpose of the Audit Committee.

But those councillors on the Committee HAVEN'T AUDITED THE COUNCIL.

This is why Ernst and Young (E & Y) is investigating Mendip District Council. Kevin Suter of E & Y mentioned the Objection in his comments.

What Denise said is below:

Leading on Governance
Denise Wyatt

"Good Evening 

My name is Denise Wyatt and I am here to speak about the Council’s accounts and governance.

For your information, I am an experienced governance officer.

Early last year I needed to find some information about the Council. I couldn’t find it. I asked questions. I hit a brick wall.

I looked more deeply at the Councils finance, governance, and decision making. I could not believe your practices and constitution. I was appalled that the Council appeared not to comply with the law.

I made further enquiries and sought assurance from the Monitoring Officer. I was unhappy with the replies.

I spoke at various council meetings including Full Council. I also emailed councillors. My concerns were ignored.

My concerns, particularly regarding finance, and councillors decision making was not a matter for the Ombudsman, as it did not personally affect me.

It was therefore my duty to ask questions about the council’s draft accounts.                                                                           

I thank the s151 Officer, Richard Bates for his forbearance. I know he had some difficulties, getting prompt and clear replies to my questions on the accounts.

I would also like to thank Kevin Suter of Ernst and Young for his assistance.

YES, I am the Objector to the Councils accounts.

This authority claims openness and transparency and yet as a Council you appear to ignore the Law of Meetings, as it applies to local government.

I refer you to the Local Government Act 1985. This Council is quick to apply the Act when you want to move to private session such as with Easthill, but in other respects you seem to fail to apply the law and best practise.   

Following my objection to the Council’s accounts, I was delighted to hear at a recent meeting, that the Council is now seeking advice on governance from the Local Government Association. Finally you are listening - thank you.

Councillors your function as a committee is to provide an independent assessment of the Councils governance and public finance.

Members you are not here to rubber stamp reports. You are here to question. I had to do it, because this Committee failed to do so. You MUST challenge challenge and challenge again.

If a member of the public comes to you with concerns about governance and finance please don’t dismiss or ignore them.

Councillors I repeat something I said to you all at the Council meeting last July.

Your practices and process of council meetings NEED to change,

You NEED to ensure the Council applies the law of meetings: and

Your Constitution NEEDS to change –

So please change it..

Thank you"

The Chair made no comment in response to Denise's speech.

The only councillor to reference Denise's Objection was the new Vice-Chair of the Committee, Councillor Michael Gay. He asked what actions E & Y can take.

Mr Suter confirmed that he could make any recommendation at any time.

This can include a Public Interest Report. We have asked that E & Y make this recommendation. This has happened at Croydon, Nottingham and York councils, to give three examples.

Mr Suter also confirmed that he could not take questions on the Objection from councillors, on the detail of the Objection.

This is because it is, in his words, a "quasi-judicial" process. In other words, a legal process governed by law applying to the audit process in councils.

E & Y's investigation into Mendip District Council's investment in property continues.  

The new Section 151 Officer Richard Bates later commented that the rules regarding property investment are changing. He asked councillors to be aware of the Council's Treasury Management, and the Council's policy.

He will report back to the Committee and the External Auditor.

Somerset Independents will continue to hold Somerset councils to account on the mismanagement of public monies, and report back to Somerset residents.

If you want more info on what happened at the meeting, our live-tweet of the meeting starts at the Twitter link below: