Showing posts with label Somerset West and Taunton Council. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Somerset West and Taunton Council. Show all posts

Sunday, July 17, 2022

UPDATE (20/7/22): Lib Dems in West Somerset TWICE Promised A Committee System Instead Of The Failed "Strong Leader" - So Where Is It?

 

The Lib Dems Stood...
...But Didn't Deliver!

One of our Official emblems

UPDATE (20/7/22)

We offered the right of reply to Liberal Democrat councillors. Only one replied, Councillor Lee Baker, but despite being a SWT Councillor that made the pledge, he did not provide any evidence that he or the Liberal Democrats have tried to meet the pledge of a committee system. Yet another Fib Dem.

 

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We stand up for residents across the whole of the County - North, South, East and West.

The First Lib Dem Promise To Bring In A Committee System

Before the Somerset West and Taunton (SWT) Council was formed in a forced merger by the Tories of West Somerset District and Taunton Deane Borough councils, we understand from residents that the Liberal Democrats pledged to change the way the Council would be run.

The Lib Dems promised to change the new Council to be a "Committee System", and for the "Strong Leader and Cabinet" model, which models the Westminster system, to be replaced.

SWT Council came into being on 1st April 2019 (no jokes please). Having run the Council under the "Strong Leader and Cabinet" model and despite the Lib Dems having a majority of councillors, the Liberal Democrats delayed two years until April 2021.

The Second Lib Dem Promise To Bring In A Committee System

As reported by Somerset Independents, the Full Council of SWT Council agreed on 29th April 2021 that they should have a committee system. It is there in the Minutes. 

Also as reported by us, Denise Wyatt from Somerset Independents asked SWT Council "to ensure that a Modern Committee System was on the ballot paper in the upcoming Referendum on how Somerset was governed, as well as a 'No Change' option." The Lib Dems on SWT Council refused to do that too, sticking with their "two buckets of manure" vote to have two or one unitary. 

The Yes/No Referendum that happened in 2007 - 82% of residents voted against having a unitary - was not going to be repeated. That was a real missed opportunity for democracy in Somerset.

The Lib Dems went with the Sedgemoor Tories and instead supported a two or one unitary Referendum. And the corrupt Tory Government duly ignored the result.

So Where Is The Committee System That The Lib Dems Promised?

At the time of writing, despite pledging to do so before the elections, and resolving to do so again in 2021, the Lib Dems have still not brought in a committee system. It is still the Strong Leader and Cabinet that was used in the precedessor councils.

As shown in our report, and in the Minutes, the SWT Full Council in April 2021 also resolved to ask the New Somerset Council to be a committee system. 

Somerset Independents wanted to see evidence of action. 

So we asked, via a Freedom of Information (FoI) request, to see the evidence of letters and any other correspondence between SWT Council and the New Somerset Council - be that from the Leader, Lib Dem Councillor Federica Smith-Roberts or any other Cabinet member from the Lib Dems.

Councillor Federica Smith-Roberts
Leader of SWT Council
 

In their response, Somerset West and Taunton Council did not provide any such evidence that it had advocated for a committee system, although our requests were very clear.

Therefore it is clear that the Lib Dems have failed to bring in a committee system in the SWT Council that they have controlled from 2019 to 2022 and will do so until it is scrapped in 2023 and then replaced by the New Somerset Council. 

The Lib Dems promised to bring in the committee system, twice. But did not.

Somerset Independents also tried to obtain evidence from the now Lib Dem-controlled Somerset County Council that they were going to bring in a committee system. Why did we think they would?

Councillor Bill Revans and the
Lib Dem Cabinet of the County Council
including Cllr Federica Smith-Roberts

Because in the FoI response, SWT Council told us:

"The proposed option for committee system has been taken to the Local Government Reorganisation officers, who will be taking a report to the New Council meeting in May this year I believe, asking the new councillors to decide whether they carry on with a Strong Leader Model or opt for a Committee System."

At the 2022 Annual General Meeting of Somerset County Council when the Lib Dems took control of the County Council, there was no evidence that we could see that they intended to bring in a committee system. In fact, the report that was brought by officers to the AGM was dismissive of the committee system. There was no consideration of it, just a continuation of the Strong Leader and Cabinet - the same as the Tories before them.

If you look carefully, Councillor Smith-Roberts who is still Leader of SWT Council, is in the Cabinet of the County Council. Why didn't she bring up the Committee System. You know why now, don't you? Because she had no intention of doing so - there is no evidence that she did, and we asked SWT Council for it.

Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope says:

Andrew Pope, Leader of Somerset Independents
 

"To show good intent of the new Lib Dem Administration, the new Leader of the Council Lib Dem Councillor Bill Revans could have insisted to officers that they switch to a committee system immediately, and ordered a report to that effect. The new Lib Dem majority could have forced it through. Cllr Smith-Roberts could have proposed it. But they did not.

So what is the only conclusion that can be drawn from all of these failures by the Lib Dems to meet their promises?

The Lib Dems lied to residents. That's why we call them Fib Dems. 

They broke their promises, not once but twice.

And it's another case of repeating what the Tories did before them. They did that on the western Somerset councils too.

That's why we say Lib Dem or Tory, same old story. 

The Lib Dems stood... but didn't deliver."


The Lib Dems stood...
... but didn't deliver

 

Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Saturday, October 30, 2021

Arrears Of The Year: Somerset's Rogue Councillors Who Didn't Pay Their Council Tax

 

The Rogue Councils Were All Lib Dem-Run or Tory-Run

Somerset Independents stands up for residents. 

We have investigated all 250+ district and county councillors, to find those who persistently did not pay their council tax.

By "persistently", we mean councillors who were two months or more in arrears. 

Their names? Bloomfield, Clarke, Durdan, Hayden, Hodgson, Osborne, Pailthorpe. 

The councils they are on? Mendip District, Somerset County, South Somerset District, Somerset West and Taunton District.

Read on to find out more.

It is AGAINST THE LAW and a CRIMINAL OFFENCE to vote on council tax-related matters when a councillor is persistently in arrears.

Green, Lib Dem, Tory and Fake Independent Councillors
Did Not Pay Their Council Tax

As we have made clear on many occasions, we have not pursued private individuals on their arrears in paying up. In fact, we have spoken up for hard-pressed residents when councillors have increased council tax without a Referendum. 

But councillors are not private individuals. They hold public and elected office, funded by the taxpayer. They are there to represent you. But we have found too many who have brought the office of councillor into disrepute.

Councillors increased your council tax during the Covid-19 Pandemic.

As described on this website, our officers turned up and spoke at ALL four district council budget meetings and the County Council budget meeting in February 2021, PLUS the Police and Crime Panel. We asked councillors to NOT put your council tax up.

But councillors at all councils did put YOUR COUNCIL TAX up.

So have all councillors been paying THEIR council tax? No, they have not.

We have documented the responses from the district councils and county council on this website, to our questions.

Councils attempted to cover up the wrongdoing of their councillors.

Some councils gave us the information without a problem - Sedgemoor, Somerset West and Taunton, and Somerset County Council. They did what they were supposed to do - answer our questions under the Freedom of Information Act.

But two councils obstructed our enquiries and have not answered our questions.  Mendip District Council and South Somerset District Council have broken the law on Freedom of Information and in other legal respects.

Private Eye and The Leveller have helped us to report on those councils and the councillors that the councils have tried to protect.

Speaking to The Leveller for their lead article in the October edition of the newspaper, Andrew Pope, Leader of Somerset Independents said:

Andrew Pope
 

"Somerset Independents is a campaign group formed to stand up for residents.

When we discovered that councillors had not paid their council tax, we were incensed. So as volunteers, we investigated the councillors of all districts and the County council.

We asked councillors directly at their February Budget meetings to not increase council tax during the Pandemic. But they did. Yet some councillors did not pay themselves - some of them did not pay over many months and even years. They hold public office but have brought it into disrepute.

Residents told us that these councillors should resign. We agree."

Andrew adds: 

"Now we have forced the councils to expose their rogue councillors, it is in the public interest that we publish the list of councillors who were persistently in arrears.

We have offered the Right of Reply to our questions to all of these councillors.

Too many of these councillors ignored our offer and those who did respond did not answer our questions fully and frankly. Some of them lied. Some of them were obnoxious. All of them were persistently in arrears, some of them over years.

They should all go, and go now. We will be publishing more details about them and the lengths their councils have gone to, in order to prevent the public knowing about their wrongdoing."

 

Arrears Of The Year... Or Rogues Gallery?

In alphabetical order of surname, the councillors who were persistently not paying their council tax are as follows. Click the links for their contact details if you want to ask them why they did not pay. 


Lib Dem, Green or Tory, Same Old Story
 

 

Councillor Neil Bloomfield (South Somerset District Council and Somerset County Council)

Councillor Neil Bloomfield

Independent (resigned from the Conservatives) Councillor for Martock Ward and Martock Division on Somerset County Council.

We offered him a right of Reply. His response was bizarre and unrepentant.

Councillor Bloomfield told us, while not answering our questions on his arrears:

"I’ve been in private eye twice now but first time for this...Yes was behind, now I’m ahead (I hope) and no I won’t be resigning."


Councillor Paul Bolton (Somerset West and Taunton Council)

Councillor Paul Bolton

Independent Councillor for Alcombe.

The Mayor of Minehead told us that he had paid up, following our investigation. He did not initially reply to our correspondence, so we used other ways of contacting him. When we did speak to him - he rang us - he did give some answers but he also claimed that we had not contacted him before - a false claim. More in our report here. The Leveller has reported on him in their October issue.



Councillor Louise Clarke (South Somerset District Council) 

Councillor Louise Clarke

Liberal Democrats Councillor for Martock Ward.

We offered her a Right of Reply. She did not respond. We have extended the time offered for a response.

 

Councillor Kelly Durdan (Somerset West and Taunton Council)

Councillor Kelly Durdan

Independent (former Conservative candidate) Councillor for Creech St. Michael.

We offered her a Right of Reply. She did not respond. We phoned her. She was obnoxious, did not answer our questions, and hung up, without providing any explanation. The Leveller has reported on her in their October issue.

 

Councillor Francis Hayden (Mendip District Council)

Councillor Francis Hayden

Green Party Councillor for Cranmore, Doulting and Nunney.

We offered him a Right of Reply. He did not respond with answers, and was obnoxious in his response. He even bragged about it in public, claiming that he prioritised his wife's business first. He refused to resign. The Leveller has reported on him in their October issue, citing our evidence that he committed criminal offences in voting on council tax-related matters. Mendip District Council has told Somerset Independents, and The Leveller, that they would change the way they worked on the issue of council tax.


Councillor Ben Hodgson (South Somerset District Council)

Councillor Ben Hodgson

Liberal Democrats Councillor for Crewkerne.

We offered him a Right of Reply. He did not respond. We have extended the time offered for a response.

 

Councillor Sue Osborne (South Somerset District Council)

Councillor Sue Osborne

Conservative Party Councillor for Windwhistle.

We offered her a Right of Reply. She did not respond. We have extended the time offered for a response.

 

Councillor Robin Pailthorpe (South Somerset District Council)

Councillor Robin Pailthorpe
 

Liberal Democrats Councillor for Crewkerne.

We offered him a Right of Reply. He did not respond. We have extended the time offered for a response.

 

UPDATE: We have also investigated North Somerset Council, Bath and North East Somerset Council and Bristol City Council. More information on all eight of our investigations is on this article here.

 

What Happens Next?

Hopefully these councillors will search their conscience and speak to the their constituents to see what they think, and whether residents think that they should resign as a councillor. 

Are any of the above councillors your councillor? Get in touch with us to tell us what you think. We have asked a lot of residents what they think about these councillors - in a democracy, residents' views are the views that really matter. 

No resident has told us that they think it is OK. In fact, many of them told us that these councillors should resign. We agree.

We will be publishing more details on each councillor's arrears and how they reacted to our investigation.

You may have noticed that they are all councillors at district councils run by the Liberal Democrats or the County Council that is run by the Conservatives. All of them except one is a Liberal Democrat or Tory. 

Only one of them was elected as an Independent (Bolton) but he is nothing to do with Somerset Independents, and if he was, we would have expelled him from our Party following due investigation.

We will expose councillors' wrongdoing, whether they are of the national political parties or of no party.

Our investigations are continuing, and we have involved the Information Commissioner's Office, as documented elsewhere on this website.

Standing Up For Residents and Taxpayers


 



Friday, October 29, 2021

Councillors in Council Tax Arrears: Information Commissioner Places Two Somerset District Councils Under Investigation

The Leveller October 2021

Above is "The Leveller" October 2021. They are reporting on our work to expose Somerset's councils and councillors, and to stand up for the vast majority residents who do pay their council tax and expect councillors to set the example.

Following action by Somerset Independents, some of Somerset's 250+ district councillors have been found to have not paid their council tax over extended periods of time, with some over years.

So why did we start this investigation?

When our officers discovered from the February 2021 Full Council Meeting that Green Mendip Councillor Francis Hayden was banned from voting on council tax due to non-payment of council tax for more than 10 months, we asked all four district councils and the County Council, about councillors who did not pay.

We sent a formal complaint to Mendip about Cllr Hayden. Mendip did not properly investigate the councillor, of whom we provided evidence that Hayden had committed one or more criminal offences in voting on council tax-related matters at the February 2021 budget meeting - despite being barred. 

Mendip District Council do not seem to investigate councillors, we have found. Instead, they cover up for them and this is another case.

We have placed some of the evidence of non-payment of councillors across Somerset, and our actions, on other articles on this website. You can obtain the articles at the link here and click the tag "Council Tax" at the top of the website. Just scroll down to see all articles.

There was a difference in response from the four councils. Two councils gave the information, whereas two other councils sought to cover up the facts. The County just passed the buck to the districts and asked that councillors confess if they were in arrears.

Sedgemoor confirmed that no councillors had been in arrears. SWT Council confirmed the details of councillors in arrears and we challenged them directly, leading to one councillor Paul Bolton paying up in full. Another, former Conservative and now "independent" Cllr Kelly Durdan, failing to provide answers to us when we challenged her.

Two councils - Mendip and South Somerset - have covered up the names and/or further details of the arrears by councillors. We challenged them. South Somerset legal officer said the names would be revealed, but nothing came of it, despite our chasing.

So we have taken those FoI requests to the Information Commissioner's Office.

The ICO has told us in both cases that:

"Your complaint has been accepted as eligible for further consideration and will be allocated to a case officer as soon as possible."

And we went to the local and national media.

Both Private Eye and The Leveller have reported on our work. In The Leveller article, Leader of Somerset Independents Andrew Pope, who led the investigation, says:

Andrew Pope

 

"Somerset Independents is a campaign group formed to stand up for residents.


When we discovered that councillors had not paid their council tax, we were incensed. So as volunteers, we investigated the councillors of all districts and the County council.


We asked councillors directly at their February Budget meetings to not increase council tax during the Pandemic. But they did. Yet some councillors did not pay themselves - some of them did not pay over many months and even years. They hold public office but have brought it into disrepute.


Residents told us that these councillors should resign. We agree."

 

We will continue our investigation and continue working with local media to expose Somerset's rogue councillors and MPs.

 




Tuesday, June 29, 2021

Somerset's Lack of Democracy - Councillor Removed for Not Turning Up After Not Paying His Council Tax Either!

 

Former Councillor Paul Bolton

UPDATE (21/3/22): FINALLY! Somerset West and Taunton have told us why Paul Bolton is no longer a councillor - because he was removed for non-attendance.

But it took over two months for the Council to tell us. They've apologised, saying it was an "oversight" by officers.

The by-election had long gone by the time they bothered to let us know. We chased on more than one occasion.

They told us today:

"This was the response from the Deputy Monitoring Officer:-

 

Apologies for the delay in responding to your query. The vacancy in the Alcombe Ward arose due to the former Councillor’s failure throughout a period of six consecutive months to attend any meeting of the authority (provisions contained under s85 of the Local Government Act 1972). The notice of vacancy did not contain the reason for the vacancy as there is no requirement for the Local Authority to provide that level of detail in the notice."

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, says:

Andrew Pope
 

"So as well as not paying his council tax - and then being exposed by the Somerset Independents investigation - Paul Bolton also did not attend council meetings for over six months.

And then he was removed.

Would he still be a councillor if we had not exposed him? I think that he would be.

Did the Westminster parties do the investigation? No.

Did the local media? No.
It was left to volunteers at Somerset Independents to do it.

Is Bolton the usual calibre of councillor that has been elected in Somerset?

Sadly, yes.

We have found, and we have contacted all 250+ Somerset councillors several times on a range of issues, between 80% and 90% of Somerset councillors are hopeless at doing the job of representing residents and standing up for them.

And as our council tax investigation discovered, Bolton was not alone is persistently failing to pay his council tax.

We also know that Paul Bolton is not alone in not attending meetings and not representing the people that he is supposed to.

At Lib Dem-run Mendip District Council, councillors have repeatedly let off councillors for not attending meetings for over six months.

At South Somerset District Council, the former Leader of the Council, Lib Dem Ric Pallister, has been jailed for eleven years - whilst the Standards Committee failed to meet.

And the current Lib Dem Leader of South Somerset faced a vote of no confidence this month. The Police and HMRC are involved in investigations. It really is shameful.

At least Somerset West and Taunton council removed Paul Bolton, as they should do - unlike Mendip.

At Mendip, as documented on this website, Wells Lib Dem Councillor Catherine McKinnell skived off for months - councillors approved her disappearance for longer - and then resigned, causing a by-election. She was not removed by councillors - she was protected by them!

And then last year, there were even more Mendip councillors who did not turn up for meetings and were let off by other councillors.

Somerset's councils resemble holiday camps, instead of serving the people. Will this new Unitary Authority be any better? This is unlikely, as it will inherit the bad councillors, bad officers and bad debts from the existing councils!

The general standard of councils in Somerset is appalling.

But this is no different to other parts of England. I should know, as a former councillor in a unitary authority for eight years. Most councillors cannot be bothered to do the work needed.

The general standard of councillor in Somerset is also appalling. 

And the general standards of council officer is poor - but this is no surprise as the councillors do not provide leadership to the council officers. 

The lack of investigative journalism in Somerset by those paid to do it, is shameful.

It is mostly left to volunteers at Somerset Independents to do the investigating, while those paid to do it are living the easy life. Other than Somerset Independents, only The Leveller does any investigative reporting - the rest are skiving off, or reporting on dogs on skateboards instead of holding the powerful to account.

SomersetLive, the County Gazette and West Country Bylines all failed to report on councillors who did not pay their council tax, despite us giving them all the information FOR FREE! We were even berated by the  former editor of the County Gazette, for our investigation. What he said to us will shock you. It doesn't shock us, because we know how bad these news outlets are.

80%-90% of Somerset councillors are rubbish. But Somerset's MPs are no better. It is no surprise when the local media are absent without leave.

There is a serious lack of democracy and accountability in our great County.

Some drastic things have to change, if residents are to be proud of their councillors, their MPs and their councils. 
We have already outlined what we think needs to change and we have made councils change. But these first two years are only the beginning."


---

VICTORY (Jan 2022)! We are delighted to report that following our investigation into his failure to pay council tax, Councillor Bolton has now resigned - or has been removed - as a Somerset West and Taunton district councillor. 

We have been waiting for officers of Somerset West and Taunton Council to advise us of the reasons for Bolton's departure. Despite chasing more than once, we have not been advised.  

The Britain Elects preview of the by-election, which has now been polled resulting in a narrow Liberal Democrat victory, mentions our work as a pressure group.

Leader of Somerset Independents, Andrew Pope, says:

Andrew Pope

"It is right that Paul Bolton is no longer a Somerset West and Taunton councillor.

Residents across the County of Somerset have told Somerset Independents that there is no valid excuse for any councillor to remain a representative of the people, if they are persistently in arrears on their own council tax.

Councillor Bolton eventually paid up, but only after we exposed his non-payment.

Meeting minutes show that he was also absent from many council meetings during 2021. If councillors are absent for more than six months, then they lose their seat.

Whatever the reasons, councillors that do not represent their residents, should not be councillors.

A by-election in the Alcombe ward has been triggered and the candidates have been confirmed - a Lib Dem, Tory, Labour and an Independent. We hope that the Independent is a better representative than Paul Bolton, if elected.

Now the other councillor in arrears who we contacted, Kelly Durdan, who refused to answer our questions when we contacted her on multiple occasions, should follow Paul Bolton and resign too. That's what residents demand."


---

UPDATE (10:15am 29/6/21): After pressure from Somerset Independents, Councillor Paul Bolton has now paid the arrears. He said in a message to our Leader Andrew Pope this morning:

"After our discussion on the phone yesterday I have taken legal advice and paid the amount in full as you can see from screenshot below of receipt and I shall continue my dispute and if need be shall claim costs back if owed at a later date. As I said I have no wish to avoid paying my council tax. And as for not replying to your emails sooner your emails were found in my junk folder. As I have stated to you on the phone yesterday i was informed in feb by the revenue department that my outstanding balance was £150 which was paid on the 11th feb. And as far as I was aware that was the end of the matter until more recently. I was not aware of the alleged full outstanding balance until I found your attachment regarding the freedom of information request. But rest assured I am now fully paid up until the start of the next financial year."

Somerset Independents listens to residents. It acts for residents.

Because we are residents, just like you!

---

Somerset Independents has been campaigning to expose councillors who have not paid their council tax. 

Councillor Paul Bolton is an Independent councillor for Alcombe in West Somerset. He is also currently the Mayor of Minehead and a Town Councillor in Minehead. 

Cllr Bolton is in arrears with his council tax. We now publish details of Cllr Bolton's arrears that we obtained from officers of Somerset West and Taunton Council, in our Freedom of Information request.

Just in case the text is not visible, here it is, including the statement by the Council that "All balances remain outstanding":

"No payments received for 2019/20 or
2020/21
In arrears of £1,747.82
Reminder notices issued - prior to 22/05/19
for 2019/20, then a court summons 05/07/19,
Liability Order granted 24/07/2019, Request
for Financial information sent 25/07/19 but no
response
For 20/21 - reminder notice issued 23/07/20,
second reminder 23/10/2020, third reminder
All balances remain outstanding"

Somerset Independents had no reason to believe that the Council's FoI response was not accurate.

However, we wanted to offer a right of reply to Cllr Bolton.

We offered Cllr Bolton a right of reply on 4th June 2021 via email. Cllr Bolton did not reply. Then he did not reply on 6th June. He did not reply on 11th June either.

Cllr Bolton's Group Leader Councillor Gwilym Wren was copied in, to see if he would be able to assist us to get answers. No response was received from Cllr Wren.

So we phoned Cllr Bolton and left a voicemail. Cllr Bolton tried to ring back but left no message. So we rang him again and there was a conversation.

In the conversation, Cllr Bolton said that he had no intention of not paying council tax. He also mentioned a long-running dispute with the Council and its predecessor council before the merger, West Somerset.

Yet the council tax remains unpaid.

So we have asked Cllr Bolton to put in writing his response to the above FoI response from SWT Council.

And we've made it clear that Cllr Bolton needs to respond very soon with his explanation and answers to our questions.

Somerset Independents will continue its campaign to expose councillors who expect you to pay your council tax and increase your council tax, but do not pay their own council tax. We will expose any councillor - whether independent or in one of the Westminster parties.

Councillors are public officials once they take office. They are no longer private individuals.

By not paying their council tax, these councillors are breaching the Council's Code of Conduct, the Nolan Principles that all public officials are bound by, and they are outraging Somerset residents with their recalcitrance.

We await Cllr Bolton's answers.




Saturday, June 26, 2021

Disgraced West Somerset Councillor Kelly Durdan Refuses To Answer Why She Didn't Pay Council Tax

 

Councillor Kelly Durdan

Councillor Kelly Durdan is an elected councillor for Creech St. Michael, near Taunton in Somerset, as shown on the Somerset West and Taunton Council website. 

Somerset Independents has been campaigning to expose councillors who have not paid their council tax, because councillors are holders of power over residents and hold elected public office. This makes them accountable to the public and they are not ordinary residents while they hold that public office. This isn't only our view. It is the accepted view of the law.

Councillors in Somerset had the power to even put your council tax up during a Global Pandemic. We asked them not to do it, with Somerset Independents speaking at all four district councils and the county council, plus the Police and Crime Panel. But councillors did put up your council tax anyway. This was not right. It was not justified.

So if councillors put up OUR council tax, councillors should be paying council tax themselves, right? WRONG. Our investigations have found councillors who have not paid. Not just for one or two months, but over YEARS!

Councillor Kelly Durdan is one of these. Somerset Independents are now revealing the full extent of her record of non-payment of council tax, going back before Covid-19.  Here is an extract from the response to our Freedom of Information request to Somerset West and Taunton Council (our emblem added):

Extract from Somerset Independents
Freedom of Information Request
To Somerset West and Taunton Council

As you can see:

  1. reminders were sent to Councillor Durdan for the previous year in January 2020 and February 2020, before the first lockdown
  2. more reminders were sent to Councillor Durdan in August 2020, September 2020, October 2020 and March 2021
  3. A COURT SUMMONS was issued in April 2021
  4. A LIABILITY ORDER was granted in May 2021

We asked Cllr Durdan a set of further questions including why she was in arrears, but she refused to answer our emails. She also refused to answer whether she was now fully up-to-date.

We have offered Councillor Durdan the right of reply on several occasions. We didn't have to. We had no reason to believe that the Council's response was not accurate. Out of courtesy, we offered her the right of reply.

We have offered it to her again. But the public deserve to know about their councillors.

The latest was a phone call yesterday, when Cllr Durdan falsely claimed that this was the first time that we had contacted her. 

We had previously contacted her by email on 4th June 2021. And on 6th June 2021. We also copied her into other correspondence with her Group Leader Councillor Gwilym Wren, in relation to her fellow offender Councillor Paul Bolton. Cllr Durdan never responded.

So in a final effort to get an answer we phoned Cllr Durdan. 

Instead of apologising to the public for her arrears, and trying to give an explanation on her arrears that pre-dated the Global Pandemic, Cllr Durdan got irate and hung up. She told us that we should contact her Group Leader Councillor Gwilym Wren. We had already tried that! He didn't reply either.

Somerset Independents Officer Denise Wyatt called Cllr Durdan:

Denise Wyatt

Denise reacted to Cllr Durdan hanging up on her and failing to answer:

"It is bad enough that this councillor failed to pay her council tax over so many months and over years.

She had to be sent reminders by her own Council, that she is a councillor on, in January 2020 and many times afterwards.

So Cllr Durdan was in arrears BEFORE the Global Pandemic.

I asked her for an explanation. She didn't give one. Cllr Durdan tried to claim that this was all due to the Pandemic. It wasn't. She was already in arrears going back to 2019.

She should resign."

Somerset Independents has asked residents of the Somerset West and Taunton (SWT) Council area what they think about councillors in their area who don't pay their council tax.

Taunton resident Shawn said:

"Councillors not paying their council tax is disgusting behaviour by Somerset West and Taunton councillors. I can't actually believe this even happens, and the Council Leadership watches it happen! What has gone wrong with the moral authority of our councillors?

As a local resident, I think any councillor in arrears should be suspended and allowances stopped until they have fully paid up. This seems perfectly reasonable to me and I think 99% of residents would agree with me."

In reference to Councillor Paul Bolton and Councillor Kelly Durdan, those of SWT Council who have both received a court summons and liability order, Shawn says:

"I think they should resign, they’ve lost all moral authority to represent their constituents who they expect to pay their council tax. I really can't believe this goes on. I also wonder what the SWT Council leadership are doing about this, anything or simply turning a blind eye?"

We agree with this resident and we have suggested to both Councillor Bolton and Councillor Durdan that they should resign.

We have also suggested to Councillor Wren that Cllr Bolton and Cllr Durdan be removed from his Group. We have also made this point to other "independent" members of this Group of Councillors. We have had no response.

Somerset Independent has discovered that many, if not all, of the councillors in the SWT Council Group of "Independents" were formerly Conservative Party members and/or had stood for Council as Tory candidates.

So our investigations have not only shown these councillors to be serial offenders in not paying their council tax. They are also fake independents. And they are giving true independent councillors a bad name.

Bolton and Durdan must go. Local residents demand it, who told us:

Resident A: "That is disgraceful. They should not need to resign - they should be automatically excluded. There are so many people who struggle to manage on very low incomes but still pay their council tax etc. Why should these people get away with it. Not fit to hold office."

Resident B: "They should resign or be expelled. They are not fit to hold a position of Councillor."

Resident C: "They’re all only looking out for themselves just like the MPs! We’re all right Jack, don’t worry about anyone else!"

We agree. And we are taking action against these councillors, PCCs and MPs too. Councillors should have criminal records checks before they are elected. And they should be checked regularly thereafter.

Somerset Independents will continue its work with residents in investigating and exposing dodgy councillors, MPs or PCCs in Somerset, whether in the national political parties or bringing the name of "independent" councillors into disrepute.

 

Standing Up For Residents


Sunday, June 6, 2021

UPDATE (29/6/21): Somerset West and Taunton Councillor Offenders Who Didn't Pay Their Council Tax On Time

 

Somerset West and Taunton

UPDATE (29/6/21): We've now spoken to both councillors who are the worst offenders on their arrears on council tax. There are two new articles that we have published with the details of their arrears and their responses.

Councillor Kelly Durdan article is here. It includes the views of local residents to her failure to pay her council tax.

Councillor Paul Bolton article is here. We have asked him to prove his claims in response to his arrears. Update (10.15am 29/6/21). Due to action from Somerset Independents, Cllr Bolton has now PAID UP! more on the article at the link above.

ZERO of the other four councillors have responded to our request for answers on their arrears. As we've said before, their arrears are not as serious as Cllr Durdan or Cllr Bolton. But we would appreciate answers from Councillors Blaker, Davies, Tully and Kravis.

---

UPDATE (14/6/21): Unlike Mendip District Council who only gave partial answers, Somerset West and Taunton gave detailed answers in response to our Freedom of Information request on councillors in arrears on their council tax.

Some of the details are below. Some we are still withholding until we have heard back from those councillors. We will not wait forever.

We want to hear it from the councillors themselves.

So now, we have asked all six councillor questions to confirm the details of their arrears.

The most serious offenders - Councillor Bolton and Councillor Kelly Durdan - have still failed to respond.

The less serious offenders - Councillors Blaker, Davies, Tully, Kravis - have received questions asking them about their short period of arrears. 

We await their answers.

---

UPDATE (11/6/21): We have sent the full details to Councillor Paul Bolton in a final attempt to get an answer. We intend to publish them if we don't get an adequate answer soon.  We will be doing the same for Councillor Kelly Durdan.

---

UPDATE (10/6/21): Councillor Paul Bolton and Councillor Kelly Durdan have still not responded to our offer of a right of reply to our questions.

Neither councillor has answered our suggestion that they should consider resigning as councillors. 

Councillor Paul Bolton is the current Mayor of Minehead and Independent Councillor for Alcombe.

Councillor Kelly Durdan is a former Conservative Council candidate and now Independent Councillor for Creech St. Michael.

We hope that they will answer our questions and consider their positions as councillors.

---

Somerset Independents has discovered that SIX councillors on Somerset West and Taunton (SWT) District Council did not pay their council tax on time.

This Council was formed without a Referendum and against the wishes of residents of the West Somerset and Taunton Deane councils.

The councillors who were in arrears were as follows (you can click on the links for more details, including their email addresses and contact details - in case you want to ask them why they didn't pay):

Councillor Mark Blaker (Independent, Wiveliscombe and District)

Councillor Hugh Davies (Independent, Watchet and Williton)

Councillor Marcus Kravis (was Liberal Democrat, now "Non-Party Aligned", and still "Portfolio Holder for Asset Management and Economic Development")

Councillor Ray Tully (Liberal Democrat, West Monkton and Cheddon Fitzpaine)

Councillor Paul Bolton (Independent, Alcombe) and currently Mayor of Minehead Town Council

Councillor Kelly Durdan (Independent and former Conservative candidate, Creech St Michael)

Now, the severity of the arrears of council tax varies.

The top four councillors - Blaker, Davies, Kravis and Tully - have now paid up according to the information that we have received from SWT Council. They received reminders and paid up.

But Councillor Paul Bolton and Councillor Kelly Durdan were so far in arrears that they received a court summons. And they still had not paid up despite both receiving a liability order. The arrears were not just for the 2020/21 financial year but going over a longer period!

We have asked both Councillor Bolton and Councillor Durdan a series of questions, to offer them a right of reply.

We have also suggested that they should resign as councillors.

We did not receive any response before we published this article (Sunday 6th June 1100 hours). We gave them two days.

We think that both Councillor Bolton and Councillor Durdan should resign their seats on this Council and any other council that they are a member of. They are not fit to represent Somerset residents.

Denise Wyatt, the Nominations Officer for Somerset Independents who chooses candidates for election for the Party, says: 

Denise Wyatt

"Somerset Independents has no association with any of the so-called "independents" on SWT Council. Their election was before we were formed in March 2020.

We are delighted to make this clear, especially with the awful behaviour of these two "independent" councillors.

We have made clear to both councillors and their Group Leader Councillor Gwil Wren that if Councillor Bolton or Councillor Durdan had been elected as Somerset Independents councillors, that they would have already been expelled from the Somerset Independents Party and Somerset Independents political group on the Council."


Friday, June 4, 2021

CAMPAIGN UPDATE: They Put Up Your Council Tax BUT Did Your Councillor Pay Their Council Tax?

 

Challenging Councillors

Somerset Independents asked the councillors on the district councils and the county council to refuse the increases to your council tax. Councillors voted on your council tax in February 2021. 

We spoke at the February public meetings of "Full Council" and said that councillors had mis-spent public money on the wrong priorities and that people were struggling during the Global Pandemic.

But councillors voted through the increases.

It is entirely reasonable that residents who pay their council tax expect that councillors would pay their council tax, especially when those same councillors increase our council tax and get paid an allowance from public money.

Councillors do not get a salary, but do get an allowance. The councillor allowance is paid for by those residents who DO pay their council tax.

The majority of residents pay their council tax, but it is clear from what we have found that some of Somerset's councillors HAVE NOT PAID THEIR COUNCIL TAX.

After all, amongst many other important decisions that affect residents and their lives, it is councillors that decide how much council tax residents have to pay and what the council tax that residents pay is spent on.

Somerset Independents has been doing more investigation of the approximately 250 district and county councillors that are supposed to represent residents on the four district councils and one County Council.

Since our investigations discovered that not just one but TWO Mendip district councillors had NOT paid their council tax, we have been making more enquiries about the other councillors in Somerset.

Why? Because residents have told us that it is disgusting that councillors have not paid up, and especially so when it is revealed that those same councillors continued to claim their councillor allowance for doing their councillor duties. We decided to investigate further.

Here is what we have discovered so far (as at 4/6/21 1100 hours):

  • On Mendip District Council, Councillor Francis Hayden who is a Green Party Councillor for Cranmore, Doulting and Nunney, did not pay his council tax between April 2020 and February 2021 and possibly longer. He now claims to have paid it, although we have yet to have written confirmation from Mendip District Council.
  • Mendip District Council has refused to reveal the identity of another councillor who was in arrears. Somerset Independents has written to all Mendip District Councillors about the arrears, and we have asked them to come forward if they know which councillor was in arrears. Zero councillors responded with the name. One Green councillor, Michael Dunk (Frome Market), even defended his Green Party colleague Councillor Hayden for not paying his council tax!
  • All Sedgemoor District councillors have paid their council tax, as confirmed to us directly by the Council.
  • SIX councillors on Somerset West and Taunton (SWT) District Council were in arrears over the 2019/20 and 2020/21 financial years. We are offering the right of reply to councillors before publishing the full details. But what we have found has happened with some of these six councillors is truly appalling. Unlike Mendip District Council, SWT Council have provided full details of the arrears and the names of the councillors.
  • A month after the information was requested, South Somerset District Council have still not replied to our request for the information on councillor who have not paid their council tax, despite two reminders. WHAT HAVE THEY GOT TO HIDE?

We will continue our investigations.

Standing Up For Residents


Friday, May 14, 2021

DEMOCRACY REFERENDUM: Somerset West and Taunton Council Backs Committee System

Somerset West and Taunton Council
was formed in a forced merger
WITHOUT a Referendum


We are pleased to report a positive development in our campaign for Somerset's councils to change to a committee system.

There is good news (woo!).

There is bad news (boo!).

The Good News is that Somerset West and Taunton Council has backed changing to a committee system and ditching the failed "Strong Leader" model where around 10 councillors decide everything. In a committee system, more councillors are involved in making decisions, making it more democratic.

The Bad News is that SWT Council will not change to a committee system now. It has been postponed to May 2022. Even worse than this is that they have not actually committed to it at all, only upon a condition. Councillors voted to bring in the committee system only if the council is not scrapped and replaced with a unitary authority. All they are doing now is changing some of the committees - see the decisions below, at the bottom of this article.

There was a huge number of votes and several very long meetings, showing how the "Strong Leader" model has failed, especially now that the Liberal Democrats have lost the majority they won in the 2019 elections. The Leader of the Council has remained the Leader of the Lib Dems and the Council, but has recently suffered a sequence of resignations and defections. Cabinet Members have been changed.

We understand that some councillors supported bringing in the committee system now, to set an example to any future council. But they were outvoted by other councillors.

Cabinet Member Councillor Chris Booth told us:

"You might have seen that at Full Council this issue very much split the political divides as others believed that changing over regardless could be a good precedent for a unitary council. However Full Council decided to maintain the view of the working group to include the backstop. Unfortunately Cllr Stone was deeply unhappy with this and so this plus his deep dislike of the national planning system ( he has my sympathies on that one) meant he felt he could no longer do the role. "

This is a missed opportunity.

It just shows that councillors cannot be trusted to act for Somerset residents, and that the "Strong Leader" model has broken down.

SWT Full Council resolved (full votes at the bottom of this article):

"2.1       The Council moves to a Committee system of governance from the Council AGM on 10 May 2022, unless a decision is made to set up a Unitary Council for the area from 2023.

2.2       The Council proposes to the Unitary Shadow Authority that a committee system of governance is adopted, if set up as the principal council for the area.

2.3      The Council writes to the Chief Executives and Leaders of the County and Districts to request ask that they consider that the Shadow Authority governance arrangements are set up as a Committee system"

The full decisions are below, at the bottom of this article.

Denise Wyatt

Denise Wyatt asked the councillors at Somerset West and Taunton directly at the virtual Full Council meeting to ensure that a Modern Committee System was on the ballot paper in the upcoming Referendum on how Somerset was governed, as well as a "No Change" option.

They refused to do that, although we did ask the councillors nicely. And more than once. The three other district councils also stuck with their "two buckets of manure" vote. The Lib Dems and other councillors patted themselves on the back, as if it was them that led the campaign for a Referendum.

In fact, they were opposed to a Referendum throughout 2020.

It was Somerset Independents that led the campaign. We were formed to stand up for Somerset residents and we have. But we are not happy with this half-baked Referendum.

As Denise told councillors, the ballot paper in their "choice of manure" public vote will be a Hobson's Choice. 

A Hobson's Choice where residents have to choose which bucket of manure to pour over their heads - the Stronger Somerset bucket of manure or the One Somerset bucket of manure.

So whilst Somerset Independents is pleased that a committee system is being discussed, it is not Somerset residents who will decide. That is what we have consistently said and campaigned for.

These decisions are being made by politicians in Westminster and Taunton.

We will continue our campaign for a Modern Committee System for the current councils and any future councils in our great County.

And for residents - not politicians - to decide.

 

Report of the Council Governance Arrangements Working Group

Recommendations were voted on 2.1-2.3, 2.4-2.5 and 2.6-2.11 and were all carried (3h 5m into the recording):-

            Relating to the 2022 Municipal Year

2.1       The Council moves to a Committee system of governance from the Council AGM on 10 May 2022, unless a decision is made to set up a Unitary Council for the area from 2023.

2.2       The Council proposes to the Unitary Shadow Authority that a committee system of governance is adopted, if set up as the principal council for the area.

2.3      The Council writes to the Chief Executives and Leaders of the County and Districts to request ask that they consider that the Shadow Authority governance arrangements are set up as a Committee system

            Relating to the 2021 Municipal Year

2.4       That a second Scrutiny Committee is introduced from the AGM in 2021, with the focus being Corporate Scrutiny Committee and Community Scrutiny Committee.  The split of workload for the two Scrutiny Committees (see Annex A at the end of this report) is approved

2.5       That the number of seats on both Scrutiny Committees is 15 from the start of the 2021/2022 Municipal Year

2.6       The Audit, Governance and Standards Committee is split into two separate Committees from the AGM in 2021, for the 2021/22 Municipal Year and becomes Audit and Governance Committee and Standards Committee.  The Terms of Reference for both Committees (see Annex B and Annex C at the end of this report) is approved.

2.7       That the number of seats on the Audit and Governance Committee is 11 from the start of the 2021/2022 Municipal Year

2.8       That the number of seats on the Standards Committee is 9 from the start of the 2021/2022 Municipal Year

2.9       The role of Shadow Portfolio Holders is included within the Constitution as per the wording in Annex D to this report

2.10     Officers and Portfolio Holders are reminded of requirements to provide information and notifications to Ward Councillors as per the Member Officer Protocol

2.11      The Corporate Scrutiny Committee are asked to work with officers to consider a system for communicating reports to Members from representatives from outside bodies