Thursday, September 1, 2022

VICTORY! Another Green Fields Campaign Won in North Somerset - But What Happens Next?

 

One of our Official emblems

 

"I am pleased that we helped to defeat it and to stand up for local residents, because that is what Somerset Independents was formed to do."

The Butts Batch development in Wrington by Strongvox has been defeated. The planning inspector G.D. Jones has dismissed the appeal after North Somerset Council had rejected the planning application.

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We stood up for residents of Wrington against a poor development. Our Leader Andrew Pope objected to the application and encouraged others to do so.

We worked with campaigners in Wrington and provided advice to the Keep Wrington as Wrington campaign.

We also held the local Independent North Somerset Councillor Steve Hogg to account, when he repeatedly refused to formally object to the application. We urged him to be stronger in his opposition and in fairness, he was.

But what happens next?

Andrew Pope says:

 

Andrew Pope
Leader of Somerset Independents

 

"This was the wrong development in the wrong place at the wrong time. I am pleased that we helped to defeat it and to stand up for local residents, because that is what Somerset Independents was formed to do.

However, it is just a matter of time before another application comes forward and it will start all over again.

Whether it will be Strongvox or another applicant, we will see.

So while the battle for Butts Batch has been won for now, it will be the site of another battle if the future application is not acceptable to local residents.

Whether us volunteers at Somerset Independents will campaign against it, and who we will work with or not work with, remains to be seen."



Who Are Somerset Independents?

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Saturday, August 27, 2022

We Asked Mayday Saxonvale Some Questions - Here Are Their Answers


 

One of our Official emblems

Following the mess at Saxonvale, Frome getting even messier, we asked Mayday Saxonvale some questions. Here are their answers. Residents can make up their own minds as to whether they answered our questions and what they think of the answers.


Questions from Somerset Independents To Mayday Saxonvale


We asked you Mayday Saxonvale on multiple occasions how it would be tenable for two applications, given that Mendip had approved one scheme before you submitted Mayday. Mayday Saxonvale never provided an answer. 

We listened to residents and businesses and objected to the Acorn proposals, with our Leader Andrew Pope speaking at the Planning Board. But the fact remained that Mendip approved it. 

There is already legal action as we reported on a long time ago. This was confirmed by legal at the Mendip Asset Management Group (AMG) meeting yesterday. 

So is Mayday now going to cost the taxpayer even more money in legal costs? 

What will you do when Mendip is scrapped and the New Council comes into force?

Are you just giving people false hope now? 

Have you tried to get Mendip and Acorn to stop their scheme? If you did, why weren't you successful?


Mayday Saxonvale's Answers

 

"Approving the signing of the S106, MDC will contravene planning law on two main counts.

Firstly, now that the Mayday recommendation is a matter of material consideration, Acorn’s application should now go back to the Planning Board meaning no consent should be signed until that is done.

Secondly, the ownership of Saxonvale is passing across to Somerset so in the S106, the enforcer and the enforcee are the same person. There is no provision in the text of the S106 for this. We will update with more information on the legal position in due course.

However, as we stated above for the first time, the council set out its position on the comparison of the two schemes. They confirmed the Acorn scheme will be re-evaluated and MDC are not bound to proceed. They confirmed they have the mechanisms to consider other options, such as Mayday Saxonvale, and proceed with them if they wish.

Mendip Council leaders have made choices and we will be holding them to account."

 

Who Are Somerset Independents?

Somerset Independents are a residents group that puts residents first. We stand up for residents.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Saxonvale, Frome - The Lib Dems' Mess at Mendip Gets Even Messier - Brownfield Last, Frome's Green Fields First

 

Dodgy Council, Dodgy Councillors

One of our Official emblems

 

"Two big developments at the same site? Ridiculous...This mess is going to drag on and on, way past when Mendip District Council will cease to exist in 2023. It will be a mess inherited by the New Somerset Council, via the courts. The legal bill will cost the taxpayer a lot of money." Andrew Pope, Leader of Somerset Independents

Somerset Independents puts residents first. We have stood up for local residents and businesses in the face of Mendip District Council's mess at Saxonvale, Frome.

Our Leader Andrew Pope spoke at the Planning Board against the Acorn proposal that was so reviled. We listened to residents and acted for them.

But as reported by us, the dodgy Planning Board approved the Acorn proposal. Mendip District Council also owns the land. This is a clear conflict of interest, which Mendip claims to have managed. 

Sadly, Mendip cannot be believed, because they have not managed conflicts of interest elsewhere, including councillors voting through a planning application on land owned by a fellow councillor - and claiming that they didn't know him!

This was the "Sandys Hill Lane" development on the outskirts of Frome, near the McDonald's and Sainsbury's complex. Land involved in that application is owned by Councillor Philip Ham. 

 

Councillor Philip Ham
(Photo: Mendip District Council)

Our investigation was reported in Private Eye and remains one of the most popular articles on this website.

Mendip has dodgy councillors and is a dodgy council. We've proved it time and time again. We tried to get them to reform their ways. Our campaigns have succeeded, including at Easthill, Frome and in reform of the Planning Board. But Mendip had already made a mess at Saxonvale, a brownfield site, dithering and delaying while approving development on the green fields around Frome.

Brownfield land has come last at Saxonvale, but greenfield development in Frome has preceded it, including at Sandys Hill Lane. It's tragic. It's wrong.

So when we heard that an alternative proposal was being proposed for Saxonvale, we were curious about it.

We asked Mayday Saxonvale on more than one occasion how they proposed to manage having two planning applications being approved for the same site. They did not answer. But that situation has now occurred. It happened at the Mendip Planning Board last week.

And to make matters worse, this week, the Asset Management Group approved the signing of the Section 106 Agreement for the Acorn development, further sealing the fate of the Saxonvale site, which remember, Mendip owns.

At the Asset Management Group (AMG) meeting this week, the legal adviser Lesley Dolan stated, when asked by "opposition" (hardly!) Councillor Tom Killen (Conservative) that there was no reason why they could not agree to allow the S106 agreement to be signed.  
 
No councillor voted at that meeting against signing the Agreement between Mendip and Acorn. The head financial officer, Richard Bates, also said there was no alternative but to do so.
 
The AMG resolved to sign the S106 with Acorn, but councillors claim that everything is hunky dory. IT ISN'T. Actions speak louder than words. It took the Lib Dems at Mendip years to get to this point and Mendip dithered and delayed.

Tory Councillor Tom Killen said at the AMG meeting that he was "proud" that the Council had bought the land when he was Deputy Leader of Mendip. That's some claim, given that it has generated zero revenue since Mendip bought it. We discovered this during our investigations of the Mendip accounts and our objections to their governance in managing public money.
 
 

What is a Section 106 (S106) Agreement?

It is an agreement between the planning authority (Mendip District Council in this case) and the applicant / developer (in this case Acorn). It places obligations on the developer. 

It is usually the last part of planning permission before the final go-ahead is given as permission. So when the Planning Board gave permission to the Acorn proposal a long time ago now (Somerset Independents opposed it and our Leader Andrew Pope spoke against at the Planning Board), it was subject to this S106 agreement being agreed. 

So technically there is an opportunity to stop the development, but Mendip District Council have shown no sign of stopping it.


What Happens Now?

At the AMG, the legal adviser mentioned that there was legal action - a Judicial Review relating to the demolition at the Saxonvale site. 

Also at the AMG, the THREAT (not realised yet) was made via Councillor John Clark that if they agreed to sign the S106 there would be a Judicial Review. In reality, it was not clear what Cllr Clark was threatening as he did not seem to understand what he was threatening (such is the way with Green councillors). We believe this Judicial Review is threatened by Mayday Saxonvale.

So if that were to occur, there would be at least two pieces of legal action, putting even more delays in the way of actual development going ahead. Saxonvale remains a derelict site.


Andrew Pope, Leader of Somerset Independents, says:
 
Andrew Pope

 
"How can you have two developments at the same site? Mendip District Council that own the land on behalf of Somerset residents, are playing everyone for fools!
 
This mess is going to drag on and on, way past when Mendip District Council will cease to exist in 2023. 
 
It will be a mess inherited by the New Somerset Council - the unitary authority that nobody wanted other than the Tories and the Lib Dems who have benefited from it - via the courts. 
 
The legal bill will cost the taxpayer a lot of money and it will be Somerset residents who will pay. It's just wrong and a terrible mess created by the Lib Dems."
 
We asked Mayday Saxonvale to respond to the situation and have received an answer from them, which we have published. Residents can make up their own minds as to whether they have answered our questions or not.


Who Are Somerset Independents?

We are a campaign group formed by residents to stand up for residents across the County of Somerset - North, South, East and West.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.