Sunday, July 24, 2022

EXPLAINER: What Is A Local Democracy Reporter? We Interviewed One to Find Out...

Somerset Independents Investigates
 

It’s the “purest form” of journalism being a “window into the Council” but your work might get garbled, edited or completely misinterpreted - even by media organisations - a Local Democracy Reporter (LDR) tells us.
 

One of our Official emblems

 

Somerset Independents puts residents first. 

Residents have been asking "What is a Local Democracy Reporter?" when they see it in articles on the BBC website, SomersetLive (if they can get past the ads), Somerset County Gazette and other local media outlets. 

And they've been asking, "How can one person work for so many media outlets?".

To get some answers, Andrew Pope (pictured) interviewed a Local Democracy Reporter from a City in England, who we have agreed to keep anonymous to protect his position and his career as a journalist.

Andrew Pope
Leader of Somerset Independents

Why did you take the job as an LDR?

“I thought it’s the purest form of journalism, because you’re doing exactly what a journalist is supposed to be doing.”


What do you see as the role of an LDR?

“To be a window into the Council so that people in the City or the Council that you’re doing it for know exactly what is going on. The Council do issue press releases that go to the newspapers but those press releases are always what the Council is doing, they are not two-sided. They are one-sided.

It’s the Council celebrating themselves and that’s not democracy so your job is to get straight through that press release into the Council. You’re not part of the Council, you’re an independent person and so people know that you are on their side and they tell you what the Council is actually doing.”


Who gets to use your work and are they allowed to modify the articles?

“It is published on The Wire which is run by the BBC. I put everything as an LDR on there... only 1,000 different publications in the country can access it.”

“They can completely (modify the articles), that’s the thing.”



So they can take a completely different editorial attitude to what you’d written?

“Yes.”


And what can you do about that? How can you complain if they garble your work?

“You can’t do anything about that. They can do what they want with your work, as long as they do it professionally.”

 

 

Daniel Mumby
Local Democracy Reporter

 

Daniel Mumby (pictured above) is the Local Democracy Reporter (LDR) for most of Somerset, the part of Somerset that is covered by Somerset County Council and the four district councils that fall within the same boundary. He is hosted by Reach (SomersetLive), not the BBC.

Stephen Sumner used to be the LDR for North Somerset Council and Bath and North East Somerset Council. He left many weeks ago. 

Somerset Independents have confirmed with Reach, who employ all LDRs in the Somerset/Bath/Bristol Region, that the position remains vacant. 

The job ad is at the link here, although the ad had expired one month before the time of this article.

Adam Postans is the LDR for Bristol, also hosted by Reach.

Reach is a private media organisation (formerly Trinity Mirror). It receives public money from the BBC for the LDRs. It is one of three media organisations that dominate LDRs across the UK, as shown by our analysis here.

Somerset Independents approached Reach LDRs to ask them to report on our investigations into councillors who were in arrears on their council tax - in all parts of the county of Somerset and in Bristol.

No story whatsoever has been published by Reach using our investigation, although we did provide significant information to the Reach LDRs. They did not prioritise it.

We have complained to their editors, Pete Gavan and Stephen D'Albiac, as we believe this story is clearly of significant public interest.

We know that the public is interested, from the reactions that residents express. Residents are usually outraged and angry when we tell them that councillors did not pay up.


Who Are Somerset Independents?

We stand up for residents and help residents to stand up for themselves.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Friday, July 22, 2022

Tories Go, Chief Executive Goes: Lib Dem Councillors at Somerset County Council Appoint New Chief Executive

Tory Councillor David Fothergill
is now ex-Leader of the Council

 

One of our Official emblems

 

Somerset Independents puts residents first. The Tories at Somerset County Council conspired with Boris Johnson's Tory Government to force through changes to Somerset's councils - against the wishes of the majority of Somerset's residents. If you remember, previously they had cancelled an election in which our candidates were ready to stand. Then we boycotted the 2022 elections which were not cancelled.

So we laughed with glee when Councillor David Fothergill refused to speak to the Local Democracy Reporter Daniel Mumby. He blamed "inappropriate" coverage by Mr Mumby. But everyone knows it was because the Tories had lost so many council seats in the May 2022 elections and Fothergill was having a strop.

Councillor Fothergill was, until then, the Leader of Somerset County Council. Now his "Local Conservatives" had lost control of the Council. Fothergill's candidates tried distancing themselves from Boris Johnson's corrupt Government despite working hand-in-glove with them - including proven dodgy Cabinet Member Robert Jenrick - to change Somerset's councils. Johnson has gone and so has Fothergill. Good riddance to both of them.

Sadly, the Lib Dems gained from the Tory demise. Lib Dem or Tory, same old story.

When the Lib Dems took majority control of the County Council, they discovered that Chief Executive Pat Flaherty was leaving to go to Harrow. Not the school, but the Council. Obviously they may have persuaded him to leave. These details are not shared with the public - see our reports on other senior officers at Somerset's councils who left under a cloud of mystery. The public just pay the council officer's huge wages, possibly huge severance package and suffer when they cut services against what the public wants or needs.

So the new Fib Dem councillors had to appoint a new Chief Executive. And they have chosen Duncan Sharkey. Unlike the lazy and censored news outlets in and around Somerset, Somerset Independents does not parrot press releases. If you want to read what Somerset County Council wants you to read, you can go to their website and see a huge photo of Mr Sharkey's impression of the Cheshire Cat from Alice in Wonderland. We include the same photo but much smaller.

Duncan Sharkey

Mr Sharkey is currently Managing Director at the Royal Borough of Windsor and Maidenhead. You can go and find out about what has happened there, if you know how to look.

It seems that we know more about Mr Sharkey than other media outlets. 

And it seems that we know more about Mr Sharkey's performance at previous councils than the Lib Dem councillors that hired him. Or perhaps they omitted some information from the County Council's PR spin?

Nice things are said about these highly-paid council officers by councillors when they join. 

Nice things are said about them when they leave by councillors (usually). Sometimes honest councillors make balanced assessments in public, but not often.

Mr Sharkey will be paid:

  • £195,000 per year. Yes, you read that right:
  • £16,250 per month or 
  • £3,750 per week. 

This is what the Lib Dem councillors have decided.

Will Mr Sharkey be worth this huge sum? 

Will Mr Sharkey be able to cope with the huge change of scale from a Borough Council to the New Somerset Council that covers a much larger area and will destroy the district councils AND County Council, and take on bad debts, suffer proven bad councillors and take on the disastrous legacies of the districts and county councils? 

And does Mr Sharkey know where the skeletons are in the closet, some of which have been exposed by Somerset Independents and Somerset Tory MP Ian Liddell-Grainger (where are the other MPs - filling their coffers with Boris Johnson's corrupt payroll, or under investigation by Parliament)?

Somerset residents, who will pay his extortionate salary, are about to find out all of the above when he finally takes up the post in a few months time - the County says "the Autumn" which is a bit vague. The reasons for the vagueness were not explained.

Is Mr Sharkey "the boss" as described by the BBC's part-time reporter Ruth Bradley? No, he is the Head of Paid Service. The councillors are supposed to be the boss, especially Councillor Bill Revans but also his Cabinet. Councillors are supposed to represent the public.

But as readers of this website will know, many councillors lack the leadership required, and rely on officers who then can run things in their interests instead of the public interest. The proverbial "Sir Humphrey" as fans of Yes, Prime Minister will know.

That is not democracy, but bureaucracy. Sadly that seems to be all-too-common at Somerset's councils because the Lib Dem or Tory councillors are not up to the job.

Time will tell in all of these things.


Who Are Somerset Independents?

We inform Somerset residents. We advise Somerset residents to be able to stand up for themselves and to hold to account national and local authority.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.




Wednesday, July 20, 2022

UPDATE (25/1/23): Regulator Agrees With Bristol! - Regulator Confirms Investigation into Bristol City Council - Council Refuses TWICE To Tell Us Which Councillors Did Not Pay Their Council Tax - We've Complained To The Information Commissioner

 

One of our Official emblems

UPDATE (25/1/23)

You may find it hard to believe... But after many months since they were going to investigate, the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) has issued a Decision Notice as below, which shows that they agreed with Bristol City Council that they can keep the identity SECRET of councillor or councillors who did not pay their council tax.

The ICO, in their Decision Notice have written to us to say the following. Therefore the people of Bristol will not know the names of councillors who did not pay up.

"The Commissioner does not require the Council to take any steps."

and despite:

"The Commissioner considers that the complainant is pursuing a
legitimate interest and that disclosure of the requested information is necessary to meet that legitimate interest."

that the ICO decided:

"The Council explained its reasons to the Commissioner as to why the circumstances in this case are compelling enough that to disclose the information would be unfair and unlawful."

"The Commissioner has chosen not to put the council’s explanations in this decision notice, as to do so could, in itself, reveal personal data of the Councillor which could lead to their identity being revealed...
Having considered the Council’s explanations for this case, the
Commissioner has determined that there is insufficient legitimate
interest to outweigh the fundamental rights and freedoms of the
individual in this specific case and considers that there is no legal basis for the council to disclose the withheld information and to do so would be in breach of principle (a)...
The Commissioners decision is that the Council is entitled to rely on section 40(2) of FOIA to refuse to provide the information it has
withheld to this request."

We would also like to remind you that we asked local media outlets to cover this story. They did not.

---

UPDATE (23/7/22)

The Regulator has confirmed today that our complaint about Bristol City Council is now eligible for investigation by the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO).

We imagine that Bristol is used to this, as they have been reported, repeatedly, to have failed to meet their obligations under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (see below). Anecdotally, we know this from other concerned citizens such as Mike Owen (again, see below).

So we await the result of the investigation, which might be a long wait.

It confirms that we were right to go the ICO.

---

So we have submitted another complaint to the Information Commissioner's Office about Bristol City Council's refusal to name councillors and give details of arrears.

Local campaigner Mike Owen told us: 

"I was surprised how councillors could manage to ignore reminders, and offer the public excuses akin to the dog ate my coursework.

Marvin Rees promised to carry out checks on councillors' council tax arrears, can I assume that all is 'really' ship shape and Bristol fashion when no public update is provided?"

Our Leader Andrew Pope submitted a Freedom of Information (FoI) request to Bristol City Council in March 2022. 

 

Andrew Pope
Leader of Somerset Independents

The FoI was ignored by Bristol City Council. So Andrew contacted the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), who ordered Bristol City Council to respond. 

Eventually, they responded. And the FoI was refused by Bristol City Council.

Then Andrew asked the Council for an Internal Review. Despite taking an age for the internal review, Bristol City Council still refused to give out information on councillors in arrears.

Andrew has referred the case to the ICO in a complaint.

 

Why are you looking at Bristol?

Somerset Independents puts Somerset residents first. So why are we reporting on Bristol City Council, when it is not in Somerset? It is because:

  • What happens in Bristol affects Somerset (e.g. on the resources for policing or on changes to governance such as the Mayor of Bristol being scrapped for a committee system - something which we are campaigning for in Somerset)
  • Bristol City Council, like the district and county councils in Somerset, is mired in controversy and is lacking in even basic governance and accountability. Councillors in Bristol and Somerset must be held to account for this, in a democracy where citizens are concerned about the lack of representation.
  • What happens in Somerset affects Bristol (e.g. the scrapping of the districts and county council which will have a knock-on effect on Bristol)

 

Our Victory In Somerset

Somerset Independents has claimed victory in its investigation of all district, county and unitary Councillors in Somerset on whether they paid their council tax or not. The results of our investigations are published on this website - link here.

 

Previous Investigations of Bristol Councillors

During our investigations in Somerset, we became aware from Bristol residents who contacted us that in 2017, the Bristol Post/BristolLive online published two stories on councillors at Bristol City Council that had been in arrears on their council tax. 

  1. "Deputy mayor owed more than £5,000 in council tax arrears - and Labour group paid it - Councillor Asher Craig paid the arrears - thanks to loan from the Labour group", 28th March 2017, Ian Onions
  2. "The five Bristol city councillors who fell behind with their council tax payments revealed - All of the councillors have given reasons for their late payments", 17th March 2017, Esme Ashcroft
     

A concerned citizen named Mike Owen had earlier submitted an FoI in January 2017. Bristol City Council had covered up the names in that case too, saying (emphasis added):

"Shortly prior to your request, checks were carried out on all 70 councillors to check their position in relation to payment of council tax. Five were found to be in arrears of two months or more and were contacted in this regard. All five have now cleared their arrears. On the basis that these arrears have been cleared in advance of the budget meeting, we are of the view that the adverse consequences of releasing the names of those councillors would be unnecessary and unjustified."

Mr Owen then requested an Internal Review. We do not know whether the outcome of this Internal Review was how the names were revealed. And we do not know whether the Bristol Post used this information in their reports. The instigator of the FoI is not credited in the report.

So the battle that Mr Owen had suffered, has been repeated in our experience by Andrew Pope, too. And possibly by others who have tried to get the information out of Bristol City Council.

We approached Mr Owen for comment on our investigation. He told us:

"I was surprised how councillors could manage to ignore reminders, and offer the public excuses akin to the dog ate my coursework.
Marvin Rees promised to carry out checks on councillors' council tax arrears, can I assume that all is 'really' ship shape and Bristol fashion when no public update is provided?"

Private Eye had also published details of arrears of councillors from the 2016-17 year in a nationwide expose of councillors (see image). They had not been blocked or refused by Bristol City Council. But both Mr Owen and Mr Pope had been blocked.

 

Again, we do not know what relationship there was, if any, between the Private Eye investigation and the Bristol Post's reports. Then in 2018, Esme Ashcroft of BristolLive again reported:

"Revealed: The Bristol, North Somerset, South Gloucestershire and B&NES councillors who missed council tax payments - Has your councillor made the list?", 29th May 2018

For 2016/17, Ms Ashcroft named:

  • Asher Craig (Labour) - again as named in the Ian Onions report, 
  • Sultan Khan (Labour)
  • Harriet Clough (Lib Dem)
  • Cleo Lake (Green)
  • Stephen Clark (Green).

Then also in Bristol for 2018:

  • Charlie Bolton (Green)
  • Harriet Clough (Lib Dem) - AGAIN (also in 2016/17)
  • Carole Johnson (Labour)
  • Paul Goggin (Labour).

The report also named North Somerset and Bath and North East Somerset councillors, but that is not relevant here. Somerset Independents has done separate investigations into those councils - please see elsewhere on this website.

It has been difficult to find any more recent reports than 2018, if they even exist.

 

Why Are Media Outlets Not Publishing On Bristol Councillors in Arrears since 2018?

We wondered why or whether local media outlets had not investigated councillors and the Mayor on council tax arrears.

It may have been that stories had been written and then had been squashed by editors not wanting to upset "powerful people" - as we know one Editor (outside Bristol) told a journalist recently when he wanted to report on an abusive and offensive MP.

Or it could have been that Bristol City Council refused Freedom of Information (FoI) requests for every year since 2018 when they did reveal the names of recalcitrant councillors to the Bristol Post? That would be true to form of Mr Owen's experience and ours too. 

Since 2018 investigations by Bristol's media outlets seem to have dried up, or not made their way into the public realm.

However, the Bristol Post has reported on Bristol City Council's atrocious record in not responding to FoIs in time:

  1. "Bristol City Council regularly misses legal deadline for answering information requests - Deputy mayor Craig Cheney has admitted the council has a "problem" responding to Freedom of Information requests", 16th April 2021
  2. "Bristol City Council cuts Freedom of Information requests target so it can meet it - Authority says the change followed Information Commissioner's Office advice on 'realistic' goals", 2nd Nov 2021, Adam Postans

Somerset Independents has approached the Bristol Post on this story. It was not taken up by them. So as we have done with our other investigations, we are publishing it ourselves. And we have approached Pete Gavan, the Editor at the Bristol Post/BristolLive, to ask what has happened.

Somerset Independents will not be spending much more time on Bristol. We are volunteers that stand up for Somerset, not Bristol.

But we report this in the public interest in the hope that Bristol residents can pick up the baton and discover what is happening, and then do something about it.

 

Who Are Somerset Independents?

We help residents to stand up for themselves and challenge those in power.

Join Somerset's own campaign group and political party to celebrate Somerset's past, protect Somerset's present and prepare Somerset for the future.

We can be contacted at the link here and via Twitter @SomerInds, via Facebook at the Somerset Independents page and via email at somerinds [at] gmail.com.